David Harvey's recent book, Justice, nature and the geography of difference (JNGD), engages with a central philosophical debate that continues to dominate human geography: the tension between the radical Marxist project of recent decades and the apparently disempowering relativism and ‘play of difference’ of postmodern thought. In this book, Harvey continues to argue for a revised ‘post-Marxist’ approach in human geography which remains based on Hegelian-Marxian principles of dialectical thought. This article develops a critique of that stance, drawing on the work of Jacques Derrida, Gilles Deleuze and Felix Guattari. I argue that dialectical thinking, as well as Harvey's version of ‘post-Marxism’, has been undermined by the wide-ranging ‘post-’ critique. I suggest that Harvey has failed to appreciate the full force of this critique and the implications it has for ‘post-Marxist’ ontology and epistemology. I argue that ‘post-Marxism’, along with much contemporary human geography, is constrained by an inflexible ontology which excessively prioritizes space in the theory produced, and which implements inflexible concepts. Instead, using the insights of several ‘post-’ writers, I contend there is a need to develop an ontology of ‘context’ leading to the production of ‘contextual theories’. Such theories utilize flexible concepts in a multilayered understanding of ontology and epistemology. I compare how an approach which produces a ‘contextual theory’ might lead to more politically empowering theory than ‘post-Marxism’ with reference to one of Harvey's case studies in JNGD.
Adorno, T.1973: Negative dialectics. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul .
2.
Albert, M.1993: Capitalism against capitalism (trans. P. Haviland). London: Whurr .
3.
Amin, A. and Thrift, N. , editors, 1994: Globalization, institutions, and regional development in Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
4.
Arac, J. , editor, 1988: After Foucault: humanistic knowledge, postmodern challenges. London: Rutgers University Press .
5.
Arthur, C.1984: Dialectics of labour. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
6.
Barnes, T.1994: Probable writing: Derrida, deconstruction, and the quantitative revolution in human geography . Environment and Planning A26, 1021–1040 .
7.
Barrett, M.1991: The politics of truth: from Marx to Foucault. Cambridge: Polity Press .
Bernstein, R.1983: Beyond objectivism and relativism: science, hermeneutics and praxis. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
10.
Bernstein, R.1991: The new constellation. Cambridge: Polity Press .
11.
Best, S. and Kellner, D.1991: Postmodern theory. London: Macmillan .
12.
Bhabha, H. , editor, 1990: Nation and narration. London: Routledge .
13.
Bhabha, H. , editor, 1993: The location of culture. London: Routledge .
14.
Bhaskar, R.1993: Dialectic: the pulse of freedom. London: Verso .
15.
Bingham, N.1997: Object-ions: from technological determinism towards geographies of relations . Environment and Planning D: Society and Space14, 635–657 .
16.
Bogue, R.1989: Deleuze and Guattari. London: Routledge .
17.
Bohm, D.1980: Wholeness and the implicate order. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul .
18.
Bohm, D. and Peat, F.1989: Science, order and creativity. London: Routledge .
19.
Boyne, R.1990: Foucault and Derrida: the other side of reason. London: Unwin Hyman .
20.
Bridge, G.1997: Towards a situated universalism: on strategic rationality and ‘local theory’ . Environment and Planning D: Society and Space15, 633–639 .
21.
Butler, J.1987: Subjects of desire: Hegelian reflections in twentieth century France. New York: Columbia University Press .
22.
Butler, J.1990: Gender trouble: feminism and the subversion of identity. London: Routledge .
23.
Butler, J.1993: Bodies that matter. London: Routledge .
24.
Cahoone, L. ,editor, 1996: From modernism to postmodernism: an anthology. Oxford: Blackwell .
25.
Callinicos, A.1989: Against postmodernism: a Marxist critique. Cambridge: Polity Press .
26.
Cameron, J. 1995: Ironing out the family: class, gender and power in the household. Unpublished paper, Department of Geography and Environmental Science, Monash University, Clayton, Australia.
27.
Castells, M.1996: The rise of the network society. Oxford: Blackwell .
28.
Chambers, I. and Curti, L. , editors, 1996: The postcolonial question. London: Routledge .
29.
Christopherson, S.1989: On being outside the project . Antipode21, 83–89 .
30.
Coletti, R.1975: Marxism and the dialectic . New Left Review93, 3–29 .
31.
