Abstract
Neural networks are now a prominent feature of materials science with rapid progress in all sectors of the subject. It is premature, however, to claim that the method is established. There are genuine difficulties caused by the often incomplete exploration and publication of models. The assessment presented here is an attempt to compile a loose set of guidelines for maximising the impact of any models that are created, in order to encourage thoroughness in publication to a point where the work can be independently verified.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
MacKay
D. J. C.
: ‘Information theory, inference, and learning algorithms'; 2003, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press,
2.
MacKay
D. J. C.
: Neural Comput ., 1992 , 4 , 448 –472 .
3.
Sumpter
B. G.
and
Noid
D. W.
Annu. Rev. Mater. Sci , 1996 , 26 , 223 –277 .
4.
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
: ISIJ Int ., 1999 , 39 , 966 –979 .
5.
Sterjovski
Z.
,
Nolan
D.
,
Carpenter
K.
,
Dunne
D.
and
Norrish
J.
J. Mater. Process. Technol , 2005 , 170 , 536 –544 .
6.
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
: Mater. Set Technot , 2008 , 24 , 128 –135 .
7.
Abrahart
R. J.
,
Heppenstall
A. J.
and
See
L. M.
HydroL Set , 2007 , 52 , 414 –432 .
8.
Maier
H. R.
and
Dandy
G. C.
Environ. Modell. Software , 2000 , 15 , 101 –124 .
9.
Gardner
M. W.
and
Dorling
S. R.
Atmosph. Environ ., 2000 , 32 , 2627 –2636 .
10.
Adeli
H.
: Comput.-Aided Civil Infrastruct. Eng ., 2001 , 16 , 126 –142 .
11.
Bulasari
A. B.
: J. Syst. Eng ., 1994 , 4 , 131 –170 .
12.
Vanluchene
R. D.
and
Sun
R.
Microcomput. Civil Eng ., 1990 , 5 , 207 –215 .
13.
Kemp
R.
,
Cottrell
G. A.
,
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
,
Odette
G. R.
,
Yamamoto
T.
and
Kishimoto
H.
J. Nucl. Mater ., 2006 , 348 , 311 –328 .
14.
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
: Mater. Set Technot , 2008 , 24 , 128 –135 .
15.
Chatterjee
S.
,
Murugananth
M.
and
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
Mater. Sci Technol , 2007 , 23 , 819 –827 .
16.
Chaudhury
A.
,
Kahtirkar
R.
,
Viswanathan
N. N.
,
Singhal
V.
,
Ingle
A.
,
Johsi
S.
and
Samajdar
I.
J. Magn. Magn. Mater ., 2007 , 313 , 21 –28 .
17.
Zacharia
T.
,
Vitek
J. M.
,
Goldak
J. A.
,
DebRoy
T. A.
,
Rappaz
M.
and
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
Modell . SimuL Mater. Sci Eng ., 1995 , 3 , 265 –288 .
18.
Ridings
G. E.
,
Thomson
R. C.
and
Thewlis
G.
Sci Technol Weld , 2002 , 7 , 265 –279 .
19.
Mishra
S.
and
DebRoy
T.
Mater. Sci Eng. A, 2007, A454, 477 –486 .
20.
Santos
C. A.
,
Fortaleza
E. L.
,
Ferreira
C. R. F.
,
Spim
J. A.
and
Garcia
A.
Modell. Simul Mater. Sci Eng ., 2005 , 13 , 1071 –1087 .
21.
Brun
F.
,
Yoshida
T.
,
Robson
J. D.
,
Narayan
V.
,
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
and
MacKay
D. J. C.
Mater. Sci Technol , 1999 , 15 , 547 –554 .
22.
Cole
D.
,
Martin-Moran
C.
,
Sheard
A.
,
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
and
MacKay
D. J. C.
Sci Technol Weld. Join ., 2000 , 5 , 81 –89 .
23.
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
: ISIJ Int ., 2001 , 41 , 621 –640 .
24.
Murugananth
M.
and
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
in ‘Mathematical modelling of weld phenomena 6’, (ed. H. Cerjak and H. K. D. H. Bhadeshia), 243-260; 2002, London, Maney.
25.
Murugananth
M.
: ‘Design of welding alloys for creep and toughness’ , PhD thesis , University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK , 2002 .
26.
Lalam
S. H.
,
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
and
MacKay
D. J. C.
Sci Technot Weld Join ., 2000 , 5 , 135 –147 .
