In this article, the author provides an econometric approach for comparing vocational
training courses, and aims to study how courses affect individual behaviour. Given
the hierarchical nature of the data and the purposes of the analysis, he proposes
the application of a discrete-time multilevel hazard model. The variable of interest
is the duration (in months) of the first job-search after the end of the course. The
author focusses on contextual and correlated (course) effects and comments on the
results also in terms of school effectiveness. The approach may be easily applied to
several other clustered structures.
Aitkin M
and
Longford N
(1986)
Statistical modelling issues in school effectiveness studies (with discussion)
. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society A149 (1),
1-43
.
2.
Allison P
(1982) Discrete-time methods for the analysis of event
histories. In
Leindhart S
, editor, Sociological methodology.
Jossey-Bass
, 61-98.
3.
Andersen P
,
Borgan O
,
Gill R
and
Keiding N
(1993) Statistical models based on counting processes.
Springer-Verlag
.
4.
Anderson D
and
Aitkin M
(1985)
Variance component models with binary response: interviewer variability
. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society B47 (2),
203-210
.
5.
Barber J
,
Murphy S
,
Axinn W
and
Maples J
(2000)
Discrete-time multilevel hazard analysis
. Sociological Methodology30,
201-235
.
6.
Barnow B
(2000)
Exploring the relationship between performance management and program
impact: a case study of the job training partnership act
. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management19 (1),
118-141
.
7.
Biggeri L
,
Bini M
and
Grilli L
(2001)
The transition from university to work: a multilevel approach to the
analysis of the time to obtain the first job
. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society A164 (2),
293-305
.
8.
Breslow N
and
Clayton D
(1993)
Approximate inference in generalized linear mixed models
. Journal of the American Statistical Association88 (421),
9-25
.
9.
Brillinger D
and
Preisler H
(1983) Maximum likelihood estimation in a latent variable
problem. In
Karlin S
,
Amemiya T
and
Goodman L
, editors, Studies in econometrics, time series, and multivariate
statistics.
Academic Press
, 31-65.
10.
Brown C
(1975)
On the use of indicator variables for studying the time dependence of
parameters in a response-time models
. Biometrics31,
863-872
.
11.
Bryk A
and
Raudenbush S
(1992) Hierarchical linear model: applications and data
analysis methods.
Sage Publications
.
12.
Coleman J
,
Campbell E
,
Hobson C
,
McPartland J
,
Mood A
,
Weinfield F
and
York R
(1966) Equality of educational opportunity.
US Government Printing
.
13.
Cox D
(1972)
Regression models and life tables (with discussion)
. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society B34 (2),
187-220
.
14.
Goldstein H
(1991)
Nonlinear multilevel models, with an application to discrete response data
. Biometrika78 (1),
45-51
.
15.
Goldstein H
(1997)
Methods in school effectiveness research
. School Effectiveness and School Improvement8 (4),
369-395
.
16.
Goldstein H
(2001)
Using pupil performance data for judging schools and teachers: scope and limitations
. British Educational Research Journal27,
433-442
.
17.
Goldstein H
and
Healy M
(1995)
The graphical presentation of a collection of means
. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society A158 (1),
175-177
.
18.
Goldstein H
and
Spiegelhalter D
(1996)
League tables and their limitations: statistical issues in comparisons of
institutional performance
. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society A159 (3),
385-443
.
19.
Goldstein H
and
Thomas S
(1996)
Using examination results as indicators of school and college performance
. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society A159 (1),
149-163
.
20.
Goldstein H
and
Woodhouse G
(2000)
School effectiveness research and educational policy
. Oxford Review of Education26 (3),
353-363
.
21.
Grilli L (1999) Sbocchi occupazionali e scelte formative dei diplomati:
un’analisi multilivello. Ph.D. thesis, Department of Statistics
‘G. Parenti’, University of Florence.
22.
