The relevance of wetlands has re-gained attention in the global socioecological agenda as part of the resurgence of nature-based solutions (NbS) for sustainable development. In global south contexts, the socio-ecological relevance of wetlands has not prevented their rapid depletion in ecologically sensitive areas due to reactive environmental planning and plurality of resource management systems. Despite multiple vested interests around wetlands, grounded multi-actor perspectives situating the divergent views on the planning and development of wetlands remain underexplored. Drawing on the southern perspective of conflicting rationalities, and using qualitative data gathered from Sakumono, the most threatened wetland site in the Greater Accra Region of Ghana, this paper distills the perspectives of residents, planners, wetland managers, and developers to unpack the underpinning contestations and conflictual views/interests that shape the exploitation and management of wetlands. The study highlights deeply rooted, inequitable, multiple but conflicting perspectives on the value and management of wetlands, as state agencies prioritize ecological functions, community stakeholders favor livelihood and cultural values, and the invisible hands of the political elite push to rationalize their property-driven investments as inseparable from conservation value. We argue that this plurality of divergent rationalities stifles the implementation of wetland conservation policies and engenders a developmental regime that tacitly supports unregulated real estate development while denying resource-dependent local population access to socio-ecological services.
AdadeRNyarkoBKAhetoDW, et al. (2017) Fragmentation of wetlands in the south eastern coastal savanna of Ghana. Regional Studies in Marine Science, and Practice12: 453–469.
2.
AgbetiJA (2023) Sustainable conservation of Sakumo wetlands for social and environmental benefits (Doctoral dissertation).
3.
AgbetiJAManteySZamanQM (2022) Detecting encroachment within wetlands using UAV techniques: the case of Sakumo Ramsar Site, Ghana. Journal of Environment and Earth Science12(2).
4.
AgrawalAErbaughJPradhanN (2023) The commons. Annual Review of Environment and Resources48(1): 531–558.
5.
AhmedADinyeRD (2011) Urbanisationand the challenges of development controls in Ghana: A case study of Wa Township. Journal of Sustainable Development in Africa13(7): 211–233.
6.
AlikhaniSNummiPOjalaA (2021) Urban wetlands: A review on ecological and cultural values. Water13(22): 3301.
7.
AndreasenMHAgergaardJKofieRY, et al. (2022) Urban encroachment in ecologically sensitive areas: Drivers, impediments and consequences. Buildings and Cities3(1): 920–938.
8.
AsanteLA BonsuBAHelbrechtI (2024) Wetland gentrification: The African variant on ecological gentrification. Environment & Urbanization36(2): 460–477.
Asomani-BoatengR (2019) Urban wetland planning and management in Ghana: A disappointing implementation. Wetlands39(2): 251–261.
11.
Ballut-DajudGASandoval HerazoLCFernández-LambertG, et al. (2022) Factors affecting wetland loss: A review. Land11(3): 434.
12.
BaoTZhuR-BWangQ (2018) Potential effects of ultraviolet radiation reduction on tundra nitrous oxide and methane fluxes in maritime. Antarctica. Scientific Reports8: 3716.
13.
BassiNKumarDSharmaA, et al. (2014) Status of wetlands in India: A review of extent, ecosystem benefits, threats and management strategies. Journal of Hydrology: Regional Studies2: 1–19.
14.
BirchKWardC (2024) Assetization and the ‘new asset geographies’. Dialogues in Human Geography14(1): 9–29.
BowdenAFox-RushbyJANyandiekaL, et al. (2002) Methods for pre-testing and piloting survey questions: Illustrations from the KENAOL survey of health-related quality of life. Health Policy and Planning17: 322–330.
17.
BraunVClarkeV (2006) Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology3(2): 77–101.
18.
BrownKMLindenbergerJHBryantCA (2003) Using pretesting to ensure your messages and materials are on strategy. Health Promotion Practice9: 116–122.
19.
BrymanA (2021) Social Research Methods. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press. ISBN: 9780190853662.
20.
CampbellSGreenwoodMPriorS, et al. (2020) Purposive sampling: Complex or simple? Research case examples. Journal of Research in Nursing25(8): 652–661.
21.
CardnoC (2018) Policy document analysis: A practical educational leadership tool and a qualitative research method. Educational Administration: Theory & Practice24(4): 623–640.
22.
Center for Remote Censing and Geographic Information Systems (CERGIS) (2021) Encroachment on the Sakumo Ramsar Site. https://cersgis.org/news/?blog_id=10.
23.
CobbinahPBAsibeyMOGyedu-PensangYA (2020) Urban land use planning in Ghana: Navigating complex coalescence of land ownership and administration. Land Use Policy99: 105054.
24.
