A central component of the Public Health 3.0 model is building partnerships between local public health departments and other community organizations/stakeholders, including public and private hospitals, as a means of promoting data sharing, service coordination, and collective action. Evidence suggests that such partnerships remain challenging and infrequent. This qualitative study used in-depth interviews to identify barriers and facilitators to building effective collaboration between local health departments (LHDs) and hospitals. We purposively recruited LHD officials (n = 12) across the United States. A directed qualitative content analysis of the interview transcripts revealed five barriers and five facilitators to building effective collaboration between the two entities. Perceived barriers included competition, inconsistent participation and engagement, communication breakdown, time constraints, and lack of financial and human resources. Perceived facilitators included finding common ground, well-established relationships, aligning and leveraging resources, open communication, and leadership commitment. Findings highlight challenges and opportunities to promote effective collaboration between LHDs and hospitals.
DeSalvoKBO’CarrollPWKooD, et al.Public health 3.0: time for an upgrade. Am J Public Health2016; 106(4): 621–622.
2.
DeSalvoKBWangYCHarrisA, et al.Public health 3.0: a call to action for public health to meet the challenges of the 21st century. Prev Chronic Dis2017; 14: E78.
3.
Public Health 3.0: a blueprint for the future of public health. Published online November 21, 2016. DOI: 10.1377/forefront.20161121.057630.
4.
GunjaMZGumasEDWilliamsRDII. U.S. Health Care from a Global Perspective, 2022: 508 Accelerating Spending, Worsening Outcomes. DOI: 10.26099/8EJY-YC74. Published online 2023.
WeinsteinJNGellerANegussieY, et al. (eds). Committee on community-based solutions to promote health equity in the United States, Board on Population Health and Public Health Practice, Health and Medicine Division, National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. In: Communities in Action: Pathways to Health Equity. Washington, DC: National Academies Press, 2017, p. 24624. DOI: 10.17226/24624.
7.
KimEJMarrastLConigliaroJ. COVID-19: magnifying the effect of health disparities. J Gen Intern Med2020; 35(8): 2441–2442.
8.
LopezLHartLHKatzMH. Racial and ethnic health disparities related to COVID-19. JAMA2021; 325(8): 719–720.
9.
ThomeerMBMoodyMDYahirunJ. Racial and ethnic disparities in mental health and mental health care during the COVID-19 pandemic. J Racial Ethn Health Disparities2023; 10(2): 961–976.
10.
Committee on Integrating Primary Care and Public Health, Board on Population Health and Public Health Practice, Institute of Medicine. Primary care and public health: exploring integration to improve population health. National Academies Press (US), 2012. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK201594/ (Accessed July 5, 2022).
11.
Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act. PSECec 9007: additional requirements for charitable hospitals, HR 3590, p. 738. Published online 2010.
12.
HydeJKShortellSM. The structure and organization of local and state public health agencies in the U.S.: a systematic review. Am J Prev Med2012; 42(5): S29–S41.
13.
WallaceMSharfsteinJLesslerJ. Performance and priorities: a cross-sectional study of local health department approaches to essential public health services. Public Health Rep2020; 135(1): 97–106.
14.
CarltonELSinghSR. Joint community health needs assessments as a path for coordinating community-wide health improvement efforts between hospitals and local health departments. Am J Public Health2018; 108(5): 676–682.
15.
2024 California Code. 2024 California code :: health and safety code - HSC :: DIVISION 107 - HEALTH CARE ACCESS AND INFORMATION :: PART 2 - HEALTH POLICY AND PLANNING :: CHAPTER 2 - health policy research and evaluation :: ARTICLE 2 - hospitals: community benefits :: section 127350. Justia law; May 2, 2025. https://law.justia.com/codes/california/code-hsc/division-107/part-2/chapter-2/article-2/section-127350/ (Accessed May 2, 2025).
CroninCESinghSRBurnsA, et al.Ohio presents opportunities for understanding hospital alignment with public health agencies on community health assessments. Health Aff (Millwood)2024; 43(6): 873–882.
