The motherhood penalty is an important issue in the field of family and gender inequality research. China has experienced rapid economic growth and drastic social change in recent decades, but existing studies fail to provide an overview of changes in the effect of the motherhood penalty during this period. This article uses data from the China Health and Nutrition Survey from 1989 to 2015 and applies a multi-layer mixed-effects model to study the severity of the motherhood penalty and the various mechanisms affecting it over that period. This study shows the following: (a) childbirth has a negative impact on women's wages and the severity of this impact continues to increase, showing that the effect of the motherhood penalty has become harsher over time; (b) although the motherhood penalty was initially lower for single mothers than for married ones, it has increased for both groups of women over the period and the rate of growth has been much faster for single mothers and, thus, the difference between the two groups in terms of the effect of the motherhood penalty has narrowed gradually over the period; (c) the long-term effect of the motherhood penalty is normally less pronounced than the short-term effect, but the long-term effect has grown at a much quicker rate over recent years compared with the short-term effect, and in more recent years these two effects are almost the same; (d) the higher the education level of women, the lower the effect of the motherhood penalty, but as the effect of the penalty has intensified over the period of study, the difference across different education levels has decreased; and (e) the effect of the motherhood penalty on female employees in the non-state sector is greater than that on female employees in the state sector, and the effect of the motherhood penalty on female employees in the non-state sector has increased rapidly, while the change has remained slow in the state sector, resulting in a widening gap between the two sectors. This study shows that the dramatic social and economic change in recent decades has subjected women to greater and greater maternal responsibilities but has afforded them disproportionately fewer benefits in relation to economic development.
AignerDJCainGG (1977) Statistical theories of discrimination in labor markets. Industrial and Labor Relations Review30(2): 175–187.
2.
Amuendo-DorantesCKimmelJ (2005) The motherhood wage gap for women in the United States: The importance of college and fertility delay. Review of Economics of the Household3: 17–48.
3.
AndersonDJBinderMKrauserK (2002) The motherhood penalty: Which mother pays and why?American Economic Review, Papers and Proceedings92(2): 354–358.
4.
AndersonDJBinderMKrauserK (2003) The motherhood wage penalty revisited: Experience, heterogeneity, work effort, and work-schedule flexibility. Industrial and Labor Relations Review56(2): 273–294.
5.
AvellarSSmockPJ (2003) Has the price of motherhood declined over time: A cross cohort comparison of the motherhood wage penalty. Journal of Marriage and the Family65(3): 597–607.
6.
BeckerGS (1985) Human capital, effort, and the sextual division of labor. Journal of Labor Economics3(1): S33–S58.
7.
BeckerGS (1991) A Treatise on the Family. Cambridge, MA: Havard University Press.
8.
BenardSCorrellSJ (2010) Normative discrimination and the motherhood penalty. Gender & Society24(5): 616–646.
9.
BlackburnMLBloomDENeumarkD (1993) Fertility timing, wages and human capital. Journal of Population Economics6: 1–30.
10.
BudigMJ (2006) Intersections on the road to self-employment: Gender, family and occupational class. Social Forces84(4): 2223–2239.
11.
BudigMJEnglandP (2001) The wage penalty for motherhood. American Sociological Review66(2): 204–225.
12.
BudigMJHodgesMJ (2010) Differences in disadvantage: Variation in the motherhood penalty across white women’s earnings distribution. American Sociological Review75(5): 705–728.
13.
CaiSYPPengYN (2016) Masculine Compromise: Migration, Family and Gender in China. Oakland, CA: University of California Press.
14.
ChenM (2018) Understanding ideal motherhood from the perspective of urban middle-class mothers: A case study of families in Shanghai. Collection of Women’s Studies2: 55–66(in Chinese).
15.
CohenJ (1988) Statistical Power Analysis of the Behavioral Sciences. Hillside, NJ: Eribaum.
16.
CookSDongXY (2011) Harsh choices: Chinese women’s paid work and unpaid care responsibilities under economic reform. Development and Change42(4): 947–965.
17.
CorrellSBenardSPaikI (2007) Getting a job: Is there a motherhood penalty?American Journal of Sociology112(5): 1297–1339.
18.
DongXY (2009) Care provision, gender equality and public policy – a feminist economic perspective. Population and Development (6): 62–68(in Chinese).
19.
EntwisleBChenFN (2002) Work patterns following a birth in urban and rural China: A longitudinal study. European Journal of Population18(2): 99–119.
20.
EnglandBBearakJBudigMJ, et al. (2016) Do highly paid, highly skilled women experience the largest motherhood penalty?American Sociological Review82(6): 116–1189.
21.
FilerRK (1985) Male–female wage differences: The importance of compensating differentials. Industrial and Labor Relations Review38(3): 426–437.
22.
GanglMZiefleA (2009) Motherhood, labor force behavior, and women’ s careers: An empirical assessment of the wage penalty for motherhood in Britain, Germany and the United States. Demography46(2): 341–369.
23.
GlauberR (2007) Marriage and the motherhood wage penalty among African Americans, Hispanics and whites. Journal of Marriage and Family69(4): 951–961.
24.
