With tourism rapidly increasing in developing nations there is an emerging focus on
integrating pro-poor tourism into both the international tourism and aid agendas.
Following a brief review of the pro-poor tourism literature, this article argues for
the explicit creation of tourism and agriculture linkages to achieve pro-poor
tourism objectives. To understand both the potential and the problems associated
with linking the two sectors, we present an in-depth case study of tourism and
agriculture in Cancun, Mexico. The case study draws on the perspectives of Cancun
hotel chefs, who control hotel food purchasing, and Quintana Roo farmers, who have
attempted to supply the tourism industry, to provide a unique thorough examination
of the challenges and potential for such linkages in a mass tourism resort.
Administradores Asociados Lerma 1983: Estudios de Factibilidad
Técnica, Económica y Financiera para la Instalación
de un Invernadero de Ambiente Controlado para la Producción de Lechuga en
Canción, Quintana Roo. Feasibility Study.
2.
Andreatta, S.1998:
Transformation of the agro-food sector: lessons from the Caribbean
. Human Organization57(4),
414-429
.
3.
Ashley, C.2000: The impacts of tourism on rural livelihoods:
Namibia’s experience. Working Paper 128.
London: Overseas Development Institute
.
4.
Ashley, C.
and
Jones, B.2001:
Joint ventures between communities and tourism investors: experience in
southern Africa
. International Journal of Tourism Research3(2),
407-423
.
5.
Ashley, C.
,
Elliott, J.
,
Sikoyo, G.
and
Hanlon, K.1999: Handbook for assessing the economic and livelihood impacts of
wildlife enterprises.
London: Overseas Development Institute (ODI)
and African Wildlife Foundation (AWF)
.
6.
Ashley, C.
,
Boyd, C.
and
Goodwin, H.2000:
Pro-poor tourism: putting poverty at the heart of the tourism agenda
. Natural Resource Perspectives (51),
1-6
.
7.
Ashley, C.
,
Goodwin, H.
and
Roe, D.2001a: Pro-poor tourism strategies: expanding opportunities for the
poor. Pro-Poor Tourism Briefing No.1 (April), for the
Centre for Responsible Tourism (CRT), International Institute for
Environment and Development (IIED) and Overseas Development Institute (ODI)
.
http://www.odi.org.uk/publications/ppt-brief1.pdf+Pro-Poor+Tourism+Strategies:+Expanding+Opportunities+for+the+Poor.++&hl-en
(last accessed June 2004).
8.
Ashley, C.
,
Roe, D.
and
Goodwin, H.2001b: Pro-poor tourism strategies: making tourism work for the
poor. Pro-Poor Tourism Report No.1 (April) for the Overseas Development
Institute, London.
Nottingham: Russell Press
.
9.
BBC2002: Poverty ‘fueling terrorism’.
BBC News
, 22 March 2002.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/hi/english/world/newsid_1886000/1886617.stm (last
accessed 13 June 2002).
10.
Bélisle, F. J.1983:
Tourism and food production in the Caribbean
. Annals of Tourism Research10,
497-513
.
11.
Bélisle, F. J.1984a:
Tourism and food imports: the case of Jamaica
. Economic Development and Cultural Change32,
819-842
.
12.
Bélisle, F. J.1984b:
The significance and structure of hotel food supply in Jamaica
. Geography1,
219-233
.
13.
Bosselman, F. P.1978: In the wake of the tourist: managing special places in eight
countries.
Washington DC: The Conservation Foundation
.
14.
Bowen, R. L.
,
Cox, L. J.
and
Fox, M.1991:
The interface between tourism and agriculture
. The Journal of Tourism Studies2(2),
43-54
.
15.
Britton, S.1981:
The spatial organisation of tourism in a neo-colonial economy: a Fiji case study
. Pacific Viewpoint21(2),
144-165
.
16.
Britton, S.1982:
The political economy of tourism in the Third World
. Annals of Tourism Research9,
331-358
.
17.
Britton, S.1991:
Tourism, capital, and place: towards a critical geography of tourism
. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space9,
451-478
.