CollierMJScottM (2009) Conflicting rationalities, knowledge and values in scarred landscapes. Journal of Rural Studies25(3): 267–277.
25.
CreightonCBoonPIBrookesJD, et al. (2015) Repairing Australia’s estuaries for improved fisheries production – what benefits, at what cost?Marine and Freshwater Research66: 493.
26.
CreswellJW (2014) Research Design: Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Methods Approaches. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
27.
DahlTEStedmanSM (2013) Status and Trends of Wetlands in the Coastal Watersheds of the Conterminous United States 2004 to 2009 (US Department of the Interior, US Fish and Wildlife Service and National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, National Marine Fisheries Service.
28.
DamastutiEde GrootR (2017) Effectiveness of community-based mangrove management for sustainable resource use and livelihood support: A case study of four villages in central Java, Indonesia. Journal of Environmental Management203: 510–521.
29.
DansoGKTakyiSAAmponsahO, et al. (2021) Exploring the effects of rapid urbanization on wetlands: Insights from the greater Accra metropolitan area, Ghana. SN Social Science1: 212.
30.
DavidsonNC (2014) How much wetland has the world lost? Long-term and recent trends in global wetland area. Marine and Freshwater Research65: 934–941.
31.
DawudaUKYonghongCAl-MasnayYA, et al. (2024) Assessment of wetland loss through industrialization and community expansion: A case study of the greater amanzule wetland in the Ellembelle district of Ghana. Frontiers in Environmental Science12: 1451394.
32.
de OliveiraMMorrisonTO'BrienKR, et al. (2024) Governance of coastal wetlands: Beyond the community conservation paradigm. Ocean & Coastal Management255: 107253.
33.
De SatgéRWatsonV (2018) Urban Planning in the Global South: Conflicting Rationalities in Contested Urban Space. Cham, Switzerland: Springer International Publishing.
34.
du ToitMJCilliersSSDallimerM, et al. (2018) Urban green infrastructure and ecosystem services in sub-Saharan Africa. Landscape and Urban Planning180: 249–261.
35.
DzorgboD-B (2017) Ghana in Search of Development: The Challenge of Governance, Economic Management and Institution Building. Routledge.
36.
EkumahBArmahFAAfrifaEKA, et al. (2020) Assessing land use and land cover change in coastal urban wetlands of international importance in Ghana using intensity analysis. Wetlands Ecology and Management28: 271–284.
37.
FattiCCPatelZ (2021) Pursuit of just sustainability: Decision-making and conflicting rationalities in government-led housing project. Local Environment28(3): 277–303.
38.
FooteALPandeySKrogmanNT (1996) Processes of wetland loss in India. Environmental Conservation23(1): 45–54.
39.
FrimpongLKOkyereSADikoSK, et al. (2022a) Everybody is taking their security in their own hands’: Exploring everyday urban safety perceptions and realities in sekondi-takoradi, Ghana. Urban Forum33: 245–265.
40.
FrimpongLKOkyereSADikoSK, et al. (2022b) Actor-network analysis of community-based organisations in health pandemics: Evidence from the COVID- 19 response in Freetown, Sierra Leone. Disasters46(4): 903–927.
41.
FrischmannBMMarcianoARamelloGB (2019) Retrospectives: Tragedy of the commons after 50 years. Journal of Economic Perspectives33(4): 211–228.
GillespieJ (2016) Catch 22: Wetlands protection and fishing for survival. Geographical Research54(3): 336–347.
44.
GillespieJ (2018) Wetland conservation and legal layering: Managing Cambodia's great lake. The Geographical Journal184(1): 31–40.
45.
GillespieJPerryN (2019) Feminist political ecology and legal geography: A case study of the Tonle Sap protected wetlands of Cambodia. Environment and Planning A51(5): 1089–1105.
46.
HaTTPvan DijkHVisserL (2014) Impacts of changes in mangrove forest management practices on forest accessibility and livelihood: A case study in mangrove-shrimp farming system in Ca Mau province, Mekong Delta, Vietnam. Land use Policy36: 89–101.
47.
HettiarachchiMMorrisonTHMcAlpineC (2019) Power, politics and policy in the appropriation of urban wetlands: The critical case of Sri Lanka. The Journal of Peasant Studies46(4): 729–746.
48.
HuSNiuZChenY, et al. (2017) Global wetlands: Potential distribution, wetland loss, and status. Science of the Total Environment586: 319–327.
49.
HurstSArulogunOSOwolabiAO, et al. (2015) Pretesting qualitative data collection procedures to facilitate methodological adherence and team building in Nigeria. International Journal of Qualitative Methods14: 53–64.
50.
