Everyone Hates the NCAA: The Role of Identity in the Evaluations of Amateurism Transgressions: A Case Study of the Chase Young Loan Scandal

Abstract

This manuscript is a case study into public responses to an amateurism transgression committed by Chase Young, a former Ohio State University football player and Heisman candidate. In November of 2019, Young utilized his personal Twitter to announce an amateurism transgression stemming from his acceptance of an improper loan. This study considers 1,674 public and direct replies to Young on Twitter. A variety of themes were identified, including attempts to support Young, externalize the blame, dispute Young’s story, exchange information, communicate ambiguously, and contemplate consequences of the transgression. Utilizing social identity theory and identity threat management, public expressions of fandom were positioned as a variable that explained the diversity in responses to Young’s transgression. Indeed, findings illustrated in-group and out-group biases, whereby Ohio State fans supported Young and fans of other teams disputed his story. Interestingly non-expressed fans engaged in image repair on Young’s behalf via externalizing blame to other institutions, especially the NCAA, which may demonstrate the interplay of multifaceted identities. Results from this manuscript help lay the groundwork for audience-centered efforts to understand athlete transgressions.

Keywords

amateurism athlete transgression identity threat management social identity theory

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abrams

Hogg

M. A.

(1988). Comments on the motivational status of self-esteem in social identity and intergroup discrimination. European Journal of Social Psychology, 18(4), 317–334. https://doi.org/10.1002/ejsp.2420180403

Allison

Pegoraro

(2018). Abby Wambach: G.O.A.T. (greatest of all time) if just a goat? In Billings

A. C.

Coombs

W. T.

Brown

K. A.

(Eds.), Reputational challenges in sport: Theory and application (pp. 210–226). Routledge.

Allison

Pegoraro

Frederick

Thompson

A. J.

(2020). When women athletes transgress: An exploratory study of image repair and social media response. Sport in Society, 23(6), 1023–1041. https://doi.org/10.1080/17430437.2019.1580266

Arendt

LaFleche

Limperopulos

M. A.

(2017). A qualitative meta-analysis of apologia, image repair, and crisis communication: Implications for theory and practice. Public Relations Review, 43(3), 517–526. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pubrev.2017.03.005

Armfield

G. G.

McGuire

(2017). Peddling the truth or coasting downhill? Lance Armstrong and the use of image repair strategies. The Sport Journal. https://thesportjournal.org/article/peddling-the-truth-or-coasting-downhill-lance-armstrong-and-the-use-of-image-repair-strategies/

Beasley

T. M.

Schumacker

R. E.

(1995). Multiple regression approach to analyzing contingency tables: Post hoc and planned comparison procedures. The Journal of Experimental Education, 64(1), 79–93. https://doi.org/10.1080/00220973.1995.9943797

Billig

Tajfel

(1973). Social categorization and similarity in intergroup behaviour. European Journal of Social Psychology, 3(1), 27–52. https://doi.org/10.1002/ejsp.2420030103

Billings

A. C.

(2014). Power in reverberation: Why Twitter matters, but not the way most believe. Communication & Sport, 2(2), 107–112. https://doi.org/10.1177/2167479514527427

Branscombe

N. R.

Ellemers

Spears

Doosje

(1999). The context and content of social identity threat. In Ellemers

Spears

Doosje

(Eds.), Social identity (pp. 35–59). Blackwell.

10.

Brooks

K. J.

(2019, October 29). NCAA to let college athletes profit from their likeness. CBSnews.com. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/ncaa-players-can-get-paid-for-likeness-name-image-and-likeness-officials-say-today-2019-10-29/

11.

Brown

K. A.

(2016). Is apology the best policy? An experimental examination of the effectiveness of image repair strategies during criminal and noncriminal athlete transgressions. Communication & Sport, 4(1), 23–42. https://doi.org/10.1177/2167479514544950

12.

Brown

K. A.

Billings

Devlin

(2016). Image repair across the racial spectrum: Experimentally exploring athlete transgression responses. Communication Research Reports, 33(1), 47–53. https://doi.org/10.1080/08824096.2015.1117442

13.

Brown

K. A.

Billings

A. C.

Mastro

Brown-Devlin

(2015). Changing the image repair equation: Impact of race and gender on sport-related transgressions. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly, 92(2), 487–506. https://doi.org/10.1177/1077699015574484

14.

Brown

K. A.

Dickhaus

Long

M. C.

(2012). LeBron James and” The Decision”: An empirical examination of image repair in sports. Journal of Sports Media, 7(1), 149–175. https://doi.org/10.1353/jsm.2012.0010

15.

Brown

N. A.

Billings

A. C.

(2013). Sports fans as crisis communicators on social media websites. Public Relations Review, 39(1), 74–81. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pubrev.2012.09.012

16.

