The Ethical and Religious Directives for Catholic Health Care Services allows the use of an emergency contraceptive for a woman who has been raped, as a defense against her attacker's sperm, provided the drug prevents fertilization and does not act against a conceived human life. Catholic emergency rooms around the country have been pressured to provide Plan B (LNG-EC) to patients seeking help after a sexual assault. Catholic bioethicists have supported the use of this drug based on their interpretation of the scientific literature regarding its mechanism of action. This paper presents a review of the mechanisms of action of LNG-EC when given during the fertile window, showing a high probability that it acts against human life rather than preventing fertilization, and proposes another class of drugs as a possible alternative.
AustriacoN.2007. Is plan B an abortifacient? A critical look at the evidence. National Catholic Bioethics Quarterly7: 703–7.
2.
BaramD.A., and BassonR.2007. Sexuality, sexual dysfunction, and sexual assault. In Berek and Novak's gynecology, 14th ed., ed. BerekJ.S., 337–49. Philadelphia: Lippincott, Williams & Wilkins.
3.
BeckmannC.R., and GroetzingerL.L.1989. Treating sexual assault victims: A protocol for health professionals. Female Patient14: 78–83.
4.
BritoK.S., BahamondesL., NascimentoJ.A.A., de SantisL., and MunuceM.J.2005. The in vitro effect of emergency contraception doses of levonorgestrel on the acrosome reaction of human spermatozoa. Contraception72: 225–8.
5.
CataldoP.J.2009. Argument in favor of the use of levonorgestrel in cases of sexual assault. In Catholic health care ethics: A manual for practitioners, 2nd ed., ed. FurtonE.J., CataldoP., and MoraczewskiA.S., 134–41. Philadelphia: The National Catholic Bioethics Center.
6.
Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. 2008. Instruction Dignitas personae (on certain bioethical questions). Boston: Pauline Books and Media.
7.
CorreaA., GilboaS.M., BottoL.D., MooreC.A., HobbsC.A., ClevesM.A., Riehle-ColarussoT.J., WallerD.K., ReeceE.A., and National Birth Defects Prevention Study. 2012. Lack of periconceptional vitamins or supplements that contain folic acid and diabetes mellitus–associated birth defects. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology206: 218e 1–218. e13.
8.
DavisT.J.Jr.2007. Plan B and the rout of religious liberty. Ethics & Medics32(12): 1–4.
9.
do NascimentoJ.A.A., SeppalaM., PerdigaoA., Espejo-ArceX., MunuceM.J., HautalaL., KoistinenR., AndradeL., and BahamondesL.2007. In vivo assessment of the human sperm acrosome reaction and the expression of glycodelin-A in human endometrium after levonorgestrel-emergency contraceptive pill administration. Human Reproduction22: 2190–5.
10.
DurandM., CraviotoM., RaymondE.G., Duran-SanchezO., Cruz-HinojosaM., Castell-RodriguezA., SchiavonR., and LarreaF.2001. On the mechanisms of action of short-term levonorgestrel administration in emergency contraception. Contraception64: 227–34.
11.
DurandM., SeppalaM., CraviotoM., KoistinenH., KoistinenR., Gonzales-MacedoJ., and LarreaF.2005. Late follicular phase administration of levonorgestrel as an emergency contraceptive changes the secretory pattern of glycodelin in serum and endometrium during the luteal phase of the menstrual cycle. Contraception71: 451–7.
12.
DurandM., KoistinenR., ChirinosM., RodriguezJ.L., ZambranoE., SeppalaM., and LarreaF.2010. Hormonal evaluation and midcycle detection of intrauterine glycodelin in women treated with levonorgestrel as in emergency contraception. Contraception82: 526–33.
13.
HamelR.2010. Thinking ethically about emergency contraception. Critical judgments require adequate and accurate information. Health Progress91: 62–7.
14.
JesamC., SalvatierraA.M., SchwartzJ.L., and CroxattoH.B.2010. Suppression of follicular rupture with meloxicam, a cyclooxygenase-2 inhibitor: Potential for emergency contraception. Human Reproduction25: 368–73.
KilpatrickD.G., EdmundsC.N., and SeymourA.K.1992. Rape in America. New York: National Victim Center.
17.
LimH., PariaB.C., DasS.J., DinchukJ.E., LangenbachR., TrzaskosJ.M., and DeyS.D.1997. Multiple female reproductive failures in cyclooxygenase 2-deficient mice. Cell91: 197–208.
18.
McFarlaneJ., MalechaA., WatsonK., GistJ., BattenE., HallI., and SmithS.2005. Intimate partner assault against women: Frequency, health consequences and treatment outcomes. Obstetrics and Gynecology105: 99–108.
19.
McShaneG.J.2009. Postcoital anovulatory hormonal treatment: An overview of the medical data. In Catholic health care ethics: A manual for practioners, 2nd ed., ed. FurtonE.J., CataldoP., and MoraczewskiA.S., 125–31. Philadelphia: The National Catholic Bioethics Center.
20.
NielsenG.L., SorensenH.T., LarsenH., and PedersenL.2001. Risk of adverse birth outcome and miscarriage in pregnant users of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs: Population based observation study and case-control study. British Medical Journal322: 266–70.
21.
NoéG., CroxattoH.B., SalvatierraA.M., ReyesV., VillarroelC., MunozC., MoralesG., and RetamalesA.2010. Contraceptive efficacy of emergency contraception with levonorgestrel given before or after ovulation. Contraception81: 414–20.
22.
NovikovaN., WeisbergE., StanczykF.Z., CroxattoH.B., and FraserI.S.2007. Effectiveness of levonorgestrel emergency contraception given before or after ovulation—a pilot study. Contraception75: 112–8.
23.
PalominoW.A., KohenP., and DevotoL.2010. A single midcycle dose of levonorgestrel similar to emergency contraceptive does not alter the expressions of the L-selectin ligand or molecular markers of endometrial receptivity. Fertility & Sterility94: 1589–94.
24.
ReznikS.E.2010. “Plan B:” How it works. Science shows it is not an abortifacient. Health Progress91: 59–61.
25.
SulmasyD.P.2006. Emergency contraception for women who have been raped: Must Catholics test for ovulation, or is testing for pregnancy morally sufficient?Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal16: 305–31.
26.
U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB). 2009. Ethical and religious directives for Catholic health care services, 5th ed. Washington, DC: USCCB.
27.
von HertzenH., and Van LookP.1996. Research on new methods of emergency contraception. In Readings on emergency contraception, 52–7, 88. New York: Alan Guttmacher Institute.
28.
WilcoxA.J., WeinbergC.R., and BairdD.D.1995. Timing of sexual intercourse in relation to ovulation. The New England Journal of Medicine333: 1517–21.
29.
YeungP., LaethemE., and ThamJ.2009. Argument against the use of levonorgestrel in cases of sexual assault. In Catholic health care ethics: A manual for practitioners, 2nd ed., eds. FurtonE.J., CataldoP., and MoraczewskiA.S., 143–50. Philadelphia: The National Catholic Bioethics Center.
30.
YeungW.S.B., ChiuP.C.N., WangC.H., YaoY.Q., and HoP.2002. The effects of levonorgestrel on various sperm functions. Contraception66: 453–7.
