Fetuses with Neural Tube Defects: ethical approaches and the role of health care professionals in Turkish health care institutions

Abstract

Neural tube defects (NTDs) are very serious malformations for the fetus, causing either low life expectancy or a chance of survival only with costly and difficult surgical interventions. In western countries the average prevalence is 1/1000-2000 and in Turkey it is 4/1000. The aim of the study was to characterize ethical approaches at institutional level to the fetus with an NTD and the mother, and the role of health care professionals in four major centers in Turkey. The authors chose perinatology units of four university hospitals and prepared questionnaires for the responsible professionals concerning their own and their institution’s ethical approaches to the fetus with an NTD and the mother. The investigation revealed that there were no institutional ethical frameworks or ethics committees available to professional teams in the units. The roles of the health care professionals and their individual decisions and approaches based on ethical principles are described. The ethical decision-making process concerning fetuses with NTDs, examples of institutional approaches to the topic and institutional frameworks, and the role of nurses and other health care professionals are all discussed, based on a literature review. The authors suggest that institutional ethical frameworks, ethics committees, professionals’ ethics education and multidisciplinary teamwork should be established for critical situations such as fetuses with an NTD.

Keywords

decision ethics neural tube defects nursing spina bifida Turkey

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ağırbaşlı H , Çalışkan S eds. Spina Bifida nedir?(What is spina bifida?) Istanbul: Istanbul University Publications , 2002: 1-4, 19-19 (in Turkish).

Berkow R. The Merck manual of diagnosis and therapy, fourteenth edition. Rahway NJ: Merck Sharp and Dohme , 1982: 1828-1829.

Cheschier N. Neural tube defects . Int J Gynaecol Obstet 2003; 83: 123-133 .

Zhu H , Wicker NJ , Volcik K et al. Promoter haplotype combinations for the human PDGFRA gene is associated with the risk of neural tube defects . Mol Genet Metab 2004; 81: 127-132 .

Tunçbilek E et al. [other authors not available] Türkiye’de Konjenital Malformasyon Sıklhığı, Dağılımı, Risk Faktörleri ve Yeni Doğan antropometric Değerleri.(The prevalence, distribution, risk factors of congenital malformations in Turkey and anthropometric values of the newborn in Turkey. A nationwide survey.) Ankara: Hacettepe University , May 1996 (in Turkish).

Muller F. Prenatal biochemical screening for neural tube defects . Childs Nerv Syst 2003; 19: 433-435 .

De Wals P , Rusen ID , Lee NS et al. Trend in prevalence of neural tube defects in Quebec . Birth Defects Res Part A Clin Mol Teratol 2003; 67: 919-923 .

Pei LJ , Li Z , Li S et al. Sex distribution of neural tube defects and their birth outcome in high- and low-prevalence areas of China . Zhonghua Yu Fang Yi Xue Za Zhi 2003; 37: 338-341 .

80-86 EUROCAT Working Group . Prevalence of neural tube defects in 20 regions of Europe and the impact of prenatal diagnosis . J Epidemiol Community Health 1991; 45: 52-58 .

10.

Wilson RD , Davies G , Desilets V et al. The use of folic acid for the prevention of neural tube defects and other congenital anomalies . J Obstet Gynaecol Can 2003; 25: 959-973 .

11.

Sawulicka-Oleszczuk H , Kostuch M.

Wplyw pierwotnej profilaktyki kwasern foliowym naczestosc wad cewy nerwowej w wojewodztwie lubelskim. (Influence of folic acid in primary prevention of neural tube defects.)

Ginekol Pol 2003; 74: 533-537 (in Polish).

12.

Deger M. Tibbi Deontoloji ve Tibbi Etik Ders Notlan.(Lecture notes of medical deontology and medical ethics.) Istanbul: Istanbul University Publications , 2004: 26-35 (in Turkish).

13.

Jonsen A , Siegler M , Winslade W. Clinical ethics, fourth edition. New York: McGraw Hill , 1998: 1-46, 117-121, 165-165.

14.

Beauchamp TL , Childress J. Informed consent. In: Veatch MR , ed. Medical ethics. Boston, MA: Jones and Bartlett , 1989: 173-199.

15.

Ackerman T , Strong C. A casebook of medical ethics. New York: Oxford University Press , 1989: 53-56, 61-64, 71-75.

16.

Ahronheim J , Moreno J , Zuckerman C. Ethics in clinical practice. Boston, MA: Little Brown , 1994: 310-329, 337-345.

17.

Willke JC. Abortion. Cincinnati, OH: Hayes , 1991.

18.

Garrison FH. An introduction to the history of medicine. Philadelphia, PA: Saunders , 1929: 171-171, 712-712, 798-798, 878-878.

19.

Castiglioni A. Histoire de la médecine. (History of medicine.) Paris: Payot , 1931: 128-128, 177-177, 245-245, 262-262 (in French).

