Danger in Public Spaces: Strengths and Limitations of Image- and Text-Based Warning Signs

Abstract

This study examines the effectiveness of images on warning signs that communicate risk and risk avoidance in public spaces. Specifically, I compared data from 749 survey responses to determine whether the use of images can increase the effectiveness of a warning sign in a public space. Although the findings indicate that image-based warning signs are better at communicating risk and deterring dangerous activity, longer expository text-only warning signs may be more effective at helping people identify and participate in safe activities. Implications and future studies are offered in the conclusion.

Keywords

warning signs risk communication visual communication public spaces

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Albers

M. J.

(Ed.). (2012).Human-information interaction and technical communication: Concepts and frameworks.Hershey, PA:IGI Global.

Argo

J. J.

Main

K. J.

(2004).Meta-analyses of the effectiveness of warning labels.Journal of Public Policy & Marketing,23,193-208.

Ayres

(2013).Warnings, anti-warnings, and pacifiers.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,57,1698-1701.

Borland

Wilson

Fong

G. T.

Hammond

Cummings

K. M.

Yong

H.-H.

. . . McNeill

(2009).Impact of graphic and text warnings on cigarette packs: Findings from four countries over five years.Tobacco Control,18,358-364.

Braun

C. C.

Silver

N. C.

(1995a).Interaction of signal word and colour on warning labels: Differences in perceived hazard and behavioural compliance.Ergonomics,38,2207-2220.

Braun

C. C.

Silver

N. C.

(1995b).Interaction of warning label features: Determining the contributions of three warning characteristics.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,39,984-988.

Braun

C. C.

Silver

N. C.

Stock

B. R.

(1992).Likelihood of reading warnings: The effect of fonts and font sizes.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,36,926-930.

Breakwell

G. M.

(2000).Risk communication: Factors affecting impact.British Medical Bulletin,56,110-120.

Cole

D. N.

Hammond

T. P.

McCool

S. F.

(1997).Information quantity and communication effectiveness: Low-impact messages on wilderness trailside bulletin boards.Leisure Sciences,19,59-72.

10.

Collins

B. L.

(1983).Evaluation of mine-safety symbols.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,27,947-949.

11.

Curtis

Ham

S. H.

Weiler

(2010).Identifying beliefs underlying visitor behaviour: A comparative elicitation study based on the theory of planned behaviour.Annals of Leisure Research,13,564-589.

12.

Desaulniers

D. R.

(1987).Layout, organization, and the effectiveness of consumer product warnings.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,31,56-60.

13.

Dragga

Voss

(2001).Cruel pies: The inhumanity of technical illustrations.Technical Communication,48,265-274.

14.

Edworthy

Adams

(1996).Warning design: A research prospective.London, England:Taylor & Francis.

15.

Espiner

S. R.

(1999).The use and effect of hazard warning signs: Managing visitor safety at Franz Josef and Fox Glaciers.Wellington, New Zealand:Department of Conservation.

16.

Espiner

S. R.

Weiss

(2010).Evaluating aspects of hazard awareness, safety message effectiveness and behavioural compliance among visitors to the Glaciers, Westland National Park, New Zealand: A report prepared for the Franz Josef Area Office.Wellington, New Zealand:Department of Conservation.

17.

Evans

A. T.

Peters

Strasser

A. A.

Emery

L. F.

Sheerin

K. M.

Romer

(2015).Graphic warning labels elicit affective and thoughtful responses from smokers: Results of a randomized clinical trial.PLoS ONE,10. Retrieved fromhttps://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0142879

18.

Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission. (2016).Case summary: Fatal alligator attack. Retrieved fromhttps://mediaassets.abcactionnews.com/document/2016/08/orlando_gator_finalreport.pdf

19.

Frantz

J. P.

(1993).Effect of location and presentation format on attention to and compliance with product warnings and instructions.Journal of Safety Research,24,131-154.

20.

Frantz

J. P.

(1994).Effect of location and procedural explicitness on user processing of and compliance with product warnings.Human Factors,36,532-546.

21.

Godfrey

S. S.

Laughery

K. R.

(1984).The biasing effects of product familiarity on consumers’ awareness of hazard.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,28,483-486.

22.

Godfrey

S. S.

Laughery

K. R.

Young

S. L.

Vaubel

K. P.

Brelsford

J. W.

Laughery

K. A.

Horn

(1991).The new alcohol warning labels: How noticeable are they? Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,35,446-450.

23.

Goldhaber

G. M.

deTurck

M. A.

(1988).Effects of consumers’ familiarity with a product on attention to and compliance with warnings.Journal of Products Liability,11,29-37.