18.
Brohman, J.1996:
New directions in tourism for Third World development
. Annals of Tourism Research23(1),
48-78
.
19.
Bryden, J. M.1973: Tourism and development: a case study of the Commonwealth
Caribbean.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
20.
Carney, D.1999: Approaches to sustainable livelihoods for the rural
poor. ODI Poverty Briefing No. 2 (January).
London: ODI
.
21.
Cater, E.1987:
Tourism in the least developed countries
. Annals of Tourism Research14,
202-226
.
22.
Cattarinich, X.2001: Pro-poor tourism initiatives in developing countries: analysis
of secondary case studies. Pro-Poor Tourism (PPT) Working Paper No. 8 for
Centre for Responsible Tourism at the University of Greenwich (CRT),
International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED) and
Department for International Development (DFID)
; http://www.propoortourism.org.uk/ppt-initiatives.html (last
accessed June 2004).
23.
Centro de Investigaciones de Quintana Roo (CIQRO) 1981: Desarrollo de la Base
Tecnológica Para la Implementaciónde Sistemas de Cultivo
Hidropónico en Quintana Roo. Project Proposal, Puerto Morelos, Quintana
Roo, Mexico
24.
Chambers, R.
and
Conway, G. R.1992: Sustainable rural livelihoods: practical concepts for the 21st
century. Institute of Development Studies discussion paper no. 296.
Brighton: University of Sussex Institute of
Development Studies
.
25.
CIAG 1999: Plan Estratégico de De sarrollo Integral de Estado de
Quintana Roo 2000-2025: Fase I. Selección de Motores y Factores Claves.
Report, ITESM, December 1999. Monteney, Mexico.
26.
Clancy, M. J.1999:
Tourism and development: evidence from Mexico
. Annals of Tourism Research26(1),
1-20
.
27.
Clancy, M. J.2001: Exporting paradise: tourism and development in Mexico.
Amsterdam: Pergamon
.
28.
Cothran, D. A.
and
Cothran, C. C.1998:
Promise or political risk for Mexican tourism
. Annals of Tourism Research25(2),
477-497
.
29.
Cox, L. J.
,
Fox, M.
and
Bowen, R. L.1994:
Does tourism destroy agriculture?Annals of Tourism Research22,
210-213
.
30.
Crick, M.1989:
Representations of international tourism in the social sciences: sun, sand,
sex, sights, savings and servility
. Annual Review of Anthropology18,
307-344
.
31.
Department for International Development (DFID)1999a: Sustainable tourism and poverty elimination study.
Report for Department for International Development by Deloitte & Touche,
IIED and ODI
.
32.
Department for International Development (DFID)1999b: Tourism and poverty elimination: untapped potential
study. Report for Department for International Development, April.
33.
Dieke, P.1991:
Policies for tourism development in Kenya
. Annals of Tourism Research18,
269-294
.
34.
Dieke, P.1993:
Tourism and development policy in Gambia
. Annals of Tourism Research20,
423-449
.
35.
Doxey, G. V.
and
Associates1971: The tourist industry in Barbados: a socio-economic
assessment.
Kitchener, Canada: Dusco Graphics
.
36.
Enriquez Savignac, A.
1972:
The computer planning of Cancun Island, Mexico: a new resort complex
. In The Travel Research Association, Proceedings of Third Annual
Conference. 13-16, August, Quebec, Canada.
37.
Estado de Quintana Roo Secretaría de Comercio y Fomento Industrial
1994: Proyecto: Centro de Acopio: Ubicación Felipe Carrillo Puerto.
Project Proposal, Chetumal, Quintana Roo, Mexico.
38.
Farrington, J.2001: Sustainable livelihoods, rights and the new architecture of
aid. ODI Natural Resource Perspectives, no. 69, June 2001.
Overseas Development Institute, UK
.
39.
Fideicomiso de Riesgo Compartido Gerencia Estatal Quintana Roo 1996: Proyecto
de Agricultura de Riego en la Zona Maya. Project Proposal, Chetumal, Quintana Roo, Mexico.