27.
Lalam
S. H.
,
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
and
MacKay
D. J. C.
Sci Technot Weld Join ., 2000 , 5 , 149 –160 .
28.
Murugananth
M.
,
Babu
S. S.
and
David
S. A.
Weld. 1, Res. Suppl, 2004, 85, 267s-276s.
29.
Murugananth
M.
,
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
,
Keehan
E.
,
Andren
H. O.
and
Karlsson
L.
in ‘Mathematical modelling of weld phenomena 6’, (ed. H. Cerjak and H. K. D. H. Bhadeshia), 205-230; 2002, London, Maney.
30.
Keehan
E.
,
Andren
H.-O.
,
Karlsson
L.
,
Murugananth
M.
and
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
in ‘Trends in welding research’, (ed.
David
S. A.
and
DebRoy
T.
695-700; 2002, Materials Park, OH, ASM.
31.
Keehan
E.
,
Karlsson
L.
and
Andren
H.-O.
Sci Technot Weld. Join ., 2006 , 11 , 1 –8 .
32.
Keehan
E.
,
Karlsson
L.
,
Andren
H.-O.
and
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
Set Technot Weld. Join ., 2006 , 11 , 9 –18 .
33.
Keehan
E.
,
Karlsson
L.
,
Andren
H.-O.
and
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
Set Technot Weld. Join ., 2006 , 11 , 19 –24 .
34.
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
: Trans. Ind. Inst. Met ., 2006 , 59 , 689 –694 .
35.
Cool
T.
,
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
and
MacKay
D. J. C.
Mater. Sci Eng. A, 1997, A223, 186 –200 .
36.
Singh
S. B.
,
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
Mater. Sci Eng. A, 1998, A245, 72 –79 .
37.
Chatterjee
S.
and
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
Mater. Sci Technol , 2007 , 23 , 606 –609 .
38.
Dimitriu
R.
and
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
Mater. Sci Technol , 2007 , 23 , 1127 –1131 .
39.
Das
S.
: ‘Bake hardening steels’ , Unpublished work , 2007 .
40.
Tenner
J.
,
Linken
D. A.
,
Morris
P. F.
and
Bailey
T. J.
Ironmaking Steelmaking , 2001 , 28 , 15 –22 .
41.
Sourmail
T.
and
Garcia-Mateo
C.
Comput. Mater. Sci , 2005 , 34 , (4 ), 323 –334 .
42.
Mukherjee
M.
,
Singh
S. B.
and
Mohanty
O. N.
Mater. Set Eng. A, 2006, A434, 237 –245 .
43.
Mirapeix
J.
,
Garcia-Allende
P. B.
,
Cobo
A.
,
Conde
O. M.
and
Lopez-Higuera
J. M.
NDT E Int ., 2007 , 40 , 315 –323 .
44.
Raju
D. V.
,
Iqbal
A.
,
Trivedi
A. K.
and
Mukhopadhyay
A.
Ironmaking Steelmaking , 2007 , 34 , 166 –176 .
45.
Mukherjee
M.
,
Singh
S. B.
and
Mohanty
O. N.
Mater. Set Technol , 2007 , 23 , 338 –346 .
46.
Kwak
T.
,
Suzuki
T.
,
Bae
W.
,
Uehara
Y.
and
Ohmori
H.
J. Mater. Process. Technot , 2005 , 170 , (1-2 ), 24 –31 .
47.
Bhadeshia
H. K. D. H.
,
MacKay
D. J. C.
and
Svensson
L.-E.
Mater. Sci Technot , 1995 , 11 , 1046 –1051 .
48.
Su
K. Y.
and
Tak
K. B.
J. Geotech. Geoenviron. Eng ., 2006 , 132 , 1502 –1504 .
49.
Sozen
A.
,
Ozalp
M.
and
Arcaklioglu
E.
Appl. Therm. Eng ., 2006 , 27 , 551 –559 .
50.
Murat
Y. S.
and
Ceylan
H.
Energy Policy , 2006 , 34 , 3165-317
2 .
51.
Inal
F.
: Fuel Process. Technot , 2006 , 87 , 1031 –1036 .
52.
Huang
R.
,
Xi
L.
,
Li
X.
,
Liu
C. R.
,
Qiu
H.
and
Lee
J.
Mech. Syst. Signal Process ., 2006 , 21 , 193 –207 .
53.
Kang
Y.
