This paper presents the findings of a sample of 2,000 articles published in English newspapers about community punishment between 2003 and 2011. The data suggest that challenges to the legitimacy of community sanctions in English media, whilst occasionally vociferous and vitriolic, are as muchlinguistic as political in nature, rooted in a tendency to dismiss non-custodial sentences as inherently inferior to incarceration, and to overstate the severity and frequency of crime. This should influence penologists' and penal reformers'attempts to improve popular support for non-custodial sanctions.
Anon (2008c), ‘A Lesson from the Lords in How Democracy Works’, The Sunday Telegraph, 6th April.
7.
Anon (2009a), ‘If Justice is Working, Why do So Many Criminals Go Free?’, Leicester Mercury, 16th May.
8.
Anon (2009b), ‘Have Your Say on Criminals' Community Work’, Nottingham Post, 30th March.
9.
Anon (2010a), ‘Parents of Tearaways Could Face Jail, Say Tories’, Daily Mail, 5th April.
10.
Anon (2010b), ‘Engineer Given Community Order for Child Porn Offences’, Rutland and Stamford Mercury, 30th July.
11.
AshworthA. (2010), Sentencing and Criminal Justice (5thedn., Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
12.
BodaZ.SzabóG. (2011), ‘The Media and Attitudes towards Crime and the Justice System: A Qualitative Approach’8 (4) European Journal of Criminology329–342.
13.
BrosterP. (2007), ‘Mum Left Girls Aged Just 2 and 4 for 16 Hours’, The Express, 20th July.
14.
CamberR. (2008), ‘Mercy for Fraudster whose Gran Needed Alzheimer's Drug’, Daily Mail, 4th July.
15.
CarterP., ‘Drug Dealers as Folk Heroes? Drugs and Television Situational Comedy’, in ManningP. (ed.), Drugs and Popular Culture: Drugs, Media and Identity in Contemporary Society (Cullompton: Willan).
16.
CaseyL. (2008), Engaging Communities in Fighting Crime (London: Cabinet Office).
17.
CollinsP. (2011), ‘Jail Works, so We Should Free More Prisoners’, The Times, 9th June.
Court Staff (2005), ‘Child Porn Man Spared Jail after Vicar Speaks’, Leicester Mercury, 22nd December.
20.
DittonJ.ChadeeD.FarrallS.GilchristE.BannisterJ. (2004), ‘From Imitation to Intimidation: A Note on the Curious and Changing Relationship between the Media, Crime and Fear of Crime’44 (4) British Journal of Criminology595–610.
21.
DownesD.MorganR. (2012), ‘Overtaking on the Left? The Politics of Law and Order in the “Big Society”’, in MaguireM.MorganR.ReinerR. (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Criminology.
22.
DurnescuI. (2011), ‘Pains of Probation: Effective Practice and Human Rights’55 (4) International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology530–545.
23.
EmsleyC. (2005), Crime and Society in England and Wales, 1750–1900 (3rdedn., Harlow: Pearson Longman).
24.
FeilzerM. Y. (2007), ‘Criminologists Making News? Providing Factual Information on Crime and Criminal Justice through a Weekly Newspaper Column’3 (3) Crime Media Culture285–304.
25.
FranklinB. (2008), ‘Newspapers: Trends and Developments’, in FranklinB. (ed.), Pulling Newspapers Apart: Analysing Print Journalism (London: Routledge).
26.
GarlandD. (2001), The Culture of Control: Crime and Social Order in Contemporary Society (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
HermanE.ChomskyN. (1988), ‘A Propaganda Model’, reprinted in Greer, C. (ed.), Crime and Media: A Reader (2010, Abingdon: Routledge).
34.
JewkesY. (2011), Media & Crime (2nd edn., London: SAGE).
35.
KahanD. (1998), ‘Punishment Incommensurability’1Buffalo Criminal Law Review691–708.
36.
KellyT. (2010), ‘The Truth about Community Payback: Criminals Sentenced to Smoke and Play Games’, The Daily Mail, 2nd September.
37.
LaceyN. (2007), The Prisoners' Dilemma: Political Economy and Punishment in Contemporary Democracies (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
38.
ListerK.ThompsonP. (2004), ‘TV “Star” Who Thinks Hitting His Girlfriend is Okay’, The Sun, 23rd April.
39.
MairG. (1998), ‘Community Penalties in England and Wales’10Federal Sentencing Reporter263–267.
40.
MairG. (2007), ‘Community Penalties’, in CantonR.HancockD. (2007), Dictionary of Probation and Offender Management (Cullompton: Willan).
41.
MairG.BurkeL. (2012), Redemption, Rehabilitation and Risk Management: A History of Probation (Abingdon: Routledge).
42.
MarunaS.KingA. (2004), ‘Public Opinion and Community Penalties’, in BottomsA.RexS.RobinsonG. (eds.), Alternatives to Prison: Options for an Insecure Society (Cullompton: Willan).
43.
MarunaS.KingA. (2008), ‘Selling the Public on Probation: Beyond the Bib’55 (4) Probation Journal337–351.
44.
McLuhanM. (1964), ‘The Medium is the Message’, reprinted in Greer, C. (ed.), Crime and Media: A Reader (2010, Abingdon: Routledge).
45.
McNeillF. (2013), ‘Community Sentences and European Penology’, in DaemsT.SnackenS.van Zyl SmitD. (eds.), European Penology? (Oxford: Hart).
46.
MorrisJ. (2008), ‘Straw in “Don't Jail Lags” Bid’, The Daily Mirror, 21st March.
47.
NellisM. (2007), ‘Humanising Justice: The English Probation Service up to 1972’, in GelsthorpeMorgan (eds.), Handbook on Probation (Cullompton: Willan).
48.
O'FlynnP. (2010), ‘So, Who is Brewing up a British Tea Party Then?’, The Daily Express, 6th November.
49.
Pascoe-WatsonG. (2009), ‘Tory Vow to Punish Yobs Fast’, The Sun, 9th April.
50.
RobinsonG.McNeillF. (2004), ‘Purposes Matter: The Ends of Probation’, in MairG. (ed.), What Matters in Probation Work (Cullompton: Willan).
51.
SchiffM. (1997), ‘Gauging the Intensity of Criminal Sanctions: Developing the Criminal Punishment Severity Scale (CPSS)’22 (2) Criminal Law Review175–206.
52.
SlackJ. (2007), ‘You're Out of Touch’, Daily Mail, 8th March.
53.
SykesG. M. (1958), The Society of Captives: A Study of a Maximum Security Prison (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press).
