Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2002-07
‘Death... more desirable than life’? The human skeletal record and toxicological implications of ancient copper mining and smelting in Wadi Faynan,southwestern Jordan
Skeletal material from 36 people, dating from the early Christian era, who lived by or worked in the notorious Roman copper mines of Phaeno, were analysed to determine their exposure to copper and lead. We demonstrate that many of the bones analysed had a substantially higher concentration of these cations than modern individuals exposed to metals through industrial processes. Health, toxicological and environmental implications of these data are reviewed.
Agricola, G.1950 (1556): De Re Metallica. Translated by Hoover, H. and Hoover, L.H. New York: Dover Publications.
2.
Ahlgren, L. and Mattsson, S.1979: An X-ray fluorescence technique for in vivo determination of lead concentration in a bone matrix. Physics in Medicine and Biology24, 136-145.
3.
Ahlgren, L., Liden, K., Mattsson, S. and Tejning, S.1976: X-ray fluorescence analysis of lead in human skeleton in vivo. Scandinavian Journal of Work and Environmental Health2, 82-86.
4.
Alloway, B. J. and Ayres, D. C.1993: Chemical principles of environmental pollution. London: Blackie Academic and Professional.
5.
Baranowska, I., Czernicki, K. and Aleksandrowicz, R.1995: The analysis of lead, cadmium, zinc, copper and nickel content in human bones from the Upper Silesian industrial district. The Science of the Total Environment159, 155-162.
6.
Barjous, M.1992: Geology of the Ash-Shawbak area. Map Sheet 3151 III. Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan: NRA, National Mapping Division.
7.
Barker, G. W., Adams, R., Creighton, O. H., Gilbertson, D. D., Grattan, J. P., Mattingly, D. J., McLaren, S., Newson, P., Reynolds, T. E. G. and Thomas, D. C.1998: Environment and land use in the Wadi Faynan: geoarchaeology and landscape archaeology. Levant30, 5-25.
8.
Barker, G. W., Adams, R.Creighton, O. H., Crook, D., Gilbertson, D. D., Grattan, J. P., Hunt, C. O., Mattingly, D. J., McLaren, S., Mohammed, H. A., Newson, P., Palmer, C., Pyatt, F. B., Reynolds, T. E. G. and Tomber, R.1999: Environment and land use in the Wadi Faynan Southern Jordan: the third season of geoarchaeology and landscape archaeology. Levant31, 255-298.
9.
Barker, G. W., Adams, R., Creighton, O. H., Daly, P., Gilbertson, D. D., Grattan, J. P., Hunt, C. O., Mattingly, D. J., McLaren, S., Newson, P., Palmer, C., Pyatt, F. B., Reynolds, T. E. G., Smith, H., Tomber, R. and Truscott, A. J.2000: Archaeology and desertification in Wadi Faynan: the fourth (1999) season of the Wadi Faynan Landscape Survey. Levant32, 27-52.
10.
Bender, F.1974: Geology of Jordan. Berlin: Gebrü der Born-traeger.
11.
Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment. 1991: Interim Canadian environmental quality criteria for contaminated sites. Report CCME EPC-CS34. Winnipeg, Manitoba.
12.
Cohen, S. R.1979: Environmental and occupational exposure to copper. In Nriagu, J., editor, Copper in the environment Pt II, human health. London: John Wiley, 1-16.
13.
Eusebius. 1969: The history of the church from Christ to Constantine. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books.
14.
Findlater, G., El-Najjar, M., Al-Shiyab, A., O’Shea, M. and Easthaugh, E.1998: The Wadi Faynan project: the south cemetery excavation, Jordan 1996. Levant30, 69-83.
15.
Finlayson, W., Mithen, S., Carruthers, D., Kennedy, A., Pirie, A. and Tipping, R.2000: The Dana-Faynan-Ghuwayr early history project. Levant32, 1-26.
16.
Gee, C., Ramsey, M. H., Maskall, J. and Thornton, I.1997: Mineralogy and weathering processes in historical smelting slags and their effect on the mobilisation of lead. Journal of Geochemistry Experiments58, 249-257.