,
Huang
C. C.
,
Lin
C. S.
,
Shen
P. C.
and
Chang
Y. P.
Tribot Int ., 2006 , 39 , 461 –469 .
54.
Vasudevan
M.
,
Bhaduri
A. K.
,
Raj
B.
and
Rao
K. P.
Mater. Set Technol , 2007 , 23 , 451 –459 .
55.
Xu
L. J.
,
Xing
J. D.
,
Wei
S. Z.
,
Zhang
Y. Z.
and
Long
R.
Mater. Set Technol , 2007 , 23 , 315 –319 .
56.
Patra
K.
,
Pal
S. K.
and
Bhattacharyya
K.
AppL Soft Comput ., 2007 , 7 , 929 –935 .
57.
Diaz
V.
and
Lopez
C.
Corros. Sci , 2007 , 49 , 949 –962 .
58.
Pala
M.
and
Caglar
N.
J. Constr. Steel Res ., 2007 , 63 , 686 –691 .
59.
Dutta
P.
and
Pratihar
D. K.
J. Mater. Process. Technot , 2007 , 184 , 56 –68 .
60.
Vasudevan
M.
,
Rao
B.
,
Venkatraman
B.
,
Jayakumar
T.
and
Raj
B.
J. Mater. Process. Technot , 2005 , 169 , 396 –400 .
61.
Reddy
N.
,
Rao
A. P.
,
Chakraborty
M.
and
Murty
B.
Mater. Sci Eng. A, 2005, A391, (1-2), 131 –140 .
62.
Curcio
S.
,
Scilingo
G.
,
Calabro
V.
and
Iorio
G.
J. Membr. Sci , 2005 , 246 , (2 ), 235 –247 .
63.
Laitinen
P. J.
and
Saxen
H.
Ironmaking Steelmaking , 2007 , 34 , 109 –114 .
64.
Kermanpur
A.
,
Ebnonnasir
A.
and
Hedayati
M.
Mater. Set Technol , 2007 , 23 , 951 –957 .
65.
Lightfoot
M. P.
,
McPherson
N. A.
,
Woods
K.
and
Bruce
G. J.
J. Mater. Process. Technol , 2006 , 172 , 238 –242 .
66.
Guzelbey
I. H.
,
Cevik
A.
and
Erklig
A.
J. Constr. Steel Res ., 2006 , 62 , 962 –973 .
67.
Sahoo
G. B.
,
Ray
C.
,
Mehnert
E.
and
Keefer
D. A.
Set Total Environ ., 2006 , 367 , 234 –251 .
68.
Mandal
A.
and
Roy
P.
J. Mater. Process. Technol , 2006 , 180 , 167 –173 .
69.
Karimzadeh
F.
,
Ebnonnasir
A.
and
Foroughi
A.
Mater. Set Eng. A, 2006, A432, 184 –190 .
70.
Chang
Y. C.
: Build. Environ ., 2006 , 42 , 180 –188 .
71.
Cetinel
H.
,
Ozturk
H.
,
Celik
E.
and
Karlik
B.
Wear , 2006 , 261 , 1064 –1068 .
72.
Walters
S. D.
,
Zoysa
M. M. D.
and
Howlett
R. J.
Meas. Set Technol , 2006 , 17 , 2773 –2782 .
73.
Moosavi
M.
,
Yazdanpanah
M. J.
and
Doostmohammadi
R.
Eng. Geol ., 2006 , 87 , 178 –194 .
74.
Vassilopoulos
A. P.
,
Georgopoulos
E. F.
and
Dionysopoulos
V.
Int. J. Fatigue , 2006 , 29 , 20 –29 .
75.
Bas
D.
,
Dudak
F. C.
and
Boyaci
I. H.
J. Food Eng ., 2006 , 79 , 1152 –1158 .
76.
Shi
J.
,
Liu
X.
and
Sun
Y.
Neurocomputing , 2006 , 79 , 280 –287 .
77.
Guessasma
S.
,
Bounazef
M.
and
Nardin
P.
Int. J. Refract. Met. Hard Mater ., 2006 , 24 , 240 –246 .
78.
Benardos
P. G.
,
Mosialos
S.
and
Vosniakos
G. C.
Robot. Comput.-Integr. Manuf , 2006 , 22 , 505 –514 .
79.
Guzelbey
I. H.
,
Cevik
A.
and
Gogus
M. T.
J. Constr. Steel Res ., 2006 , 62 , 950 –961 .
80.
