Rare earths are among the most promising options for replacing chromate conversion coatings on aluminium. In nearly three decades of research, several hundred papers have been published in the area, the bulk of which has never been reviewed. This paper reviews the literature on rare earth coating processes, with particular emphasis on those based on cerium. It is concluded that several process areas are poorly understood, some of which are critical to further progress in the field. These include the development of industrially suitable pretreatments, technologies for coating non-aerospace alloys and seals to enhance corrosion performance and paint adhesion.
SmithCJEErrickerSLEvansVMKimptonHJSmithKSGibsonM: Proc. 9th European Symp. on ‘Corrosion inhibitors’2000Vol. 1, Ann. Univ. Ferrara, Sez., 2000, 11, (5 Suppl.)415–426.
JeffcoateCSVoevodinNNKhobaibMReynoldsLBKuhnWKDonleyMS: ‘Materials and process affordability – keys to the future’(Book 2), Proc. Int. SAMPE Symp. Exhibition1998Vol. 43, 2113-2122.
6.
BuchheitRGHughesAE: ‘Sect. 4b: chromate and chromate-free conversion coatings’in ‘A corrosion: fundamentals, testing and protection’, Vol. 13720–736; 2003Materials Park, OHAmerican Society for Materials.
7.
DullDLMansfeldFB: ‘Use of rare earth metal salt solutions for sealing or anodized aluminum for corrosion protection and paint adhesion’US Patent 62481842001.
8.
YuPStofferJOO'KeefeTJLinXWuYMorrisE: Proc. Int. Waterborne, High-Solids, Powder Coat. Symp., New Orleans, LA, USA, February 1998, The University of Southern Mississipi, Vol. 25409–422.
9.
StofferJO'KeefeT: ‘Environmentally compliant coatings using non-chromated systems’S442011. AFRLMLWPTR20014163, ADA398836, Air Force Research Laboratory (AFRL), (NTIS) Springfield, VA, USA2001.
10.
ButlerAHintonBMcAdamGHughesAEHardinSGHarveyTGNikpourTStonhamAHarrisSJFigguresCChurchSDixonDMorganPBowdenC: ‘Testing repairs of conversion-coated aluminium alloys’Proc. 3rd Int. Symp. on ‘Aluminium surface science and technology’Bonn, Germany May 2003Benelux Métallurgie.ATB Metallurgie200343(1-2)273–277.
11.
KendigMWBuchheitRG: Corrosion200359(5)379–400.
12.
StofferJOO'KeefeTJAndersonHLinXMorrisEYuPPittmanM: Proc. Int. Waterborne, High-Solids, Powder Coat. Symp.New Orleans, LA, USA February 1999The University of Southern Mississipi, Vol. 2620–34.
13.
StofferJOO'KeefeTJLinXMorrisEYuPHayesS: ‘Surface characterization of cerium based conversion coatings’Proc. 40th AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASC Structures, Structural Dynamics, and Materials Conf. and Exhibition, Vol. 2St. Louis, MO, USA April 1999American Institute of Aeronautics & Astronautics903–917.
14.
OsborneJH: Prog. Org. Coat.200141(4)280–286.
15.
ArenasMABethencourtMBotanaFJde DamboreneaJJDavoBMarcosM: ‘Green inhibition of aluminium alloys in NaCl solution’EUROCORR 2001Riva del Garda, Italy September–October 2001Italian Association of Metallurgy. 10 pp. ISBN 8885298419.
MansfeldFWangY: ‘Corrosion protection of high-copper aluminum alloys by surface modification’Proc. 7th Int. Symp. on ‘Oxide films on metals and alloys’Miami Beach, FL, USA October 1994Electrochemical Society Inc.200–215.
20.
MansfeldFShihH: ‘Chemical passivation of Al alloys and Al-based metal matrix composites in rare earth metal chlorides’Proc. 11th Int. Corrosion Cong. on ‘Innovation and technology transfer for corrosion control (ICC)’, Florence, Italy, April 1990, World Corrosion Organization, Paper no. 4·555-4·564.