KabiriSAllenMOkuonziaJT, et al. (2022) Detecting wetland encroachment and urban agriculture land classification in Uganda using hyper-temporal remote sensing. Open Research Africa3: 18.
51.
KadomaAPerryMRenaudFG (2023) Stakeholders’ perceptions of wetland conservation and restoration in wakiso district, Uganda. Environment, Development and Sustainability27: 3177–3200.
52.
KansangaMAndersenPAtuoyeK, et al. (2018) Contested commons: Agricultural modernization, tenure ambiguities and intra-familial land grabbing in Ghana. Land Use Policy75: 215–224.
KondraM (2018) The status of the wetlands in the Greater Accra Region. WaterPower Working Paper. https://doi.org/10.25353/ubtr-xxxx-ef05-4176/.
55.
KuusaanaEDAhmedACampionBB, et al. (2021) Characterisation and typology of urban wetlands in Ghana: Implications for the governance of urban commons in secondary cities in Africa. Urban Governance1(1): 38–50.
56.
LamsalPPantPWKumarL, et al. (2016) Sustainable livelihoods through conservation of wetland resources: A case of economic benefits from Ghodaghodi Lake, western Nepal. Ecology and Society20(1): 10.
57.
LawhonMErnstsonHSilverJ (2014) Provincializing urban political ecology: Towards a situated UPE through African urbanism. Antipode46(2): 497–516.
58.
LiXLiuG (2022) Study on the change monitoring of typical estuarine wetland and its effect on ecological factors in Bohai Rim region, China. Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution10: 967593.
59.
LiwurSBTakyiSAAsibeyMO, et al. (2023) Sustainable functional roles of ecologically sensitive areas in the Greater Kumasi Metropolis of Ghana: Exploring local perceptions and attitudes from a socio-economic purview. Urban Ecosystems27: 85–99.
60.
MakhaleSLandmanK (2018) Gating and conflicting rationalities: Challenges in practice and theoretical implications. International Planning Studies23(2): 130–143.
61.
ManningJ (2017) In vivo coding. In: MatthesJ (eds) The International Encyclopedia of Communication Research Methods. New York, NY: Wiley.
62.
MarambanyikaTBeckedahlHNgetarNS (2017) Community strategies to promote sustainable wetland-based food security in rural areas of Zimbabwe. GeoJournal82(5): 987–1003.
63.
MensahSLFrimpongLKOkyereSA, et al. (2023) A digital turn for urban management? Residents’ perception and utilisation of the digital property address system in Accra, Ghana. Urban Governance3(2): 157–167.
64.
MilesMBHubermanAMSaldañaJ (2019) Qualitative Data Analysis: A Methods Sourcebook, 4th ed.Thousand Oak, CA: Sage Publishing.
65.
MorgeraE (2005) An update on the Aarhus convention and its continued global relevance. Review of European Community & International Environmental Law14(2): 138–147.
66.
MorseJMBarrettMMayanM, et al. (2002) Verification strategies for establishing reliability and validity in qualitative research. International Journal of Qualitative Methods1(2): 13–22.
67.
MusasaTMuringanizaKCRManyatiM (2023) The role of stakeholder participation in wetland conservation in urban areas: A case of Monavale Vlei, Harare. Scientific African19: e01574.
68.
NgwenyaNCiroliaLR (2021) Conflicts between and within: The ‘conflicting Rationalities’ of informal occupation in South Africa. Planning Theory & Practice22(5): 691–706.
69.
Obeng-OdoomF (2020) The Commons in an Age of Uncertainty: Decolonizing Nature, Economy, and Society. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
70.
OkyereSAFrimpongLKOviedoD, et al. (2024) Policy-reality gaps in Africa’s walking cities: Contextualizing institutional perspectives and residents’ lived experiences in Accra. Journal of Urban Affairs47: 2381–2402.
71.
OstrovskayaEDouvenWSchwartzK, et al. (2013) Capacity for sustainable management of wetlands: Lessons from the WETwin project. Environmental Science & Policy34: 128–137.
72.
OumaS (2020) This can (’t) be an asset class: The world of money management,“society”, and the contested morality of farmland investments. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space52(1): 66–87.
73.
OwusuG (2008) Indigenes’ and migrants’ access to land in peri-urban areas of Accra, Ghana. International Development Planning Review30(2): 177–198.
74.
Owusu-AchiawROsei-OwusuY (2023) Community-based approach to wetland restoration: Case study of the Songor Wetland, Ghana. In: NishiMSubramanianSM (eds) Ecosystem Restoration Through Managing Socio-Ecological Production Landscapes and Seascapes (SEPLS). Satoyama Initiative Thematic Review. Gateway East, Singapore: Springer.
75.
