Health disparities scholars describe the existence of a race mental health paradox—specifically, when black adults face higher levels of adversity compared with whites yet have similar or better mental health outcomes. Whether such a paradox exists among youth is unclear. Using data from the Longitudinal Studies of Child Abuse and Neglect, I examine black–white differences in children’s internalizing problems scores and consider the role of childhood adversities. Black children experience more adversity within family and neighborhood domains and cumulatively across ecological levels yet have comparable or better mental health at age 4 that endures over the early life course compared with white children (p < .05). Evidence suggests that among children with the greatest adversity (at the parent level), having three supportive adults and high degrees of support at age 6 were more effective for black youth than their white peers in diminishing risk for internalizing problems later in childhood (p < .05).
AchenbachThomas M.1991. Manual for Child Behavior Checklist: 4–18 and 1991 Profile. Burlington: University of Vermont, Department of Psychiatry.
2.
BarnesDavid M.BatesLisa M.2017. “Do Racial Patterns in Psychological Distress Shed Light on the Black–White Depression Paradox? A Systematic Review.”Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology52(8):913–28.
3.
BoardmanJason D.AlexanderKari B.2011. “Stress Trajectories, Health Behaviors, and the Mental Health of Black and White Young Adults.”Social Science & Medicine72(10):1659–66.
4.
BreslauJoshuaAguilar-GaxialoSergioKendlerKenneth S.SuMaxwellWilliamsDavidKesslerRonald C.2006. “Specifying Race-Ethnic Differences in Risk for Psychiatric Disorder in a U.S. National Sample.”Psychological Medicine36(1):57–68.
5.
BronfenbrennerUrieMorrisPamela A.2006. “The Biological Model of Human Development.” Pp.793–828 in Handbook of Child Psychology, edited by DamonW.LernerR. M.New York: John Wiley & Sons.
6.
BrownDanice L.2008. “African American Resiliency: Examining Racial Socialization and Social Support as Protective Factors.”Journal of Black Psychology34(1):32–48.
7.
CainDaphne S.Combs-OrmeTerri. 2005. “Family Structure Effects on Parenting Stress and Practices in the African-American Family.”Journal of Sociology and Social Welfare32(2):19–40.
8.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 2014. “Prevalence and Characteristics of Sexual Violence, Stalking, and Intimate Partner Violence Victimization: National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey, United States, 2011.”Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report63(8):1–24. Retrieved May17, 2018 (https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/pdf/ss/ss6308.pdf).
9.
CicchettiDanteRogoschFred A.GunnarMegan R.TothSheree L.2010. “The Differential Impacts of Early Physical and Sexual Abuse and Internalizing Problems on Daytime Cortisol Rhythm in School-aged Children.”Child Development81(1):252–69.
10.
ColeyRebekah LevineLynchAlicia DoyleKullMelissa. 2015. “Early Exposure to Environmental Chaos and Children’s Physical and Mental Health.”Early Childhood Research Quarterly32:94–104.
11.
CongerRand D.WallaceLora ElbertSunYumeiSimonsRonald L.McLoydVonnie C.BrodyGene H.2002. “Economic Pressure in African American Families: A Replication and Extension of the Family Stress Model.”Developmental Psychology38(2):179–93.
12.
ConnellArin M.GoodmanSherryl H.2002. “The Association between Psychopathology in Fathers versus Mothers and Children’s Internalizing and Externalizing Behavior Problems: A Meta-analysis.”Psychological Bulletin128(5):746–70.
13.
CoultonC. J.KorbinJ. E.SuM.1996. “Measuring Neighborhood Context for Young Children in an Urban Area.”American Journal of Community Psychology24:5–31.
DunnJames R.2000. “Housing and Health Inequalities: Review and Prospects for Research.”Housing Studies. 15(3):341–66.
16.
EdwardsLloyd J.2000. “Modern Statistical Techniques for the Analysis of Longitudinal Data in Biomedical Research.”Pediatric Pulmonology30:330–344.
17.
Elder Jr.Glen H.JohnsonMonica KirkpatrickCrosnoeRobert. 2003. “The Emergence and Development of Life Course Theory.” Pp.3–19 in Handbook of the Life Course, edited by MortimerJ. T.ShanahanM. J.New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers.
18.
EllisonChristopher G.BoardmanJason D.WilliamsDavid R.JacksonJames S.2001. “Religious Involvement, Stress, and Mental Health: Findings from the 1995 Detroit Area Study.”Social Forces80(1):215–49.
19.
ErvingChristy L.ThomasCourtney S.2018. “Race, Emotional Reliance, and Mental Health.”Society and Mental Health8(1):69–83.