GustafssonBLiS (2000) Economic transformation and the gender earnings gap in urban China. Journal of Population Economics13(2): 305–329.
25.
HarknessSWaldfogelJ (2003) The family gap in pay: Evidence from seven industrialized countries. Journal of Labor Research22: 369–413.
26.
HeGYWuXG (2015) Marketization, economic development, and gender income inequality in Chinese cities. Sociological Studies30(1): 140–165(in Chinese).
27.
HillMS (1979) The wage effects of marital status and children. Journal of Human Resources14(4): 579–594.
28.
JiaNDongXY (2013) Economic transition and the motherhood wage penalty in urban China: Investigation using panel data. Cambridge Journal of Economics37(4): 819–843.
29.
JiaNGanLZhangJ (2013) Wage rate, the mommy trap and unobserved types. Economic Research Journal (5): 61–72(in Chinese).
30.
JinYH (2013) Chinese working mothers in social transformation. Academia Bimestris2: 56–63(in Chinese).
31.
JinYHYangD (2015) Coming into the times of “competing mothers in educational field”: The popularity of parentocracy and reconstruction of motherhood. Social Sciences in Nanjing (2): 61–67(in Chinese).
32.
KahnJRGarcia-ManglanoJBianchiS (2014) The motherhood penalty at midlife: Long-term effects of children on women’s careers. Journal of Marriage and Family76(1): 56–72.
33.
KorenmanSNeumarkD (1992) Marriage, motherhood and wages. Journal of Human Resources27(2): 233–255.
34.
LeibowitzAKlermanJA (1995) Explaining changes in married mothers’ employment over time. Demography32: 365–378.
35.
LiCLLiS (2008) Rising gender income gap and its dynamics in China: Market competition or sex discrimination?Sociological Studies23(2): 98–121(in Chinese).
36.
LiHL (2008) Chinese unit system in transition: Reflections in retrospection. Chinese Journal of Sociology (Chinese version) 28(3): 1–10(in Chinese).
37.
LiLL (2009) Market transformation and the transition of “units”: Rediscussion on “units”. Chinese Journal of Sociology (Chinese version) 29(4): 1–25(in Chinese).
38.
LiLL (2013) Transition and research on the unit system. Jilin University Journal Social Sciences Edition53(1): 11–14(in Chinese).
39.
LiLLZhuBWangY (2016) Market transformation, labor market segmentation and flow of work organizations. Social Sciences in China (9): 126–145(in Chinese).
40.
LiSGustafssonB (2008) Unemployment, earlier retirement and changes in the gender income gap in urban China, 1995–2002. In: GustafssonBLiSSicularT (eds) Income Inequality and Public Policy in China. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp.243–266.
41.
LiSSongJLiuXC (2014) The evolution of the gender wage gap of urban workers in China. Management World (3): 53–65(in Chinese).
42.
LiuBHZhangYYLiYN (2010a) Reform and improvement in public policies on a view through the balance between work and family. Journal of China Women’s University (6): 12–38(in Chinese).
43.
LiuJM (2006) Marketization and state regulation: Income distribution in the urban labor market during the period of transition. Social Sciences in China (5): 110–124(in Chinese).
44.
LiuLDongXYZhengXY (2010b) Parental care and married women’s labor supply in urban China. Feminist Economics16(3): 169–192.
45.
LoughranDZissimopoulosJM (2008) Why wait? The effect of marriage and childbearing on the wage growth of men and women. Journal of Human Resources44(2): 326–349.
46.
LundbergSRoseE (2000) Parenthood and the earnings of married men and women. Labor Economics7(6): 689–710.
47.
Maurer-FazioMHughesJ (2002) The effects of market liberalization on the relative earnings of Chinese women. Journal of Comparative Economics30(4): 709–731.
48.
Maurer-FazioMConnellyRChenL, et al. (2011) Childcare, eldercare and labor force participation of married women in urban China, 1982–2000. Journal of Human Resources46(2): 261–294.
49.
MincerJ (1974) Schooling, Experience and Earnings. New York: Columbia University Press.
50.
MincerJPolachekS (1974) Family investments in human capital: Earnings of women. Journal of Political Economy82(2): S76–S108.
51.
MisraJBudigMJMollerS (2007) Reconciliation policies and the effects of motherhood on employment, earnings and poverty. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis9(2): 135–155.
52.
PanJT (2003) The history and current situation of China’s maternity insurance system. Population Research27(2): 29–35(in Chinese).
53.
PetersenTPennerAMHøgsnesG (2014) From motherhood penalties to husband premia: The new challenge for gender equality and family policy, lessons from Norway. American Journal of Sociology119(5): 1434–1472.
54.
PhelpsES (1972) The statistical theory of racism and sexism. American Economic Review62(4): 659–661.
55.
QingSS (2019) Social–cultural roots of gender income difference in China: Evidence from the gender role attitudes. Sociological Studies34(1): 106–131(in Chinese).
56.
RidgewayC (2004) Motherhood as a status characteristic. Journal of Social Issues60(4): 683–700.
57.
RidgewayC (2011) Framed by Gender: How Gender Inequality Persists in the Modern World. New York: Oxford University Press.