Guo G
and
Rodriguez G
(1992)
Estimating a multivariate proportional hazards model for clustered data
using the EM algorithm, with an application to child survival in Guatemala
. Journal of the American Statistical Association87 (420),
969-976
.
23.
Hank K
(2002)
Regional social contexts and individual fertility decisions: a multilevel
analysis of first and second births in Western Germany
. European Journal of Population18 (3),
281-299
.
24.
Hannan M
and
Burstein L
(1974)
Estimation from grouped observations
. American Sociological Review39,
374-392
.
25.
Hedeker D
and
Gibbons R
(1994)
A random-effects ordinal regression model for multilevel analysis
. Biometrics50 (4),
933-944
.
26.
Hedeker D
,
Siddiqui O
and Hu F (2000)
Random-effects regression analysis of correlated grouped-time survival data
. Statistical Methods in Medical Research9,
161-179
.
27.
Hox J
(2002) Multilevel analysis: techniques and
applications.
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
.
28.
Jencks C
,
Smith M
,
Ackland H
,
Bane M
,
Cohen D
,
Gintis H
,
Heyns B
and
Micholson S
(1972) Inequality: a reassessment of the effect of family and
schooling in America.
Basic Books
.
29.
Lancaster T
(1990) The econometric analysis of transition data.
Cambridge University Press
.
30.
Ma X
and
Willms J
(1999)
Dropping out of advanced mathematics: how much do students and schools
contribute to the problem?Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis21,
365-383
.
31.
Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference on Logic and
Methodology. Second expanded edition, Leske + Budrich
Verlag (CD-ROM).
32.
Manski C
(1995) Identification problems in the social sciences.
Harvard University Press
.
33.
Paccagnella O (2002) Relative effects of ESF vocational training courses
on the duration of the first job-search in the province of Bolzano: a multilevel
approach. Ph.D. thesis, Department of Statistics, University of Padua.
34.
Paccagnella O
(2003)
The accuracy of estimates in discrete response multilevel models: New
simulation results
. In Proceedings of S.Co.2003 Meeting: Modelli Complessi e Metodi
Computazionali Intensivi per la Stima e la Previsione.
Treviso, 4-6 September 2003,
296-301
.
35.
Paccagnella O
(2006)
Centering or not centering in multilevel models? The role of the group mean
and the assessment of group effects
. Evaluation Review30 (1),
66-85
.
36.
Pinheiro J
and
Bates D
(1995)
Approximations to the log-likelihood function in the nonlinear
mixed-effects model
. Journal of Computational and Graphical Statistics4 (1),
12-35
.
37.
Raudenbush S
and
Willms J
(1995)
The estimation of school effects
. Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics20 (4),
307-335
.
38.
Reardon S
,
Brennan R
and
Buka S
(2002)
Estimating multi-level discrete-time hazard models using cross-sectional
data: neighborhood effects on the onset of adolescent cigarette use
. Multivariate Behavioral Research37 (3),
297-330
.
39.
SAS Institute (1999) SAS/STAT User’s Guide, Version 8,
Volumes 1-3.
40.
Sastry N
(1997)
A nested frailty model for survival data, with an application to the study
of child survival in Northeast Brazil
. Journal of the American Statistical Association92 (438),
426-435
.
41.
Steele F
,
Diamond I
and
Wang D
(1996)
The determinants of the duration of contraceptive use in China: A
multilevel multinomial discrete-hazards modeling approach
. Demography33 (1),
12-23
.
42.
Vaida F
and
Xu R
(2000)
Proportional hazards model with random effects
. Statistics in Medicine19 (24),
3309-3324
.
43.
Yang M
,
Heath A
and
Goldstein H
(2000)
Multilevel models for repeated binary outcomes: attitudes and vote over the
electoral cycle
. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society A163 (1),
49-62
.
44.
Zhang F
,
Tsui A
and
Suchindran C
(1999) The determinants of contraceptive discontinuation in
Northern India: a multilevel analysis of calendar data. Wp-99-15,
Measure Evaluation, Carolina Population Center, University of North Carolina
.
