Indonesia under threat: The danger of corruption to political legitimacy

Abstract

The association between corruption and poverty, inequality, economic development and resource distribution has been investigated widely in the Indonesian context. However, the impact of corruption on political legitimacy is still understudied, particularly for post-Soeharto Indonesia. Hence, we are left with many puzzles and a baffling picture of political legitimacy. This research corrects this picture and aims to ascertain two interrelated questions: (a) how and in what way does corruption erode political legitimacy? and (b) what evidence suggests that corruption deteriorates legitimacy? A qualitative and a quantitative research method are deployed to address these questions. The quantitative analysis demonstrates that corruption is statistically significant in predicting political legitimacy, suggesting that corruption erodes citizens’ trust in the rule of law, democracy, political actors and institutions. The qualitative model reinforces the quantitative results that corruption undermines the rule of law, hijacks democracy and erodes people’s trust in political actors and institutions.

Keywords

corruption democracy government legitimacy political institutions rule of law

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aiken

West

(1991) Multiple regression: Testing and Interpreting Interactions. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Amrunsyah

(2017) Tajam ke bawah tumpul ke atas [Sharp down, blunt up]. Legalite: Jurnal Perundang Undangan dan Hukum Pidana Islam 2(1): 50–72.

Anderson

Tverdova

(2003) Corruption, political allegiances, and attitudes toward government in contemporary democracies. American Journal of Political Science 47(1): 91–109.

Aspinall

Berenschot

(2019) Democracy for Sale: Elections, Clientelism, and the State in Indonesia. Ithaca, NY and London: Cornell University Press.

Aspinall

Noor

Ahmad

et al. (2017) Vote buying in Indonesia: Candidate strategies, market logic and effectiveness. Journal of East Asian Studies 17(1): 1–27.

Azwar

Saragih

(2018) Does corruption affect poverty in Indonesia. Jurnal BPPK 11(1): 1–14.

Bakker

(2000) Corruption and legitimacy: An institutional perspective. In: Bakker

Nordholt

(eds) Corruption and Legitimacy. Amsterdam: Netherlands Universities Institute for Coordination of Research in Social Sciences, pp.135–152

Bappenas (2014) Data pemilu [The data of general election]. Available at: http://ditpolkom.bappenas.go.id/v2/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/6_Data-Partisipasi-Pemilu-dan-Pilkada.pdf (accessed 30 July 2021).

Bellina

Darbon

Eriksen

et al. (2009) The Legitimacy of the State in Fragile Situations. Oslo: Norad.

10.

Berenschot

(2018) The political economy of clientelism: A comparative study of Indonesia’s patronage democracy. Comparative Political Studies 51(12): 1563–1593.

11.

Booth

Seligson

(2008) Inequality and democracy in Latin America: Individual and contextual effects of wealth on political participation. In: Krishna

(ed.) Poverty, Participation and Democracy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp.143–165.

12.

Booth

Seligson

(2009) The Legitimacy Puzzle in Latin America: Political Support and Democracy in Eight Nations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

13.

Bryman

(2007) Barriers to integrating quantitative and qualitative research. Journal of Mixed Methods Research 1(1): 8–22.

14.

Buchanan

(2002) Political legitimacy and democracy. Ethics 112(4): 689–719.

15.

Chang

Chu

(2006) Corruption and trust: Exceptionalism in Asian democracies? Journal of Politics 68(2): 259–271.

16.

Chu

Bratton

Lagos

, et al. (2008) Public opinion and democratic legitimacy. Journal of Democracy 19(2): 13–24.

17.

Citrin

(1974) The political relevance of trust in government. American Political Science Review 68: 973–988.

18.

Clarke

Yaros

(1988) Research blenders: Commentary and response. Transitions to new methodologies in nursing sciences. Nursing Science Quarterly 1(4): 147–151.

19.

Clausen

Kraay

Nyiri

(2011) Corruption and confidence in public institutions: Evidence from a global survey. The World Bank Economic Review 25(2): 212–249.

20.

CNN (2018) SBY 10 tahun tahan emosi soal tudingan kasus Century [SBY holds emotions for 10 years about Century case] Available at: https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20181111180715-32-345694/sby-10-tahun-tahan-emosi-soal-tudingan-kasus-century (accessed 13 September 2021).