18.
Justia Free Databases of U.S. Laws. Codes & statutes. 2024 Maryland statutes :: health - general :: title 19 - health care facilities :: subtitle 3 - hospitals and related institutions :: Part I - definitions; general provisions :: section 19-303 - nonprofit hospitals; community benefit. Justia Law; May 2, 2025. https://law.justia.com/codes/maryland/health-general/title-19/subtitle-3/part-i/section-19-303/ (Accessed May 2, 2025).
19.
CramerGRYoungGJSinghS, et al.Evidence that collaborative action between local health departments and nonprofit hospitals helps foster healthy behaviors in communities: a multilevel study. BMC Health Serv Res2021; 21(1): 1.
20.
IsehunwaOODobalianAAhnS, et al.Local health department and hospital collaboration around community health needs assessment to improve health outcomes. Fam Community Health2021; 44(3): 136–145.
21.
SantosTLeeSYDEastC, et al.Can collaboration between nonprofit hospitals and local health departments influence population health investments by nonprofit hospitals?Med Care2021; 59(8): 687–693.
22.
SinghSRCarltonEL. Exploring the link between completion of accreditation prerequisites and local health departments’ decision to collaborate with tax-exempt hospitals around the community health assessment. J Public Health Manag Pract2017; 23(2): 138–147.
23.
ErwinPC. The performance of local health departments: a review of the literature. J Public Health Manag Pract2008; 14(2): E9–18.
24.
Martin-MisenerRValaitisRWongST, et al.A scoping literature review of collaboration between primary care and public health. Prim Health Care Res Dev2012; 13(4): 327–346.
25.
ValaitisRMeagher-StewartDMartin-MisenerR, et al.Organizational factors influencing successful primary care and public health collaboration. BMC Health Serv Res2018; 18(1): 420.
26.
SantosT. Non-profit hospital targeted health priorities and collaboration with local health departments in the first round post-ACA: a National Descriptive study. Front Public Health2020; 8: 124. https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpubh.2020.00124 (Accessed July 5, 2022).
27.
CroninCEFranzBPagánJA. Why are some US nonprofit hospitals not addressing opioid misuse in their communities?Popul Health Manag2020; 23(6): 407–413.
28.
MontoyaAJenqGMillsJP, et al.Partnering with local hospitals and public health to manage COVID-19 outbreaks in nursing homes. J Am Geriatr Soc2021; 69(1): 30–36.
29.
Abdel-SamadMCalzoJPFelnerJK, et al.Conceptualizing an interdisciplinary collective impact approach to examine and intervene in the chronic cycle of homelessness. Int J Environ Res Public Health2021; 18(4): 2020.
KarpynAWolgastHTracyT. Realizing collective impact for community health: a Wilmington case study. Del J Public Health2018; 4(5): 8–13.
32.
SchafferKCilentiDUrlaubDM, et al.Using a collective impact framework to implement evidence-based strategies for improving maternal and child health outcomes. Health Promot Pract2022; 23(3): 482–492.
FloodJMinklerMHennessey LaveryS, et al.The collective impact model and its potential for health promotion: overview and case study of a healthy retail initiative in San Francisco. Health Educ Behav2015; 42(5): 654–668.
35.
GwynneKRambaldiniBChristieV, et al.Applying collective impact in Aboriginal health services and research: three case studies tell an important story. Public Health Res Pract2022; 32(2): 3222215.
36.
AssarroudiAHeshmati NabaviFArmatMR, et al.Directed qualitative content analysis: the description and elaboration of its underpinning methods and data analysis process. J Res Nurs2018; 23(1): 42–55.
37.
BowenGA. Grounded theory and sensitizing concepts. Int J Qual Methods2006; 5(3): 12–23.
38.
GlaserBGStraussAL. The discovery of grounded theory: strategies for qualitative research. New Brunswick, NJ: Aldine, 1967.
39.
PadgettD. Qualitative and mixed methods in public health. Los Angeles: Sage Publications, Inc., 2012. DOI: 10.4135/9781483384511.
40.
