Abstract
Background:
For the establishment and monitoring of the immune status, CD4 count is critical.
Objectives:
To determine the CD4 count range of apparently healthy Nigerians resident in Ilorin and compare with the national value.
Methods:
An automated blood analyzer was used to determine the full blood count and CD4 count. The percentage of CD4 count was derived by using other variables.
Results:
Of the 1205 participants, the reference CD4 count (percentage of CD4) range for adult was 400 to 1288 cells/mm3 (19%-48%) and for children was 582 to 3652 cells/mm3 (17%-50%). CD4 count and percentage of CD4 were significantly (P = .001) higher in females than in males, and the CD4 count declined significantly with increasing age (r = −.174, P ≤ .0001). The percentage of CD4 count shows less variation with age (r = −.051, P = .076). Adult residents of Ilorin had significantly lower absolute mean CD4 count (808 ± 260) than that of the national reference values of 847.0 ± 307.0 cells/mm3 (P = .001).
Conclusion:
We therefore advocate the use of CD4 count range derived in this study is lower than that of the national reference values.
Introduction
The CD4 or helper T cells are subgroups of lymphocytes and are major determinant of the integrity of human immune system. It is responsible for the way the body responds to immunogens. The estimation of CD4 counts is a critical parameter in the establishment and monitoring of the immune status of an individual both in healthy and disease states. 1 -3 Determination of CD4 count is of particular importance in this era of HIV pandemic. It is used to stage the severity of HIV infection, determine the initiation of highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART), and also monitor the response to HAART. 1 -3 These qualities of CD4 count are quite relevant where viral assay is not readily available, cost effective, or just impractical as found in some resource-poor nations like Nigeria. There are several factors that affect the interpretation and the level of CD4 count in healthy and disease states; some of these are genetic inheritance, nutritional pattern, age, gender, and race. 4,5 For instance, the CD4 count in healthy children is known to be much higher than that of the adults and varies from one ethnic population to the other. 6 -9 Similarly, CD4 count values in normal Africans have been reported to be lower than those of the North American and European populations. 10 Normal CD4 count in the Caucasians are said to range from 500 to 1600 cells/mm3. Although a few studies have tried to set the reference CD4 count in Nigeria, 11,12 the result of those studies may not be comprehensive enough. This is because the studies were conducted with adults, excluding the children. Furthermore, no participant was recruited from Ilorin, Nigeria. The reference CD4 count of 365 to 1571 cells/mm3 reported by the study in question for Nigerians therefore requires a validation within the Ilorin environment. The present study therefore is designed to determine the CD4 count range of apparently healthy Nigerians of all age-groups living in Ilorin, Nigeria.
Methodology
Study Design and Setting
This was a cross-sectional study carried out in Ilorin, Kwara State, from January to December 2010. The study site is in the middle belt region of Nigeria, which is about 400 km north of Lagos, lying at 8°30'N 4°33'E.
Study Population
The study population comprises apparently healthy, HIV nonreactive persons of various age-groups resident of Ilorin and its environs.
Sample Size
Using Fishers formula and 50% as the proportion of the population targeted, the sample size of 384 was arrived at as detailed subsequently: sample size (n) = z2p (1 − p) = 1.962 × 0.031 × (1 − 0.031) = 384 d2 = 0.052, where z = standard error and taken as 1.96, p = proportion of the population targeted (50%), and d = desired degree of accuracy taken as 0.05. However, the number of participants recruited into the study was far in excess of the calculated sample size in order to have a good representative of the study population and increase the power of the study.
Selection of Participants
Apparently healthy, HIV nonreactive persons belonging to various age-groups were recruited into the study. The participants were selected by simple random sampling technique from schools, churches, mosques, markets, and barracks in and around Ilorin. Each consented participant was assessed clinically by an adult physician and a pediatrician for eligibility to take part in the study. The participants and their parents or guardians completed a screening questionnaire. They were assessed for signs of febrile illnesses, active infection, malnutrition, chronic medical condition, and infection. In addition, they were questioned to determine their medication history with the associated illness. Participants who gave history of systemic and local symptoms that are suggestive of diabetes mellitus, tuberculosis, cancer, and physical appearance that is typical of malnutrition were excluded outright. HIV sero-reactivity of the participants was also determined, and only those who were nonreactive were recruited into the study. The consented participants were certified healthy after a thorough history taking to exclude illnesses/conditions that may cause immune suppression like HIV, diabetes, malnutrition, tuberculosis, cancers, and pregnancy. All participants with other comorbidity that can affect the outcome of this study or who cannot adequately screen them of any illness were also excluded. The following categories of people were also excluded from the study: those who received blood transfusion within the last 6 months, pregnant women, and those on steroid or other immunosuppressive therapy. This method of screening participants was used in the previous studies 7 -10 and was adapted to our local setting.
