This article examines intellectual property rights (IPR) regimes as they apply to agricultural germplasm in the context of global North-South relations. The issue is pertinent particularly since TRIPs (Trade-related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights) became enshrined in the statutes of the World Trade Organization in 1994, institutionalizing the notion of ‘germplasm as property’ throughout the globe. Yet, the idea of ‘germplasm as property’ is a notion culturally specific to the global North historically. It is perhaps no surprise that many germplasm patents are being held on biological matter that originated in the South–in the Vavilovian ‘centers of diversity’. This paradox situates the contest over biodiversity resources in a world-historic context and undermines the declared reasons for germplasm IPRs. Besides, more than just a North-South conflict over resources, this episode features also a confrontation between competing worldviews of nature-human relations.
ActionAid (2001). Crops and robbers. London: ActionAid.
2.
AndersonLuke2000. Genetic engineering, food and our environment. Melbourne: Scribe Publications.
3.
AtkinsonRichard C.BeachyRoger N.ConwayGordonCordovaFrance A.FoxMarye AnnHolbrookKaren A.KlessigDaniel F.McCormickRichard L.McPhersonPeter M.RawlingsHunter R.IIIRapsonRipVanderhoefLarry N.WileyJohn D.YoungCharles E. (2003). Intellectual property rights: Public sector collaboration for agricultural IP management, Science301(5630), 174–75.
4.
BakerGladys L.RasmussenWayne D.WiserVivianPorterJane M. (1963). Century of service: The first one hundred years of the department of agriculture. Washington DC: US Government Printing Office (USGPO).
5.
BalanyaBelenDohertyAnnHoedemanOlivierMa’anitAdamWesseliusErik (2000). Europe Inc. London: Pluto Press.
6.
BerlanJean-PierreLewontinRichard (1986). The political economy of hybrid corn, Monthly Review, 38(3).
BurkDan L.BarovskyKennethMonroyGladys H. (1993). Biodiversity and biotechnology, Science260(5116), 1900–01.
9.
CoatesKen (2004). A global history of indigenous peoples: Struggle and survival. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
10.
CrosbyAlfred (1972). The Columbian exchange: Biological and cultural consequences of 1492. Westport, CT: Greenwood Publishing Company.
11.
DutfieldGraham (2003). Intellectual property rights and the life science industries: A twentieth century history. Aldershot: Ashgate Publishing.
12.
EnyartJames (1990). A GATT intellectual property code, Les Nouvelles, June, 53–56.
13.
GolleyFrank1993. A history of the ecosystem concept in ecology: More than the sum of the parts. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
14.
GrilichesZvi (1958). Research costs and social returns: Hybrid corn and related innovations, Journal of Political Economy, 66, 419–31.
15.
HelferLaurence (2004). Regime shifting: The TRIPs agreement and new dynamics of international intellectual property lawmaking, Yale Journal of International Law, 29, 1–81.
16.
KloppenburgJack (1988). First the seed. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
17.
KloseNelson (1950). America’s crop heritage: The history of foreign plant introduction by the federal government. Ames, IA: Iowa State College Press.
18.
LeibenluftRobert. (1981). Competition in farm inputs: An examination of four industries. Washington, DC: Office of Policy Planning, Federal Trade Commission, National Technical Information Service.
19.
LewontinRichard (1982). Agricultural research and the penetration of capital, Science for the People, 14(1), 12–17.
20.
PorterC. (1961). Certified seed in a merchandising program. In Annual Report of the International Crop Improvement Association. ICIA.
21.
RaustialaKalVictorDavid (2004). The regime complex for plant genetic resources, International Organization, 58(2): 277–309.
22.
RAFI/UNDP [Rural Advancement Foundation International and United Nations Development Programme] (1994). Conserving indigenous knowledge: integrating two systems of innovation. New York, NY: UNDP.
23.
SafrinSabrina (2004). Hyperownership in a time of biotechnological promise: The international conflict to control the building blocks of life, The American Journal of International Law, 98, 641–85.
24.
SantanielloVittorioEvensonRobertZilbermanDavidCarlsonGerald (Eds) (2000). Agriculture and intellectual property rights: Economic, institutional and implementation issues in biotechnology (pp. 1–10) Oxon: CABI Publishing.
ShivaVandana (2001). Protect or plunder: Understanding intellectual property rights. New York, NY: Zed Books.
27.
ShivaVandana (1997). The turmeric patent is just the first step in stopping biopiracy, Third World Network, available at www.twnside.org.sg/title/tur-cn.htm, accessed on 26 August 2012.
28.
SimmondsNorman (1979). Principles of crop improvement. New York, NY: Longman.
29.
SteeleLeonard (1978). The hybrid corn industry in the United States. In WaldenDavid B. (Ed.), Maize breeding and genetics (pp. 29–39). New York, NY: Wiley Interscience.
30.
WilkesGarrison (1983). Current status of crop germplasm, Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences, 1(2), 133–81.
31.
World Bank (2001). Global economic prospects and the developing countries 2002: Making trade work for the world’s poor. Washington, DC: World Bank.
32.
ZevenAnton C.ZhukovskyPetr. M. (1975). Dictionary of cultivated plants and their centres of diversity. Wageningen: Centre for Agricultural Publishing and Documentation.