Brown

N. A.

Brown

K. A.

Billings

A. C.

(2015). “May No Act of Ours Bring Shame” Fan-enacted crisis communication surrounding the Penn state sex abuse scandal. Communication & Sport, 3(3), 288–311. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.janxdis.2014.07.005

17.

Brown

(2000). Social identity theory: Past achievements, current problems and future challenges. European Journal of Social Psychology, 30(6), 745–778. https://doi/org10.1002/1099-0992(200011/12)30:63.0.co;2-o

18.

Brown-Devlin

Brown

K. A.

(2020). When crises change the game: Establishing a typology of sports-related crises. Journal of International Crisis and Risk Communication Research, 3(1), 49–70. https://doi.org/10.30658/jicrcr.3.1.3

19.

Chien

P. M.

Kelly

S. J.

Weeks

C. S.

(2016). Sport scandal and sponsorship decisions: Team identification matters. Journal of Management, 30(5), 490–505. https://doi.org/10.1123/jsm.2015-0327

20.

Cho

Xiong

Boatwright

(2021). Through the lens of ethnicity: Semantic network and thematic analyses of United Airlines’ dragging crisis. Public Relations Review, 47(1), 102006.

21.

Coombs

W. T.

Holladay

S. J.

(2014). How publics react to crisis communication efforts. Journal of Communication Management, 18(1), 40–57. https://doi.org/10.1108/jcom-03-2013-0015

22.

Cranmer

G. A.

Cassilo

Sanderson

Troutman

(2019). Social media discourse about Division-I football players’ announcements of early exit: The role of expressed fandom. Communication & Sport. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1177/2167479519874804

23.

Cranmer

G. A.

Sanderson

(2018). “Rough week for testosterone”: Public commentary around the Ivy League’s decision to restrict tackle football in practice. Western Journal of Communication, 82(5), 631–647. https://doi.org/10.1080/10570314.2018.1441431

24.

Doise

Csepeli

Dann

H. D.

Gouge

Larsen

Ostell

(1972). An experimental investigation into the formation of intergroup representations. European Journal of Social Psychology, 2(2), 202–204. https://doi.org/10.1002/ejsp.2420020208

25.

Erik Meier

Utesch

Raue

Uhlenbrock

Chababi

Strauss

(2019). Fan identification and national identity. Sport in Society, 22(3), 476–498.

26.

Forde

(2019, November 8). College sports’ black Friday further damages NCAA’s rocky foundation. SI.com. https://www.si.com/college/2019/11/09/chase-young-james-wiseman-ruling-damage-ncaa-foundation

27.

Frederick

Pegoraro

(2018). Scandal in college basketball: A case study of image repair via Facebook. International Journal of Sport Communication, 11(3), 414–429. https://doi.org/10.1123/ijsc.2018-0076

28.

Frederick

E. L.

Burch

L. M.

Sanderson

Hambrick

M. E.

(2014). To invest in the invisible: A case study of Manti Te’o’s image repair strategies during the Katie Couric interview. Public Relations Review, 40(5), 780–788. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pubrev.2014.05.003

29.

Giles

Stohl

(2017). Sport as intergroup communication: Fans, rivalries, communities, and nations. In Billings

A. C.

(Ed.), Defining sport communication (pp. 150–164). Routledge.

30.

Godfrey

(2014, April 10). Meet the bag man: 10 rules for paying college football players: How to buy college football players, in the words of men who deliver the money. SBNation.com. https://blog.sbnation.com/2014/4/16/5621370/college-football-fans-must-read-meet-the-bag-man

31.

Hambrick

M. E.

(2018). Investigating athletes and their image repair strategies during crises. In Billings

A. C.

Coombs

W. T.

Brown

K. A.

(Eds.), Reputational challenges in sport: Theory and application (pp. 137–152). Routledge.

32.

Hambrick

M. E.

Frederick

E. L.

Sanderson

(2015). From yellow to blue: Exploring Lance Armstrong’s image repair strategies across traditional and social media. Communication & Sport, 3(2), 196–218. https://doi.org/10.1177/2167479513506982

33.

Harker

(2019). Identification and crisis: An exploration into the influence of sports identification on stakeholder perceptions of sports-related crisis. Journal of Sports Media, 14(1), 171–199.

34.

Hobson

(2018, October 1). Inside the basketball black market that put Adidas in the FBI’s crosshairs. WashingtonPost.com . https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/inside-the-basketball-black-market-that-put-adidas-in-the-fbis-crosshairs/2018/10/01/2a73ba76-c1ad-11e8-97a5-ab1e46bb3bc7_story.html

35.

Jenkins

(2014). Social identity. Routledge.

36.

