In this article, we study how the marketing of single-family homes explains the racial and income makeup of mortgage applicants in a neighborhood. We use a case study of the robust housing market of Charlotte, North Carolina, and annual, longitudinal real estate listing advertisements alongside mortgage lending data, to demonstrate how the share of properties advertised a certain way in a neighborhood in 1 year explains shares of mortgage applicants by race and income the following year. We classify property advertisement text using a semi-supervised learning algorithm into five categories following a housing investment and disinvestment to renewal continuum. We find stark racial disparities in mortgage applicants by housing type, even after controlling for income. We find that Black applicants nearly exclusively apply for mortgages in neighborhoods with a high share of properties advertised as disinvested with little profit-making promise. High-income White applicants rise as the share of advertised properties becomes more homogenous.
AalbersM (2009) Geographies of the financial crisis. Area41(1): 34–42.
2.
AliprantisDCarrollDRYoungER (2024) What explains neighborhood sorting by income and race?Journal of Urban Economics141: 103508.
3.
AnselinLBeraAKFloraxR, et al. (1996) Simple diagnostic tests for spatial dependence. Regional Science and Urban Economics26(1): 77–104.
4.
AnselinLLe GalloJJayetH (2008) Spatial panel econometrics. In: MatyasLSevestreP (eds) The Econometrics of Panel Data: Fundamentals and Recent Developments in Theory and Practice. Germany: Springer-Verkag Berlin Heidelberg.
5.
BesbrisM (2020) Upsold: Real Estate Agents, Prices, and Neighborhood Inequality. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
6.
BlackKRoseKTreuhaftS (2011) When investors buy up the neighborhood: Preventing investor ownership from causing neighborhood decline. Community Investments23: 19–22.
7.
BradfordC (1979) Financing home ownership: The federal role in neighborhood decline.Urban Affairs Quarterly14(3): 313–335.
8.
BridgeG (2001) Estate agents as interpreters of economic and cultural capital: the gentrification premium in the Sydney housing market. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research25(1): 87–101.
9.
ChristensenPTimminsC (2022) Sorting or steering: the effects of housing discrimination on neighborhood choice. Journal of Political Economy130(8): 2110–2163. DOI: 10.1086/720140/SUPPL_FILE/20191181DATA.ZIP.
ClarkWAV (2008) Changing residential preferences across income, education, and age: findings from the multi-city study of urban inequality. Education, and Age44(3): 334–355. DOI: 10.1177/1078087408321497.
12.
CurrieMASorensenJ (2019) Repackaged “urban renewal”: issues of spatial equity and environmental justice in new construction, suburban neighborhoods, and urban islands of infill. Journal of Urban Affairs41(4): 464–485.
13.
DelmelleE. C. (2016) Mapping the DNA of urban neighborhoods: Clustering longitudinal sequences of neighborhood socioeconomic change. Annals of the American Association of Geographers106(1): 36–56.
14.
DelmelleECNilssonI (2021) The language of neighborhoods: a predictive-analytical framework based on property advertisement text and mortgage lending data. Computers, Environment and Urban Systems88: 101658.
15.
DelmelleECNilssonIAduP (2021a) Poverty suburbanization, job accessibility, and employment outcomes. Social Inclusion9(2): 166–178.
16.
DelmelleECNilssonISchuchJC (2021b) Who’s moving in? A longitudinal analysis of home purchase borrowers in new transit neighborhoods. Geographical Analysis53(2): 237–258.
17.
DrakeS. C.CaytonH. R. (1945) Black Metropolis. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
18.
EmersonMOYanceyGChaiKJ (2001) Does race matter in residential segregation?Exploring the Preferences of White Americans66(6): 922–935. DOI: 10.1177/000312240106600607.
GalsterG (1996) William Grigsby and the analysis of housing sub-markets and filtering. Urban Studies33(10): 1797–1805.
21.
GalsterGGodfreyE (2005) By words and deeds: racial steering by real estate agents in the U.S. in 2000. Journal of the American Planning Association71(3): 251–268.
22.
GalsterGTatianP (2009) Modeling housing appreciation dynamics in disadvantaged neighborhoods. Journal of Planning Education and Research29(1): 7–22.
23.
HanlonB (2009) A typology of inner–ring suburbs: class, race, and ethnicity in US suburbia. City & Community8(3): 221–246.
24.
HarveyHFongKEdinK, et al. (2020) Forever homes and temporary stops: housing search logics and residential selection. Social Forces98(4): 1498–1523.
25.
HaupertT (2019) Racial patterns in mortgage lending outcomes during and after the subprime boom. Housing Policy Debate29(6): 947–976.
26.
HollansHMartinRWMunnekeHJ (2013) Measuring price behavior in new residential subdivisions. The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics47: 227–242.
27.
HuYMaoHMcKenzieG (2019) A natural language processing and geospatial clustering framework for harvesting local place names from geotagged housing advertisements. International Journal of Geographical Information Science33(4): 714–738.
28.
HwangJDingL (2020) Unequal displacement: Gentrification, racial stratification, and residential destinations in Philadelphia. American Journal of Sociology126(2): 354–406.
29.
ImmergluckD (2009) Foreclosed: High risk lending, deregulation, and the undermining of America’s mortgage market. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
30.