21.

CNN (2019) KPU umumkan caleg mantan koruptor tambahan, total 81 orang [General Election Commission announces ex-corruptor legislature candidates a total of 81 people] Available at: https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20190219115418-32-370617/kpu-umumkan-caleg-mantan-koruptor-tambahan-total-81-orang (accessed 9 September 2021).

22.

CNN (2020) ICW: Ada 444 kasus korupsi sepanjang 2020, negara rugi Rp18 Triliun [ICW: There are 444 corruption cases throughout 2020, and the state loss was IDR18 Trillion] Available at: https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20210815163442-12-680645/icw-ada-444-kasus-korupsi-sepanjang-2020-negara-rugi-rp18-t (accessed 10 September 2021).

23.

Cohen

(1994) The earth is round (P < .05). The American Psychologist 49(912): 997–1003.

24.

Coicaud

(2002) Legitimacy and Politics: A Contribution to the Study of Political Right and Political Responsibility. New York: Cambridge University Press.

25.

Creswell

Plano

CVL

(2007) Designing and Conducting Mixed Methods Research. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

26.

Dalton

(2004) Democratic Challenges, Democratic Choices: The Erosion of Political Support in Advanced Industrial Democracies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

27.

Dean

(2011) On Barry Hindess’s discourses of power. Alternatives: Global, Local, Political 36(1): 4–9.

28.

Detik News (2017) Korupsi APBD oleh kepala daerah [Corruption of Regional Revenue and Expenditure Budgets by regional heads] Available at: https://news.detik.com/berita/d-3876999/icw-korupsi-apbd-oleh-kepala- daerah-terjadi-paling-banyak-di-2017 (accessed 13 September 2021)

29.

Dick

Mulholland

(2016) The politics of corruption in Indonesia. Georgetown Journal of International Affairs 17(1): 43–49.

30.

Economist Intelligence Unit (2020) Democracy Index. Available at https://www.eiu.com/n/campaigns/democracy-index-2021/?utm_source=google&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=democracy-index-2021&gclid=CjwKCAjwyaWZBhBGEiwACslQo1TnO7YUl1nrAmt4wKIBPC0CSbNI4IflNIo3tQY2Wlk2tKC3Cu-QBBoCQnoQAvD_BwE (accessed 26 September 2021).

31.

Fuchs

(1999) The democratic culture of unified Germany. In: Norris

(ed.) Critical Citizens: Global Support for Democratic Government. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.75–102.

32.

Golberg

Cho

(2004) Introduction to Regression Analysis. Boston, MA: Wtt Press.

33.

Hakim

Jurdi

(2017) Immature politicians and oligarchy as a threat to democracy. Fiat Justisia Jurnal Ilmu Hukum 11(4): 342–354.

34.

Hamzah

(2005) Perbandingan Pemberantasan Korupsi di Berbagai Negara [Comparison of Corruption Eradication in Various Countries]. Jakarta: Sinar Grafika.

35.

Harman

(2012) Negeri Mafia Republik Koruptor: Menggugat Peran DPR Reformasi [The Republic of Corrupt Mafia: Challenging the Role of the Parliament]. Yogyakarta: Penerbit Lamalera.

36.

Heidenheimer

(1996) The topography of corruption: Explorations in a comparative perspective. International Social Science Journal 48: 337–347.

37.

Heywood

(2004) Introduction: Concepts and theories in politics. In: Heywood

(ed.) Political Theory: An Introduction. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, pp.1–25.

38.

Hidayat

(2007) Shadow state? Business and politics in the province of Banten. In: Nordholt

van Klinken

(eds) Renegotiating Boundaries: Local Politics in Post-Suharto Indonesia. Leiden: KITLV Press, pp.126–152.

39.

Hindess

(1996) Discourses of Power: From Hobbes to Rousseau. Oxford: Blackwell.

40.

Huntington

(1989) Modernization and corruption. In: Heidenheimer

Johnston

LeVine

(eds) Political Corruption: A Handbook. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers, pp.157–187.

41.

Hurrelmann

Steffen

Jens

(2007) Legitimacy in an Age of Global Politics. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

42.