Corbridge, S.1998: Reading David Harvey: entries, voices, loyalties . Antipode3043–55 (special issue: review symposium on David Harvey's ‘JNGD’).
32.
Deleuze, G.1969: The logic of meaning [Logique de sens]. Paris: Minuit .
33.
Deleuze, G.1988 [1966]: Bergsonism (trans. H. Tomlimson and B. Habberjam). New York: Zone Books .
34.
Deleuze, G.1994 [1968]: Difference and repetition (trans. P. Patton). London: Athlone Press .
35.
Deleuze, G. and Guattari, F.1972: Anti-Oedipus: capitalism and schizophrenia. London: Athlone Press .
36.
Deleuze, G. and Guattari, F.1982: A thousand plateaus. London: Athlone Press .
37.
Deleuze, G. and Guattari, F.1994: What is philosophy?London: Verso .
38.
Derrida, J.1973 [1967]: ‘Speech and phenomena’ and other essays on Husserl's theory of signs(trans. D. Allison). Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press .
Derrida, J.1982 [1972]: Margins of philosophy (trans A. Bass). Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press .
45.
Derrida, J.1991 [1982]: From ‘Différance’. In Camuf, P. , editor, A Derrida reader: between the blinds, Oxford: Blackwell .
46.
Derrida, J.1994: Spectres of Marx: the state of debt, the work of mourning and the new international. London: Routledge .
47.
Diamond, I. and Quinby, L. , editors, 1988: Feminism and Foucault: reflections on resistance. Boston, MA: Northeastern University Press .
48.
Dicken, P.1994: Global–local tensions: firms and states in the global space-economy . Economic Geography70, 101–128 .
49.
Diskin, J. and Sandler, B.1993: Essentialism and the economy in the post-Marxist imaginery: reopening the sutures . Rethinking Marxism6: 28–48 .
50.
Docherty, T.1990: After theory: postmodernism/ postmarxism. London: Routledge .
51.
Doel, M.1996: A hundred thousand lines of flight: a machinic introduction to the nomad thought and scrumpled geography of Gilles Deleuze and Félix Guattari . Environment and Planning D: Society and Space14, 421–439 .
52.
Dreyfus, H. and Rabinow, P.1982: Michel Foucault: beyond structuralism and hermeneutics. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press .
53.
Duncan, J. and Ley, D. , editors, 1993: Place/ culture/representation. London: Routledge .
54.
Eckersley, R.1992: Environmentalism and political theory: towards an ecocentric approach. London: University College Press .
55.
Evans, J.1977: Aristotle's conception of dialectic. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
56.
Foucault, M.1979: The history of sexuality: an introduction. London: Allen Lane .
57.
Foucault, M.1980: Power/knowledge: selected interviews and other writings1972–1977 (ed. C. Gordon ). Brighton: Harvester .
58.
Foucault, M.1981: The order of discourse (trans. R. Young). In Young, R. , editor, Untying the text: a poststructuralist reader, London: Routledge .
59.
Foucault, M.1984: Nietzsche, genealogy, history. (trans. D. Bouchard and S. Simon). In Rabinow, P. , editor, The Foucault reader, New York: Pantheon .
60.
Foucault, M.1993: About the beginning of the hermeneutics of the self: two lectures at Dartmouth . Political Theory21: 200–227 .
61.
Fraad, H. , Resnick, S. and Wolff, R.1994: Bringing it all back home: class, gender and power in the modern household. London: Pluto .
62.
Game, A.1991: Undoing the social: towards a deconstructive sociology. Milton Keynes: Open University Press .
63.
Geras, N.1987: Post-Marxism?New Left Review163, 40–82 .
64.
Gergen, T.1991: The saturated self: dilemmas of identity in contemporary life. New York: Basic Books .
65.
Gibson-Graham, J.K.1996: The end of capitalism (as we knew it). Oxford: Blackwell .
66.
Goodchild, P.1996: Gilles Deleuze and the question of philosophy. Cranbury: Associated University Press .
67.
Goodman, R. and Fisher, W. , editors, 1994: Rethinking knowledge: reflections across the disciplines. Albany, NY: State of New York University Press .
68.
Graham, J.1992: Anti-essentialism and overdetermination – a response to Dick Peet . Antipode24, 141–156 .
Gregory, D. , Martin, R. and Smith, G.1994: Introduction: human geography, social change and social science. In Gregory, D. , Martin, R. and Smith, G. , editors, Human geography: society, space and social science, Basingstoke: Macmillan .
