The European Global Strategy (EUGS) is a significant document that came out at a critical time. Decision makers and scholars need to identify and assess the challenges the EU is facing in its effort to pursue its new Strategy. This paper addresses the lack of a tool for identifying those challenges and assessing the EU's ability to respond to them by introducing a new analytical framework based on the conceptualization of the EU as a small power in the international system, and the literature about the international relations of small states. The framework combines the factors that impact upon a small state's behaviour and performance in the international system and consists of the following elements: a) the EU's relations with the great powers in the system, b) developments in the EU's neighbourhood, c) the EU's politics, and d) the EU's reputation. After discussing each one of them, the paper contributes a comprehensive assessment of the EU's ability to implement its Strategy. It concludes that in order to implement its Strategy, the EU should respond to specific challenges. Therefore, the framework this paper introduces can improve our understanding of both the EUGS and the Union's strengths and weaknesses, shed some light on what measures should be taken for the Union to respond to challenges that lie ahead and be used as a yardstick to assess the Union's progress. Moreover, the framework can be applied to other areas of the EU's external action and contribute to both drafting better informed strategic documents and supporting their implementation.
ArterDavid (2000), ‘Small State Influence within the EU: The Case of Finland's “Northern Dimension Initiative”’, JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies, 38(5): 677–697.
BaillieShasha (1998), ‘The Position of Small States in the EU’, in GoetschelLaurent (ed.) Small States Inside and Outside the European Union, NY: Springer, pp. 193–205.
5.
BarrinhaAndré (2016), ‘Progressive Realism and the EU's International Actorness: Towards a Grand Strategy?’, Journal of European Integration, 38(4): 441–454.
6.
BaunMichael (1995), ‘The Maastricht Treaty as High Politics: Germany, France, and European Integration’, Political Science Quarterly, 110(4): 605–624.
BeauregardPhillippe (2016), ‘Taking Flight or Crashing Down? European Common Foreign Policy and International Crises’, Journal of European Integration, 38(4): 375–392.
9.
BellouFotini (2016), ‘Reconsidering the Nexus of Internal and External Security in South Eastern Europe’, Paper presented at the CISS-ISA conference in Thessaloniki, 14/06/2016.
10.
BiscopSven (2012), ‘The UK and European Defence: Leading or Leaving?’, International Affairs, 88(6): 1297–1313.
11.
BiscopSven (2015), ‘Game of Zones: Power Struggles in the EU's Neighbourhood’, Global Affairs, 14(5): 369–379.
BrethertonCharlotte, and VoglerJohn (2013), ‘A Global Actor Past Its Peak?’, International Relations, 27(3): 375–390.
17.
BrowningChristopher (2006), ‘Small, Smart and Salient? Rethinking Identity in the Small States Literature’, Cambridge Review of International Affairs, 19(4): 669–684.
18.
ChabanNatalia, and ElgströmOliver (2014), ‘The Role of the EU in an Emerging New World Order in the Eyes of the Chinese, Indian and Russian Press’, Journal of European Integration, 36(2): 170–188.
19.
ConnollyRichard (2018), ‘Western Sanctions and the Russian Response’, in ConnollyRichard, Russia's Response to Sanctions: How Western Economic Statecraft Is Reshaping Political Economy in Russia, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 56–77.
20.
ContessiNicola (2015), ‘Foreign and Security Policy Diversification in Eurasia: Issue Splitting, Coalignment, and Relational Power’, Problems of Post-Communism, 62(5): 299–311.
DeightonAnne (2002), ‘The European Security and Defence Policy’, JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies, 40(4): 719–741.
24.
DoeserFredrik (2011), ‘Domestic Politics and Foreign Policy Change in Small States: The Fall of the Danish “Footnote Policy”’, Cooperation and Conflict, 46(2): 222–241.
25.
DrentMargriet, and ZandeeDick (2016), ‘European Defence: From Strategy to Delivery’, Global Affairs, 2(1): 69–78.
26.