Korver-GlennE (2018) Compounding inequalities: how racial stereotypes and discrimination accumulate across the stages of housing exchange. American Sociological Review83(4): 627–656.
31.
Korver-GlennE (2021) Race brokers: housing markets and segregation. In: 21st Century Urban America. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
32.
KrysanMFarleyR (2002) The residential preferences of blacks: do they explain persistent segregation?Social Forces80(3): 937–980.
33.
KrysanMCouperMPFarleyR, et al. (2009) Does race matter in neighborhood preferences? Results from a video experiment. American Journal of Sociology115(2): 527–559.
34.
LichterDTThiedeBCBrooksMM (2023) Racial diversity and segregation: comparing principal cities, inner-ring suburbs, outlying suburbs, and the suburban fringe. RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences9(1): 26–51.
35.
LoganJR (2018) Relying on the census in urban social science. City & Community17(3): 540–549.
36.
LoganJRXuZStultsB (2012) Interpolating US decennial census tract data from as early as 1970 to 2010: a longitudinal tract database. The Professional Geographer66(3): 412–420.
37.
MallachA (2024) Shifting the redlining paradigm: the home owners’ loan corporation maps and the construction of urban racial inequality. Housing Policy Debate.
38.
MarkleySNHafleyTJAllumsCA, et al. (2020) The limits of homeownership: racial capitalism, black wealth, and the appreciation gap in atlanta. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research44(2): 310–328.
39.
MasseyDS (2020) Still the linchpin: segregation and stratification in the USA. Race and Social Problems12(1): 1–12.
NilssonIDelmelleEC (2023a) An Embedding-Based Text Classification Approach for Understanding Micro-geographic Housing Dynamics. Philadelphia: International Journal of Geographic Information Science.
42.
NilssonIDelmelleEC (2023b) Smart growth as a luxury amenity? Exploring the relationship between the marketing of smart growth characteristics and neighborhood racial and income change. Journal of Transport Geography106: 103522.
43.
NowakAPriceBSSmithPS (2021) Real estate dictionaries across space and time. The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics62(1): 139–163.
44.
PattilloM (2005) Black middle-class neighborhoods. Annual Review of Sociology31: 305–329.
45.
PattilloM (2013) Black on the block: The politics of race and class in the city. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
46.
PerkinsHCThornsDCNewtonBM (2008) Real estate advertising and intraurban place meaning: real estate sales consultants at work. Environment and Planning A40(9): 2061–2079.
47.
QuericaRGGalsterGC (2000) Threshold effects and neighborhood change. Journal of Planning Education and Research20(2): 146–162.
48.
QuillianLLeeJJHonoréB (2020) Racial discrimination in the U.S. Housing and mortgage lending markets: a quantitative review of trends, 1976–2016. Race and Social Problems12(1): 13–28.
49.
Rucks-AhidianaZ (2021a) Racial composition and trajectories of gentrification in the United States. Urban Studies58(13): 2721–2741.
50.
Rucks-AhidianaZ (2021b) Theorizing gentrification as a process of racial capitalism.
51.
RughJ. S.MasseyD. S. (2010) Racial segregation and the American foreclosure crisis. American Sociological Review75(5): 629–651.
52.
SchopfTBraunDMatthesF (2021) Lbl2Vec: An embedding-based approach for unsupervised document retrieval on predefined topics. Proceedings of the 17th International Conference on Web Information Systems and Technologies - WEBIST124–132.
53.
ShahbaziMBarrJRHristidisV, et al. (2016) Estimation of the investability of real estate properties through text analysis. In: 2016 IEEE Tenth International Conference on Semantic Computing (ICSC). Piscataway: IEEE, 301–306.
54.
SkaburskisA (2010) Gentrification in the context of ‘risk society. Environment and Planning A42(4): 895–912.
55.
SlaterG (2021) Freedom to discriminate: how realtors conspired to segregate housing and divide America. New York: Heyday.
56.
SmithHGravesW (2005) Gentrification as corporate growth strategy: the strange case of Charlotte, North Carolina and the Bank of America. Journal of Urban Affairs27(4): 403–418.
57.
SorensenJGamezJCurrieM (2014) Windy Ridge: a neighborhood built to fail. Applied Geography51: 8–25.
58.
SperlingJ (2012) The tyranny of census geography: small-area data and neighborhood statistics. Cityscape14(2): 219–223.
59.
TaylorKY (2019) Race for Profit: How Banks and the Real Estate Industry Undermined Black Homeownership. Chapel Hill: UNC Press Books.
60.
TurnbullGKDombrowJ (2006) Spatial competition and shopping externalities: evidence from the housing market. The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics32: 391–408.
61.
TurnerMASantosRLevyDK, et al. (2016) Housing discrimination against racial and ethnic minorities 2012: executive summary.
62.
Van ZandtS (2007) Racial/ethnic differences in housing outcomes for first‐time, low‐income home buyers: findings from a National homeownership education program. Housing Policy Debate18(2): 431–474.
63.
Van ZandtSRoheWM (2011) The sustainability of low-income homeownership: the incidence of unexpected costs and needed repairs among low-income home buyers. Housing Policy Debate21(2): 317–341.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