SmithCJEHewinsMAHBaldwinKR: ‘Corrosion inhibitors for advanced aerospace aluminium–lithium alloys’Proc. 8th European Symp. on ‘Corrosion inhibitors’, Ferrara, Italy, June 1995, University of Ferrara, Vol. 2807–816.
26.
NylundA: Alum. Trans.20002(1)121–137.
27.
MansfeldFBShihHWangY: ‘Method for creating a corrosion-resistant aluminum surface’US Patent 51941381993.
LinXMorrisEYuPO'KeefeTStofferJ: ‘Electrochemical aspects of coating systems for the corrosion protection of aluminum’Proc. 1st Int. Non-Ferrous Processing and Technology Conf.St Louis, MO, USA March 1997ASM International493–499.
HellerDKFahrenholtzWGO'KeefeMJ: J. Electrochem. Soc.2009156(11)C400–C406.
34.
KendigMBuchheitR: ‘Corrosion inhibition of Al and Al alloys by hexavalent Cr compounds – a mechanistic overview’Proc. Corros. 2000 Res. Top. Symp. on ‘Surface conversions of aluminum and ferrous alloys for corrosion resistance’Orlando, FL, USA May 2000NACE International1–31.
35.
KetchamSJBrownSR: Met. Finish.197674(11)37–41.
36.
HintonBRW: Met. Finish.199189(9)55–61.
37.
HintonBRW: Met. Finish.199189(10)15–20.
38.
HendersonMJHintonBRHughesAETaylorRJTrathenPNWilsonL: ‘Chromate-free conversion coating processes’Proc. Asia Pacific Interfinish’94Melbourne, Vic., Australia October 1994Institute of Metal FinishingVol. II 46.0–11.
RolandWAHartR: ‘Chromium-free metal pretreatment processes’Proc. Interfinish 96 – 14th World Interfinish Congress and ExhibitionBirmingham, UK September 1996Institute of Metal Finishing265–277.
RyanNE: ‘Rare earths in high and low temperature corrosion protection’Proc. Int. Symp. on ‘Rare earths: resources, science, technology and applications’San Diego, CA, USA March 1992TMS389–405.
NelsonKJHTaylorRJHughesAEHintonBRWHendersonMJWilsonLNugentSA: ‘Conversion coating and process and solution for its formation’US Patent 60224252000.
62.
NelsonKJHTaylorRJHughesAEHintonBRWHendersonMJWilsonLNugentSA: ‘Acidic redox bath and process for conversion coating of aluminum alloy surface with an oxide layer finished by sealing’World Intellectual Property Organization Patent 95346931995.
63.
TruemanARMcAdamGHintonBRWHughesAE: ‘Corrosion protection performance and EIS characterisation of a thickened oxide conversion coating containing cerium ions formed on AA2024’Proc. 2nd Int. Symp. on ‘Aluminium surface science and technology’Manchester, UK May 2000University of Manchester270–276.
64.
MansfeldFWangVShihH: J. Electrochem. Soc.1991138(12)L74–L75.
65.
KindlerA: ‘Chromium-free method and composition to protect aluminum’EP Patent 05341201993.
66.
KindlerA: ‘Coating of aluminum with chromium-free protective layer’US Patent 51923741993.
67.
RungtaR: ‘Rare earth coating process for aluminum alloys’US Patent 53623351994.
68.
MillerRN: ‘Non-toxic corrosion resistant conversion coating for aluminum and aluminum alloys and the process for making the same’US Patent 53992101995.
69.
MillerRN: ‘Non-toxic corrosion resistant conversion process coating for aluminum and aluminum alloys’US Patent 53564921994.
70.
MillerRN: ‘Manufacture of corrosion-resistant conversion coatings on aluminum and aluminum alloys using chromate-free baths’US Patent 52213711993.
71.
MillerRN: ‘Non-toxic corrosion resistant conversion coating for aluminum and aluminum alloys’US Patent 54197901995.
72.
HamdyASBeccariaAM: J. Appl. Electrochem.200535(5)473–478.