20.

Bettmann OL. A pictorial history of medicine. Springfield, IL: Charles C Thomas , 1956: 41-41.

21.

Atabek E , Deger M. T1bbi Deontoloji Konular1.(Topics of medical deontology.) Istanbul: Istanbul University , 2000: 115-125 (in Turkish).

22.

Sehiralti M. Aile Plantamas1 Uygulamalarında T1p Etiği ile İlgili Sorunlarınİncelenmesi.(Problems related to medical ethics for family planning practice [Thesis].) Istanbul: Istanbul University, Department of Deontology, 1993 (in Turkish).

23.

Sachedine Z. Islam, procreation and the law . Int Fam Perspect 1990; 16: 107-111 .

24.

Yakit İ.

Kuran’da İnsanın Yaradılışı ve Evrimi. (Creation and evolution of the human being in the Holy Koran.)

Ufuk Ç izgisi 1990: 1(6): 8-15 (in Turkish).

25.

Camp J. Magic, myth and medicine. London: Priory Press , 1973: 35-48.

26.

Fromer MJ. Abortion ethics . Nurs Outlook 1982; 30: 234-240 .

27.

Lyons A , Petrucelli J. Medicine: an illustrated history. New York: Abradale Press , 1987: 50-50, 82-82, 101-101, 214-215.

28.

Yurtcan E. Türk Hukukunda Kürtaj ve Uygulamas1.(Abortion in Turkish legislation and application.) Istanbul: Istanbul Publications , 1984: 102-103, 107-107, 108-108, 112-112 (in Turkish).

29.

Simon A. A right to life for the unborn? The current debate on abortion in Germany and Norbert Hoerster’s legal-philosophical justification for the right to life . J Med Philos 2000; 25: 220-239 .

30.

Renne EP. The pregnancy that does not stay: the practice and perception of abortion by Ekiti Yoruba women . Soc Sci Med 1996; 42: 483-494 .

31.

Debate on the legalization of abortion in Zimbabwe . Wom Global Network Reprod Rights Newsletter. 1994; 45: 18-19 .

32.

Bills to decriminalize abortion in Brazil . Wom Global Network Reprod Rights Newsletter. 1994; 45: 18-18 .

33.

Beller FK , Reeve J. Brain life and brain death - the anencephalic as an explanatory example. A contribution to transplantation . J Med Philos 1989; 14: 5-23 .

34.

Johnsen D. A new threat to pregnant women’s autonomy . Hastings Cent Rep 1987; 17(4): 33-40 .

35.

Kaufman BA. Neural tube defects . Pediatr Clin North Am 2004; 51: 389-419 .

36.

Oi S. Diagnosis, outcome, and management of fetal abnormalities: fetal hydrocephalus . Childs Nerv Syst 2003; 19: 508-516 .

37.

Grunberg J , Rebori A , Verocay MC. Peritoneal dialysis in children with spina bifida and ventriculoperitoneal shunt: one center’s experience and review of the literature . Perit Dial Int 2003; 23: 481-486 .

38.

Di Lorenzo C , Benninga MA. Pathophysiology of pediatric fecal incontinence . Gastroenterology 2004; 126(1 suppl 1): S33-S40 .

39.

Del Gado R , Aceto G , Del Gaizo D et al. Desmopressin for the treatment of nocturnal bedwetting in patients with neural tube closure defects . J Urol 2004; 171: 1656-1658 .

40.

Erdinçler P , Kaynar M , Canbaz B et al.

Meningomyeloselli Çocuklarda Prenatal Tani Konma Sansi. (Prenatal diagnosis in children with meningomyelocele.)

Pernatoloji Dergisi 1995; 3(3-4): 31-34 .

41.

Erdinçler P , Kaynar M , Akar Z.

Meningomyeloselin Cerrahi Tedavisi. (Surgical treatment of meningomyelocele.)

Cerrahpasa T1p Dergisi 1996; 27(1): 33-37 .

42.

Oi S. Current status of prenatal management of fetal spina bifida in the world: worldwide cooperative survey on the medico-ethical issues . Childs Nerv Syst 2003; 19: 596-599 .

43.

Bouchard L , Renaud M , Kremp O , Dallaire L. Selective abortion: a new moral order? Consensus and debate in the medical community . Int J Health Serv 1995; 25: 65-84 .

44.

Julian C , Huard P , Gouvernet J , Mattei JF , Ayme S. Physicians’ acceptability of termination of pregnancy after prenatal diagnosis in southern France . Prenat Diagn 1989; 9(2): 77-89 .

45.

Fletcher J , Lombardo P , Marshall M et al. Introduction to clinical ethics, second edition. Frederrick, MD: University Publishing Group , 1997; 181-205.

46.

Knapp R , Miller C. Clinical epidemiology and biostatistics. Baltimore, MD: Williams and Wilkin 1992; 2-2,10-11,110-110.