24.

Goodman

Kuniavsky

Moed

(2012).Observing the user experience: A practitioner’s guide to user research(2nd ed.).Waltham, MA:Morgan Kaufmann.

25.

Harris

J. E.

Wiklund

M. E.

(1989).Consumer acceptance of threatening warnings in the residential environment.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,33,989-993.

26.

Hughes

Morrison-Saunders

(2002).Impact of trail-side interpretive signs on visitor knowledge.Journal of Ecotourism,1,122-132.

27.

Jackson

M. S.

White

G. N.

Schmierer

C. L.

(1996).Tourism experiences within an attributional framework.Annals of Tourism Research,23,798-810.

28.

Kalsher

M. J.

Pucci

Wogalter

M. S.

Racicot

B. M.

(1994).Enhancing the perceived readability of pharmaceutical container labels and warnings: The use of alternative designs and pictorials.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,38,384-388.

29.

Kalsher

M. J.

Wogalter

M. S.

Racicot

B. M.

(1996).Pharmaceutical container labels: Enhancing preference perceptions with alternative designs and pictorials.International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics,18,83-90.

30.

Kees

Burton

Andrews

J. C.

Kozup

(2010).Understanding how graphic pictorial warnings work on cigarette packaging.Journal of Public Policy & Marketing,29,265-276.

31.

Laughery

K. R.

Rowe-Hallbert

A. L.

Young

S. L.

Vaubel

K. P.

Laux

L. F.

(1991).Effects of explicitness in conveying severity information in product warnings.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,35,481-485.

32.

Laughery

K. R.

Stanush

J. A.

(1989).Effects of warning explicitness on product perceptions.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,33,431-435.

33.

Laughery

K. R.

Vaubel

K. P.

Young

S. L.

Brelsford

J. W.

Jr. Rowe

A. L.

(1993).Explicitness of consequence information in warnings.Safety Science,16,597-613.

34.

Laughery

K. R.

Young

S. L.

(1991a).An eye scan analysis of accessing product warning information.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,35,585-589.

35.

Laughery

K. R.

Young

S. L.

(1991b).Consumer product warnings: Design factors that influence noticeability. In Queinnec

Daniellou

(Eds.),Proceedings of the 11th Congress of the International Ergonomics Association(pp.1104-1106).London, England:Taylor & Francis.

36.

Leonard

Ponsi

K. A.

Silver

N. C.

Wogalter

M. S.

(1989).Pest-control products: Reading warnings and purchasing intentions.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,33,436-440.

37.

Leonard

S. D.

Creel

Karnes

E. W.

(1991).Adequacy of responses to warning terms.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,35,1024-1028.

38.

Leonard

S. D.

Matthews

Karnes

E. W.

(1986).How does the population interpret warning signals? Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,30,116-120.

39.

Main

B. W.

Frantz

J. P.

Rhoades

T. P.

(1993).Do consumers understand the difference between “flammable” and “combustible?” Ergonomics in Design,1(3),14-32.

40.

Map: 15 years of bison incidents in Yellowstone Park. (2015,August 4).Bozeman Daily Chronicle. Retrieved fromhttps://www.bozemandailychronicle.com/multimedia/maps/map-years-of-bison-incidents-in-yellowstone-park/html_8f681f08-0043-5074-99ca-64b2c3305b0c.html

41.

Mettler

Sharma

(2016,June 17).Disney installing signs warning of alligator’s after boy’s death.The Washington Post. Retrieved fromhttps://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2016/06/17/disney-will-begin-posting-alligator-warning-signs-after-boys-death/?utm_term=.cdb6524d87f1

42.

Miller

M. E.

(2015,July 23).Bison selfies are a bad idea: Tourist gored in Yellowstone as another photo goes awry.The Washington Post. Retrieved fromhttps://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2015/07/23/bison-selfies-are-a-bad-idea-tourist-gored-in-yellowstone-as-another-photo-goes-awry/?utm_term=.2fc32bdf7e36

43.

Monárrez-Espino

Liu

Greiner

Bremberg

Galanti

(2014).Systematic review of the effect of pictorial warnings on cigarette packages in smoking behavior.American Journal of Public Health,104(10),e11-e30.

44.

National Park Service. (n.d.).Visitor use in national parks. Retrieved fromhttps://www.nps.gov/yell/learn/nature/visitoruse.htm

45.

Njome

M. S.

Suh

C. E.

Chuyong

de Wit

M. J.

(2010).Volcanic risk perception in rural communities along the slopes of Mount Cameroon, West-Central Africa.Journal of African Earth Sciences,58,608-622.