DucheneFrançois (1973), ‘The European Community and the Uncertainties of Interdependence’, in KohnstammMax, and HagerWolfgang, A Nation Writ Large? Foreign-Policy Problems before the European Community, London: Macmillan, pp. 19–20.
27.
DunneTim (2008), ‘Good Citizen Europe’, International Affairs, 84(1): 13–28.
European External Action Service (2016), European Global Strategy: Shared Vision, Common Action, A Stronger Europe: A Global Strategy for the European Union's Foreign and Security Policy, Brussels: EEAS. Available at: http://eeas.europa.eu/top_stories/pdf/eugs_review_web.pdf.
FabbriniSergio (2014), ‘The European Union and the Libyan Crisis’, International Politics, 51(2): 177–195.
42.
FiottDaniel (ed.) (2015), The Common Security and Defence Policy: National Perspectives, Brussels: EGMONT – The Royal Institute for International Relations.
FoxAnnete (1959), The Power of Small States: Diplomacy in World War II, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
45.
GebhardCarmen, and SmithSimon (2015), ‘The Two Faces of EU-NATO Cooperation: Counter-piracy Operations off the Somali Coast’, Cooperation and Conflict, 50(1): 107–127.
46.
GoetschelLaurent (2011), ‘Neutrals as Brokers of Peacebuilding Ideas?’, Cooperation and Conflict, 46(3): 312–333.
GrabbeHeather (2014), ‘Six Lessons of Enlargement Ten Years On: The EU's Transformative Power in Retrospect and Prospect’, JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies, 52(S1): 40–56.
49.
GrægerNina (2016), ‘European Security as Practice: EU-NATO Communities of Practice in the Making?’, European Security, 25(4): 478–501.
50.
GrønCaroline, and WivelAnders (2011), ‘Maximizing Influence in the European Union after the Lisbon Treaty: From Small State Policy to Smart state Strategy’, Journal of European Integration, 33(5): 523–539.
51.
HaineJean-Yves (2003), ‘ESDP: An Overview’, European Union Institute for Security Studies.
52.
HandelMichael (1985), Weak States in the International System, London: Frank Cass.
53.
HillChristopher, and SmithMichael (2005), International Relations and the European Union, Oxford: OUP.
54.
HornatJan (2016), ‘Closing the Closing Space: Sustaining Democracy Promotion in European Foreign Policy’, Global Affairs, 2(3): 273–285.
55.
IngebritsenChristine (2002), ‘Norm Entrepreneurs: Scandinavia's Role in World Politics’, Cooperation and Conflict, 37(1): 11–23.
KeohaneRobert (1969), ‘Lilliputians’ Dilemmas: Small States in International Politics’, International Organization, 23(2): 291–310.
62.
KeohaneRobert (1971), ‘The Big Influence of Small Allies’, Foreign Policy, 2: 161–182.
63.
KeukeleireStephan, and DelreuxTom (2015), ‘Competing Structural Powers and Challenges for the EU's Structural Foreign Policy’, Global Affairs, 1(1): 43–50.
64.
KouskouvelisIlias (2013), ‘The Problem with Turkey's “Zero Problems”’, Middle East Quarterly, Winter: 47–56.
65.
KouskouvelisIlias (2015), ‘“Smart” Leadership in a Small State: The Case of Cyprus’, in TziampirisAristotle, and LitsasSpyridon (eds.) The Eastern Mediterranean in Transition: Multipolarity, Politics and Power, Abingdon: Routledge, pp. 93–117.
66.
KouskouvelisIlias (2017), ‘The MENA Region Power Competition and the Challenges to Security’, Defence Review, 2: 75–92.
67.
LavalléeChantel (2012), ‘From the Rapid Reaction Mechanism to the Instrument for Stability: The Empowerment of the European Commission in Crisis Response and Conflict Prevention’, Journal of Contemporary European Research, 9(3): 372–389.
68.