58.
ShenHC (2020) Recourse activation: Group differences of parental participation in the tide of parentocracy. Chinese Journal of Sociology (Chinese version) 40(2): 168–203(in Chinese).
59.
StaffJMortimerJT (2012) Explaining the motherhood wage penalty during the early occupational career. Demography49(1): 1–21.
60.
TaniguchiH (1999) The timing of child bearing. Journal of Marriage and the Family61(4): 1008–1019.
61.
TaoYL (2015) Motherhood recreation in popular parenting magazines. Journal of Chinese Women’s Studies (3): 75–85(in Chinese).
62.
TaoYL (2018) Raising happy children – love and the myth of parental discourse in popular parenting magazines. Journal of Chinese Women’s Studies (3): 31–45(in Chinese).
63.
ToddEL (2001) Educational attainment and family gaps in women’s wages: Evidence from five industrialized countries. Luxembourg Income Study Working Paper No. 246. Available at:http://www.lisdatacenter.org/wps/liswps/246.pdf(accessed 30 November 2018).
64.
TongX (2017) Care labor and gendered regimes of production. Jiangsu Social Sciences (3): 43–54(in Chinese).
65.
TongXChenYP (2019) Embedded changes in the care policies for preschool children in Chinese cities and towns – a discussion on the change of women’s social roles in urban areas. Shandong Social Sciences (10): 87–97(in Chinese).
66.
TongXLiuAY (2015) A model of conjugal cooperation in housework for urban dual-career couples based on the third survey of women’s status in China. Social Sciences in China (6): 96–111(in Chinese).
67.
WaldfogelJ (1997) The effect of children on women’s wages. American Sociological Review62(2): 209–217.
68.
WaldfogelJ (1998a) The family gap for young women in the United States and Britain: Can maternity leave make a difference. Journal of Labor Economics16(3): 505–545.
69.
WaldfogelJ (1998b) Understanding the “family gap” in pay for women with children. Journal of Economic Perspectives12(1): 137–156.
70.
WangFQ (2010) Human capital, labor market segmentation and income distribution. Chinese Journal of Sociology (Chinese version) 30(1): 109–126(in Chinese).
71.
WangTFLiBBLaiYE (2008) The gender income gap under redistribution and its evolution: 1995–2003. Sociological Studies23(2): 23–53(in Chinese).
WuHFWuYRChenJ (2019) Accompanying mothers: New characteristics of rural women’s care work from the perspective of gender. Journal of Chinese Women’s Studies (4): 28–38(in Chinese).
74.
WuYX (2011) Labor market segmentation, job mobility and the two-track model of Chinese urban workers’ acquisition of economic status. Social Sciences in China (3): 119–137(in Chinese).
75.
WuYXWuXG (2009) Occupational gender segregation and the gender wage gap in urban China. Sociological Studies24(4): 88–111(in Chinese).
76.
WuYXWangPHuangC (2015) Family asylum, institutional asylum and work–family conflict. Sociological Studies30(6): 122–144(in Chinese).
77.
XiaoSW (2014) “Yan Mu Ci Zu”: The intergenerational collaboration and conflicts in childbearing among urban families in contemporary China. Sociological Studies29(6): 148–171(in Chinese).
78.
YangK (2018) Motherhood as educational agent: Changes in motherhood in the context of market orientation education. Journal of Chinese Women’s Studies2: 79–90(in Chinese).
79.
YuJXieY (2014) The effect of fertility on women’s wages in China. Population Research (1): 18–29(in Chinese).
80.
YuJXieY (2018) Motherhood penalties and living arrangements in China. Journal of Marriage and Family80(5): 1067–1086.
81.
ZhangHK (2016) On the need of building early education and care service system for 0–3-year-old children based on the continuity and evolution of childcare in China. Preschool Education Research (9): 16–24(in Chinese).
82.
ZhangYPHannumE (2013) Marriage, parenthood and labor outcomes for women and men in contemporary China. In: BeshrovDJBaehlerK (eds) Chinese Social Policy in a Time of Transition. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.223–248.
83.
ZhangYPHannumE (2015) Diverging fortunes: The evolution of gender wage gaps for singles, couples and parents in China, 1989–2009. Chinese Journal of Sociology1(1): 15–55.
84.
ZhangYPHannumEWangMY (2008) Gender-based employment and income differences in urban China: Considering the contribution of marriage and parenthood. Social Forces86(4): 1529–1560.
85.
ZhangYXMacleanM (2012) Rolling back of the state in childcare? Evidence from urban China. International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy32(11–12): 664–681.
86.
ZhouYXieY (2019) Job mobility and its income effects under system segmentation in urban China. Chinese Journal of Sociology (Chinese version) 39(4): 186–209(in Chinese).
87.
ZuoJPJiangYP (2012) Work-to-family conflict and women’s construction of work/family roles in post-Mao China. In: SegalMTChowENLDemosV (eds) Social Production and Reproduction at the Interface of Public and Private Spheres. Advances in Gender Research, Vol. 16. Bingley, UK: Emerald Group Publishing Limited, pp.139–146.