17.
Gilfillan, SC.1965: Lead poisoning and the fall of Rome. Journal of Occupational Medicine7, 53-60.
18.
González-Reimers, E., Velasco-Vásquez, J., Arnay-de-la-Rosa, M., Santolaria-Fernández, F. and Galindo-Martin, L.2001: Palaeonutritional analysis of the pre-Hispanic population of Fuerte Ventura (Canary Islands). The Science of the Total Environment264, 215-220.
19.
González-Reimers, E., Velasco-Vásquez, J., Arnay-de-la-Rosa, M., Alberto-Barroso, V., Galindo-Martin, L. and Santolaria-Fernández, F.2003: Bone cadmium and lead in prehistoric inhabitants and domestic animals from Gran Canaria. The Science of the Total Environment301, 97-103.
20.
Grattan, J. P., Huxley, S. and Pyatt, F. B.2003a: Modern Bedouin exposures to copper contamination: an imperial legacy?Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety55, 108-115.
21.
Grattan, J. P., Condron, A., Gilbertson, D. D., Karali, L. O., Pyatt, F. B., Taylor, S. and al Saad, Z.2003b: A legacy of Empires? An exploration of the environmental and medical consequences of metal production in Wadi Faynan, Jordan. In Catherine, H., Skinner, W. and Berger, A., editors, Geology and health: closing the gap. Oxford University Press, 99-105.
22.
Hauptmann, A.2000: Zur Fruhen matallurgie des kupfers in Fenan/Jordanien. Bochum: Deutch Bergbau Museum.
23.
Hauptmann, A., Begemann, F., Heitkemper, E., Pernicka, E. and Schmitt-Strecker, S.1992: Early copper produced at Faynan, Wadi Araba, Jordan: the composition of ores and copper. Archaeomaterials6, 1-33.
24.
Hong, S., Candelone, J.-P., Patterson, C. C. and Boutron, C. F.1994: Greenland ice evidence of hemispheric lead pollution two millennia ago by Greek and Roman civilisations. Science265, 1841-1843.
25.
Hong, S., Candelone, J.-P., Patterson, C. and Boutron, C. F., 1996: History of ancient copper smelting pollution during Roman and Mediaeval times recorded in the Greenland ice. Science272, 246-249.
26.
Kachur, A. N., Arzhanova, V. S., Yelpatyevsky, P. V., Von Braun, M. and Von Lindern, I. H.2003: Environmental conditions in the Rudnaya River watershed - a compilation of Soviet and post-Soviet era sampling around a lead smelter in the Russian Far East. The Science of the Total Environment. 303, 97-103
27.
Karaki, L.O.A. 1999: Skeletal biology of the people of Wadi Faynan: a bioarchaeological study. Unpublished MA Thesis. Jordan: Yarmouk University.
28.
Klein, S. and Hauptmann, A.1999: Iron Age leaded tin bronzes from Khirbet edh-Dharih, Jordan. Journal of Archaeological Science26, 1075-1082.
29.
Knauf, E. A. and Lentzen, C. J.1987: Edomite copper industry. Studies in the History and Archaeology of Jordan3, 83-88.
30.
Leita, L., Enne, G., De Nobile, M., Baldini, M. and Segui, P.1991: Heavy metal bioaccumulation in lamb and sheep bred in smelting and mining areas of SW Sardinia, Italy. Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology48, 887-893.
31.
Maskall, J. E. and Thornton, I.1998: Chemical partitioning of heavy metals in soils, clays and rocks at Historical lead smelting sites. Water, Air and Soil Pollution108, 391-409.
32.
Mason, J.1979: A conspectus of research on copper metabolism and requirements. Journal of Nutrition109, 1979-2006.
33.
Moustakas, M., Ouzounidou, G., Symeonidis, L. and Karataglis, S.1997: Field study of the effects of excess copper on wheat photosynthesis and productivity. Soil Science and Plant Nutrition43, 531-539.
34.