LitsasSpyridon (2017), ‘Russia in the Eastern Mediterranean. Intervention, Deterrence, Containment’, Digest of Middle East Studies, 26(1): 56–73.
69.
LobellSteven, RipsmanNorrin, and TaliaferroJeffrey (eds.) (2009), Neoclassical Realism, the State, and Foreign Policy, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
70.
MaassMatthias (2014), ‘Small States: Survival and Proliferation’, International Politics, 51(6): 709–728.
71.
MälksooMaria (2016), ‘From the ESS to the EU Global Strategy: External Policy, Internal Purpose’, Contemporary Security Policy, 37(3): 374–388.
72.
ManchinRobert (2011), ‘Balkan Public Opinion and EU Accession’, Institute for Security Studies Chaillot Paper126: 165–172.
73.
MannersIan (2002), ‘Normative Power Europe: A Contradiction in Terms?’, JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies, 40(2): 235–258.
74.
MannersIan, and MurrayPhilomena (2016), ‘The End of a Noble Narrative? European Integration Narratives after the Nobel Peace Prize’, JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies, 54(1): 185–202.
75.
MarshallHannah, and DrieschovaAlena (2018), ‘Post-Truth Politics in the UK's Brexit Referendum’, New Perspectives, 26(3): 1–18.
76.
MellanderMaria, and MouritzenHans (2016), ‘Learning to Assert Themselves: Small States in Asymmetrical Dyads – Two Scandinavian Dogs Barking at the Russian Bear’, Cooperation and Conflict, 51(4): 447–466.
77.
MikelisKyriakos (2016), ‘“Neocolonial Power Europe”? Postcolonial Thought and the Eurozone Crisis’, French Journal for Media Research, 5: 1–18.
78.
MiskimmonAlister (2012), ‘German Foreign Policy and the Libyan Crisis’, German Politics, 21(4): 392–410.
79.
MissiroliAntonio (2013), ‘Security Governance Matters’, Journal of Contemporary European Research, 9(3): 477–483.
MoravcsikAndrew (2009), ‘Europe: The Quiet Superpower’, French Politics, 7: 403–422.
83.
MüllerPatrick (2016), ‘EU Foreign Policy: No Major Breakthrough Despite Multiple Crises’, Journal of European Integration, 38(3): 359–374.
84.
NeumannIver, and de CarvalhoBenjamin (2015), ‘Introduction: Small States and Status’, in CarvalhoBenjamin De, and NeumannIver (eds.) Small State Status Seeking: Norway's Quest for International Standing, Abingdon: Routledge, pp. 1–21.
85.
NielsenKristian (2013), ‘EU Soft Power and the Capability-Expectations Gap’, Journal of Contemporary European Research, 9(5): 723–739.
86.
NitoiuChristian (2016), ‘Russia and the EU's Quest for Status: The Path to Conflict in the Post-Soviet Space’, Global Affairs, 2(2): 143–153.
87.
NitoiuChristian, and SusMonika (2019), ‘Introduction: The Rise of Geopolitics in the EU's Approach in Its Eastern Neighbourhood’, Geopolitics, 24(1): 1–18.
88.
NizhnikauRynar (2016), ‘When Goliath Meets Goliath: How Russia and the EU Created a Vicious Circle of Instability in Moldova’, Global Affairs, 2(2): 203–216.
PediRevecca (2016), Theory of International Relations: Small States in the International System (Unpublished PhD Thesis), Department of International and European Studies, University of Macedonia, Thessaloniki. Available at https://www.didaktorika.gr/eadd/handle/10442/38599.
91.
PeterPomerantsev, and WeissMichael (2014), The Menace of Unreality: How the Kremlin Weaponizes Information, Culture and Money, New York: Institute for Modern Russia & The Interpreter. Available at http://www.galerie9.com/blog/the_menace_of_unreality_fin.pdf.
92.
ReiterDan (1994), ‘Learning, Realism, and Alliances: The Weight of the Shadow of the Past’, World Politics, 46(4): 490–526.
93.