71.
Grosz, E.1994: A thousand tiny sexes: feminism and rhizomatics. In Boundas, C. and Olkowski, D. , editors, Gilles Deleuze and the theater of philosophy, London: Routledge .
72.
Habermas, J.1987: The philosophical discourse of modernity. Oxford: Blackwell .
73.
Hall, S.1990: Cultural identity and the diaspora. In Rutherford, J. , editor, Identity, London: Lawrence and Wishart .
74.
Hall, S.1992: The question of cultural identity. In Hall, S. , Held, D. and McGrew, A. , editors, Modernity and its futures, Cambridge: Polity .
75.
Hampden-Turner, C. and Trompenaars, A.1994: The seven cultures of capitalism. London: Piatkus Press .
76.
Haraway, D.1988: Situated knowledges: the science question in feminism and the privilege of the partial perspective. In Haraway, D. , editor, Simians, cyborgs and women: the reinvention of nature, London: Free Association Books .
77.
Haraway, D.1990: A manifesto for cyborgs: science, technology and socialist feminism in the, 1980s. In Nicholson, L. , editor, Feminism/postmodernism, London: Routledge .
78.
Hartsock, N.1987: Rethinking modernism: minority and majority theories . Cultural Critique7, 187–206 .
79.
Harvey, D.1973: Social justice and the city. Oxford: Blackwell .
80.
Harvey, D.1982: The limits to capital. Oxford: Blackwell .
81.
Harvey, D.1985: The urban experience. Oxford: Blackwell .
82.
Harvey, D.1989: The condition of postmodernity. Oxford: Blackwell .
83.
Harvey, D.1995: A geographer's guide to dialectical thinking. In Cliff, A. et al., editors, Diffusing geography, London: Institute of British Geographers .
84.
Harvey, D.1996: Justice, nature and the geography of difference. Oxford: Blackwell .
85.
Hegel, G.1967 [1821]: The philosophy of right (trans. T. Knox). Oxford: Oxford University Press .
86.
Hegel, G.1977 [1802]: Phenomenology of spirit. Oxford: Clarendon Press .
87.
Heller, A.1990: Can modernity survive?Cambridge: Polity Press .
88.
Hirst, P. and Thompson, G.1996: Globalization in question. London: Sage .
89.
hooks, B.1990: Yearning: race, gender and cultural politics. London: Turnaround .
90.
Hoy, D.1986: Foucault: a critical reader. Oxford: Blackwell .
91.
Hutton, W.1995: The state we're in. London: Jonathan Cape .
92.
Irigaray, L.1985a: Speculum of the other women. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press .
93.
Irigaray, L.1985b: This sex which is not one. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press .
94.
Jameson, F.1989: Marxism and post-modernism . New Left Review176, 31–46 .
95.
Jay, M.1986: The dialectical imagination: a history of the Frankfurt school. London: Heinemann .
96.
Kaplan, E. and Sprinker, M. , editors, 1993: The Althusserian legacy. New York: Verso .
97.
Kariel, H.1989: The desperate politics of postmodernism. Amhurst: University of Massachusetts Press .
98.
Katz, C.1995: Major/minor: theory, nature, and politics . Annals of the Association of American Geographers85, 164–168 .
99.
Katz, C.1996: Towards minor theory . Environment and Planning D: Society and Space14, 487–499 .
100.
Kearney, R.1984: Interview between Derrida and Kearney. In Kearney, R. , editor, Dialogues with contemporary continental thinkers, Manchester: Manchester University Press .
101.
Keith, M. and Pile, S. , editors, 1993: Place and the politics of identity. London: Routledge .
Kristeva, J.1987: Black sun (trans. L.S. Roudiez). New York: Columbia University Press .
104.
Laclau, E.1995: This time is out of joint . Diacritics25, 86–96 .
105.
Laclau, E. and Mouffe, C.1985: Hegemony and socialist strategy. London: Verso .
106.
Latour, B.1993: We have never been modern (trans. C. Porter). London: Harvester Wheatsheaf .
107.
Latour, B.1996: Aramis, or the love of technology (trans. C. Porter). London: Harvester Wheatsheaf .
108.
Law, J. , editor, 1992: A sociology of monsters. London: Routledge .
109.
Law, J. , 1994: Organising modernity. Oxford: Blackwell .
110.
Lechte, J.1994: 50 key contemporary thinkers: from structuralism to postmodernity. London: Routledge .