PattonMQ (2015) Qualitative Research and Evaluation Methods, 4th ed.Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications.
76.
PaulSKüselKAlewellC (2006) Reduction processes in forest wetlands: Tracking down heterogeneity of source/sink functions with a combination of methods. Soil Biology and Biochemistry38(5): 1028–1039.
PedrosaELJOkyereSAFrimpongLK, et al. (2021) Planning for informal urban green spaces in African cities: Children’s perception and use in peri-urban areas of Luanda, Angola. Urban Science5(3): 50.
79.
PerryNGillespieJ (2019) Restricting spatial lives? The gendered implications of conservation in Cambodia’s protected wetlands. Environment and Planning E2(1): 73–88.
80.
PournabiNJanatrostamiSAshrafzadehA, et al. (2021) Resolution of internal conflicts for conservation of the Hour Al-Azim wetland using AHP-SWOT and game theory approach. Land Use Policy107: 105495.
81.
PuplampuDABoafoYA (2021) Exploring the impacts of urban expansion on green spaces availability and delivery of ecosystem services in the Accra Metropolis. Environmental Challenges5: 100283.
82.
Rahimi-FeyzabadFYazdanpanahMGholamrezaiS, et al. (2021) Institutional constraints to groundwater resource management in arid and semi-arid regions: A Straussian grounded theory study. Hydrogeology Journal29: 925–947.
83.
RingimASAbubakarMMMohammedSI, et al. (2015) Wetlands resource use, conflict, management and conservation: Review of the Hadejia-Nguru wetlands, northeast. Nigeria. International Journal of Innovative Science, Engineering and Technology2(10): 507–516.
84.
SaundersBSimJKingstoneT, et al. (2018) Saturation in qualitative research: Exploring its conceptualization and operationalization. Quality & Quantity52: 1893–1907.
85.
SchensulJ (2011) Methodology, methods and tools in qualitative research. In: LapanSQuartaroliMRiemerF (eds) Qualitative Research. Hoboken: Wiley, 69–103.
86.
SchmitterP (2000) Governance. Paper presented at the Conference ‘Democratic and Participatory Governance: From Citizens to “Holders”’, European University Institute, Florence, September.
87.
SelmanP (2004) Community participation in the planning and management of cultural landscapes. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management47(3): 365–392.
SunX (2015) Selective enforcement of land regulations: Why large-scale violators succeed. The China Journal74: 66–90.
90.
SwyngedouwE (2005) Governance innovation and the citizen: The Janus face of governance-beyond-the-state. Urban Studies42(11): 1991–2006.
91.
TacconiLWilliamsDA (2020) Corruption and anti-corruption in environmental and resource management. Annual Review of Environment and Resources45: 305–329.
92.
TaherdoostH (2016) Sampling methods in research methodology; how to choose a sampling technique for research. International Journal of Academic Research in Management (IJARM)5.
93.
TakyiSAAmponsahODarkoG, et al. (2022) Urbanization against ecologically sensitive areas: Effects of land use activities on surface water bodies in the kumasi metropolis. International Journal of Urban Sustainable Development14(1): 460–479.
94.
ThapaDBudhathokiNRMunkvoldBE (2017) Analyzing crisis response through actor-network theory: The case of Kathmandu living labs. Communications of the Association for Information Systems41(1): 414–428.
95.
TzaninisYMandlerTKaikaM, et al. (2021) Moving urban political ecology beyond the ‘urbanization of nature. Progress in Human Geography45(2): 229–252.
ValizadehNSadeghi ShahrnoyKBijaniM, et al. (2022) Towards conserving wetlands: Application of the social identity model of collective action. Land Degradation & Development33(18): 3703–3717.
98.
WangT (2020) Wetland governance: Contested aspirations and reflexive roles of local professionals toward Worlding cities in Tai Lake Basin. Frontiers in Environmental Science8: 577357.
99.
WangaiPWBurkhardBMüllerF (2016) A review of studies on ecosystem services in Africa. International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment5(2): 225–245.
100.
WatsonV (2003) Conflicting rationalities: Implications for planning theory and ethics. Planning Theory and Practice4(4): 395–407.
101.
WilkinsKPejcharLCarrollSL, et al. (2021) Collaborative conservation in the United States: A review of motivations, goals, and outcomes. Biological Conservation259: 109165.
102.
ZhouJWuJGongY (2020) Valuing wetland ecosystem services based on benefit transfer: A meta-analysis of China wetland studies. Journal of Cleaner Production276: 122988.
103.
ZiervogelGWaddellJSmitW, et al. (2014) Flooding in Cape Town’s informal settlements: barriers to collaborative urban risk governance. South African Geographical Journal98(1): 1–20.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