40.
Food and Agriculture Organization
/
Economic Commission for Europe
(FAO/ECE) 1982:
Report of the symposium on agriculture and tourism
. Report Presented at FAO/ECE Working Party on Agrarian Structures
and Farm Rationalization. Symposium on Agriculture and Tourism,
Mariehamn, Finland, 7-12 June 1982.
New York: UN Economic Commission for Europe.
41.
Ghimire, K.1997: Emerging mass tourism in the south: reflections on the social
opportunities and costs of national and regional tourism in developing
counties. Discussion Paper No.85, April.
Geneva: United Nations Research Institute for
Social Development (UNRISD)
.
42.
Gobierno del Estado de Quintana Roo Secretaría de Fomento
Agropecuario 1983: Programa de Hortalizas en las Unidades de Riego de Tampak.
Project Proposal, Chetumal, Quintana Roo, Mexico.
43.
Goffe, P. W.1975:
How developing nations view tourism: development potential of international
tourism in Jamaica
. The Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly16,
24-31
.
44.
Gomes, A. J.1993: Integrating tourism and agricultural development.
In
Gayle, D. J.
and
Goodrich, J. N.
, editors, Tourism marketing and management in the Caribbean.
London and New York: Routledge
, 155-166.
45.
Gooding, E. G. B.1971: Food production in Barbados with particular reference to
tourism. In
Doxey, G. V.et al.
(eds) The tourist industry in Barbados.
Ontario: Dusco Graphics
.
46.
Goodwin, H.
1998:
Sustainable tourism and poverty alleviation
. Discussion paper for DFID/DETR Workshop on Sustainable Tourism
and Poverty, 13 October 1998.
http://216.239.39.104/search?q-cache:6hMYSdSE-1MJ:www.icrtourism.org/Publications/PovertPaper2.doc+Goodwin,+Harold+1998+Sustainable+Tourism
(last accesed 13 July 2004).
47.
Goodwin, H.2000: Pro-poor tourism: opportunities for sustainable
development.
Frankfurt
, Development and Cooperation Paper No. 5, September/October, 12-14.
48.
Green, J. 1987: Paper presented to the Centro de Investigaciones de Quintana
Roo, A.C. Cancun, Quintana Roo, Mexico, unpublished.
49.
Guzman, L.2001: Mexico: market development reports.
Mexico’s Caribbean Market for Food Products
. Gain Report #MX1216, US Department of Agriculture (USDA) Foreign
Agricultural Service.
50.
Hemmati, M.
editor 1999: Gender and tourism: women’s employment
and participation in tourism.
London: UNED-UK
.
51.
Hermans, D.1981:
The encountering of agriculture and tourism: a catalan case
. Annals of Tourism Research8,
462-479
.
52.
Konrad, H.1980:
Una Población Chiclera: Contexto Histórico,
Económico y un Perfil Demográfico
. Boletín E.C.A.U.D.Y.8(45),
2-39
.
53.
Liebman Parrinello, G.1996: Motivational and anticipation in post-industrial
tourism. In
Apostolopoulos, Y.
,
Leivadi, S.
and
Yiannakis, A.
, editors, The sociology of tourism: theoretical and empirical
investigaciones.
London and New York: Routledge
, 75-89.
54.
Lundgren, J.
1971:
Agricultural marketing and distribution arrangements with respect to the
resort hotel in the Caribbean
. In
Thomas, R. D.
, editor, Sixth West Indian Agricultural Economics Conference,
Proceedings. Georgetown, Guyana, 28 March-2
April 1971. St. Augustine: University of the West Indies, Department
of Agricultural Economics and Farm Management.
55.
Mathieson, A.
and
Wall, G.1982: Tourism: economic, physical and social impacts.
New York: Longman
.
56.
McElroy, J. L.
and
de Albuquerque, K.1990:
Sustainable small-scale agriculture in small Caribbean islands
. Society and Natural Resources3,
109-129
.
57.