73.
LuYIvesMB: ‘Method of increasing corrosion resistance of metals and alloys by treatment with rare earth elements’US Patent 60687112000.
74.
BaldwinKRSmithCJELanePL: ‘Treatment of aluminium or aluminium alloys’US Patent 59548931999.
75.
BaldwinKRSmithCJELanePL: ‘Treatment of aluminium or aluminium alloys’World Intellectual Property Organization Patent WO-1996-152961996.
76.
BaldwinKRLanePLSmithCJE: ‘A chromate-free post-anodizing treatment for aluminum alloys using a double-immersion process’Proc. Interfinish 2000, Garmisch-Patenkirchen, German, September 2000, Deutsche Gesellschaft fuer Galvano- und Oberflaechentechnik526–538.
77.
HughesAEHardinSGHarveyTGNikpourTHintonBGalassiAMcAdamGTohSKMcCullochDDDuPlessisJStonhamAHarrisSJFigguresCChurchSDixonDBowdenCMorganP: ‘Characterisation of various conversion coatings on 2024-T3’Proc. 3rd Int. Symp. on ‘Aluminium surface science and technology’Bonn, Germany May 2003Benelux Métallurgie. ATB Metallurgie200343(1-2)264–272.
78.
BethencourtMBotanaFJCauquiMAMarcosMRodriguezMARodriguez-IzquierdoJM: J. Alloys Compd1997250(1-2)455–460.
79.
ArnottDrHintonBRWRyanNE: Corrosion198945(1)12–18.
80.
MansfeldFWangYShihH: ‘Evaluation of the surface properties of aluminum alloys by electrochemical methods’Corrosion 91, NACE Annual Conf. and Corrosion Show, Cincinnati, OH, USA, March 1991, NACE International, Paper no. 134.
YasakauKAZheludkevichMLLamakaSVFerreiraMGS: J. Phys. Chem. B2006110B(11), 5515-5528.
93.
O'DriscollSMcMurrayHNMorganPC: ‘Efficiency of pitting corrosion inhibitors on AA2024 T3 quantified using numerical integrated SVET data’Proc. 42nd Corrosion Science Symp.Swansea, UK September 2001The Institute of Corrosion15–29.
94.
RangelCMPaivaTIda LuzPP: ‘Conversion coatings formation on 2024 aluminium alloy: the effect of cleaning pre-treatments’EUROCORR 2004 ‘Long term prediction & modelling of corrosion’Nice, France September 2004CEFRACOR. 6 pp. ISBN 295168441X</othinfo>.
KimptonHJErrickerSLSmithCJEHarrisSJ: ‘Cerium based conversion coatings for aerospace applications’Proc. 2nd Int. Symp. on ‘Aluminium surface science & technology’Manchester, UK May 2000University of Manchester467–472.
97.
DavenportAJMoulinierFAMLiuBMorganPC: ‘Surface finishing of aluminum aerospace alloys’Proc. 2nd Int. Symp. on ‘Aluminium surface science & technology’Manchester, UK May 2000University of Manchester455–460.
98.
CampestriniPTerrynHde WitJHW: ‘SEM and SKPFM investigation of the formation of the cerium-based conversion coating on 2024-T3 aluminium alloy’Proc. 15th Int. Corrosion Cong. ‘Frontiers in corrosion science and technology’, Granada, Spain, September 2002, National Centre for Metallurgical Research, Paper no. 193-1-8.
99.
YuXLiG: J. Alloys Compd2004364(1-2)193–198.
100.
YuXCaoCYaoZ: J. Mater. Sci. Lett.200019(21), 1907-1908.
de FrutosAArenasMALiuYSkeldonPThompsonGEde DamboreneaJCondeA: Surf. Coat. Technol.2008202(16), 3797-3807.
106.
KolicsABesingASBaradlaiPWieckowskiA: J. Electrochem. Soc.2003150(11)B512–B516.
107.
KendigMJeanjaquetS: J. Electrochem. Soc.2002149(2)B47–B51.
108.