20.
FarmerMelissa M.FerraroKenneth F.2005. “Are Racial Disparities in Health Conditional on Socioeconomic Status?”Social Science Medicine60(1):191–204.
21.
FerraroKenneth F.ShippeeTetyana Pylypiv. 2009. “Aging and Cumulative Inequality: How Does Inequality Get under the Skin?”The Gerontologist49(3):333–43.
22.
FerraroKenneth F.ShippeeTetyana PylypivSchaferMarkus H.2009. “Cumulative Inequality Theory for Research on Aging and the Life Course.” Pp.413–33 in Handbook of Theories of Aging, edited by BengtsonV. L.GansD.PutneyN. M.MerrillS.New York: Springer.
23.
FischerAnn R.ShawChristina M.1999. “African Americans’ Mental Health and Perceptions of Racist Discrimination: The Moderating Effects of Racial Socialization Experiences and Self-esteem.”Journal of Counseling Psychology46(3):395–407.
24.
GarnerAndrew S.ShonkoffJack P.2012. “Early Childhood Adversity, Toxic Stress, and the Role of the Pediatrician: Translating Developmental Science into Lifelong Health Abstract.”Pediatrics129(1):e224–31.
25.
GershoffElizabeth T.2016. “Should Parents’ Physical Punishment of Children Be Considered a Source of Toxic Stress That Affects Brain Development?”Family Relations 1248(February):151–62.
26.
HallL.1983. “Social Supports, Everyday Stressors, and Maternal Mental Health.” Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.
27.
HarlandP.ReijneveldS. A.BrugmanE.Verloove-VanhorickS. P.VerhulstF. C.2002. “Family Factors and Life Events as Risk Factors for Behavioural and Emotional Problems in Children.”European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry11:176–84.
28.
HermanKeith C.CohenDanielReinkeWendy M.OstranderRickBurrellLoriMcFarlaneElizabethDugganAnne K.2018. “Using Latent Profile and Transition Analyses to Understand Patterns of Informant Ratings of Child Depressive Symptoms.”Journal of School Psychology69(May):84–99.
HunterWanda M.CoxChristine E.TeagleSarahJohnsonRenee M.MathewRaviKnightElizabeth D.LeebRebecca T.2001. “Measures for Assessment of Functioning and Outcomes in Longitudinal Research on Child Abuse Volume 1: Early Childhood.” National Data Archive on Child Abuse and Neglect. Retrieved May15, 2018 (http://www.ndacan.cornell.edu).
31.
HunterW. M.EversonM. D.1991. “Mother’s History of Loss and Harm.” Unpublished manuscript, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.
32.
HusseyJon M.ChangJen JenKotchJonathan B.2006. “Child Maltreatment in the United States: Prevalence, Risk Factors, and Adolescent Health Consequences.”Pediatrics118(3):933–42.
33.
JacksonJames S.KnightKatherine M.RaffertyJane A.2010. “Race and Unhealthy Behaviors: Chronic Stress, the HPA Axis, and Physical and Mental Health Disparities over the Life Course.”American Journal of Public Health100(5):933–39.
34.
KawachiIchiroBerkmanLisa F.2001. “Social Ties and Mental Health.”Journal of Urban Health: Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine78(3):458–67.
35.
KeyesCorey L. M.2009. “The Black–White Paradox in Health: Flourishing in the Face of Social Inequality and Discrimination.”Journal of Personality77(6):1677–1706.
36.
LeventhalTamaBrooks-GunnJeanne. 2000. “The Neighborhoods They Live In: The Effects of Neighborhood Residence on Child and Adolescent Outcomes.”Psychological Bulletin126(2):309–37.
37.
LevittMary J.Guacci-FrancoNathalieLevittJerome L.1993. “Convoys of Social Support in Childhood and Early Adolescence: Structure and Function.”Developmental Psychology29(5):811–18.
38.
LewisTene T.CogburnCourtney D.WilliamsDavid R.2015. “Self-reported Experiences of Discrimination and Health: Scientific Advances, Ongoing Controversies, and Emerging Issues.”Annual Review of Clinical Psychology11:407–40.
39.
LittleRoderick J.2008. “Selection and Pattern-mixture Models.” Pp.409–31 in Longitudinal Data Analysis, edited by FitzmauriceG.DavidianM.VerbekeG.MolenberghsG.Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.
40.
LONGSCAN Investigators. 1991. LONGSCAN Neighborhood Short Form [Instrument]. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Injury Prevention Research Center.
41.
LONGSCAN Investigators. 1992. LONGSCAN Neighborhood Risk Assessment [Instrument]. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Injury Prevention Research Center.
