For decades, governments have sought to deter migration by investing in the development of migrant-sending communities, despite macroeconomic data that shows that development can increase emigration. However, emerging research suggests that well-designed aid can promote rootedness in home communities. The US Agency for International Development (USAID) has increasingly attempted to use development to deter migration from the Northern Triangle states of Central America. Is this policy sound?
This paper argues that development should not be instrumentalized to discourage people from migrating. It examines migration and development policies from the lens of Catholic social teaching, which recognizes the need for states to respect the agency of individuals. This is particularly important when it comes to complex and consequential decisions like whether to migrate. The Catholic Church recognizes both a right to migrate, when necessary, and the responsibility of states, particularly wealthy nations, to help people realize the right not to migrate; that is, to thrive in their home communities. The paper argues for US government assistance to alleviate poverty and invest in human capital in Central America, but independently of efforts to deter migration. Prioritizing aid to potential migrants risks reducing its effectiveness. The United States should instead pursue a whole-of-government strategy that emphasizes the right relationships with aid recipients, and that prioritizes and empowers the poor and marginalized. The paper is strongly influenced by the author's 15 years of work for Catholic agencies on migration and development, more than one-half of those with Catholic Relief Services.
ClemensMichael A.2014b. “Does Development Reduce Migration?” In International Handbook on Migration and Economic Development, edited by LucasRobert E.B., 152–85. Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar.
DeLoreyMary. 2009. “International Migration: Social, Economic, and Humanitarian Considerations.” In And You Welcomed Me: Migration and Catholic Social Teaching, edited by KerwinDonaldGerschutzJill Marie, 31–53. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.
15.
Dexis Consulting Group and The University of Notre Dame. 2021. “Final Migration Report.” USAID. Monitoring and Evaluation Support for Collaborative Learning and Adapting Activity.
16.
DonatoKatharine M.SiskBlake. 2015. “Children’s Migration to the United States from Mexico and Central America: Evidence from the Mexican and Latin American Migration Projects.” Journal on Migration and Human Security3(1):58–79. https://doi.org/10.1177/233150241500300103.
17.
EasterlyWilliam. 2006. The White Man’s Burden. New York: The Penguin Press.
GAO (Government Accountability Office). 2021. “Northern Triangle of Central America: The 2019 Suspension and Reprogramming of US Funding Adversely Affected Assistance Projects” GAO-21-104366. September.https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-21-104366.pdf.
23.
GarcíaEscamillaAlfonsoAngel. 2021. “When Internal Migration Fails: A Case Study of Central American Youth Who Relocate Internally Before Leaving Their Countries.” Journal on Migration and Human Security9(4):297–310. https://doi.org/10.1177/23315024211042735.
GubertFlore. 2014. “The Discourse and Practice of co-Development in Europe.” In International Handbook on Migration and Economic Development, edited by LucasRobert E.B, 113–51. Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar.
26.
HollandbyrdHannahOmar RiosJ.. 2021. No Queda de Otra: An Exploration of the Root Causes of Migration to the Southern Border. El Paso: Hope Border Institute. https://www.hopeborder.org/noquedadeotra.
27.
HollenbachDavid. 1979. Claims in Conflict: Retrieving and Renewing the Catholic Human Rights Tradition. New York: Paulist Press.
28.
HollenbachDavid. 2002. The Common Good & Christian Ethics. New York: Cambridge University Press.
29.
HorstCindyEzzatiRojan TordholGuglielmoMatteoMezzettiPetraPirkkalainenPäiviSaggiomoValeriaSinattiGiuliaWarneckeAndrea. 2010. Participation of Diasporas in Peacebuilding and Development. A Handbook for Practitioners and Policymakers. Oslo: Peace Research Institute Oslo (PRIO). https://www.prio.org/publications/7305.
30.
IbáñezMaría Ana. 2014. “Growth in Forced Displacement: Cross-Country, sub-National and Household Evidence on Potential Determinants.” In International Handbook on Migration and Development, edited by LucasRobert E. B., 350–87. Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar.
JonesRick. 2019. “Written Testimony of Rick Jones, Senior Technical Advisor for Latin America and the Caribbean, Catholic Relief Services.” Hearing on Assessing the Impact of Cutting Foreign Assistance to Central America Before the House Comm. on Foreign Affairs Subcommittee on the Western Hemisphere, Civilian Security, and Trade, 116th Cong.https://www.congress.gov/116/meeting/house/110041/witnesses/HHRG-116-FA07-Wstate-JonesR-20190925.pdf.
34.
KerwinDonaldWarrenRobert. 2017. “National Interests and Common Ground in the US Immigration Debate: How to Legalize the US Immigration System and Permanently Reduce Its Undocumented Population.” Journal on Migration and Human Security5(2):297–330. https://doi.org/10.1177/233150241700500205.
35.
KicanasV. Rev. Gerald. 2009. Address at Jesuit Refugee Services Conference in Washington, DC, Georgetown University.
LucasRobert E. B.2014. “Migration and Economic Development: An introduction and Synopsis.” In International Handbook on Migration and Development, edited by LucasRobert E. B., 1–8. Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar.
39.
MeyerPeter. 2021. Central American Migration: Root Causes and US Policy. Washington, D.C.: Congressional Research Service. https://sgp.fas.org/crs/row/IF11151.pdf.
40.
Molina MillánTeresaMacoursKarenMaluccioJohn A.TejerinaLuis. 2019. The Long-Term Impacts of Honduras’ CCT Program: Higher Education and International Migration. Washington, D.C.: Inter-American Development Bank. https://doi.org/10.18235/0001670.
41.
MorrisonThomas K.1982. “The Relationship of U.S. Aid, Trade and Investment to Migration Pressures in Major Sending Countries.” The International Migration Review16(1):4–26. https://doi.org/10.2307/2545241.
O’NeillWilliam. 2009. “Christian Hospitality and Solidarity with the Stranger.” In And You Welcomed Me, Migration and Catholic Social Teaching, edited by KerwinDonaldGerschutzJill Marie, 149–55. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.
45.
ParsonsChristopher R.Alan WintersL.. 2014. “International Migration, Trade and aid: A Survey.” In International Handbook on Migration and Development, edited by LucasRobert E. B., 65–112. Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar.
SchmidtSusanSomersAryah. 2014. Children on the Run: Unaccompanied Children Leaving Central America and Mexico and the Need for International Protection. Washington, DC: United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR). https://www.unhcr.org/56fc266f4.html.
SmithCory. 2020. Addressing the Sex and Gender-Based Violence in Guatemala, Honduras, and El Salvador Fueling the US Border Crisis. Notre Dame: Pulte Institute for Global Development, University of Notre Dame.
56.
StecklovGuyWintersPaulStampiniMarcoDavisBenjamin. 2005. “Do Conditional Cash Transfers Influence Migration? A Study Using Experimental Data from the Mexican Progresa Program.” Demography42(4):769–90. https://doi.org/10.1353/dem.2005.0037.