Miller, L. G.1985: Linking tourism and agriculture to create jobs and reduce
migration in the Caribbean. In
Pastor, R. A.
editor, Migration and development in the Caribbean: the unexplored
connection.
Boulder CO and London: Westview Press
, 289-300.
58.
Milne, S.1992:
Tourism and development in South Pacific Microstates
. Annals of Tourism Research19,
191-212
.
59.
Milne, S.1997: Tourism, dependency and South Pacific Microstates: beyond
the vicious cycle? In
Lockhart, D. G.
and
Drakakis-Smith, D.
, editors, Island tourism: trends and prospects.
London and New York: Pinter
, 281-301.
60.
Momsen, J.1972: Report on vegetable production and the tourist industry in St
Lucia.
University of Calgary, Canada
.
61.
Momsen, J.1973: Report on vegetable production and the tourist industry in
Montserat.
Universityof Calgary, Canada
.
62.
Momsen, J.1986: Linkages between tourism and agriculture: problems for the
smaller Caribbean economies.
University of Newcastle-upon-Tyre
, Seminar Paper 45.
63.
Momsen, J.1998: Caribbean tourism and agriculture: new linkages in the
global Era? In
Klak, T.
, editor, Globalization and neoliberalism: the Caribbean context.
Lanham MD and Oxford: Rowman &
Littleman Publishers, Inc.
, 115-133.
64.
Momsen, J.1999: A sustainable tourism project in Mexico. In
Hammati, M.
, editor, Gender and tourism: women’s employment and
participation in tourism.
London: UNED-UK
, 142-148.
65.
Momsen, J. H.2002:
NGOs, gender and indigenous grassroots development
. Journal of International Development14,
1-9
.
66.
Momsen, J. H.2003: Participatory development and indigenous communities in the
Mexican Carib-bean. In
Pugh, J.
and
Potter, R.
, editors, Participatory planning in the Caribbean: lessons from
practice.
Aldershot: Ashgate
, 155-172.
67.
Monk, J.
and
Alexander, C. S.1986:
Freeport fallout: gender, employment, and migration on Margarita Island
. Annals of Tourism Research13,
393-413
.
68.
Moscardo, G.
and
Pearce, P. L.1999:
Understanding ethnic Tourists
. Annals of Tourism Research26(2),
416-434
.
69.
Mowforth, M.
and
Munt, I.1998: Tourism and sustainability: new tourism in the Third
World.
London and New York: Routledge
.
70.
O’Ferral, A. M.1991:
Tourism and agriculture on the north coast of the Dominican Republic
. Revista Geográfica113,
171-191
.
71.
Organization of American States (OAS)
/
Caribbean Tourism Research and Development Centre (CTRC)
1984:
Tourism and agricultural linkages in the Caribbean
. Final Report OAS/CTRC Workshop, 18-19
July, Hastings, Barbados.
72.
Overseas Development Institute2001: How is pro poor tourism different from other tourismisms?http://www.odi.org.uk/rpeg/pptdifference.html (last accessed 10 June 2002).
73.
Pattullo, P.1996: Last resorts.
London: Latin America Bureau and Cassell
.
74.
Pi-Sunyer, O.1973:
Tourism and its discontents: the impact of a new industry on a Catalan Community
. Studies in European Society1,
1-20
.
75.
Pi-Sunyer, O.
and
Thomas, R. B.1997: Tourism, environmentalism, and cultural survival in
Quintana Roo. In
Johnson, B. R.
, editor, Life and death matters: human rights and the environment at the
end of the Millennium.
Walnut Creek CA: AltaMira Press
, 187-212.
76.
Pizam, A.
and
Sussmann, S.1995:
Does nationality affect tourist behavior?Annals of Tourism Research4,
901-917
.
77.
Poon, A.1989: Competitive strategies for a ‘New
Tourism.’ In
Cooper, C.
, editor, Progress in tourism, recreation and hospitality
management. 1,
London: Belhaven Press
.
78.
