Heterogeneous austenite grain growth in ASTM A213 Grade T91 steels: Analysis of austenitic grain size distribution using kernel density estimation methodology

Abstract

The present work studies, using statistical methods, the features of austenite grain size distributions (AGSDs) obtained in an ASTM A213-T91 steel by applying two-step thermal cycles, namely, thermal treatment at tempering temperature+‘in situ’ austenitisation. Changes in AGSD were produced by varying the holding time at tempering temperature and the heating rate to austenite. The application of different thermal cycle conditions induced two main characteristics in the AGSDs, i.e. the growth of a few very large grains in a matrix of small to medium sized grains, that is, heterogeneous grain size, and a bimodal grain size distribution in that matrix. Statistical techniques were used to describe the resulting AGSDs and to investigate a possible correlation between bimodality and heterogeneity. The characterisations have been carried out using the kernel density estimation (KDE) technique to compute the underlying statistical distribution, and then applying a significance test able to assess whether or not bimodality, if detected with KDE, is statistically significant. Results indicate that bimodality is evidenced for the higher heating rates to austenite and is very likely related to the development of the heterogeneous grain size structure.

Keywords

T91 steel Austenitisation Bimodality Heterogeneous grain growth Grain size distribution Statistical analysis

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Fujita

: ‘Current progress in advanced high Cr ferritic steels for high-temperature applications’, ISIJ Int. , 1992, 32, 175–181.

Masuyama

: ‘History of power plants and progress in heat resistant steels’, ISIJ Int. , 2001, 41, 612–625.

Klueh

: ‘Elevated temperature ferritic and martensitic steels and their application to future nuclear reactors’, Int. Mater. Rev. , 2005, 50, 287–310.

Maruyama

, Sawada

and Koike

: ‘Strengthening mechanisms of creep resistant tempered martensitic steel’, ISIJ Int. , 2001, 41, 641–653.

Cerjak

, Hofer

and Schaffernak

: ‘The influence of microstructural aspects on the service behaviour of advanced power plant steels’, ISIJ Int. , 1999, 39, 874–888.

Shiue

, Lan

and Chen

: ‘Toughness and austenite stability of modified 9Cr-1Mo welds after tempering’, Mater. Sci. Eng. A , 2000, A287, 10–16.

Shibli

: ‘Performance of P91 thick section welds under steady and cyclic loading conditions: power plant and research experience’, OMNI , 2002, 1, 1–17.

Shome

, Gupta

and Mohanty

: ‘Effect of simulated thermal cycles on the microstructure of the heat-affected zone in HSLA-80 and HSLA-100 steel plates’, Metall. Mater. Trans. A , 2004, 35A, 985–996.

Cuddy

and Raley

: ‘Austenite grain coarsening in microalloyed steels’, Metall. Trans. A , 1983, 14A, 1989–1995.

10.

Sheard

and Nutting

: ‘Examination of recrystallization and grain growth of austenite with the photoemission electron microscope’, Met. Sci. , 1979, 13, 131–135.

11.

Zener

, quoted by Smith in

: Trans. AIME , 1948, 175, 15–51.

12.

Peñalba

, García de Andrés

, Carsi

and Zapirain

: ‘Austenitic grain size evolution and continuous cooling transformation diagrams in vanadium and titanium microalloyed steels’, J. Mater. Sci. , 1996, 31, 3847–3852.

13.

Rossi

, Mascanzoni

, Crispoldi

and de Meo

, ‘Development of a Nb-Ti-N steel for production of tractor links by hot forging and direct quenching’, in ‘Fundamentals of microalloying forging steels’, (ed. Kraus

and Banerji

S K

), 351–365; 1987, Warrendale, PA, TMS-AIME.

14.

Gladman

and Pickering

: ‘Grain coarsening of austenite’, J. Iron Steel Inst. , 1967, 205, 653–664.

15.

Coladas

, Masounave

, Guérin

and Baïlon

: ‘Austenite grain growth in medium and high carbon steels microalloyed with niobium’, Met. Sci. , 1977, 11, 509–516.

16.

Speich

, Cuddy

, Gordon

and DeArdo

: ‘Formation of ferrite from control-rolled austenite’, in ‘Phase transformations in ferrous alloys’, (ed. Marder

A R

and Goldstein

J I

), 341–389; 1984, Warrendale, PA, TMS-AIME.

17.

Baker

: in ‘Future developments of metals and ceramics’, (ed. Charles

J A

et al.), 75; 1992, London, Institute of Materials.

18.

San Martin

, García Caballero

, Capdevila

and García de Andrés

: ‘Austenite grain coarsening under the influence of niobium carbonitrides’, Mater. Trans. JIM , 2004, 45, 2797–2804.

19.

Danón

, Servant

, Alamo

and Brachet

: ‘Heterogeneous austenite grain growth in 9Cr martensitic steels: influence of the heating rate and the austenitization temperature’, Mater. Sci. Eng. A , 2003, A348, 122–132.

