This study examines why women exhibit higher rates of psychological distress and affective and anxiety disorders whereas men report more problems with alcohol and alcohol-related disorders. Using two waves of panel data from 5,001 respondents to the National Co-morbidity Survey, confirmatory factor analysis and structural equation modeling are utilized to compare the stress process of distress, alcohol misuse, and meeting the diagnostic criteria for affective, anxiety, and alcohol-related disorders according to access to resources and exposure to stressors. Theories of emotional socialization, self-salience, and gender roles are applied to interpret gender differences in the determinants of mental health outcomes. The results reveal that gender role theory fits best for models of psychological distress and affective and anxiety disorders, whereas emotional socialization and self-salience theories fit best for models of alcohol intake and alcohol-related disorders. The implications of these results and directions for future research on gender differences in mental health are discussed.
AneshenselCarol S.RutterCarolyn M.LachenbruchPeter A.1991. “Social Structure, Stress, and Mental Health: Competing Conceptual and Analytic Models.” American Sociological Review56:166-78.
2.
AsparouhovTihomir2005. “Sampling Weights in Latent Variable Modeling.” Structural Equation Modeling12:411-34.
3.
BebbingtonPaul. 1996. “The Origins of Sex Differences in Depressive Disorder: Bridging the Gap.” International Review of Psychiatry8:295-332.
4.
BernardJessie. 1982. The Future of Marriage. New Haven: Yale University Press.
5.
BlauFrancineKahnLawrence M.2007. “The Gender Pay Gap: Have Women Gone as Far as They Can?” The Academy of Management Perspectives21:7-23.
6.
BrennanPenny L.SchuuteKathleen K.MoosRudolf H.1999. “Reciprocal Relations between Stressors and Drinking Behavior: A Three-wave Panel Study of Late Middle-aged and Older Women and Men.” Addiction94:737-49.
7.
BultmannUteKantIjmert J.Van Den BrandtPiet A.KaslStanislav V.2002. “Psychosocial Work Characteristics as Risk Factors for the Onset of Fatigue and Psychological Distress: Prospective Results from the Maastricht Cohort Study.” Psychological Medicine32:333-45.
8.
CaspiAvshalomBolgerNiallEckenrodeJohn1987. “Linking Person and Context in the Daily Stress Process.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology52:184-95.
9.
CooperM. LynneRussellMarciaFroneMichael R.1990. “Work Stress and Alcohol Effects: A Test of Stress-induced Drinking.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior 31:260-76.
10.
DentonMargaretPrusStevenWaltersVivienne2004. “Gender Differences in Health: A Canadian Study of the Psychosocial, Structural and Behavioral Determinants of Health.” Social Science & Medicine58:2585-600.
11.
D’ErcoleAnn. 1988. “Single Mothers: Stress, Coping, and Social Support.” Journal of Community Psychology16:41-3.
12.
DroomersMarielSchrijversCarola T. M.StronksKarienvan de MheenDikeMackenbachJohan P.1999. “Educational Differences in Excessive Alcohol Consumption: The Role of Psychosocial and Material Stressors.” Preventive Medicine29:1-10.
13.
ElliottMarta. 2001. “Gender Differences in Causes of Depression.” Women & Health33:163-77.
14.
FirstMichael B.SpitzerRobert L.GibbonMiriamWilliamsJanet B.2002. Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV Axis I Disorders: Research Version, Non-patient Edition (SCID-I/NP). New York: Biometrics Research. New York State Psychiatric Institute.
15.
FuhrerR.StansfeldS. A.2002. “How Gender Affects Patterns of Social Relations and Their Impact on Health: A Comparison of One or Multiple Sources of Support from ‘Close Persons.’” Social Science & Medicine54:811-25.
16.
GrantBridget F.HarfordThomas C.DawsonDeborah A.ChouS. PatriciaDufourMary C.PickeringRoger1994. “Prevalence of DSM-IV Alcohol Abuse and Dependence: United States, 1992.” Alcohol Health Research World19:243-48.
17.
GrantBridget F.HarfordThomas C.1995. “Comorbidity betweenDSM-IVAlcohol Use Disorders and Major Depression: Results of a National Survey.”Drug and Alcohol Dependence39:197-206.
18.
GriffinJoan M.FuhrerRebeccaStansfeldStephen A.MarmotMichael2002. “The Importance of Low Control at Work and Home on Depression and Anxiety: Do These Effects Vary by Gender and Social Class?”Social Science & Medicine54:783-98.
19.
HaiyiXieDainBradley J.BeckerDeborah R.DrakeRobert E.1997. “Job Tenure among Persons with Severe Mental Illness.” Rehabilitation Counseling Bulletin40:230-39.
20.
HatchStephani L.2005. “Conceptualizing and Identifying Cumulative Adversity and Protective Resources: Implications for Understanding Health Inequalities.” Journals of Gerontology: SERIES B60B:130-34.
21.
HeiderFritz. 1958. The Psychology of Interpersonal Relations. New York: John Wiley and Sons.
22.