Specimen Collection
Blood specimens were collected from the participants between 9.00
Specimen Handling
HIV sero-reactivity was determined according to the national algorithm. Parallel screening was quickly carried out using 2 rapid kits, and discordant results resolved with the third kit (tie breaker). Three kits (Start Pack, Chembio Diagnostics Systems, Inc, USA; Determine, Alere Medical C. Ltd, Japan; and Uni-gold, Trinity Biotech Plc, Ireland) were used according to manufacturer’s instruction. Participants were categorized as HIV nonreactive when they do not react to HIV in at least 2 rapid kits. The CD4 count and FBC were determined within 6 hours of blood specimen collection with Cyflow SL (Partec, Münster, Germany) and automatic blood count analyzer Sysmex KX21 (Sysmex, Japan), according to the manufacturer’s instruction.
Ethical Issues
Written informed consent and assent were obtained from all the participants. Ethical approval was obtained from the ethical review committee of UITH, Ilorin, Nigeria.
Pre- and Post-HIV Screening Counseling
Participants were all counseled before the HIV screening test was done and were also counseled before the results were disclosed to them. Some of the sero-reactive participants were referred to the HIV/AIDS clinic for documentation and initiation of care.
Disclosure of Results
All participants were encouraged to check personally with researchers at the UITH for the outcome of their test. Those individuals who failed to check were sent reminders through text messages to their mobile phone, especially those who provided their phone numbers at the time of recruitment. In cases where there were no responses, researchers located participants' residence based on the address given at the time of recruitment and counseled and communicated the result irrespective of their HIV status but maintained confidentiality.
Data Handling
Data generated were entered into SPSS with the results presented in tables. Comparisons of categorical data were done by chi-square analysis or Fisher exact tests as appropriate while continuous variables were described by means and compared by Student t test. Normality of CD4 count and its percentage were determined using 1-sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov test. The values that were normally distributed were expressed in mean, and standard deviation and nonnormally distributed variables were expressed as median and 2.5th to 97.5th percentile. P values < .05 were considered to be statistically significant.
Results
Sociodemographic Distribution of the Participants
A total of 1205 apparently healthy, HIV nonreactive persons resident in Ilorin and its environs were recruited in the study. The median age of the participants was 29 years, and interquartile range was 20 to 41 years. The minimum age was 1 month, while the maximum age was 65 years. In all, 595 (49.4%) were males and 610 (50.6%) were females, giving a male to female ratio of 1:1. The participants were predominantly employed (82.9%) and Muslim (63.9%), and a majority (68.6%) had tertiary education (Table 1).
Sociodemographic Distribution of the Participants.
NA, not applicable especially in children; yrs, years.
CD4 Count of the Participants
The absolute mean CD4 count obtained for whole population of Ilorin was 1023 ± 603 cells/mm3 (median 842 cells/mm3, range: 408-2785 cells/mm3). For the adult population, the mean CD4 count obtained was 808 ± 260 cells/mm3 (median 779 cells/mm3, range: 400-1288 cells/mm3). The total mean absolute CD4 count obtained for the children was 1816 ± 810 cells/mm3 (median 1792 cells/mm3, range: 582-3652 cells/mm3). Table 2 shows the mean CD4 count obtained for children of different age-groups.
Normal CD4 Count Ranges of Nigerians Resident in Ilorin.
Abbreviations: SD, standard deviation: yrs, years.
The Percentage of CD4 Count of the Participants
The percentage of absolute mean CD4 obtained for whole population of Ilorin was 32% ± 7% (median 32%, range:18%-46%). The percentage of mean CD4 for adults was 32% ± 7% (median 32%, range: 19%-48%), and for children was 32% ± 8% (median 32.0%, range 17-50). Table 3 shows the percentage of CD4 for children and adults.
Normal CD4 Percentage Ranges in Nigerians Residents in Ilorin.
Abbreviations: SD, standard deviation: yrs, years.
Sociodemographic Factors Associated with CD4 Count and Percentage of CD4
Females significantly had a higher absolute mean CD4 count (1077 ± 609 versus 965 ± 589) and percentage of CD4 (34% ± 6% versus 30% ± 7%) than adults; similarly, children had a significantly higher absolute mean CD4 count (1770 ± 821 versus 807 ± 260) than the adults, while there was no significant difference in their percentage of CD4 (32% ± 0% versus 32% ± 1%) in this study. Other sociodemographic variables had no significant effects on the CD4 count (Table 4). CD4 count declined significantly with increasing age (r = −0.174, P ≤ .0001; Table 5). The absolute mean CD4 count of adult males and females was significantly lower in this study than in the national study (Table 6).