ICW (2020) Catatan akhir tahun pemberantasan korupsi tahun 2020: Pandemi, kemunduran demokrasi, dan redupnya spirit pemberantasan korupsi [Year-end notes for eradicating corruption in 2020: The pandemic, the decline of democracy, and the dim measures of eradicating corruption]. Available at: https://antikorupsi.org/id/article/catatan-akhir-tahun-pemberantasan-korupsi-tahun-2020–pandemi-kemunduran-demokrasi-dan (accessed 15 September 2021).

43.

Johnston

(2000) The new corruption rankings: Implication for analysis and reform. Paper presented at the International Political Science Association meeting, Quebec, Canada.

44.

Komisi Pemberantasa Korupsi (KPK) (2020) Graph TPK berdasarkan profesi/jabatan [Corruption crime based on position/profession]. Available at: https://www.kpk.go.id/id/statistik/penindakan/tpk-berdasarkan-profesi-jabatan (accessed 10 January 2021).

45.

Kompas (2013) Adhyaksa ragu Deddy Kusdinar ubah anggaran Hambalang Jadi Rp 2,5 T [Adhyaksa doubts Deddy Kusdinar will change Hambalang's budget to IDR2.5 trillion]. Available at: https://nasional.kompas.com/read/2013/11/19/1637150/Adhyaksa.Ragu.Deddy.Kusdinar.Ubah.Anggaran.Hambalang.Jadi.Rp.2.5.T (accessed 13 February 2021).

46.

Kompas (2019) Caleg eks koruptor, siapa saja mereka dan apa kata parpolnya [Ex-corrupt legislatures candidates, who are they, and what do their political parties say?]. Available at: https://jeo.kompas.com/caleg-eks-koruptor-siapa-saja-dan-apa-kata-parpolnya (accessed 13 February 2021).

47.

Kompas (2020) KPK catat 397 pejabat politik terjerat korupsi sejak 2004 hingga Mei 2020 [KPK records 397 political officials involved in corruption from 2004 to May 2020]. Available at: https://nasional.kompas.com/read/2020/09/30/11223141/kpk-catat-397-pejabat-politik-terjerat-korupsi-sejak-2004-hingga-mei-2020 (accessed 22 September 2021).

48.

Kontan (2019) Sandiaga Uno disebut bayar mahar ke PAN dan PKS Rp 500 miliar [Sandiaga Uno is said to have paid a dowry to PAN and PKS of IDR500 billion]. Available at: https://nasional.kontan.co.id/news/sandiaga-uno-disebut-bayar-mahar-ke-pan-dan-pks-rp-500-miliar (accessed 12 August 2021).

49.

Korsgaard

(1997) The Sources of Normativity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

50.

KPK (2019) Menyajikan informasi perkembangan penanganan tindak pidana korupsi yang dilakukan oleh Komisi Pemberantasan Korupsi [Presenting information on handling corruption crimes carried out by the Corruption Eradication Commission]. Available at https://acch.kpk.go.id/id/datagrafis/info (accessed 12 February 2021).

51.

La Porta

Lopez-de Silanes

Shleifer

, et al. (1999) The quality of government. Journal of Law, Economics and Organization 15(1): 222–279.

52.

Liputan 6 (2013) Akil Mochtar ditangkap KPK, kepercayaan publik ke MK anjlok [KPK arrests Akil Mochtar, public trust in Constitutional Court plummets]. Available at https://www.liputan6.com/news/read/712924/akil-mochtar-ditangkap-kpk- kepercayaan-publik-ke-mk-anjlok (accessed 21 August 2021).

53.

Listhaug

Wiberg

(1995) Confidence in political and private institutions. In: Klingemann

Fuchs

(eds) Citizens and the State. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.226–262.

54.

Medcom (2018) Bank Century dirancang menjadi pengucur dana partai penguasa? [Is the century bank designed to be a disbursement of funds for the ruling party?]. Available at: https://www.medcom.id/nasional/hukum/Zke0DLZb-bank-century-dirancang-menjadi-pengucur-dana-partai-penguasa (accessed 21 August 2021).

55.

Merdeka (2018) Survei Charta Politika: Kepercayaan publik terhadap parpol masih rendah [Charta Politica Survey: Public confidence in political parties is still shallow]. Available at https://www.merdeka.com/politik/survei-charta-politika-kepercayaan-publikterhadap- parpol-masih-rendah.html (accessed 16 September 2021).