111.
Lefebvre, H.1991 [1974]: The production of space. Cambridge, MA: Blackwell .
112.
Levins, R. and Lewonthin, R.1985: The dialectical biologist. Cambridge, MA: Blackwell .
113.
Leyshon, A. and Pollard, J. 1997: Globalization, conventions of restructuring and the regional reorganisation of banking . Paper given at RGS/IBG Conference, Exeter, January. Available from the authors: Andrew Leyshon, School of Geographical Sciences, University of Bristol, University Road, Bristol BS8 1SS, UK, and Jane Pollard, Department of Geography, University of Birmingham, Edgbaston, Birmingham B15 2TT, UK.
114.
Lipietz, A.1988: Reflections on a tale: the Marxist foundations of the concepts of regulation and accumulation . Studies in Political Economy26, 7–36 .
115.
Lipietz, A.1993: From Althusserianism to ‘regulation theory’. In Kaplan, E. and Sprinker, M. , editors, The Althusserian legacy, New York: Verso .
116.
Lloyd, G.1984: The man of reason: ‘male’ and ‘female’ in western philosophy. London: Methuen .
117.
Lyons, M.1996: Employment, feminisation and gentrification in London 1981–93 . Environment and Planning A28, 341–356 .
118.
Lyotard, J.1984: The postmodern condition. Manchester: Manchester University Press .
119.
Marx, K.1975: Early political writings. Harmondsworth: Penguin .
120.
Massey, D.1993: Politics and space/time. In Keith, M. and Pile, S. , editors, Place and the politics of identity, London: Routledge .
121.
Massumi, B.1996: Becoming-Deleuzian . Environment and Planning D: Society and Space14, 395–406 .
122.
McDowell, L.1994: The transformation of cultural geography. In Gregory, D. , Martin, R. and Smith, G. , editors, Human geography: society, space and social science, Basingstoke: Macmillan .
123.
McDowell, L.1997: Capital culture. Oxford: Blackwell .
124.
McDowell, L. and Court, G.1994: Missing subjects: gender, power and sexuality in merchant banking . Economic Geography70229–251 .
125.
McNay, L.1992: Foucault and feminism. Cambridge: Polity Press .
126.
McNay, L.1994: Foucault. a critical introduction. Cambridge: Polity Press .
127.
Meyer, G.1952: Leibniz and the seventeenth century revolution. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
128.
Mouffe, C.1995: Post-Marxism: democracy and identity . Environment and Planning D: Society and Space13, 259–266 .
129.
Naess, A.1989: Ecology, community and lifestyle. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
130.
Norris, C.1987: Derrida. London: HarperCollins .
131.
Norris, C.1993: The truth about postmodernism. Oxford: Blackwell .
132.
Ollman, B.1976: Alienation: Marx's conception of man in capitalist society. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
133.
Ollman, B.1990: Putting dialectics to work: the process of abstraction in Marx's method . Rethinking Marxism3, 26–74 .
134.
Ollman, B.1993: Dialectical investigations. New York: Routledge .
135.
Peet, R.1992: Some critical questions for anti-essentialism . Antipode25, 4-4 .
136.
Pile, S.1993: Human agency and human geography revisited: a critique of ‘new models’ of the self . Transactions Institute of British Geographers18, 122–139 .
137.
Pile, S. and Thrift, N.1995: Mapping the subject: geographies of cultural transformation. London: Routledge .
138.
Pinkard, T.P.1988: Hegel's dialectic: the explanation of possibility. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press .
139.
Probyn, E.1993: Sexing the self: gendered positions in cultural studies. London: Routledge .
140.
Reich, R.1991: The work of nations: preparing ourselves for 21st century capitalism. New York: Vintage .
141.
Resnick, S. and Wolff, R.1987: Knowledge and class: a Marxian critique of political economy. Chicago: Chicago University Press .
142.
Resnick, S. and Wolff, R.1989: The new Marxian economics: building on Althusser's legacy . Economies and Societies, Serie Oeconomia – PE11, 185–200 .
143.
Resnick, S. and Wolff, R. , editors, 1997: Class: the next postmodern frontier. New York: Guilford .
144.
Rorty, R.1991: Essays on Heidegger and others: philosophical papers. Volume 2. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
145.
Rosen, S.1982: Hegel's dialectic and its criticism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
146.
Ruccio, D.1992: Failure of socialism, future of socialists?Rethinking Marxism5, 7–22 .