Poultney, C.
and
Spenceley, A.2001: Practical strategies for pro-poor tourism, wilderness safaris
South Africa: Rocktail Bay and Ndumu Lodge. Pro-Poor Tourism Working Paper
No. 7, April. For the
Centre for Responsible Tourism (CRT), International Institute for
Environment (IIED) and Development and Overseas Development Institute (ODI)
.
79.
Renard, Y.2001: Practical strategies for pro-poor tourism: A case study of the
St. Lucia Heritage Tourism Programme. Pro-Poor Tourism Working Paper No.
7, April. for the
Centre for Responsible Tourism (CRT), International Institute for
Environment (IIED) and Development and Overseas Development Institute (ODI)
.
80.
Rodenburg, E. E.1980:
The effect of scale in economic development: tourism in Bali
. Annals of Tourism Research12(2),
177-196
.
81.
Roe, D.
and
Urquhart Khanya
, P. 2001: Pro-poor tourism: harnessing the world’s
largest industry for the world’s poor. Prepared for World Summit
on Sustainable Development, Johannesburg, 2002.
London: International Institute for Environment
and Development (IIED) and Regional and International Networking Group (RING)
.
82.
Roe, D.
,
Goodwin, H.
and
Ashley, C.2002: The tourism industry and poverty reduction: a business
primer. Pro-poor Tourism Briefing No. 2 (March). For the
Centre for Responsible Tourism (CRT), International Institute for
Environment (IIED) and Development and Overseas Development Institute (ODI)
.
83.
Saville, N. M.2001: Practical strategies for pro-poor tourism: case study of
pro-poor tourism and SNV in Humla District, West Nepal. Working Paper No.
8 for
Centre for Responsible Tourism at the University of Greenwich (CRT),
International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED) and
Department for International Development (IAD)
.
84.
Secretaria de Agricultura, Garadaria y Desarouo (SAGAR) 1995 Programa de
Abastos de Productos Hortofrutícolas a Grupos Hoteleros de
Cancún, Quintana Roo. Project Proposal, Chetumal, Quintana Roo, Mexico.
85.
Secretaria de Agricultura y Recursos Hidraulicos (SAHR) Map of Quintana Roo
regions of agricultural potential. Internal map prepared by the Quintana Roo
Secretaria de Agricultura y Recursos Hidraulicos (SARH) (Department of Agriculture).
86.
Shah, K.
and
Gupta, V.2000: Tourism, the poor and other stakeholders: experience in
Asia. Report for the Overseas Development Institute and the Fair Trade in
Tourism Project, London (April).
Nottingham: Russell Press
.
87.
Sharkey, D. A.
and
Momsen, J.1995:
Tourism in Dominica, West Indies: problems and prospects
. Caribbean Geography6(1),
40-51
.
88.
Shaw, G.
and
Williams, A. M.1994: Critical issues in tourism: a geographical perspective.
Oxford and Cambridge MA: Blackwell
.
89.
Singh, N.
and
Wanmali, S.1998: Sustainable livelihoods concept paper.
New York: United Nations Development Programme
.
90.
Sutherland, N. S.Agriculture and tourism in the Scottish Highlands and Islands. Report
transmitted by the Government of the United Kingdom.
91.
Taylor, B. E.
,
Morison, J. B.
and
Fleming, E. M.1991:
The economic impact of food import substitution in the Bahamas
. Social and Economic Studies40(2)
45-62
.
92.
Telfer, D. J.1996:
Food purchases in a five-star hotel: a case study of the Aquila Prambanan
Hotel, Yogyakarta, Indonesia
. Tourism Economics: The Business and Finance of Tourism and Recreation2,
321-338
.
93.
Telfer, D. J.2000:
Tastes of Niagara: building strategic alliances between tourism and agriculture
. International Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Administration1(1),
71-88
.
94.
Telfer, D. J.2001:
Strategic alliances along the Niagara wine route
. Tourism Management22,
21-30
.
95.
Tefler, D. J.
and
Wall, G.1996:
Linkages between tourism and food production
. Annals of Tourism Research23(3),
635-653
.
96.