56.

Merdeka (2018) Charta Politika: Kepercayaan publik kepada partai politik masih rendah [Charta Politika: Public trust in political parties is still shallow]. Available at: https://www.merdeka.com/politik/survei-charta-politika-kepercayaan-publik-terhadap-parpol-masih-rendah.html (accessed 16 September 2021).

57.

Mietzner

(2011) Indonesia’s political party: Cartelized and poorly institutionalized? Academic paper presented at Leiden University, Netherlands.

58.

Mietzner

(2013) Money, Power, and Ideology: Political Parties in Post-Authoritarian Indonesia. Singapore: NUS Press.

59.

Mietzner

(2015) Reinventing Asian populism: Jokowi’s rise, democracy, and political contestation in Indonesia. Policy Studies 72(1): 246–252.

60.

Morris

Klesner

(2010) Corruption and trust: Theoretical considerations and evidence from Mexico. Comparative Political Studies 43(10): 1258–1285.

61.

Muhtadi

(2019) Vote Buying in Indonesia: The Mechanism of Electoral Bribery. Singapore: Palgrave Macmillan.

62.

Mungiu-Pippidi

(2011) Contextual choices in fighting corruption: Lessons learned. Report 4/2011.

63.

Norad (2010) Political Economy Analysis with a Legitimacy Twist: What Is It and Why Does It Matter? Oslo: Norad.

64.

Norris

(1999) Critical Citizens: Global Support for Democratic Government. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

65.

Nye

(1997) The decline of confidence in government. In: Nye

(ed.) People Don't Trust Government. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, pp.98–124.

66.

Republika (2015a) Mahfud MD: Hukum di Indonesia masih bisa dibeli [Mahfud MD: Law in Indonesia is to be auctioned off]. Available at: https://www.republika.co.id/berita/nasional/politik/15/11/18/ny0ltb257-mahfud-md-hukum-di-indonesia-masih-bisa-dibeli (accessed 6 August 2021).

67.

Republika (2015b) Bubarkan DPR [Dismiss the DPR]. Available at: https://www.republika.co.id/berita/o07f4c8/bubarkan-dpr (accessed 14 February 2021).

68.

Reus-Smit

(2007) International crises of legitimacy. International Politics 44(2–3): 157–174.

69.

Robison

Hadiz

(2004) Reorganizing Power in Indonesia: The Politics of Oligarchy in the Age of Markets. London: Routledge Curzon.

70.

Robison

Hadiz

(2017) Indonesia: A tale of misplaced expectations. The Pacific Review 30(6): 895–909.

71.

Rock

Bonnett

(2004) The comparative politics of corruption: Accounting for the East Asian paradox in empirical studies of corruption, growth and investment. World Development 32(6): 999–1017.

72.

Sahrasad

(2009) Centurygate: Refleksi Ekonomi-Politik Skandal Bank Century. Jakarta: Freedom Institute, YIB and LSIK.

73.

Sekaran

Bougie

(2016) Research Methods for Business: A Skill Building Approach. 7th edn. New York: John Wiley & Sons Inc.

74.

Seligson

(2006) The Political Culture of Democracy in Mexico, Central America, and Colombia. Nashville, TN: Vanderbilt University.

75.

Simon

(1995) Support for the democratic system. In: Klingemann

Fuchs

(eds) Citizens and the State. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.89–114.

76.

Sindo News (2014) Anas ungkap SBY tahu di balik persoalan Century [Anas said president SBY knew behind the Century issue]. Available at: https://nasional.sindonews.com/berita/859661/13/anas-ungkap-sby-tahu-di-balik-persoalan-century (accessed 9 October 2021).

77.

Sjafrina

(2019) Dampak politik uang terhadap mahalnya biaya pemenangan pemilu dan korupsi politik [The impact of money politics on the high cost of winning elections and political corruption]. Jurnal Anti Korupsi Integritas 5(1): 43–53.

78.

Slater

(2018) Party cartelization, Indonesian-style: Presidential power-sharing and the contingency of democratic opposition. Journal of East Asian Studies 18(1): 23–46.