42.
LONGSCAN Investigators (1998). LONGSCAN history of witnessed violence [Instrument]. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Injury Prevention Research Center.
43.
MartinJoyce A.HamiltonBrady E.OstermanMichelle J. K.DriscollAnne K.DrakePatrick. 2018. “National Vital Statistics Reports Births: Final Data for 2016.”U.S. Department of Health and Human Services67(1). Retrieved December10, 2018 (https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr67/nvsr67_01.pdf).
44.
MartinezPedroRichtersJohn E.1993. “The NIMH Community Violence Project: II. Children’s Distress Symptoms Associated with Violence Exposure.”Psychiatry Interpersonal & Biological Processes56:22–35.
45.
MayfieldDemmieMcLeodGailHallPatricia. 1974. “The CAGE Questionnaire: Validation of a New Alcoholism Screening Instrument.”American Journal of Psychiatry131:1121–23.
46.
MclaughlinKatie A.BreslauJoshuaGreenJennifer GreifLakomaMatthew D.SampsonNancy A.ZaslavskyAlan M.KesslerRonald C.2011. “Childhood Socio-economic Status and the Onset, Persistence, and Severity of DSM-IV Mental Disorders in a U.S. National Sample.”Social Science & Medicine73(7):1088–96.
47.
MezukBrianaRaffertyJane A.KershawKiarri N.HudsonDarrellAbdouCleopatra M.LeeHedwigEatonWilliam W.JacksonJames S.2010. “Reconsidering the Role of Social Disadvantage in Physical and Mental Health: Stressful Life Events, Health Behaviors, Race, and Depression.”American Journal of Epidemiology172(11):1238–49.
48.
MezukBrianaAbdouCleopatra M.HudsonDarrellKershawKiarri N.RaffertyJane A.LeeHedwigJacksonJames S.2013. “Health Behaviors: The Environmental Affordances Model.”Society and Mental Health3(2):1–22.
49.
MouzonDawne M.2013. “Can Family Relationships Explain the Race Paradox in Mental Health?”Journal of Marriage and Family75(2):470–85.
50.
MouzonDawne M.2014. “Relationships of Choice: Can Friendships or Fictive Kinships Explain the Race Paradox in Mental Health?”Social Science Research44:32–43.
51.
MoylanCarrie A.HerrenkohlTodd I.SousaCindyTajimaEmiko A.HerrenkohlRoy C.RussoM. Jean. 2010. “The Effects of Child Abuse and Exposure to Domestic Violence on Adolescent Internalizing and Externalizing Behavior Problems.”Journal of Family Violence25:53–63.
52.
O’DonnellDeborah A.Schwab-stoneMary E.MuyeedAdaline Z.2002. “Multidimensional Resilience in Urban Children Exposed to Community Violence.”Child Development73(4):1265–82.
53.
PearlinLeonard I.2010. “The Life Course and the Stress Process: Some Conceptual Comparisons.”Journal of Gerontology: Social Sciences65B(2):207–15.
54.
PearlinLeonard I.SchiemanScottFazioElena M.MeersmanStephen C.2005. “Stress, Health, and the Life Course: Some Conceptual Perspectives.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior46(June):205–20.
55.
PerleJonathan G.LevineAlison B.OdlandAnthony P.KettererJessica L.CannonMegan A.MarkerCraig D.2013. “The Association between Internalizing Symptomology and Risky Behaviors.”Journal of Child & Adolescent Substance Abuse22(1):1–24.
56.
RadloffL. S.1977. “The CES-D Scale: A Self-report Depression Scale for Research in the General Population.”Applied Psychological Measurement1:385–401.
57.
ReardonSean F.BischoffKendra. 2011. “Income Inequality and Income Segregation.”American Journal of Sociology116(4):1092–1153.
58.
ReissFranziska. 2013. “Socioeconomic Inequalities and Mental Health Problems in Children and Adolescents: A Systematic Review.”Social Science and Medicine90:24–31.
59.
RichtersJ. E.MartinezP.1990. Things I Have Seen and Heard: A Structured Interview for Assessing Young Children’s Violence Exposure. Rockville, MD: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, National Institutes of Health, National Institute of Mental Health.
60.
RunyanDesmondDubowitzHowardEnglishDiana J.KotchJonathan B.LitrownikAlanThompsonRichardand The LONGSCAN Investigator Group. 2014. “Longitudinal Studies of Child Abuse and Neglect (LONGSCAN) Assessment 0–18 (Dataset).” Retrieved May15, 2018 (http://www.ndacan.cornell.edu).