HearldLRTafiliAKellyRJ. Patterns and trends in local health departments’ efforts to promote access to care in local communities throughout the United States: the contributions of governance structures. Int J Health Plann Manag2023; 38(5): 1284–1299.
41.
NewmanSJYeJLeepCJ. Workforce turnover at local health departments: nature, characteristics, and implications. Am J Prev Med2014; 47(5 Suppl 3): S337–343.
42.
HorneyJACarboneEGLynchM, et al.How health department contextual factors affect public health preparedness (PHP) and perceptions of the 15 PHP capabilities. Am J Public Health2017; 107(S2): S153–S160.
43.
BrownsonRCBurkeTAColditzGA, et al.Reimagining public health in the aftermath of a pandemic. Am J Public Health2020; 110(11): 1605–1610.
44.
LarkinsSLAllardNLBurgessCP. Management of COVID ‐19 in the community and the role of primary care: how the pandemic has shone light on a fragmented health system. Med J Aust2022; 217(S9): S3–S6.
45.
BrandertKAlperinMLloydLM, et al.Learning to lead: 3 models to support public health leadership development. J Public Health Manag Pract2022; 28(Supplement 5): S203–S211.
46.
RukchartNBuakatePMohd ShamsudinF, et al.Managerial skills required for new community public health graduates during the COVID-19 pandemic: employers’ perspective. Cogent Educ2022; 9(1): 2151249.
Silow-CarrollSRodinD. Forging community partnerships to improve health care: the experience of four Medicaid managed care organizations. Issue Brief Commonw Fund2013; 19: 1–17.
49.
ScutchfieldFDKnightEAKellyAV, et al.Local public health agency capacity and its relationship to public health system performance. J Public Health Manag Pract2004; 10(3): 204–215.
50.
BeattyKEWilsonKDCieciorA, et al.Collaboration among Missouri nonprofit hospitals and local health departments: content analysis of community health needs assessments. Am J Public Health2015; 105(S2): S337–S344.
51.
ErwinPCGreeneSBMaysGP, et al.The association of changes in local health department resources with changes in state-level health outcomes. Am J Public Health2011; 101(4): 609–615.
52.
MaysGPSmithSA. Evidence links increases in public health spending to declines in preventable deaths. Health Aff (Millwood)2011; 30(8): 1585–1593.
53.
LimSMAllardNLDevereuxJ, et al.The COVID Positive Pathway: a collaboration between public health agencies, primary care, and metropolitan hospitals in Melbourne. Med J Aust2022; 216(8): 413–419.
54.
CroninCESinghSRBurnsA, et al.Ohio presents opportunities for understanding hospital alignment with public health agencies on community health assessments. Health Aff (Millwood)2024; 43(6): 873–882.
55.
BommersbachTBorgerKStevermanS, et al.Behavioral health, local health department accreditation, and public health 3.0: leveraging opportunities for collaboration. Am J Public Health2018; 108(10): 1334–1340.
56.
FowlerKEFormanJAmelingJM, et al.Qualitative assessment of a state partner-facilitated health care-associated infection prevention national collaborative. Ann Intern Med2019; 171(7_Suppl): S75–S80.
57.
ZhuXWeigelPBalohJ, et al.Mobilising cross-sector collaborations to improve population health in US rural communities: a qualitative study. BMJ Open2019; 9(11): e030983.
58.
BeehlerSBoulgerJFriedrichsenSC, et al.Teaching community health needs assessment to first year medical students: integrating with longitudinal clinical experience in rural communities. J Community Health2019; 44(4): 784–789.
59.
DiazHJMAinsworthDSchmidtleinMC. Funding priorities: data-driven approach for prioritizing community health needs in vulnerable communities. Health Promot Pract2019; 20(4): 616–623.
60.
Public Health Accreditation Board. Spectrum of sharing arrangements. Center for Innovation; 2021, phaboard.org.
61.
ShahGH. Local health departments’ role in nonprofit hospitals’ community health needs assessment. Am J Public Health2018; 108(5): 595–597.
