Behavioral Compliance with Safety Signs and Labels: An Analysis of Research Methods from the Past 25 Years

Abstract

This paper reviews research published from 1998 to 2022 that involved collection of original data related to behavioral compliance with safety signs and labels. This review provides a needed update to previous similar reviews using a published taxonomical approach. The approach was used here to categorize study methodology and was extended to further categorize studies by whether they addressed behavioral compliance or intention/predicted likelihood of compliance. Nearly all of the studies reviewed assessed behavior in laboratories or via surveys of hypothetical scenarios, and relatively few used real-world experimental or real-world observational methods. Results revealed a lack of empirical demonstrations that intention and predicted likelihood of compliance are reliable predictors of real-world behavioral compliance. There was also a notable lack of evidence that warnings design aspects impact such real-world compliance.

Keywords

On-Product Labels Literature Review Behavior Change Warnings Effectiveness Laboratory Research Real-World Contexts Warnings Research Research Methods Taxonomy Warning Messages

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abulhassan

Bani Hani

Davis

G. A.

(2018). Effectiveness of pictogram instructions for donning smoke hoods. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 62(1), 1504-1507.

Adams

Bochner

Bilik

(1998). The effectiveness of warning signs in hazardous work places: Cognitive and social determinants. Applied Ergonomics, 29(4), 247-254.

Almeida

Rebelo

Noriega

Vilar

Borges

(2015). Virtual environment evaluation for a safety warning effectiveness study. Procedia Manufacturing, 3, 5971-5978.

Arndt

S. R.

Ayres

T. J.

McCarthy

R. L.

Schmidt

R. A.

Wood

C. T.

Young

D. E.

(1998). Warning labels and accident data. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 42(6), 550-553.

Ayres

T. J.

Gross

M. M.

Horst

D. P.

Robinson

J. N.

(1992). A methodological taxonomy for warnings research. Proceedings of the Human Factors Society Annual Meeting, 36(5), 499-503.

Ayres

T. J.

Wood

Schmidt

Young

Murray

(1998). Effectiveness of warning labels and signs: An update on compliance research. Proceedings of the Silicon Valley Ergonomics Conference & Exposition, 199, 199-205.

Bowles

C. T.

Fisk

A. D.

Rogers

W. A.

(2002). Inference and the use of similes and metaphors in warnings. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 46(19), 1703-1707.

Burnett

T. J.

Purswell

J. L.

Purswell

J. P.

Krenek

R. F.

(1998). Hot water burn hazards: Warning label influence on user temperature adjustment. International Journal of Cognitive Ergonomics, 2, 145-157.

Cox

E. P.

Wogalter

M. S.

Stokes

S. L.

Murff

E. J. T.

(1997). Do product warnings increase safe behavior? A meta-analysis. Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 16(2), 195–204.

10.

Davies

Haines

Norris

Wilson

J. R.

(1998). Safety pictograms: Are they getting the message across? Applied Ergonomics, 29(1), 15-23.

11.

Deppa

S. W.

(2000). Methodology for performing applied research to improve an existing product warning (soda bottle). Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 44(27), 298-301.

12.

DeJoy

D. M.

(1989). Consumer product warnings: Review and analysis of effectiveness research. Proceedings of the Human Factors Society Annual Meeting, 33(15), 936-940.

13.

deTurck

M. A.

Chih

I. H.

Hsu

Y. P.

(1999). Three studies testing the effects of role models on product users’ safety behavior. Human Factors, 41(3), 397-412.

14.

Duarte

Rebelo

Teles

Noriega

(2012). What should I do?–A study about conflicting and ambiguous warning messages. Work, 41(Supplement 1), 3633-3640.

15.

Duarte

Rebelo

Teles

Wogalter

M. S.

(2010). Behavioral compliance in virtual reality: Effects of warning type. In Karwowski

Salvendy

(Eds.), Advances in Human Factors, Ergonomics and Safety in Manufacturing and Service Industries. CRC Press.

16.

Duarte

Rebelo

Teles

Wogalter

M. S.

(2014a). Safety sign comprehension by students, adult workers and disabled persons with cerebral palsy. Safety Science, 62, 175-186.

17.

Duarte

Rebelo

Teles

Wogalter

M. S.

(2014b). Behavioral compliance for dynamic versus static signs in an immersive virtual environment. Applied Ergonomics, 45(5), 1367-1375.

18.