147.
Sayer, A.1993: Radical political economy. London: Sage .
148.
Sayer, A. and Storper, M.1997: Guest editorial essay: ethics unbound: for a normative turn in social theory . Environment and Planning D: Society and Space15, 1–17 .
149.
Serres, M.1982: Hermes: art, literature and science. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press .
150.
Serres, M.1995: Genesis. East Lansing, MI: University of Michigan Press .
151.
Serres, M. and Latour, B.1995: Conversations on science, culture and technology. East Lansing, MI: Michigan University Press .
152.
Shildrick, M.1997: Leaky bodies and boundaries: feminism, postmodernism and (bio)ethics. London: Routledge .
153.
Simons, H. and Billig, M. , editors, 1994: After postmodernism: reconstituting ideology. London: Sage .
154.
Simons, J.1995: Foucault and the political. London: Routledge .
155.
Smart, B.1992: Modern conditions, postmodern controversies. London: Routledge .
156.
Smith, D.1997: Back to the good life: towards an enlarged conception of social justice . Environment and Planning D: Society and Space15: 1–17 .
157.
Smith, N.1986: Gentrification and uneven development . Economic Geography58, 139–155 .
158.
Smith, N.1987: Of yuppies and gentrification: gentrification, social restructuring and the urban dream . Environment and Planning D: Society and Space5, 151–172 .
159.
Smith, N.1993: Homeless/global: scaling places. In Bird, J. , Curtis, B. , Putnam, T. , Robertson G. , and Tickner, L. , editors, Mapping the futures: local cultures, global change, London: Routledge .
160.
Smith, N. , Duncan, B. and Reid, L.1994: From disinvestment to reinvestment: mapping the urban frontier in the Lower East Side. In Abu-Lughod, J. , editor, From urban village to east village, Oxford: Blackwell .
161.
Soja, E.1996: ThirdSpace. Oxford: Blackwell .
162.
Soll, I.1964: Hegel's metaphysics. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press .
163.
Spivak, G.1987: Subaltern studies: deconstructing historiography. In Spivak, G. , editor, In other worlds: essays in cultural politics, London: Methuen .
164.
Squires, J. ,editor, 1993: Principled positions: postmodernism and the rediscovery of value. London: Lawrence and Wishart .
165.
Still, A. and Velody, I. ,editors, 1992: Rewriting the history of madness: studies in Foucault's Histoire de la folie. London: Routledge .
166.
Strathern, M.1996: Cutting the network . Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute NS 2: 517–535 .
167.
Taylor, C.1994: Multiculturalism: examining the politics of recognition. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press .
168.
Thrift, N.1996: Strange country: meaning, use and style in non-representational theories. In Spatial formations, London: Routledge .
169.
Thrift, N. 1998: The place of complexity . Paper presented at the RGS-IBG Annual Conference, Kingston, January. Available from the author, Nigel Thrift, School of Geographical Sciences, University of Bristol, University Road, Bristol BS8 1SS, UK.
170.
Thrift, N. and Olds, K.1996: Refiguring the economic in economic geography . Progress in Human Geography20, 311–337 .
171.
Thurow, L.1992: Head to head: the coming economic battle among Japan, Europe and America. New York: William Morrow .
172.
Warde, A.1991: Gentrification as consumption: issues of class and gender . Environment and Planning D: Society and Space9, 223–231 .
173.
Whatmore, S.1997: Dissecting the autonomous self: hybrid cartographies for a relational ethics . Environment and Planning D: Society and Space15, 37–53 .
174.
White, S.1991: Political theory and postmodernism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
175.
Whitehead, A.1985: Science and the modern world. London: Free Association Books .
176.
Wood, D.1990: Philosophy at the limit. London: Unwin Hyman .
177.
Wood, D.1992: Derrida: a critical reader. Oxford: Blackwell .
178.
Woodiwiss, A.1990: Social theory after postmodernism: rethinking production, law and class. London: Pluto Press .
179.
Yeatman, A.1994: Postmodern revisionings of the political. London: Routledge .
180.
Young, I.1990a: Justice and the politics of difference. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press .
181.
Young, I.1990b: The ideal community and the politics of difference. In Nicholson, L. , editor, Feminism/postmodernism. New York: Routledge .
182.
Young, I.1998: Harvey's complaint with race and gender struggles . Antipode30, 36–42 (special issue: review symposium on David Harvey's JNGD).