RiddervoldMariane, and RosénGuri (2016), ‘Trick and Treat: How the Commission and the European Parliament Exert Influence in EU Foreign and Security Policies’, Journal of European Integration, 38(6): 687–702.
94.
RobinsonSteven (2016), ‘Still Focused on the Atlantic: Accounting for the Limited Europeanization of Portuguese Security Policy’, European Security, 25(1): 134–158.
SchmidlErwin (2001), ‘Small States and International Operations’, in ReiterErich, and GärtnerHeinz (eds.) Small States and Alliances, Heidelberg: Physica-Verlag HD, pp. 85–88.
97.
SchmittOliver (2013), ‘A Tragic Lack of Ambition: Why EU Security Policy Is No Strategy’, Contemporary Security Policy, 34(2): 413–416.
98.
SchwarzOliver (2016), ‘Two Steps Forward One Step Back: What Shapes the Process of EU Enlargement in South-Eastern Europe?’, Journal of European Integration, 38(7): 757–773.
99.
SelchowSabine (2016), ‘The Construction of “European Security” in the European Union in a Changing Global Environment: A Systematic Analysis’, European Security, 25(3): 281–303.
100.
SeposAndreas (2013), ‘Imperial Power Europe? The EU's Relations with the ACP Countries’, Journal of Political Power, 6(2): 261–287.
101.
SmithMichael (2013), ‘Beyond the Comfort Zone: Internal Crisis and External Challenge in the European Union's Response to Rising Powers’, International Affairs, 89(3): 653–671.
102.
SmithMichael (2016), ‘Implementing the Global Strategy Where It Matters Most: The EU's Credibility Deficit and the European Neighbourhood’, Contemporary Security Policy, 37(3): 446–460.
103.
Stanley-LockmanZoe, and WolfKatharina (2016), ‘European Defence Spending 2015: The Force Awakens’, Brief Issue, 10.1-4, Paris: EUISS. Available at http://www.iss.europa.eu/uploads/media/ Brief_10_Defence_spending.pdf.
TallisBenjamin, and ŠimečkaMichal (2017), ‘Charting the EU–National Strategic Constellation: Understanding EU Strategy through Member States’ Strategic Partnerships – an Analysis of the Czech Case’, International Politics, https://doi.org/10.1057/s41311-017-0124-y.
106.
ThorhallssonBaldur (2012), ‘Small States in the UN Security Council: Means of Influence?’, The Hague Journal of Diplomacy, 7(2): 135–160.
107.
ThorhallssonBaldur, and KirbyPeadar (2012), ‘Financial Crises in Iceland and Ireland: Does European Union and Euro Membership Matter?’, JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies, 50(5): 801–818.
108.
TocciNathalie (2016), ‘The Making of the EU Global Strategy’, Contemporary Security Policy, 37(3): 461–472.
109.
TojeAsle (2008a), ‘The European Union as a Small Power, or Conceptualizing Europe's Strategic Actorness’, journal of European Integration, 30(2): 199–215.
TojeAsle (2010), The European Union as a Small Power: After the Cold War, London: Palgrave Macmillan.
112.
TojeAsle (2011), ‘The European Union as a Small Power’, JCMS: journal of Common Market Studies, 49(1): 43–60.
113.
TojeAsle, and KunzBarbara (eds.) (2012), Neoclassical Realism in European Politics: Bringing Power Back in, Manchester: Manchester University Press.
114.
TreibOliver (2014), ‘The Voter Says No, but Nobody Listens: Causes and Consequences of the Eurosceptic Vote in the 2014 European Elections’, Journal of European Public Policy, 21(10): 1541–1554.
VitalDavid (1967), The Inequality of States: A Study of the Small Power in International Relations, Gloucestershire: Clarendon Press.
117.
WagnerWolfang, and AnholtRosane (2016), ‘Resilience as the EU Global Strategy's New Leitmotif: Pragmatic, Problematic or Promising?’, Contemporary Security Policy, 37(3): 414–430.