Edworthy

Dale

(2000). Extending knowledge of the effects of social influence in warning compliance. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 44(25), 107-110.

19.

Edworthy

Hellier

Morley

Grey

Aldrich

Lee

(2004). Linguistic and location effects in compliance with pesticide warning labels for amateur and professional users. Human Factors, 46(1), 11-31.

20.

Frantz

J. P.

Rhoades

T. P.

Shah

R. J.

Hall

S. M.

Isaacson

J. J.

Burhans

C. G.

(2005b). ANSI Z535 signal words and the ability to infer hazard and consequence information-1992 versus 2004. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 49(19), 1790-1794.

21.

Frantz

J. P.

Rhoades

T. P.

Young

S. L.

Schiller

J. A.

(2000). Assessing the effects of adding messages to warning labels. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 44(28), 818-821.

22.

Frantz

J. P.

Young

S. L.

Rhoades

T. P.

Wisniewski

E. C.

(2005a). Predicted versus actual response to warning signs and labels: Examining the role of ANSI Z535 features. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 49(19), 1785-1789.

23.

Freeman

Wogalter

M. S.

(2001). Evaluation of pictorial symbols to warn computer keyboard users about carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS). Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 45(20), 1468-1472.

24.

Hancock

P. A.

Kaplan

A. D.

MacArthur

K. R.

Szalma

J. L.

(2020). How effective are warnings? A meta-analysis. Safety Science, 130, 104876.

25.

Harrell

W. A.

(2003). Effect of two warning signs on adult supervision and risky activities by children in grocery shopping carts. Psychological Reports, 92(3), 889-898.

26.

Heckman

G. M.

Harley

E. M.

Scher

Young

D. E.

(2010). Helmet use in sledding: Do users comply with manufacturer warnings? Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 54(10), 733-737.

27.

Kalsher

M. J.

Gallo

J. B.

Williams

K. J.

Wogalter

M. S.

(2000). High levels of behavioral compliance in a realistic product assembly task. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 44(28), 822-825.

28.

Kalsher

M. J.

Obenauer

W. G.

Weiss

C. F.

(2016). Evaluating ANSI Z535-formatted warning labels as an integrative system. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 60(1), 1642-1646.

29.

Kalsher

M. J.

Williams

K. J.

(2006). Behavioral compliance: Theory, methodology, and results. In Wogalter

M.S.

(Ed.), Handbook of Warnings (pp. 335-354). CRC Press.

30.

Khan

Krauss

Alper

Droll

Arndt

Lakhiani

Cades

(2013). Do people heed warnings at gas stations? Proceedings of the 2nd Annual World Conference of the Society for Industrial and Systems Engineering, 114-117.

31.

Kim

Cowley

Wogalter

M. S.

(2007). Emphasis terms for warning directives on compliance intent. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 51(9),569-573.

32.

Kim

Wogalter

M. S.

(2015). Effects of emphasis terminology in warning instructions on compliance intent and understandability. Journal of Safety Research, 55, 41-51.

33.

Laughery

K. R.

Laughery

K. A.

Lovvoll

D. R.

(1998). Tire rim mismatch explosions: the role of on-product warnings. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 42(15), 1088-1091.

34.

Laughery

K. R.

Paige

D. L.

(2003). The effectiveness of warning information in dietary supplement product labels. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 47(14), 1740–1743.

35.

Laughery

K. R.

Paige

D. L.

Laughery

B. R.

Wogalter

M. S.

Kalsher

M. J.

Leonard

S. D.

(2002). Guidelines for warnings design: Do they matter? Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 46(19), 1708-1712.

36.

Lesch

M. F.

(2008). Warning symbols as reminders of hazards: Impact of training. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 40(3), 1005–1012.

37.

Lim

R. W.

Wogalter

M. S.

(2004). Printed warning statements and signal words on intended carefulness. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 48(16), 2031–2034.

38.

Martin

B. J.

(2000). The value of explicit hazard and consequence warnings for products with hidden hazards. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 44(27), 302–305.

39.

McCarthy

R. L.

Finnegan

J. P.

Krumm-Scott

McCarthy

G. E.

(1984). Product information presentation, user behavior, and safety. Proceedings of the Human Factors Society Annual Meeting, 28(1), 81-85.

40.

Meingast

(2001). Increasing attention and retention of warnings: Effects of container hazardousness, warning quality, and severity of injury. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 45(20), 1482–1486.

41.

Mortimer

R. G.

(2007). Effectiveness of a warning as measured by behavior change. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 51(9), 574–577.

