Abstract
This article proceeds in three main parts. First, it provides an account of a moral panic that unfolded during a short period in the Australian state of New South Wales over warring motorbike or ‘bikie’ gangs. Second, it sketches a recent history of laws in New South Wales that have expanded police powers, including ‘anti-bikie’ gang laws. The article shows how policing and crime control has become politicised since 9/11 and, accordingly, the extension of police powers has entailed the blurring of the functions of police and security services. This, in turn, raises serious concerns about civil liberties and the rule of law. Third, the article interprets
the events surrounding the ‘bikie gang wars’ using classic and more recent moral panic theory as well as ideas around the ‘new penology’. The article concludes by considering the utility of applying the concept of moral panic to the bikie case.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Ackland
R.
(2009 , May
22 ). Bikie laws sideline the rule of law . The Sydney Morning Herald , p. 15 .
2.
Alexander
C.
(2000 ). The Asian gang: Ethnicity, identity, masculinity . London , Berg .
3.
Altheide
D.L.
(2009 ). Moral panic: From sociological concept to public discourse . Crime, Media, Culture , 5 (1 ), 79 –99 .
4.
Arden
M.
(2006 ). Meeting the challenge of terrorism: The experience of English and other courts . Australian Law Journal , 80 , 818 –838 .
5.
Ashworth
A.
(2000 ). Is the criminal law a lost cause?
Law Quarterly Review , 116 , 225 –256 .
6.
Barker
I.
(2005 ). Human rights in an age of counter terrorism . Australian Bar Review , 26 , 267 –286 .
7.
Baker
J.
(2008 , January
12 ). Crime Inc's Riders . The Sydney Morning Herald . Retrieved from http://www.smh.com.au/news/national/crime-incs-riders/2008/01/11/1199988590155.html
8.
Bauman
Z.
(2004 ). Wasted lives: Modernity and its outcasts . Cambridge : Polity Press .
9.
Bayley
D.
Shearing
C.
(1996 ). The future of policing . Law & Society Review , 30 (3 ), 585 –606 .
10.
Becker
H.S.
(1963 ). Outsiders: Studies in the sociology of deviance . New York : Free Press .
11.
Benson
S.
(2009 , April 7). Army in lockdown over bikie threats . The Daily Telegraph . Retrieved from http://www.news.com.au/dailytelegraph/story/0,22049,25300385-5001021,00.html
12.Bikie boss stood down from RTA job . (2009c , March
25 ). The Sydney Morning Herald . Retrieved from http://www.smh.com.au/national/bikie-boss-stood-down-from-rta-job-20090325-9a4b.html
13.
Bliss
R.
(2009 , March
10 ). Street wars: Bikie gang warfare has moved out of the shadows and onto our streets . Inner West Courier , pp. 1 , 5 .
14.
Bottoms
A.
(1995 ). The philosophy and politics of punishment and sentencing . In
Clarkson
C.
Morgan
R.
(Eds.) , The politics of sentencing reform (pp. 17 –51 ). Oxford : Clarendon Press .
15.
Brodeur
J-P.
(1983 ). High policing and low policing: Remarks about the policing of political activities . Social Problems , 30 (5 ), 507 –520 .
16.
Brodeur
J-P.
(2007 ). High and low policing in post-9/11 times . Policing , 1 (1 ), 25 –37 .
17.
Brookbanks
W.
(2002 ). Public policy, moral panics and the lure of anticipatory containment . Psychiatry, Psychology and Law , 9 (2 ), 127 –35 .
18.Brutal airport murder: Bikies seek peace talks . (2009b , March
23 ). ABC Radio News , Retrieved from http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2009/03/23/2523230.htm
19.
Clarke
J.
(2008 ). Still policing the crisis?
Crime, Media, Culture , 4 (1 ), 123 –129 .
20.
Clennell
A.
(2007 , November
14 ). Sun sets on two-year expiry, but Cronulla riot laws to stay . The Sydney Morning Herald , p. 5 .