JonesPPadwalAYuPO'KeefeMJFahrenholtzWO'KeefeT: ‘Characterization of alkaline cleaned and cerium oxide coated Al 2024-T3’Proc. Materials Science and Technology 2006 Conf. on ‘Surface protection for enhanced materials performances (MS&T’06)’Cincinnati, OH, USA October 2006American Ceramic Society591–597.
109.
JonesPSYuPPincWRO'KeefeMJFahrenholtzWGO'KeefeTJ: Int. J. Appl. Ceram. Technol.20085(1)63–73.
GengSPincWRJonesPSO'KeefeMJFahrenholtzWGO'KeefeTJ: J. Appl. Surf. Finish.20072(4)276–282.
112.
GengSJoshiSPincWFahrenholtzWGO'KeefeMJO'KeefeTJYuP: ‘Influence of processing parameters on cerium based conversion coatings’Proc. Tri-Service Corrosion Conf.Denver, CO, USA Decemeber 2007NACE International10.
HughesAETaylorRJHintonBRWWilsonL: ‘Characterisation of hydrated cerium oxide conversion coatings’Proc. Asia Pacific Interfinish’94Melbourne, Vic., Australia October 1994Institute of Metal FinishingVol. III 70.1–70.9.
120.
HendersonMJHintonBRWWilsonLTaylorRJNugentSAHughesAENelsonKJH: ‘Metal cleaning treatment with acidic solutions containing rare-earth ions and suitable for desmutting’World Intellectual Property Organization WO Patent 9508008, 1995.
121.
HughesAENelsonKJH: ‘Rare earth conversion coatings – a status report’Proc. Interfinish 96 – 14th World Interfinish Congress and ExhibitionBirmingham, UK September 1996Institute of Metal Finishing241–264.
122.
HughesAEHardinSGWittelKWMillerPR: ‘Accelerated cerium-based conversion coatings’Proc. Corros. 2000 Res. Top. Symp. on ‘Surface conversions of aluminum and ferrous alloys for corrosion resistanceOrlando, FL, USA May 2000NACE International47–66.
123.
HughesAENelsonKJHTaylorRJ.HintonBRWHendersonMJWilsonLNugentSA: ‘Metal treatment with acidic, rare earth ion containing cleaning solution’US Patent 65035652003.
HughesAEHardinSGHarveyTGNikpourTHintonBGalassiAMcAdamGTohSKMcCullochDDDuPlessisJStonhamAHarrisSJFigguresCChurchSDixonDBowdenCMorganP: ‘Some observations on the deoxidation of 2024-T3’Proc. 3rd Int. Symp. on ‘Aluminium surface science and technology’Bonn, Germany May 2003Benelux Métallurgie. ATB Metallurgie200343(1-2)459–466.
127.
HintonBHughesATaylorRHendersonMNelsonKWilsonL: ‘The corrosion protection properties of an hydrated cerium oxide coating on aluminum’Proc. 13th Int. Corrosion Cong. on ‘Towards corrosion prevention’Melbourne, Australia November 1996Australasian Corrosion Association 337.1–337.7.
MolJMCHintonBRWvan der WeijdeDHde WitJHWvan der ZwaagS: J. Mater. Sci.200035(7), 1629-1639.
134.
RangelCMPaivaTIDa LuzPP: ‘Anticorrosion treatments for aluminium and aluminium alloys’Proc. 9th European Symp. on ‘Corrosion inhibitors’, Vol. 1Ferrara, Italy September 2000University of Ferrara507–519.
MorrisEStofferJTriplettLChuppS: ‘Chrome-free coatings for the corrosion protection of high-strength aluminum alloys’Proc. Tri-Service Corrosion Conf.Las Vegas, NV, USA November 2003AMPTIAC1–11.
HughesAETurneyTWNelsonKJH: ‘Acidic bath and process for conversion coating suitable for aluminum alloy surface’World Intellectual Property Organization Patent 96152921996.
151.
HughesAETurneyTWNelsonKJH: ‘Process and solution for providing a conversion coating on a metal surface’US Patent 62069822001.