47.

Görkey ş. Gebeliğin Sonlandırılmasında Karş1laş1lan Etik Sorunlar. (Ethical problems about abortion.) In: Hatemi H , Doğan H eds. Medikal Etik III.(Medical ethics III.) Istanbul: Yuce , 2001: 80-109.

48.

Beauchamp T , Childress JF. Principles of biomedical ethics, third edition. New York: Oxford University Press , 1989.

49.

Weir R. Selective treatment of handicapped newborns: moral dilemmas in neonatal medicine. New York: Oxford University Press , 1984.

50.

Ramsey P. Ethics at the edges of life. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press , 1978: 155-155.

51.

Doğan H. Neural Tüp Defektleri ve Etik Yaklaş1mlar. (Neural tube defects and ethical approaches.) In: Hatemi H , Doğan H , eds. Medikal Etik III.(Medical ethics III.) Istanbul: Yuce , 2001: 151-154.

52.

Freeman JM. Making decisions for the severely handicapped newborn . J Health Polit Policy Law 1986; 11: 285-296 .

53.

The prognosis for babies with meningomyelocele and high lumbar paraplegia at birth. Comment by an ethical working group . Lancet 1985; ii: 996-997 .

54.

Bliton MJ. Ethics: ‘life before birth’ and moral complexity in maternal-fetal surgery for spina bifida . Clin Perinatol 2003; 30: 449-464 .

55.

Lyerly AD , Mahowald MB. Maternal-fetal surgery: the fallacy of abstraction and the problem of equipoise . Health Care Anal 2001; 9: 151-165 .

56.

Mrozik E.

Problematik und Möglichkeiten der Fetalchirurgie. (Problems of and possibilities in fetal surgery.)

Geburtshilfe Frauenheilkd 1985; 45: 503-510 (in German).

57.

Smith A. The teaching of medical ethics . J Med Ethics 1985; 11: 35-36 .

58.

Karmarkar SJ. Spina bifida clinic - organisational aspects . Indian J Pediatr 1997; 64(6 suppl): 83-85 .

59.

Chervenak FA , McCullough LB. A comprehensive ethical framework for fetal research and its application to fetal surgery for spina bifida . Am J Obstet Gynecol 2002; 187: 10-14 .

60.

Chervenak FA , Mc McCullough LB. The Cornell University experience . Fetal Diagn Ther 2003; 18: 217-222 .

61.

Andrews DR. Fostering ethical competency: an ongoing staff development process that encourages professional growth and staff satisfaction . J Contin Educ Nurs 2004; 35: 27-33 .

62.

Van Cleve L. Nurses’ experience caring for anencephalic infants who are potential organ donors . J Pediatr Nurs 1993; 8: 79-84 .

63.

Perkin RM , Young T , Freier MC et al. Stress and distress in pediatric nurses: lessons from Baby K . Am J Crit Care 1997; 6: 225-232 .

64.

Burkett KW. Trends in pediatric rehabilitation . Nurs Clin North Am 1989; 24: 239-255 .

65.

Hasenau SM , Covington C. Neural tube defects . Am J Matern Child Nurs 2002; 27(2): 87-91 .

66.

Grant SS. Prenatal genetic screening . Online J Issues Nurs 2000; 5(3): 2-2 . Retrieved 8 March, 2004, from: http://www.nursingworld.org/ojin/topic13/tpc13_3.htm

67.

Fry ST. The ethical dimensions of policy for prenatal diagnostic technologies: the case of maternal serum alpha-fetoprotein screening . ANS Adv Nurs Sci 1987; 9(3): 44-55 .

68.

Schrander-Stumpel C.

Preconception care: challenge of the new millennium?

Am J Med Genet 1999; 89(2): 58-61 .

69.

Zipitis CS , Paschalides C. Caring for a child with spina bifida: understanding the child and carer . J Child Health Care 2003; 7: 101-112 .

70.

Sawin KI , Bellin MH , Roux G et al. The experience of parenting an adolescent with spina bifida . Rehabil Nurs 2003; 28: 173-185 .

71.

Benjamin C. The use of health care resources by young adults with spina bifida . Z Kinderchir 1988; 43(suppl 2): 12-14 .

72.

Holmbeck GN , Johnson SZ , Wills KE et al. Observed and perceived parental overprotection in relation to psychosocial adjustment in preadolescents with a physical disability: the mediational role of behavioural autonomy . J Consult Clin Psychol 2002; 70: 96-110 .

73.

Monsen RB. Mothers’ experiences of living worried when parenting children with spina bifida . J Pediatr Nurs 1999; 14: 157-163 .

74.

Macias MM , Saylor CF , Rowe BP , Bell NL. Age-related parenting stress differences in mothers of children with spina bifida . Psychol Rep 2003; 93: 1223-1232 .