21.
Clennell
A.
Bibby
P.
Narushima
Y.
(2009 , March
24 ). Bikie brawl watched by security men . The Sydney Morning Herald . Retrieved from http://www.smh.com.au/national/bikie-brawlwatched-by-security-men-20090323-97gf.html?page=-1
22.
Cohen
S.
(1985 ). Visions of social control: crime, punishment and classification . Cambridge : Polity Press .
23.
Cohen
S.
(2002 ). Folk devils and moral panics: The creation of the Mods and Rockers (3rd ed. ). London : Routledge .
24.
Collins
J.
Noble
G.
Poynting
S.
Tabar
P.
(2000 ). Kebabs, kids, cops and rime: Youth, ethnicity and crime . Sydney : Pluto Press .
25.
Cowdery
N.
(2009 ). Comments on organisation/association legislation: ‘bikie gangs’ . Retrieved from http://www.odpp.nsw.gov.au/speeches/speeches.html
26.Criminal Investigation (Exceptional Powers) and Fortification Removal Bill 2001 . (2002 ). Brief (April) , 29 (3 ), 26 –7 .
27.
Cunneen
C.
Findlay
M.
Lynch
R.
Tupper
V.
(1989 ). Dynamics of collective conflict: Riots at the Bathurst Bike Races . North Ryde, Australia : The Law Book Company .
28.
Findlay
M.
Loughnan
A.
(2009 ). Press Release Re: Crimes (Criminal Organisations Control) Act 2009 . Outlaw Motorcycle Gang Laws ‘may make things worse’ say legal experts . Retrieved from http://www.law.usyd.edu.au/~criminology/Outlaw%20Motorcycle%20Gangs%20Law%20.pdf
29.
Frieberg
A.
(2000 ). Guerrillas in our midst?
In
Brown
M.
Pratt
J.
(Eds.), Dangerous offenders: Punishment and social order (pp. 51 –71 ). New York : Routledge .
30.
Garland
D.
(2008 ). On the concept of moral panic . Crime, Media, Culture , 4 (1 ), 9 –30 .
31.
Goode
E.
Ben-Yehuda
N.
(1994 ). Moral panics: The social construction of deviance . Oxford : Blackwell .
32.
Gottschalk
P.
Greenberg
G.
(2008 ). Islamophobia: Making Muslims the enemy . Lantham, MD : Rowman and Littlefield Publishers .
33.
Hall
S.
Jefferson
T.
Clarke
J.
Roberts
B.
(1978 ). Policing the crisis: Mugging, the state and law and order . Basingstoke, UK : Macmillan .
34.Hells Angels bombed: police fear revenge . (2009a , February
4 ). The Sydney Morning Herald . Retrieved from http://www.smh.com.au/news/national/hells-angels-bombing-revengefear/2009/02/04/1233423289480.html
35.
Hocking
J.
(2004 ). Terror laws: ASIO, counter-terrorism and the threat to democracy . Sydney, Australia : UNSW Press .
36.
Hogg
R.
(2007 ). Criminology, crime and politics before and after 9/11 . The Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology , 40 (1 ), 83 –105 .
37.
Hogg
R.
Brown
D.
(1998 ). Rethinking law and order . Sydney, Australia : Pluto Press .
38.
Hudson
B.
(1987 ). Justice through punishment: A critique of the ‘justice’ model of corrections . Basingstoke, UK : Macmillan .
39.
Hudson
B.
(2003 ). Justice in the risk society: Challenging and re-affirming justice in late modernity . London : Sage .
40.
Jean
P.
Tydd
J.
Braithwaite
A.
(2005 , December
16 ). Riot laws bolster force of 1500 . The Sydney Morning Herald .
41.
Johnston
L.
(1992 ). The rebirth of private policing . London : Routledge .
42.
Johnston
L.
Shearing
C.