152.
HardinSGWittelKWHughesAENelsonKJH: ‘Method and solution for providing a conversion coating on aluminum, magnesium, zinc, and alloys on their basis for paint adhesion and corrosion protection I’World Intellectual Property Organization Patent WO-2001-0710582001.
153.
HardinSGWittelKWHughesAENelsonKJH: ‘Method and solution for providing a conversion coating on aluminum, magnesium, zinc, and alloys at their basis for paint adhesion and corrosion protection II’World Intellectual Property Organization Patent WO-2001-0710592001.
154.
HardinSGWittelKWHughesAENelsonKJH: ‘Process and solution for providing a conversion coating on a metallic surface I’US Patent 67735162004.
DabalaMCalliariIMagriniM: ‘Microstructure and corrosion resistance of cerium based chemical conversion coatings on AA 5083 aluminum alloy’EUROCORR 2001Riva del Garda, Italy September–October 2001Italian Association of Metallurgy. 6 pp. ISBN 8885298419.
AballeABethencourtMBotanaFJCauquiMAMarcosMPerezJRodriguez-ChaconMA: ‘Cerium containing coatings on Al-Mg alloys’Proc. EUROCORR’97, Trondheim, Norway1998The Institute of Materials, Vol. II339–344.
BethencourtMBotanaFJCanoMJMarcosM: ‘Cerium based conversion coatings for aluminium alloys. Improving the formation mechanism’Proc. EUROCORR 2001Riva del Garda, Italy September–October 2001Italian Association of Metallurgy. 10 pp. ISBN 8885298419.
BethencourtMBotanaFJCanoMJOsunaRMMarcosM: ‘Ceralumina: cerium-aluminium oxide heterogeneous conversion coating’Proc. 15th Int. Corrosion Cong. on ‘Frontiers in corrosion science and technology’Granada, Spain September 2002National Centre for Metallurgical Research396-1-8.
HughesAEHardinSGHarveyTGNikpourTHintonBMcAdamGGalassiAButlerAStonhamAHarrisSJFigguresCChurchSDixonDMorganPBowdenCRansonM: ‘A methodology for selecting chromate replacements’Proc. 3rd Int. Symp. on ‘Aluminium surface science and technology’Bonn, Germany May 2003Benelux Métallurgie. ATB Metallurgie200343(1-2)467–474.
HughesAETaylorRJHammonKJHintonBRWWilsonL: ‘Surface chemistry in the preparation of 2024 alloy for conversion coating’Proc. Conf. Asia Pacific Interfinish’94Melbourne, Australia October 1994Institute of Metal Finishing Vol. II 38.1–38.10.
ShihHWangYMansfeldF: ‘DC and AC passivation of aluminum alloys’Proc. Conf. Corrosion 91, Cincinnati, OH, USA, March 1991, NACE International, Paper no. 136.
207.
MansfeldFBWangYLinSH: ‘Method for creating a corrosion-resistant surface on an aluminum-copper alloy’US Patent 56350841997.
208.
MansfeldFBWangYLinSH: ‘Method for creating a corrosion-resistant surface on aluminum alloys having a high copper content’US Patent 55826541996.
209.
TadrosME: ‘Nonchromate deoxidizer for aluminum alloys’US Patent 48835411989.
MoulinierFDavenportABowenPMorganP: ‘Effects of a surface treatment on the corrosion and the behaviour of a high strength aluminium alloy’Proc. 42nd Corrosion Science Symp.Swansea, UK September 2001Institute of Corrosion. 11 pp.
215.
MorganPCNichollsP: ‘A desmutting solution for use prior to anodising’Patent GB 23284471999.
216.
MorganPCNichollsP: ‘A desmutting solution and anodising process’Patent EP 08993611999.
JaworowskiMrKryzmanMA: ‘Non-chromium conversion coatings for aluminum alloys’US Patent 66133902003.
229.