46.

Noar

S. M.

Hall

M. G.

Francis

D. B.

Ribisl

K. M.

Pepper

J. K.

Brewer

N. T.

(2016).Pictorial cigarette pack warnings: A meta-analysis of experimental studies.Tobacco Control,25,341-354.

47.

Norman

Boer

Seydel

E. R.

(2005).Protection motivation theory. In Conner

Norman

(Eds.),Predicting health behaviour: Research and practice with social cognition models(2nd ed., pp.81-126).Maidenhead, England:Open University Press.

48.

Peters

Romer

Slovic

Jamieson

K. H.

Wharfield

Mertz

C. K.

Carpenter

S. M.

(2007).The impact and acceptability of Canadian-style cigarette warning labels among U.S. smokers and nonsmokers.Nicotine & Tobacco Research,9,473-481.

49.

Rhoades

T. P.

Frantz

J. P.

Miller

J. M.

(1990).Emerging methodologies for the assessment of safety-related product communications.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,34,998-1002.

50.

Riley

M. W.

Cochran

D. J.

Ballard

J. L.

(1982).An investigation of preferred shapes for warning labels.Human Factors,24,737-742.

51.

Rogers

W. A.

Lamson

Rousseau

G. K.

(2000).Warning research: An integrative perspective.Human Factors,42,102-139.

52.

Silver

N. C.

Braun

C. C.

(1993).Perceived readability of warning labels with varied font sizes and styles.Safety Science,16,615-625.

53.

Silver

N. C.

Kline

P. B.

Braun

C. C.

(1994).Type form variables: Differences in perceived readability and perceived hazardousness.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,38,821-825.

54.

Silver

N. C.

Leonard

D. C.

Ponsi

K. A.

Wogalter

M. S.

(1991).Warnings and purchase intentions for pest-control products.Forensic Reports,4,17-33.

55.

Smither

J. A.-A.

Braun

C. C.

(1994).Readability of prescription drug labels by older and younger adults.Journal of Clinical Psychology in Medical Settings,1,149-159.

56.

Trommelen

(1997).Effectiveness of explicit warnings.Safety Science,25,79-88.

57.

Vanderplas

J. M.

Vanderplas

J. H.

(1980).Some factors affecting legibility of printed materials for older adults.Perceptual and Motor Skills,50,923-932.

58.

Veer

Rank

(2012).Warning! The following packet contains shocking images: The impact of mortality salience on the effectiveness of graphic cigarette warning labels.Journal of Consumer Behaviour,11,225-233.

59.

Vukelich

Whitaker

L. A.

(1993).The effects of context on the comprehension of graphic symbols.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,37,511-515.

60.

Wachinger

Renn

Begg

Kuhlicke

(2013).The risk perception paradox: Implications for governance and communication of natural hazards.Risk Analysis,33,1049-1065.

61.

Whittlesey

L. H.

(2014).Death in Yellowstone: Accidents and foolhardiness in the first national park(2nd ed.).Lanham, MD:Rinehart.

62.

Wogalter

M. S.

Barlow

(1990).Injury severity and likelihood in warnings.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,34,580-583.

63.

Wogalter

M. S.

Godfrey

S. S.

Fontenelle

G. A.

Desaulniers

D. R.

Rothstein

P. R.

Laughery

K. R.

(1987).Effectiveness of warnings.Human Factors,29,599-612.

64.

Wogalter

M. S.

Jarrard

S. W.

Simpson

S. N.

(1994).Influence of warning label signal words on perceived hazard level.Human Factors,36,547-556.

65.

Wogalter

M. S.

Silver

N. C.

(1990).Arousal strength of signal words.Forensic Reports,3,407-420.

66.

Young

S. L.

(1991).Increasing the noticeability of warnings: Effects of pictorial, color, signal icon and border.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,35,580-584.

67.

Young

S. L.

Laughery

K. R.

Bell

(1992).Effects of two type density characteristics on the legibility of print.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,36,504-508.

68.

Young

S. L.

Wogalter

M. S.

(1988).Memory of instruction manual warnings: Effects of pictorial icons on conspicuous print.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,32,905-909.

69.

Young

S. L.

Wogalter

M. S.

(1990).Comprehension and memory of instruction manual warnings: Conspicuous print and pictorial icons.Human Factors,32,637-649.

70.

Young

S. L.

Wogalter

M. S.

Laughery

K. R.

Magurno

Lovvoll

(1995).Relative order and space allocation of message components in hazard warning signs.Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,39,969-973.