(2003 ). Governing security: Explorations in policing and justice . London : Routledge .
43.
Lawrence
K.
(2009a , March
23 ). Bikie war explodes . The Daily Telegraph , p. 1 .
44.
Lawrence
K.
(2009b , March
24 ). Tension in the air on Qantas flight 430 from Melbourne . The Daily Telegraph . Retrieved from http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/news/tension-on-flight-430/story-e6freuy9-1225690989515
, p. 4 –5 .
45.
Loader
I.
(2000 ). Plural policing and democratic governance . Social and Legal Studies , 9 (3 ), 323 –345 .
46.
Loughnan
A.
(2009 ). The legislation we had to have?: The Crimes (Criminal Organisations Control) Act 2009 (NSW) . Current Issues in Criminal Justice , 20 (3 ), 457 –465 .
47.
Martin
G.
(2008 ). Case and comment: ‘Anti-terrorism’ laws upheld in High Court challenge . Criminal Law Journal , 32 (2 ), 114 –119 .
48.
McCulloch
J.
(2002 ). ‘Counter-terrorism’, human security and globalisation: From welfare to warfare state?
Current Issues in Criminal Justice , 14 (3 ), 283 –98 .
49.
McHugh
M.
(2006 ). Terrorism legislation and the constitution . Australian Bar Review , 28 , 117 –135 .
50.
McSherry
B.
(2004 ). Terrorism offences in the criminal code: Broadening the boundaries of Australian criminal laws . University of New South Wales Law Journal , 27 (2 ), 354 –372 .
51.
McVeigh
T.
Syal
R.
Hinsliff
G.
(2009 , April
19 ). How the image of UK police took a beating . The Observer , pp. 12 –13 .
52.
Morgan
G.
(2009 , March
15 ). Beware giving police a bigger stick . The Sydney Morning Herald , p. 15 .
53.
Newburn
T.
Reiner
R.
(2004 ). From PC Dixon to Dixon PLC: Policing and policing powers since 1954 . Criminal Law Review, August , 601 –18 .
54.
Noakes
J.A.
Gillham
P.F.
(2006 ). Aspects of the ‘New Penology’ in the police response to major political protests in the United States, 1999–2000 . In
della Porta
D.
Peterson
A.
Reiter
H.
(Eds.) , The policing of transnational protest (pp. 97 –115 ). Aldershot, UK : Ashgate .
55.
Noble
G.
(2005 ). The discomfort of strangers: Racism, incivility and ontological security in a relaxed and comfortable nation . Journal of Intercultural Studies , 26 (1 ), 107 –120 .
56.NSW Government, Legislative Council . (2006 ). Hansard Parliamentary Debates , 6 September 2009 .
57.NSW Government, Legislative Council . (2007 ). Hansard Parliamentary Debates , 28 November 2007 .
58.NSW Government, Legislative Council . (2009a ) Hansard Parliamentary Debates , 24 March 2009 .
59.NSW Government, Legislative Council . (2009b ) Hansard Parliamentary Debates , 2 April 2009 .
60.NSW Government, Legislative Council . (2009 ). Hansard Parliamentary Debates , 11 March 2009 .
61.
O’Neill
M.
(2009 , April
5 ). Cops are ‘stirring’ conflict, claims Sam Ibrahim . The Sunday Telegraph . Retrieved from http://www.news.com.au/entertainment/story/0,28383,25290933-5001021,00.html
62.
O’Reilly
C.
Ellison
G.
(2006 ). Eye spy private high: Re-conceptualizing high policing theory . British Journal of Criminology , 46 (4 ), 641 –660 .
63.
Park
N.
(2008 , June
9 ). Police warning on youth binge drinking . The Age . Retrieved from http://news.theage.com.au/national/police-warning-on-youth-binge-drinking-20080609-2nvx.html
64.
Pearson
G.
(1983 ). Hooligan: A history of respectable fears . Houndmills, UK : Macmillan .