Graham
L. D.
,
Forbes
D. R.
and
Smith
S. D.
Autom. Constr ., 2006 , 15 , 656 –663 .
81.
Olabi
A. G.
,
Casalino
G.
,
Benyounis
K. Y.
and
Hashmi
M. S. J.
Adv. Eng. Software , 2006 , 37 , 643 –648 .
82.
Yurdusev
M. A.
,
Ata
R.
and
Cetin
N. S.
Energy , 2006 , 31 , 2153 –2161 .
83.
Pao
H. T.
: Energy , 2006 , 31 , 2129 –2141 .
84.
Hao
W.
,
Zhu
X.
,
Li
X.
and
Turyagyenda
G.
J. Mater. Process. Technol , 2006 , 180 , 23 –29 .
85.
Jain
S.
and
Ali
M. M.
IEE Geosci. Remote Sens. Lett ., 2006 , 3 , 467 –470 .
86.
Carvalho
A. A.
,
Rebello
J. M. A.
,
Sagrilo
L. V. S.
,
Camerini
C. S.
and
Miranda
I. V. J.
NDT E Int ., 2006 , 39 , 661 –667 .
87.
Kuzniar
K.
and
Waszczyszyn
Z.
J. Comput. Civil Eng ., 2006 , 20 , 431 –436 .
88.
Axinte
D. A.
: Int. J. Mach Tools Manuf , 2006 , 46 , 1445 –1448 .
89.
Lee
D. J.
and
Cha
S. S.
Opt. Eng., 2006, 45, 107202-1-107202-8.
90.
Sencan
A.
: Renew. Energy , 2006 , 32 , 314 –328 .
91.
Kawabe
H.
,
Tsukiyama
N.
and
Yoshida
K.
Mater. ScL Eng. A, 2006, A442, 547 –550 .
92.
Zhang
M.-X.
and
Kelly
P. M.
Mater. ScL Eng. A, 2006, A438—A440, 272 –275 .
93.
Jia
J.
and
Davalos
J. F.
Compos. Struct ., 2006 , 74 , 106 –114 .
94.
Salam
M. A.
,
Al-Alawi
S. M.
and
Maqrashi
A. A.
J. Electrostat ., 2006 , 64 , 338 –342 .
95.
Nene
N. R.
,
Vieira
A.
and
Barradas
N. P.
NIMB Beam Interact. Mater. Atoms , 2006 , 246 , 471 –478 .
96.
Datta
S.
and
Banerjee
M. K.
Mater. ScL Eng. A, 2006, A420, 254 –264 .
97.
Qiang
L.
,
Yuan
Y. J.
,
Chun
M. B.
and
Dong
S. X.
Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 2006, A419, 214 –217 .
98.
Zhang
H. J.
,
Wang
X. J.
,
Jia
Q. L.
and
Sun
H. W.
Mater. Sci. Technol , 2007 , 23 , 1021 –1026 .
99.
Sanjay
C.
,
Neema
M.
and
Chin
C.
J. Mater. Process. Technol , 2005 , 170 , (3 ), 494 –500 .
100.
Sterjovski
Z.
,
Nolan
D.
,
Carpenter
K.
,
Dunne
D.
and
Norrish
J.
J. Mater. Process. Technol , 2005 , 170 , (3 ), 536 –544 .
101.
Zhecheva
A.
,
Malinov
S.
and
Sha
W.
Surf Coat. Technol , 2005 , 7 , 2332 –2334 .
102.
Bahrami
A.
,
Anijdan
S. M.
,
Hosseini
H. M.
,
Shafyei
A.
and
Narimani
R.
Comput. Mater. Set , 2005 , 34 , (4 ), 335 –341 .
103.
Luo
H.
,
Zeng
H.
,
Hu
L.
,
Hu
X.
and
Zhou
Z.
J. Mater. Process. Technol , 2005 , 170 , (1-2 ), 403 –411 .
104.
Laurinen
P.
and
Rning
J.
J. Mater. Process. Technot , 2005 , 168 , (3 ), 423 –430 .
105.
Parthiban
T.
,
Ravi
R.
,
Parthiban
G.
,
Srinivasan
S.
,
Ramakrishnan
K.
and
Raghavan
M.
Corros . Sci , 2005 , 47 , (7 ), 1625 –1642 .
106.
Guo
Z.
,
Malinov
S.
and
Sha
W.