42.

Nemire

(2016). Ratings of the effectiveness of warnings on consumer paint stripper products: Evaluation by university students and MTurk workers of FHSA- and ANSI Z535.4-formatted warning labels. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 60(1), 480–484.

43.

Nemire

(2018). Consumer perception of portable ladder hazards and warnings. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 62(1), 411–415.

44.

Ortiz

Resnick

M. L.

Kengskool

(2000). The effects of familiarity and risk perception on workplace warning compliance. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 44(28), 826–829.

45.

Parikhal

Abraham

Mehler

McWilliams

Dobres

Chahine

Reimer

(2018). These labels are nuts: Challenges to safe product identification for nut-allergic consumers. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 62(1), 987–991.

46.

Reis

Duarte

Rebelo

(2015). Research on workplace safety sign compliance: Validation of a virtual environment prototype. Procedia Manufacturing, 3, 6599–6606.

47.

Rogers

W. A.

Lamson

Rousseau

G. K.

(2000). Warning research: An integrative perspective. Human Factors, 42(1), 102-139.

48.

Rojas

K. M.

(2017). Adverse events and over-the-counter (OTC) drugs: Is inappropriate labeling the problem? - The case of acetaminophen. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 61(1), 676–680.

49.

Santos

Resnick

M. L.

(2002). Comparison of on-line and physical presentation of product safety information. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 46(19), 1748–1752.

50.

Shaver

E. F.

Braun

C. C.

(2000). Effects of warning symbol explicitness and warning color on behavioral compliance. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 44(27), 290–293.

51.

Shaver

E. F.

Young

S. L.

Frantz

J. P.

Rhoades

T. P.

Hall

S. M.

Shah

R. J.

(2006). Comparison of ANSI and ISO standard formats on people’s response to product warnings. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 50(19), 2197–2201.

52.

Silver

N.C.

Braun

C.C.

(1999). Behavior. In Wogalter

W.S.

DeJoy

D.M.

Laughery

K.R.

(Eds.), Warnings and Risk Communication (pp. 245-262). Taylor & Francis.

53.

Silver

N. C.

Drake

K. L.

Niaghi

Z. B.

Brim

A. C.

Pedraza

(2002). The effects of product, signal word, and color on warning labels: Differences in perceived hazard. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 46(6), 735–739.

54.

Smith-Jackson

Durak

(2000). Posted warnings, compliance, and behavioral intent. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 44(25), 115–118.

55.

Taylor

V. A.

Bower

A. B.

(2004). Improving product instruction compliance: “If you tell me why, I might comply.” Psychology and Marketing, 21(3), 229–245.

56.

Thorley

Hellier

Edworthy

(2001). Habituation effects in visual warnings. In Hanson

M. A.

(Ed.), Contemporary Ergonomics. Taylor & Francis.

57.

Vredenburgh

Longden

Williams

Kalsher

(2003). Medical product labeling: The evaluation of latex glove warnings in a realistic setting. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 47(12), 1554–1558.

58.

Weaver

J. L.

Helmick

J. A.

Burke

K. A.

(2003). An investigation of individual differences in relation to warning compliance and user affect: Preliminary findings. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 47(9), 1102–1106.

59.

Wogalter

M. S.

Kalsher

M. J.

Glover

B. L.

Magurno

A. B.

(1998). Connecting jumper cables: The effectiveness of pictorial warnings. In Zwaga

Boersema

Hoonhout

(Eds.), Visual Information For Everyday Use (pp. 161-166). CRC Press.

60.

Wogalter

M. S.

Kalsher

M. J.

Rashid

(1999). Effect of signal word and source attribution on judgments of warning credibility and compliance likelihood. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 24(2), 185–192.

61.

Wogalter

M. S.

Magurno

A. B.

Rashid

Klein

K. W.

(1998). The influence of time stress and location on behavioral warning compliance. Safety Science, 29(2), 143–158.

62.

Wogalter

M. S.

Young

S. L.

Brelsford

J. W.

Barlow

(1999). The relative contributions of injury severity and likelihood information on hazard-risk judgments and warning compliance. Journal of Safety Research, 30(3), 151–162.

63.

Young

S. L.

Shah

R. J.

Frantz

J. P.

Rhoades

T. P.

(2004). Exploring the influence of message length, location, repeated exposure and user evaluation on response to warnings and instructions. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 48(16), 2055–2059.