65.
Pickering
S.
McCulloch
J.
Wright-Neville
D.
(2008 ). Counter-terrorism policing: Community, cohesion and security . New York : Springer .
66.
Poynting
S.
Morgan
G.
(Eds.) . (2007 ). Outrageous! Moral panics in Australia . Hobart, Tasmania : ACYS Publishing .
67.
Poynting
S.
Noble
G.
Tabar
P.
Collins
J.
(2004 ). Bin Laden in the suburbs: Criminalising the Arab other . Sydney, Australia : Sydney Institute of Criminology .
68.
Pratt
J.
Brown
D.
Brown
M.
Hallsworth
S.
Morrison
W.
(Eds.) . (2005 ). The new punitiveness: Trends, theories, perspectives . Cullompton, UK : Willan Publishing .
69.
Roberts
J. V.
Stalans
L. J.
Indermaur
D.
Hough
M.
(2003 ). Penal populism and public opinion: Lessons from five countries . New York : Oxford University Press .
70.
Salusinszky
I.
(2009 , April
30 ). Labor Party maintains the gains in NSW . The Australian , p. 1 .
71.
Scraton
P.
(2002 ). An anthology of dissent . London : Pluto Press .
72.
Schloenhardt
A.
(2008 , April ). Battling the bikies: South Australia's Serious and Organised Crime (Control) Bill 2007
. Law Society Bulletin (SA) , 30 (3 ), 8 –11 .
73.
Shearing
C.
(2001 ). Punishment and the changing face of governance . Punishment & Society , 3 (2 ), 203 –220 .
74.
Snell
L.
(2008 ). Protest, policing, protection: The expansion of police powers and the impact on human rights in NSW — The policing of APEC as a case study . Sydney, Australia : Combined Community Legal Centres Group (NSW) and Kingsford Legal Centre . Retrieved from http://www.nswclc.org.au/ Publications/APEC_Report.pdf
75.
Stenning
P.
(2009 ). Governance and policing in a plural policing environment: The story so far . Policing , 3 (1 ), 22 –33 .
76.
Stenson
K.
(2009 ). Governance and policing . Policing , 3 (1 ), 5 –6 .
77.
Stratton
J.
(1997 ). On the importance of subcultural origins . In
Gelder
K.
Thornton
S.
(Eds.) , The subcultures reader (pp. 181 –90 ). London : Routledge .
78.
Welch
D.
(2008 , October
16 ). Tears, proud words and a bit of biff at bikie funeral . The Sydney Morning Herald . Retrieved from http://www.smh.com.au/news/national/tears-proud-words-anda-bit-of-biff-at-bikie-funeral/2008/10/15/1223750129826.html
79.
Welch
D.
(2009 , May
2 ). Defendant ‘seen swinging bollard’ . The Sydney Morning Herald . Retrieved from http://www.smh.com.au/national/defendant-seen-swinging-bollard-20090501-aq6i.html
80.
Welch
D.
Kennedy
L.
Harvey
E.
(2009 , March
23 ). Bikie killed in Sydney Airport brawl . The Sydney Morning Herald . Retrieved from http://www.smh.com.au/national/bikie-killed-insydney-airport-brawl-20090323–95xc.html
81.
White
R.
(2007 ). Taking to the streets: The larrikins and the Lebanese . In
Poynting
S.
Morgan
G.
(Eds.) , Outrageous! Moral panics in Australia (pp. 40 –52 ). Hobart, Australia : ACYS Publishing .
82.
Willis
P.
(1978 ). Profane culture . London : Routledge & Kegan Paul .
83.
Young
J.
(2005 ). Moral panics, Margate and Mary Poppins: Mysterious happenings in south coast seaside towns . Crime, Media, Culture , 1 (1 ), 100 –105 .
84.
Zedner
L.
(2007 ). Pre-crime and post-criminology?
Theoretical Criminology , 11 (2 ), 261 –81 .