20.

Brachet

and Alamo

: ‘Alliages martensitiques 9Cr–1Mo: effet des éléments mineurs N, V, Nb sur la précipitation et les transformations de phase’, Mém. Et. Sci. Rev. Métall. , 1990, 87, 33–46.

21.

García de Andrés

and Álvarez

: ‘Optimization of the properties obtained by quenching in martensitic stainless steels X30–40Cr13 and X40–60CrMoV14’, J. Mater. Sci. , 1993, 28, 1264–1268.

22.

Morozov

and Popova

: ‘Influence of heating rate on stability of the fine austenite grain formed during α→γ recrystallization’, Phys. Met. Metall. , 1986, 61, 100–108.

23.

Berbenni

, Favier

and Berveiller

: ‘Impact of the grain size distribution on the yield stress of heterogeneous materials’, Int. J. Plast. , 2007, 23, 114–142.

24.

Ghosh

and Raj

: ‘Grain size distribution effects in superplasticity’, Acta Metall. , 1981, 29, 607–616.

25.

Kurzydlowski

and Bucki

: ‘Flow stress dependence on the distribution of grain size in polycrystals’, Acta Metall. Mater. , 1993, 41, 3141–3146.

26.

Gulyaev

and Serebrennikov

: ‘Effect of differences in grain size on the mechanical properties of steel 18 Kh2N4MA’, Met. Sci. Heat Treat. , 1977, 19, 253–256.

27.

Zavaleta Gutiérrez

, Luppo

, García de Andrés

and Danón

: ‘Heterogeneous austenite grain growth in martensitic 9Cr steel: coupled influence of initial metallurgical state and heating rate’, Mater. Sci. Technol., to be published.

28.

García de Andrés

, Caballero

, Capdevila

and Álvarez

: ‘Application of dilatometric analysis to the study of solid–solid phase transformations in steels’, Mater. Charact. , 2002, 48, 101–111.

29.

ASTM International : ‘Standard test methods for determining average grain size’, Standard E112-10, ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA, USA, 2010.

30.

Silverman

: ‘Density estimation for statistics and data analysis’, in ‘Monographs on statistics and applied probability’; 1986, London, Chapman and Hall.

31.

Ruppert

, Sheather

and Wand

: ‘An effective bandwidth selector for local least squares regression’, J. Am. Stat. Assoc. , 1995, 90, 1257–1270.

32.

Marron

: ‘Smoothing, functional data analysis, and distance weighted discrimination software’, 2008. http://vm1.cas.unc.edu/stat-or/webspace/miscellaneous/marron/Matlab7Software/.

33.

Chang

, Rubin

, Winchell

and Liedl

: ‘The determination of size distribution of martensite plates by kernel estimation’, Scr. Metall. , 1982, 16, 531–536.

34.

Godtliebsen

, Marron

and Chaudhuri

: ‘Significance in scale space for density estimation’, J. Comput. Graph. Stat., 2002, 11, (Special Invited Article), 1–21.

35.

http://www.unc.edu/∼marron/marron.html.

36.

Zavaleta Gutiérrez

: PhD thesis, Institute of Technology ‘Jorge Sábato’, National University of San Martín, San Martín, Argentina, 2010.

37.

Zavaleta Gutiérrez

, de Cicco

, Marrero

, Danón

and Luppo

: ‘Evolution of precipitated phases during prolonged tempering in a 9Cr1MoVNb ferritic-martensitic steel: influence on creep performance’, Mater. Sci. Eng., A , 2011, A528, 4019–4029.

38.

Kurtz

and Carpay

FMA

: ‘Microstructure and normal grain growth in metals and ceramics. Part I: Theory’, J. Appl. Phys. , 1980, 51, 5725–5744.

39.

Bergmann

and Bill

: ‘On the origin of logarithmic-normal distributions: an analytical derivation, and its application to nucleation and growth processes’, J. Cryst. Growth , 2008, 310, 3135–3138.

40.

Chakrabarty

, Davis C

and Strangwood

: ‘Characterization of bimodal grain structures in HSLA steels’, Mater. Charact. , 2007, 58, 423–438.

41.

Vander Voort

and Friel

: ‘Image analysis measurements of duplex grain structures’, Mater. Charact. , 1992, 29, 293–312.

42.

Zavaleta Gutiérrez

, Luppo

and Danón

: ‘Heterogeneous austenite grain growth in ASTM A213-T91 steel’, ISIJ Int. , 2007, 47, 1178–1187.

43.

Abruzzese

and Lücke

: ‘A theory of texture controlled grain growth. I: derivation and general discussion of the model’, Acta Metall. , 1986, 34, 905–914.

44.

, Kazaryan

, Dregia

and Wang

: ‘Computer simulation of texture evolution during grain growth: effect of boundary properties and initial microstructure’, Acta Mater. , 2004, 52, 3869–3879.