HorwitzAllan V.WhiteHelene RaskinHowell-WhiteSandra1996. “The Use of Multiple Outcomes in Stress Research: A Case Study of Gender Differences in Responses to Marital Dissolution.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior37:278-91.
23.
HoschschildArlie R.1979. “Emotion Work, Feeling Rules, and Social Structure”American Journal of Sociology85:551-75.
24.
HuLi-tzeBentlerPeter M.1999. “Cutoff Criteria for Fit Indices in Covariance Structure Analysis: Conventional Criteria versus New Alternatives.” Structural Equation Modeling6:1-55.
25.
KelleyHarold. 1967. “Attribution Theory in Social Psychology.” Nevada Symposium on Motivation15:192-238.
26.
KesslerRonald C.NATIONAL COMORBIDITY SURVEY, 1990-1992 [Computer file]. Conducted by University of Michigan, Survey Research Center. 2nd ICPSR ed. Ann Arbor, MI: Inter-university Consortium for Political and Social Research [producer and distributor].
27.
KesslerRonald C.BerglundPatriciaDemlerOlgaJinRobertKoretzDoreenMerikangasKathleen R.RushJohnWaltersEllen E.WangPhilip S.2003. “The Epidemiology of Major Depressive Disorder: Results from the National Comorbidity Survey Replication (NCS-R).” Journal of the American Medical Association289:3095-105.
28.
KesslerRonald C.CrumRosa M.WarnerLynn A.NelsonChristopher B.SchulenbergJohnAnthonyJames C.1997. “Lifetime Co-occurrence of DSM-III-R Alcohol Abuse and Dependence with Other Psychiatric Disorders in the National Comorbidity Survey.” Archives of General Psychiatry54:313-21.
29.
KesslerRonald C.McLeodJane D.WethingtonElaine1985. “Cost of Caring: A Perspective on the Relationship Between Sex and Psychological Distress.” Pp. 491-506 in Social Support, Theory, Research and Application, edited by SarasonI. G.SarasonB. R.The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff.
30.
KesslerRonald C.UstunT. B.2004. “The World Mental Health (WMH) Survey Initiative Version of the World Health Organization (WHO) Composite International Diagnostic Interview (CIDI).” International Journal of Methods of Psychiatric Research13:93-121.
31.
KrauseNealJayGinaLiangJersey1991. “Financial Strain and Psychological Well-being among the American and Japanese Elderly.” Psychology and Aging6:170-81.
32.
LazarusRichard S.1966. Psychological Stress and the Coping Process. New York: McGraw Hill.
33.
LeeYun-SukWaiteLinda J.2005. “Husbands’ and Wives’ Time Spent on Housework: A Comparison of Measures.” Journal of Marriage and Family67:328-36.
34.
LefcourtHerbert M.1976. Research with the Locus of Control Construct. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
35.
LennonMary Clare. 1987. “Sex Differences in Distress: The Impact of Gender and Work Roles.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior28:290-305.
36.
LevensonHanna. 1973. “Multidimensional Locus of Control in Psychiatric Patients.” Journal of Consulting & Clinical Psychology41:397-404.
37.
LittleTodd D.SlegersDavid W.2005. “Factor Analysis: Multiple Groups.” Pp. 617-23 in Encyclopedia of Statistics in Behavioral Science, edited by EverittB. S.HowellD. C.Chichester: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
38.
LongJ. Scott. 1983. Confirmatory Factor Analysis. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
39.
McDonoughPeggyWaltersVivienne2001. “Gender and Health: Reassessing Patterns and Explanations.” Social Science and Medicine52:547-59.
40.
McWilliamsLachlan A.CoxBrian J.EnnsMurray W.2003. “Psychometric Properties of an Index of Emotional Distress in the U.S. National Comorbidity Survey.” Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology38:256-61.
41.
MenaghanElizabeth G.1983. “Individual Coping Efforts and Family Studies: Conceptual and Methodological Issues.” Marriage and Family Review6:113-35.
42.
MirowskyJohnRossCatherine E.1989a. “Psychiatric Diagnosis as Reified Measurement.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior30:11-25.
43.
MirowskyJohnRossCatherine E.1989b. Social Causes of Psychological Distress. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
44.
MirowskyJohnRossCatherine E.2001. “Age and the Effect of Economic Hardship on Depression.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior42:132-50.
45.
MoosRudolf H.FennCatharine B.BillingsAndrew G.MoosBernice S.1989. “Assessing Life Stressors and Social Resources: Applications to Alcoholic Patients.” Journal of Substance Abuse1:135-52.
46.
MossakowskiKrysia N.2008. “Is the Duration of Poverty and Unemployment a Risk Factor for Heavy Drinking?”Social Science & Medicine67:947-55.
National Center for Health Statistics. 2007. Health United States. Hyattsville, MD: Public Health Service.
49.
Nolen-HoeksemaSusanHiltLori2006. “Possible Contributors to the Gender Differences in Alcohol Use and Problems.” Journal of General Psychology133:357-74.
50.