79.

Soseco

(2002) Corruption pattern in Indonesia: A geographical analysis. Journal of Economics and Policy 5(2): 117–229.

80.

Springborg

(2007) The Cambridge Companion to Hobbes's Leviathan. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

81.

Steckler

McLeroy

Goodman

, et al. (1992) Toward integrating qualitative and quantitative methods: An introduction. Health Education Quarterly 19(1): 1–8.

82.

Supreme Court (2014) Putusan Pengadilan untuk Budi Mulya dalam kasus Bank Century [Court decision for Budi Mulya in Century Bank case]. Available at: http://putusan.mah kamahagung.go.id/putusan/19574d87580d4db4d0d0d4f7da5a3d52 (accessed 13 September 2021).

83.

Tempo (2021) Mayoritas pimpinan Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat memiliki perusahaan [The majority of the leaders of the House of Representatives own companies]. Available at: https://koran.tempo.co/read/berita-utama/446368/mayoritas-pimpinan-dpr-miliki-perusahaan (accessed 12 September 2021).

84.

Tempo (2013a) Pekerjaan rumah memulihkan kepercayaan [Homework restores confidence]. Available at: https://koran.tempo.co/read/berita-utama/457509/pekerjaan-rumah-memulihkan-kepercayaan (accessed 18 September 2021).

85.

Tempo (2013b) BPK: Negara rugi Rp 7,4 Triliun karena Century [BPK: The state loses IDR7.4 trillion in the Century case]. Available at: https://bisnis.tempo.co/read/539682/bpk-negara-rugi-rp-74-triliun-karena-century (accessed 9 October 2021).

86.

Tirto (2019) Menkopolhukam Mahfud MD: Hukum bisa dibeli [Coordinating Minister for Political, Legal and Security Affairs Mahfud MD: Law is purchasable]. Available at: https://tirto.id/menkopolhukam-mahfud- md-hukum-bisa-dibeli-enKc (accessed 10 August 2021).

87.

Transparency International (2021) Corruption Perception Index. Available at: https://www.transparency.org/en/countries/indonesia (accessed 26 December 2020).

88.

Tribun News (2013) Wali kota Makassar akui biaya politik sangat mahal [Makassar Mayor admits political costs are prohibitive]. Available at: https://www.tribunnews.com/nasional/2013/09/19/wali-kota-makassar-akui-biaya-politik-sangat-mahal (accessed 26 September 2021).

89.

Ufen

(2010) Electoral campaigning in Indonesia: The professionalization and commercialization after 1998. Journal of Current Southeast Asian Affairs 29(4): 11–37.

90.

Umam

Whitehouse

Head

et al. (2018) Addressing corruption in post-Soeharto Indonesia: The role of the corruption eradication commission. Journal of Contemporary Asia 50(1): 125–143.

91.

Uslaner

(2008) The Bulging Pocket and the Rule of Law: Corruption, Inequality, and Trust. New York: Cambridge University Press.

92.

Uyanik

Guler

(2013) Study on multiple linear regression analysis. Procedia – Social and Behavioral Sciences 106: 234–240.

93.

Walker

(1988) The Rule of Law: Foundation of Constitutional Democracy . Carlton: Melbourne University Press.

94.

Wardah F (2019) KPK belum tuntaskan kasus besar [KPK has not yet completed significant scandals]. Available at: https://www.voaindonesia.com/a/kpk-belum-tuntaskan-18-kasus-besar/4914747.html (accessed 10 October 2021).

95.

Winters

(2011) Oligarchy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

96.

Winters

(2013) Oligarchy and democracy in Indonesia. Indonesia 96: 11–33.

97.

World Bank (2017) World development report 2017. Available at: https://www.worldbank.org/en/publication/wdr2017 (accessed 26 September 2021).

98.

Worldwide Governance Indicator (2020) Reports. Available at: http://info.worldbank.org/governance/wgi/Home/Reports (accessed 9 February 2021).

99.

Yuliono

(2013) Kepercayaan masyarakat pada partai politik [Public Trust in Political Parties]. Jurnal Administrasi Publik 11(1): 173–184.

100.

Zulkarwin Z (2021) Corruption and legitimacy. Journal of Governance 6(1): 63–72.