Johansen

B. F.

Johansen

Weckesser

N. M.

(2016). Emotional stakeholders as “crisis communicators” in social media. Corporate Communications: An International Journal, 21(3), 289–308. https://doi.org/10.1108/ccij-05-2015-0026

37.

Johansen

(2018). Rhetorical arena. In Heath

R. L.

Johansen

(Eds.), The international encyclopedia of strategic communication (pp. 1–9). Wiley-Blackwell.

38.

Kent

M. L.

Boatwright

B. C.

(2018). Ritualistic sacrifice in crisis communication: A case for eliminating scapegoating from the crisis/apologia lexicon. Public Relations Review, 44(4), 514–522.

39.

Knoester

Ridpath

B. D.

(2020). Should college athletes be allowed to be paid? A public opinion analysis. Sociology of Sport Journal. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1123/ssj.2020-0015

40.

Krippendorff

(1980). Content analysis: An introduction to its methodology. Sage.

41.

Lee

Bang

Lee

(2013). Regaining fans trust after negative incidents: Fit between responses and nature of incidents. Sport Marketing Quarterly, 22(4), 235–245. https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Cindy_Lee12/publication/308172837_Regaining_fans’_trust_after_negative_incidents_Fit_between_responses_and_nature_of_incidents/links/57dc3cd208ae72d72ea68d30/Regaining-fans-trust-after-negative-incidents-Fit-between-responses-and-nature-of-incidents.pdf

42.

National Collegiate Athletic Association. (2019, August 1). 2019–20 NCAA Division I Manual. NCAA.com . http://www.ncaapublications.com/productdownloads/D120.pdf

43.

Saldaña

(2013). The coding manual for qualitative researchers (2nd ed.). Sage.

44.

Sanderson

(2013). From loving the hero to despising the villain: Sports fans, Facebook, and social identity threats. Mass Communication and Society, 16(4), 487–509. https://doi.org/10.1080/15205436.2012.730650

45.

Sanderson

Emmons

(2014). Extending and withholding forgiveness to Josh Hamilton: Exploring forgiveness within parasocial interaction. Communication & Sport, 2(1), 24–47. https://doi.org/10.1177/2167479513482306

46.

Sanderson

Frederick

Stock

(2016). When athlete activism clashes with group values: Social identity threat management via social media. Mass Communication and Society, 19(3), 301–322. https://doi.org/10.1080/15205436.2015.1128549

47.

Sanderson

Truax

(2014). “I hate you man!”: Exploring maladaptive parasocial interaction expressions to college athletes via Twitter. Journal of Issues in Intercollegiate Athletics, 7, 333–351.

48.

Silver

(2011). The geography of college football fans (and realignment chaos). New York Times. https://thequad.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/09/19/the-geography-of-college-football-fans-and-realignment-chaos/

49.

Smith

R. A.

(2011). Pay for play: A history of big-time college athletic reform. University of Illinois Press.

50.

Stacy

(2019, November 8). Ohio State star Chase Young will miss Saturday’s game against Maryland because of a possible NCAA violation in 2018. ChicagoTribune.com . https://www.chicagotribune.com/sports/college/ct-ohio-state-chase-young-ncaa-violation-20191108-jahwimorvnapjpjiuwjmmiepwe-story.html

51.

Stets

J. E.

Burke

P. J.

(2000). Identity theory and social identity theory. Social Psychology Quarterly, 63(3), 224–237. https://doi.org/10.2307/2695870

52.

Tajfel

(1972). ‘La categorisation sociale [Social categorization]. In Moscovici

(Ed.), Introduction a la psychologie sociale (pp. 272–302). Larousse.

53.

Tajfel

Billig

M. G.

Bundy

R. P.

Flament

(1971). Social categorization and intergroup behavior. European Journal of Social Psychology, 1(2), 149–178. https://doi.org/10.1002/ejsp.2420010202

54.

Tajfel

Turner

J. C.

(1979). An integrative theory of intergroup conflict. In Austin

Worchel

(Eds.), The social psychology of intergroup relations (pp. 33–47). Brooks/Cole.

55.

Turner

J. C.

(1975). Social comparison and social identity: Some prospects for intergroup behaviour. European Journal of Social Psychology, 5(1), 1–34. https://doi.org/10.1002/ejsp.2420050102

56.

Turner

J. C.

Hogg

M. A.

Oakes

P. J.

Reicher

S. D.

Wetherell

M. S.

(1987). Rediscovering the social group: A self-categorization theory. Basil Blackwell.

57.

Vermeer

S. A. M.

Araujo

T. B.

(2020). Keep the ball rolling: Information diffusion within large sports-related networks through social mediators. Communication & Sport, 8(6), 803–824.

58.

Walsh

McAllister-Spooner

S. M.

(2011). Analysis of the image repair discourse in the Michael Phelps controversy. Public Relations Review, 37(2), 157–162. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pubrev.2011.01.001