PearlinLeonard I.1983. “Role Strains and Personal Stress.” Pp. 3-32 in Psychosocial Stress: Trends in Theory and Research, edited by KaplanH. B.New York: Academic Press.
51.
PearlinLeonard I.1999. “The Stress Process Revisited: Reflections on Concepts and their Interrelationships.” Pp. 395-415 in Handbook on the Sociology of Mental Health, edited by AneshenselC. S.PhelanJ.New York: Plenum Press.
52.
PearlinLeonard I.LiebermanMichael A.MenaghanElizabethMullanJ. T.1981. “The Stress Process.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior22:337-56.
53.
PearlinLeonard I.SchiemanScottFazioElena M.MeersmanStephen C.2005. “Stress, Health, and the Life Course: Some Conceptual Perspectives.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior46:205-19.
54.
PriceRichard H.ChoiJin NamVinokurAmiram D.2002. “Links in the Chain of Adversity Following Job Loss: How Financial Strain and Loss of Personal Control Lead to Depression, Impaired Functioning, and Poor Health.” Journal of Occupational Health Psychology7:302-12.
55.
RiekerPatricia P.BirdChloe E.2005. “Rethinking Gender Differences in Health: Why We Need to Integrate Social and Biological Perspectives.” Journals of Gerontology60b:40-7.
56.
RobbinsL. N.WingJ.WittchenH. U.HelzerJohn E.BaborT. E.BurkeJ.1988. “The Composite International Diagnostic Interview: An Epidemiological Instrument Suitable for Use in Conjunction with Different Diagnostic Systems and in Different Cultures.” Archives of General Psychiatry45:1069-77.
57.
RosenbergMorris. 1989. Society and the Adolescent Self-image. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
58.
RosenfieldSarahLennonMary ClareWhiteHelene Raskin2005. “The Self and Mental Health: Self-salience and the Emergence of Internalizing and Externalizing Problems.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior46:323-40.
59.
RosenfieldSarahVertefuilleJeanMcAlpineDonna D.2000. “Gender Stratification and Mental Health: An Exploration of Dimensions of the Self.” Social Psychology Quarterly63:208-23.
60.
RubleDiane N.GreulichFaithPomerantzEva M.GochbergBarbra1993. “The Role of Gender-related Processes in the Development of Sex Differences in Self-evaluation and Depression.” Journal of Affective Disorders29:97-128.
61.
SatorraAlbertBentlerPeter M.2001. “A Scaled Difference Chi-square Test Statistic for Moment Structure Analysis.” Psychometrika66:507-14.
62.
SimonRobin W.1998. “Assessing Sex Differences in Vulnerability among Employed Parents: The Importance of Marital Status.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior39:38-54.
63.
SimonRobin W.2002. “Revisiting the Relationships among Gender, Marital Status, and Mental Health.” American Journal of Sociology107:1065-96.
64.
SpitzerRobert L.WilliamsJanet B.GibbonMiriamFirstMichael B.1992. “The Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-III-R (SCID). I: History, Rationale, and Description.” Archives of General Psychiatry49:624-29.
65.
StroudLaura R.SaloveyPeterEpelElissa S.2002. “Sex Differences in Stress Responses: Social Rejection versus Achievement Stress.” Biological Psychiatry52:318-27.
66.
SwendsenJoelConwayKevin P.DegenhardtLouisaGlantzMeyerJinRobertMerikangasKathleen R.SampsonNancyKesslerRonald C.2010. “Mental Disorders as Risk Factors for Substance Use, Abuse and Dependence: Results from the 10-year Follow-up of the National Comorbidity Survey.” Addiction105:1117-28.
67.
ThoitsPeggy A.1989. “The Sociology of Emotions.” Annual Review of Sociology15:317-42.
68.
ThoitsPeggy A.2010. “Stress and Health: Major Findings and Policy Implications.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior51:S41-53.
69.
TurnerR. JayAvisonWilliam R.1989. “Gender and Depression: Assessing Exposure and Vulnerability to Life Events in a Chronically Strained Population.” Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease177:443-55.
70.
TurnerR. JayLloydDonald A.1999. “The Stress Process and the Social Distribution of Depression.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior40:374-404.
71.
TurnerR. JayRoszellPatricia1994. “Psychosocial Resources and the Stress Process.” Pp. 179-210 in Stress and Mental Health: Contemporary Issues and Prospects for the Future, edited by AvisonW. R.GotlibI. H.New York: Plenum Press.
72.
TurnerR. JayWheatonBlairLloydDonald A.1995. “The Epidemiology of Social Stress.” American Sociological Review60:104-25.
73.
VermeulenMarianMustardCameron2000. “Gender Differences in Job Strain, Social Support at Work, and Psychological Distress.” Journal of Occupational Health Psychology5:428-40.
74.
World Health Organization. Composite International Diagnostic Interview (CIDI) Version t.0. Geneva, Switzerland: Author.
75.
YuChing Yun. 2002. “Evaluation of Model Fit Indices for Latent Variable Models with Categorical and Continuous Outcomes.” PhD dissertation. Department of Education, University of California, Los Angeles.