Nriagu, J., Sakamoto, M., Blum, J., Klaue, B., Schwarcz, H., Prowse, T., Machiarelli, R. and Bondioli, L. In press: Exposure of a Roman Middle Class population to lead. The Science of the Total Environment.
35.
Oakberg, K., Levy, T. and Smith, P.2000: A method of skeletal arsenic analysis, applied to the chalcolithic copper smelting site of Shiqmim, Israel. Journal of Archaeological Science27, 895-901.
36.
Pike, A. W. G. and Richards, M. P.2002: Diagenetic arsenic uptake in archaeological bone. Can we really identify copper smelters?Journal of Archaeological Science29, 607-611.
37.
Pyatt, F. B. and Grattan, J. P.2001: Consequences of ancient mining activities on the health of ancient and modern human populations. Journal of Public Health Medicine23, 235-236.
38.
Pyatt, F. B. and Grattan, J. P.2002: A public health problem? Aspects and implications of the ingestion of copper and lead contaminated food by Bedouin. Environmental Management and Health13, 467-470.
39.
Pyatt, F. B., Barker, G. W., Birch, P., Gilbertson, D. D., Grattan, J. P. and Mattingly, D. J.1999: King Solomon’s miners - starvation and bioaccumulation? An environmental archaeological investigation in southern Jordan. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety43, 305-308.
40.
Pyatt, F. B., Gilmore, G., Grattan, J. P., Hunt, C. O. and McLaren, S.2000: An imperial legacy? An exploration of ancient metal mining and smelting in Southern Jordan. Journal of Archaeological Science27, 771-778.
41.
Pyatt, F. B., Amos, D., Grattan, J. P., Pyatt, A. J. and Terrell-Nield, C. E.2002: Invertebrates of Ancient heavy metal spoil and smelting tip sites in Southern Jordan: their distribution and use as bio indicators of metalliferrous pollution derived from ancient sources. Journal of Arid Environment52, 53-62.
42.
Rabb’a, I.1994: The geology of the Al Quraryqira (Jabal Hamra Fadda). Map Sheet 305 II. Amman: Geology Directorate, Geological Mapping Division, Bulletin 28.
43.
Rice, T. M., Clarke, R. W., Godleski, J. J., Al-Mutairi, E., Jiang, N., Hauser, R. and Paulauskis, J. D.2001: Differential ability of transition metals to induce pulmonary inflammation. Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology177, 46-53.
44.
Scheinberg, I. H.1979: Human health effects of copper. In Nriagu, J., editor, Copper in the environment Pt II, human health. London: John Wiley, 17-39.
45.
Schick, R.1995: The Christian communities of Palestine from Byzantine to Islamic rule: a historical and archaeological study. London: Darwin Press.
46.
Skinner, H. C. W.2000: In praise of phosphates, or why vertebrates chose apatite to mineralise their skeletal elements. Geology International42, 232-240.
47.
Tandon, S. K., Chatterjee, M., Bhargava, A., Shukla, V. and Bihari, V.2001: Lead poisoning in Indian silver refiners. The Science of the Total Environment281, 177-182.
48.
Theophanides, T. and Anastassopoulou, J.2002: Copper and carcinogenesis. Critical Reviews in Oncology/Hematology42, 57-64.
49.
Waldron, T.1988: The heavy metal burden in ancient societies. In Grupe, G. and Herrann, B., editors, Trace elements in environmental history. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 125-133.
50.
Wittmers, L. E., Wallgren, J., Allich, A., Aufderheide A. C. and Rapp, G.1988: Lead in bone IV. Distribution of lead in the human skeleton. Archives of Environmental Health43, 381-391.
51.
Williams, D. M.1982: Clinical significance of copper deficiency and toxicity in the world population. In Prasad, A. S., editor, Clinical, biochemical and nutritional aspects of trace elements. New York: A.R. Liss, 277-299.
52.
Ylaranta, T.1996: Uptake of heavy metals by plants from airborne deposition and polluted soils. Agriculture and Food Science in Finland5, 431-477.