TaylorRJHughesAE: ‘The development of a chromium-free conversion coating for aluminium alloys’Proc. Asia Pacific Interfinish 94, Melbourne, Vic., Australia, October 1994, Australasian Institute of Metal Finishing, Paper no. 19.
230.
HintonBRWRyanNEArnottDr: ‘Cerium oxide coatings for corrosion protection of aluminium alloys (retroactive coverage)’Proc. Asia Pacific Interfinish’86 on ‘Surface finishing – today and tomorrow’Hobart, Australia October 1986Australasian Institute of Metal Finishing 34.1–34.9.
WilsonLHintonBRW: ‘A method of forming a corrosion resistant coating’World Intellectual Property Organization Patent WO-1988-066391988.
233.
StofferJOO'KeefeTJLinXMorrisEYuPSitaramSP: ‘Electrodeposition of cerium-based coatings for corrosion protection of aluminum alloys’US Patent 59320831999.
234.
StofferJOO'KeefeTJMorrisELHayesSYuPWilliamsALinX: ‘Additive-assisted cerium-based electrolytic coating process for corrosion protection of aluminum alloys’US Patent 68181162004.
PincWJoshiSO'KeefeMFahrenholtzW: ‘Effect of an artificial defect on the corrosion behavior of a cerium-based conversion coating’Proc. DoD Corrosion Conf. 2009Washington, DC, USA August 2009NACE International. Paper 8013.
237.
StofferJOO'KeefeTJO'KeefeMMorrisELHayesSYuPWilliamsARiveraBFLinX: ‘Cerium-based spontaneous coating of aluminum alloys for corrosion resistance’US Patent US-2004-288202004.
Onofre-BustamanteEDominguez-CrespoMATorres-HuertaAMOlvera-MartinezAGenesca-LlonguerasJRodriguez-GomezFJ: J. Solid State Electrochem.200913(11), 1785-1799.
240.
HintonBRWTrathenPNWilsonLRyanNE: ‘The inhibition of corrosion on mild steel in tap water by cerous chloride’Proc. 28th Conf. of Australasian Corrosion Assoc. on ‘Corrosion: a tax forever’, Perth, Australia, November 1988, Australasian Corrosion Association, Paper no. 4.
EdingtonJO'KeefeMJO'KeefeTJ: J. Electrochem. Soc.2007154(11)D563–D566.
250.
LiJCaoBZhangWTianHGaoL: ‘Improvement of use of cerium salt for aluminum alloys surface treating’Proc. 14th Int. Corrosion Congress (ICC), Cape Town, South Africa, September–October 1999, Corrosion Institute of Southern Africa, 80.2.
251.
MansfeldFBSunZ: ‘Corrosion protection of steel in ammonia/water heat pumps’US Patent 66322942003.
252.
MansfeldMSunZ: ‘Corrosion protection of aluminum alloys and mild steel with rare earth metal salts’Proc. Corros. 2000 Res. Top. Symp. on ‘Surface conversions of aluminum and ferrous alloys for corrosion resistance’Orlando, FL, USA May 2000NACE International32–46.
253.
MansfeldF: Russ. J. Electrochem.200036(10), 1063-1071.
StofferJO'KeefeTJMorrisELHayesSAYuPWilliamsARivera VasquezBFLinX: ‘Cerium-based spontaneous coating process for corrosion protection of aluminum alloys’US Patent 70488072006.
MolJMCHintonBRWHughesAEde WitJHWvan der ZwaagS: ‘Filiform corrosion on coated aluminium alloys: the effect of alloy composition and pretreatment’Proc. 14th Int. Corrosion Congress (ICC), Cape Town, South Africa, September–October 1999, Corrosion Institute of Southern Africa, Paper no. 103.
258.
HardinSGWittelKWHughesAENelsonKJH: ‘Process and solution for providing a conversion coating on a metallic surface I’Patent EP 11986142002.
MansfeldF: ‘Surface modification of aluminum alloys: non-toxic processes for improved corrosion resistance’Corros. Adv. Mater. Syst., Proc. Corros./98 Res. Top. Symp.San Diego, CA, USA March 1998NACE International81–103.
