Caught between ideal and reality: A study on occupational burnout among inside-system legal professionals under the rule-of-law reform in contemporary China
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online October, 2017
Caught between ideal and reality: A study on occupational burnout among inside-system legal professionals under the rule-of-law reform in contemporary China
This paper analyzes job burnout of inside-system legal professionals under the rule-of-law reform in China and its possible causes. Social cognitive theory, including cognitive dissonance, expectancy theory, and social comparison theory, provides the analytic framework for this study. The conclusion reveals a relatively high level of job burnout among inside-system legal professionals in China. Further analysis indicates that the individual’s commitment to the rule of law, confidence in the legal reform, and practice of non-rule-of-law in daily work are influential factors affecting his/her job burnout levels. Importantly, the interaction coefficients between these variables are statistically significant, clearly demonstrating that the discrepancy between expectation and reality is one of the root causes of job burnout in the legal profession. The discrepancy causes cognitive dissonance and psychological imbalance. At a theoretical level, this finding opens a new way of examining a particular type of occupational burnout. It shows that under the rule-of-law reform, Chinese inside-system legal professionals exhibit cognitive dissonance between ideals and reality, which constitutes a micro-political psychological basis for organizational change as speculated by neo-institutionalists and, in turn, reveals insights that may help us to understand the legal reform process within the bureaucratic system.
Aronson E (2007) The Social Animal (trans. Xiang ZJ) (In Chinese). Shanghai, China: East China Normal University Press.
2.
AveyJBLuthansFJensenSM (2009) Psychological capital: A positive resource for combating employee stress and turnover. Human Resource Management48(5): 677–693.
3.
BacharachSBBambergerPSonnenstuhlWJ (1996) The organizational transformation process: The micropolitics of dissonance reduction and the alignment of logics of action. Administrative Science Quarterly41(3): 477–506.
4.
BakkerABDemeroutiE (2007) The job demands-resources model: State of the art. Journal of Managerial Psychology22(3): 309–328.
5.
BakkerABKillmerCHSiegristJet al.(2000) Effort–reward imbalance and burnout among nurses. Journal of Advanced Nursing31(4): 884–891.
6.
BarkanS (2015) Law and Society: An Introduction, New York, NY: Routledge.
7.
BergerPLLuckmannT (1967) The Social Construction of Reality: A Treatise in the Sociology of Knowledge, New York, NY: Anchor Books.
8.
Blau P (1988) Exchange and Power in Social Life (trans. Sun F and Zhang LQ) (In Chinese). Beijing, China: Huaxia Publishing Company.
9.
Bourdieu P (2004) State Nobility: Elite Schools in the Field of Power (trans. Yang YP) (In Chinese). Beijing, China: The Commercial Press.
10.
Bourdieu P and Wacquant L (1998) An Invitation to Reflexive Sociology (trans. Li M and Li K) (In Chinese). Beijing, China: Central Compilation & Translation Press.
11.
Bourdieu P, Sayad A, Christin R, et al. (1999) The Weight of the World: Social Suffering in Contemporary Society (trans. Ferguson PP). Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
12.
BresóESchaufeliWBSalanovaM (2011) Can a self-efficacy-based intervention decrease burnout, increase engagement, and enhance performance? A quasi-experimental study. Higher Education61(4): 339–355.
13.
BrewerEWShapardL (2004) Employee burnout: A meta-analysis of the relationship between age or years of experience. Human Resource Development Review3(2): 102–123.
14.
Burawoy M (2005) Manufacturing Consent: Changes in the Labor Process under Monopoly Capitalism (trans. Lin ZH et al.) (In Chinese). Taipei, China: Socio Publishing Co., Ltd.
15.
ByrneB (1999) The nomological network of teacher burnout: A literature review and empirically validated model. In: VandenbergheRHubermanM (eds) Understanding and Preventing Teacher Burnout: A Source Book of International Research and Practice, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, pp. 15–37.
16.