SampsonR. J.RaudenbushS. W.EarlsF.1997. “Neighborhoods and Violent Crime: A Multilevel Study of Collective Efficacy. Science277:918–924.
63.
SchaferMarkus H.FerraroKenneth F.2011. “Childhood Misfortune as a Threat to Successful Aging: Avoiding Disease.”The Gerontologist52(1):111–20.
64.
SchaferMarkus H.FerraroKenneth F.MustilloSarah A.2011. “Children of Misfortune: Early Adversity and Cumulative Inequality in Perceived Life Trajectories.”American Journal of Sociology116(4):1053–91.
65.
SchillingElizabeth A.AseltineRobert H.GoreSusan. 2007. “Adverse Childhood Experiences and Mental Health in Young Adults: A Longitudinal Survey.”BMC Public Health7:1–10.
StataCorp. 2017a. Stata 15 Base Reference Manual. College Station, TX: Stata Cress.
69.
StataCorp. 2017b. Stata Statistical Software: Release 15. College Station, TX: StataCorp LLC.
70.
StewartTiffanySuldoShannon. 2011. “Relationships between Social Support Sources and Early Adolescents’ Mental Health: The Moderating Effect of Student Achievement Level.”Psychology in the Schools48(10):1016–33.
71.
StrausMurray A.1979. “Measuring Intrafamily Conflict and Violence: The Conflict Tactics Scales.”Journal of Marriage and Family41:75–88.
72.
StrausMurray A.DonnellyDenise A.2008. Beating the Devil out of Them: Corporal Punishment in American Families and Its Effects on Children, Second Edition. New Brunswick, CT: Transaction Publishers.
73.
StrausM. A.HambyS. L.Boney-McCoyS.SugarmanD. B.1996. “The Revised Conflict Tactics Scales (CTS2): Development and Preliminary Psychometric Data (CTS2).”Journal of Family Issues17(3):283–316.
74.
TaillieuTamara L.AfifiTracie O.MotaNatalieKeyesKatherine M.2014. “Age, Sex, and Racial Differences in Harsh Physical Punishment: Results from a National Representative United States Sample.”Child Abuse & Neglect38(12):1885–94.
75.
TeicherMartin H.SamsonJacqueline A.PolcariAnnMcGrenneryCynthia E.2006. “Sticks, Stones, and Hurtful Words: Relative Effects of Various Forms of Childhood Maltreatment.”American Journal of Psychiatry163(6):993–1000.
76.
Tomaskovic-DeveyDonald. 1993. “The Gender and Race Composition of Jobs and the Male/Female, White/Black Pay Gaps.”Social Forces72(1):45–76.
77.
TurnerHeather A.ShattuckAnneFinkelhorSavidHambySherry. 2016. “Polyvictimization and Youth Violence Exposure across Contexts.”Journal of Adolescent Health58(2):208–14.
78.
TurnerR. JayAvisonWilliam R.2003. “Status Variations in Stress Exposure: Implications for the Interpretation of Research on Race, Socioeconomic Status, and Gender.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior44(4):488–505.
VillodasMiguel T.LitrownikAlan J.ThompsonRichardRoeschScott C.EnglishDiana J.DubowitzHowardKotchJonathan B.RunyanDesmond K.2012. “Changes in Youth’s Experiences of Child Maltreatment across Developmental Periods in the LONGSCAN Consortium.”Psychology of Violence2(4):325–338.
81.
WatersElizabethDoyleJodieWolfeRoryWrightMartinWakeMelissaSalmonLouisa. 2000. “Influence of Parental Gender and Self-reported Health and Illness on Parent-reported Child Health.”Pediatrics106(6):1422–28.
82.
WidomCathy SpatzCzajaSally J.DumontKimberly A.2015. “Intergenerational Transmission of Child Abuse and Neglect: Real or Detection Bias?”Science347(6229):1480–85.
83.
WilcoxonFrank. 1945. “Individual Comparisons by Ranking Methods.”Biometrics Bulletin1(6):80–83.
84.
WilliamsDavid R.1999. “Race, Socioeconomic Status, and Health: The Added Effects of Racism and Discrimination.”Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences896(1):173–88.
85.
WilliamsDavid R.MohammedSelina A.2009. “Discrimination and Racial Disparities in Health: Evidence and Needed Research.”Journal of Behavioral Medicine32(1):20.
86.
WilliamsDavid R.YuYanJacksonJames S.AndersonNorman B.1997. “Racial Differences in Physical and Mental Health. Socio-economic Status, Stress and Discrimination.”Journal of Health Psychology2(3):335–51.