Comput. Mater. ScL , 2005 , 32 , (1 ), 1 –12 .
107.
Bruschi
S.
,
Casotto
S.
,
Negro
T. D.
and
Bariani
P. F.
CIRP Ann , Manuf Technot , 2005 , 54 , (1 ), 229 –232 .
108.
Kim
I. S.
,
Son
J. S.
,
Park
C. E.
,
Kim
I. J.
and
Kim
H. H.
J. Mater. Process. Technol , 2005 , 159 (1 ), 113 –118 .
109.
Trzaska
J.
and
Dobrzanski
L.
J. Mater. Process. Technol , 2005 , 164 –165 , 1637-1643.
110.
Son
J.-S.
,
Lee
D.-M.
,
Kim
I.-S.
and
Choi
S.-G.
J. Mater. Process. Technot , 2005 , 164 –165 , 1612-1617.
111.
Bahrami
A.
,
Anijdan
S. M.
and
Ekrami
A.
J. Alloys Compd , 2005 , 392 , (1-2 ), 177 –182 .
112.
Dobrzanski
L.
,
Kowalski
M.
and
Madejski
J.
J. Mater. Process. Technot , 2005 , 164 –165 , 1500-1509.
113.
Altinkok
N.
and
Koker
R.
Mater. Des ., 2005 , 26 , (4 ), 305 –311 .
114.
Anijdan
S. M.
and
Bahrami
A.
Mater. Set Eng. A, 2005, A396, (1-2), 138 –142 .
115.
Fu
R.-Q.
,
Xu
T.-W.
and
Pan
Z.-X.
J. Membr. Set , 2005 , 251 , (1-2 ), 137 –144 .
116.
Moliner
M.
,
Serra
J.
,
Corma
A.
,
Argente
E.
,
Valero
S.
and
Botti
V.
Micropor. Mesopor. Mater ., 2005 , 78 , (1 ), 73 –81 .
117.
Chakraborty
D.
: Mater. Des ., 2005 , 26 , (1 ), 1 –7 .
118.
Dobrzanski
L.
,
Drak
M.
and
Trzaska
J.
J. Mater. Process. Technot, 2005, 164-165, 795 –804 .
119.
Jean
M.-D.
,
Liu
C.-D.
and
Wang
J.-T.
AppL Surf Sci , 2005 , 245 , (1-4 ), 290 –303 .
120.
Hamzaoui
O. E. R.
,
Guessasma
S.
and
Gaffet
E.
Mater. ScL Eng. B, 2005, B119, (2), 164 –170 .
121.
Song
K.
,
Xing
J.
,
Dong
Q.
,
Liu
P.
,
Tian
B.
and
Cao
X.
Mater. Des ., 2005 , 26 , (4 ), 337 –341 .
122.
Tymvios
F.
,
Jacovides
C.
,
Michaelides
S.
and
Scouteli
C.
Solar Energy , 2005 , 78 , (6 ), 752 –762 .
123.
Aydiner
C.
,
Demir
I.
and
Yildiz
E.
J. Membr. ScL , 2005 , 248 , (1-2 ), 53 –62 .
124.
Islam
T.
,
Pramanik
C.
and
Saha
H.
Microelectron. Rehab ., 2005 , 45 , (3-4 ), 697 –703 .
125.
Cherigui
M.
,
Guessasma
S.
,
Fenineche
N.
and
Coddet
C.
Mater. Set Eng. B, 2005, B116, (1), 40 –46 .
126.
Cui
W.-Z.
,
Thu
C.-C.
and
Zhao
H.-P.
Thin Solid Films , 2005 , 473 , (2 ), 224 –229 .
127.
Fenineche
N.
,
Guessasma
S.
and
Abdelbaki
N.
Mater. ScL Eng. B, 2005, B119, (1) 65 –70 .
128.
Negro
C.
,
Alonso
A.
,
Blanco
A.
and
Tijero
J.
Compos. Part A , Appl. ScL Manuf , 2005 , 36A , (12 ), 1617 –1626 .
129.
He
X.
,
Zhang
X.
,
Zhang
S.
,
Liu
J.
and
Li
C.
Fluid Phase Equilib ., 2005 , 238 , (1 ), 52 –57 .
130.
Smith
J. R.
,
Kholodovych
V.
,
Knight
D.
,
Kohn
J.
and
Welsh
W. J.
Polymer , 2005 , 46 , (12 ), 4296 –4306 .