CarrollJXWhiteWL (1982) Theory building: Integration individual and environmental factors within an ecological framework. In: PaineWSHillsB (eds) Job Stress and Burnout: Research, Theory, and Intervention Perspectives, Beverly Hills, CA: SAGE Publications, pp. 41–60.
17.
ChenHLuoDH (2012) The empirical research on the condition of prosecutors’ mental health. Present-day Law Science10(3): 29–35.
18.
ChenZGSunHWWingLet al.(2012) Chinese hotel employees in the smiling masks: Roles of job satisfaction, burnout, and supervisory support in relationships between emotional labor and performance. The International Journal of Human Resource Management23(4): 826–845.
19.
ChengFMengAFTaoJ (2015) Correlation between burnout and professional value in Chinese oncology nurses: A questionnaire survey. International Journal of Nursing Sciences2(2): 153–157.
20.
ChernissC (1993) Role of professional self-efficacy in the etiology and amelioration of burnout. In: SchaufeliWBMaslachCMarekT (eds) Professional Burnout: Recent Developments in Theory and Research, Philadelphia, PA: Taylor and Francis, pp. 135–149.
21.
DemeroutiEBakkerABNachreinerFet al.(2001) The job demands-resources model of burnout. Journal of Applied Psychology86(3): 499–512.
22.
DylagAJaworekMKarwowskiWet al.(2013) Discrepancy between individual and organizational values: Occupational burnout and work engagement among white-collar workers. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics43(3): 225–231.
23.
EdwardsHDiretteD (2010) The relationship between professional identity and burnout among occupational therapists. Occupational Therapy in Health Care24(2): 119–129.
24.
Ehrlich E (2009) Fundamental Principles of the Sociology of Law (trans. Shu GY) (In Chinese). Beijing, China: Encyclopedia of China Publishing House.
25.
FestingerL (1954) A theory of social comparison processes. Human Relations7(2): 117–140.
26.
FestingerL (1957) A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
27.
FestingerLCarlsmithJM (1959) Cognitive consequences of forced compliance. The Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology58(2): 203–210.
28.
FreudenbergerH (1974) Staff burn-out. Journal of Social Issues30(1): 159–165.
29.
GardenAM (1991) Relationship between burnout and performance. Psychological Reports68(3): 963–977.
30.
Giddens A (1998) The Constitution of Society: Outline of the Theory of Structuration (trans. Li K and Li M) (In Chinese). Beijing, China: SDX Joint Publishing Company.
31.
GongXLZhangQL (2008) Investigation and analysis on mental health of judges in Chinese middle-level and primary court. China Journal of Health Psychology16(1): 88–90.
32.
HalbeslebenJ (2006) Sources of social support and burnout: A meta-analytic test of the conservation of resources model. Journal of Applied Psychology91(5): 1134–1145.
33.
HarrisonD (1983) A social competence model of burnout. In: BarryAF (ed.) Stress and Burnout in the Human Service Professions, New York, NY: Pergamon, pp. 29–39.
34.
HeuvenEBakkerA (2003) Emotional dissonance and burnout among cabin attendants. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology12(1): 81–100.
35.
HobfollSFreedyJ (1993) Conservation of resources: A general stress theory applied to burnout. In: SchaufeliWBMaslachCMarekT (eds) Professional Burnout: Recent Developments in Theory and Research, Philadelphia, PA: Taylor & Francis, pp. 115–133.
36.
HouYLiYX (2007) Job burnout of judges and its relevant factors. Chinese Mental Health Journal21(11): 787–790.
37.
HouYLiYX (2008) Relationship between job burnout in judges and social support. Journal of Environmental and Occupational Medicine25(4): 383–385.
38.
HouYTangYLiYX (2008) Relationship between personality, locus of control of judges and job-burnout. Chinese Journal of Clinical Psychology16(4): 397–398.
39.