Tefler, D. J.
and
Wall, G.2000:
Strengthening backward economic linkages: local food purchasing by three
Indonesian hotels
. Tourism Geographies2,
421-447
.
97.
Torres Maldonado, E.J. 1997: From tropical hell to tourist paradise: state
intervention and tourist entrepreneurship in Mexican Caribbean. Ph.D. Dissertation,
The University of Texas at Austin.
98.
Torres, R. 2000: Linkages between tourism and agriculture in Quintana Roo,
Mexico. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of California at Davis.
99.
Torres, R.2002a:
Cancun’s tourism development from a Fordist spectrum of analysis
. Tourist Studies2(1),
87-116
.
100.
Torres, R.2002b:
Toward a better understanding of tourism and agriculture linkages in the
Yucatan: tourist food consumption and preferences
. Tourism Geographies4(3),
282-306
.
101.
Torres, R.2003:
Linkages between tourism and agriculture in Quintana Roo, Mexico
. Annals of Tourism Research30(3),
546-566
.
102.
Torres, R. M.
and
Momsen, J. H.
(in press) Grin-golandia: the construction of transnational tourism
space in Mexico. In
Bloom, N.
, editor, Mexican lands, American spaces: building a second nation in
Mexico, 1930-present.
Scholarly Resources
.
103.
Torres, R. M.
and
Skillicorn, P. W.2004:
Montezuma’s revenge: how sanitation concerns may injure
Mexico’s tourist industry
. Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly45,
132-144
.
104.
Turner, L.
and
Ash, J.1975: The golden hordes: international tourism and the pleasure
periphery.
London: Constable
.
105.
Tyrakowski, K.1986:
The role of tourism in land utilization conflicts on the Spanish
Mediterranean coast
. GeoJournal13,
19-26
.
106.
Urry, J.1990. The tourist gaze: leisure and travel in contemporary
societies.
London, Newbury Park CA, New Delhi: Sage Publications
.
107.
Urry, J.1995: Consuming places.
London and New York: Routledge
.
108.
USAID and the Caribbean Development Bank1984: The study of linkages between tourism and local agriculture in
Grenada, St. Vincent, St. Lucia and the Bahamas. Study Report.
109.
Valarche, J.
1984:
Agriculture and tourism. Conflict and complementarity: the Swiss example
. In Agriculture and the management of natural resources:
proceedings of the eighth symposium of the European Association of Agriculture
Economics. Milan, Italy.
110.
Vanhove, N.1997: Mass tourism: benefits and costs. In
Wahab, S.
and
Pigram, J. J.
, editors, Tourism, development and growth: the challenge of
sustainability.
London and New York: Routledge
, 50-77.
111.
Villa Rojas, A.1945: The Maya of East Central Quintana Roo.
Washington DC: Carnegie Institution
.
112.
Wall, G.1997: Sustainable tourism: unsustainable development. In
Wahab, S.
and
Pigram, J. J.
, editors, Tourism, development and growth: the challenge of
sustainability.
London and New York: Routledge
, 33-49.
113.
Weaver, D. B.1991:
Atternative to mass tourism in Dominica
. Annals of Tourism Research18,
414-432
.
114.
Weaver, D. B.1998:
Peripheries of the periphery: tourism in Tobago and Barbuda
. Annals of Tourism Research25(2),
292-313
.
115.
Williams, A.
and
Shaw, G.1998: Tourism and the environment: sustainability and economic
restructuring? In
Hall, C. M.
and
Lew, A. A.
, editors, Sustainable tourism: a geographical perspective.
New York: Longman
, 49-59.
116.
World Bank2002: Millennium development goals: eradicate extreme poverty and
hunger. http://www.developmentgoals.org/poverty.htm (last accessed
6 June 2002).
117.
World Tourism Organization (WTO)1999: Tourism highlights.
Madrid: WTO
.
118.
Yah Sánchez, T. 1997: Cancún, Buen Mercado Para los
Productores del País. Novedades de Quintana Roo Monday, 29 April, 1997, 8A