Influence of Sociodemographic Variables on Normal CD4 Count.
Abbreviation: yrs, years.
a Data did not add up because of children.
The Association between Age, Gender, and Normal CD4 Count.
Comparison of Mean CD4 Counts of the Present Study with Previous National Study.
Discussion
This study has determined the CD4 count range of apparently healthy Nigerians of all age-groups living in Ilorin and its environs. This study presents the data on normal reference CD4 count to facilitate the assessment of degree of immune suppression, which is widely used in the stratification, treatment, and follow-up of HIV-infected individuals in clinical practice and AIDS-related research studies.
The mean CD4 count obtained in this study for adult population is comparatively lower than the national average of 847.0 + 307.0 cells/mm3 and 828 cells/mm3 reported in Jos Nigeria. 11,12 Similarly, when compared with other studies outside Nigeria, it is higher than the 746 cells/mm3 in Tanzania, 13 759 cells/mm3 in Botswana, 14 727 cells/mm3 in China, 15 and 753 cells/mm3 in Ethiopia 1 the and lower than, 830 cells/mm3 in the United Kingdom, 16 865 cells/mm3 in India, 2 910 cells/mm3 in Thailand, 17 1095 cells/mm3 in Turkey, 18 and 1256 cells/mm3 in Uganda. 19 The observed differences in CD4 reference values might be due to the heterogeneity of population as a result of ethnoracial variations, interlaboratory variability, and the differences in the laboratory methodologies of measuring CD4 count especially where the variations were not controlled.
The mean percentage of CD4 obtained in this study for adult population is similar to the Malaysian population 20 and is lower than the 42% in Romania 21 and 47% in Turkey. 18 In this study, in view of the statistical difference in both the CD4 count and the percentage of CD4 obtained for both gender in adult and childhood, it is imperative to establish a reference range separately for each of them. The reference range of CD4 count was significantly higher in females than in the males, and this result is in agreement with other studies in Africa, 8,12,14,19 India, 2,22 and Britain. 23 This reported gender difference in CD4 counts is attributed to the effect of sex hormones. 23
In children ≤1 month of age, the mean CD4 count obtained is lower than the 3050 reported in Saudi Arabia 24 but higher than the 2000 reported in Malawi, 25 2001 in Cameron, 26 and 1816 in Ethiopia. 27 For those between 2 months of life to 1 year, the mean CD4 count is lower than the 2200 in Malawi 25 and 2252 in Cameron, 26 but lower values were obtained in the developed countries like the Netherlands 28 and the United States. 29,30 The CD4 count observed in children of African countries was found to be lower than the values reported in children of developed countries. This difference is attributed to genetics or environmental factors or a combination of both factors. We observed that the mean CD4 count and percentage of CD4 peaked in the first year of life and then decreased during childhood. Similar trend was also observed in previous studies in Africa and elsewhere. 24,26,27
The present study also shows that age and gender are significant determinants of CD4 count and its percentage. CD4 count and percentage of CD4 were significantly higher in females than in males and declined significantly with increasing age. From the neonatal period to adulthood, the percentage of CD4 shows less variation than that of CD4 count. The World Health Organization has stated that percentage of CD4 rather than the CD4 absolute count may be preferred as the best surrogate marker for monitoring HIV-infected children of all ages, rather than just among those aged <5 years. 31
We also compared our findings with the previous study in Nigeria and found a statistically significant difference in the values of CD4 count obtained in the 2 studies. Considering the significant difference in parameter between the 2 studies in the same country, this result has an important implication for the use of T-lymphocyte subset measurements for the evaluation and treatment of HIV-infected patients in this locality and recruitment in clinical trials.
The strength of this study was its ability to establish a reference range in both adult and children population in Nigeria with a large sample size. However, we were limited by our inability to determine the counts of other subsets of T lymphocytes.
Conclusion
We therefore advocate the use of CD4 count range derived in this study because it is lower than the national reference values.
Footnotes
Acknowledgments
The authors wish to thank the Laboratory staff of Abaniselolu Hospital, Adeta, Ilorin, for their assistance. We also appreciate the scientists working at HIV/HAART Laboratory of the University of Ilorin Teaching Hospital for their support.
Declaration of Conflicting Interests
The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
Funding
The author(s) received no financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