HuangPC (2007) Law, Society and Culture in the Qing: Representation and Practice of Civil Justice (In Chinese). Shanghai, China: Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House.
40.
IvancevichJMMattesonMT (1976) Stress Diagnostic Survey (SDS): Comments and Psychometric Properties of a Multidimensional Self-Report Inventory, Houston, TX: FD Associates.
41.
JermiasJ (2001) Cognitive dissonance and resistance to change: The influence of commitment confirmation and feedback on judgment usefulness of accounting systems. Accounting, Organizations and Society26(2): 141–160.
42.
JiWD (2001) The possibility of rule by law in China: Also on the interpretation and reflection of Chinese cultural tradition. Strategy and Management5(1): 1–15.
43.
KenworthyJFayCFrameMet al.(2014) A meta-analytic review of the relationship between emotional dissonance and emotional exhaustion. Journal of Applied Social Psychology44(2): 94–105.
44.
KimHStonerM (2008) Burnout and turnover intention among social workers: Effects of role stress, job autonomy and social support. Administration in Social Work32(3): 5–25.
45.
LeeCK (2002) From the specter of Mao to the spirit of the law: Labor insurgency in China. Theory and Society31(2): 189–228.
46.
LeiterM (1991) Coping patterns as predictors of burnout: The function of control and escapist coping patterns. Journal of Organizational Behavior12(2): 123–144.
LeiterMMaslachC (2001) Burnout and quality in a sped-up world. The Journal for Quality and Participation24(2): 48–51.
49.
LemyrePNHallHKRobertsGC (2008) A social cognitive approach to burnout in elite athletes. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports18(2): 221–234.
50.
LiangZP (1997) Law and order in rural society. In: WangMMFeuchtwangS (eds) The Order, Justice and Authority of the Rural Society (In Chinese). Beijing, China: China Politics & Law University Press, 425–480.
51.
LiuSD (2005) Legal transplants and the conflicts of legitimacy: Chinese grassroots judicial practice in the context of modernity. Sociological Studies20(3): 20–51.
52.
LiuSD (2007) The dilemma of legal reform: Reflection on the construction of a legal system in Contemporary China. The Leaders15(1): 22–29.
53.
MaH (2015) Influence of social support on job burnout of Chinese judges: Coping style as a mediator. Chinese Journal of Clinical Psychology23(3): 552–555.
54.
MaslachCJacksonSE (1981) The measurement of experienced burnout. Journal of Occupational Behavior2(2): 99–113.
55.
MaslachCJacksonSE (1985) The role of sex and family variables in burnout. Sex Roles12(7–8): 837–851.
56.
MaslachCLeiterMP (1997) The Truth about Burnout: How Organizations Cause Personal Stress and What to Do about It, San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
57.
MaslachCSchaufeliWB (1993) Historical and conceptual development of burnout. In: SchaufeliWBMaslachCMarekT (eds) Professional Burnout: Recent Developments in Theory and Research, Philadelphia, PA: Taylor & Francis, pp. 1–16.
MaslachCSchaufeliWBLeiterMP (2001) Job burnout. Annual Review of Psychology52(1): 397–422.
60.
MerrySE (1988) Legal pluralism. Law and Society Review22(5): 869–896.
61.
MertonRK (1940) Bureaucratic structure and personality. Social Forces18(4): 560–568.
62.
Merton RK (2006) Social Theory and Social Structure (trans. Tang SJ and Qi X) (In Chinese). Nanjing, China: Yilin Press.
63.
MeyerJWScottWR (1983) Organizational Environments: Ritual and Rationality, Beverly Hills, CA: SAGE Publications.
64.
MeyerJWRowanB (1977) Institutionalized organizations: Formal structure as myth and ceremony. American Journal of Sociology83(2): 340–363.
65.
MolinerCMartínez-TurVPeiróJMet al.(2005) Relationships between organizational justice and burnout at the work-unit level. International Journal of Stress Management12(2): 99–116.
66.
ParkerPAKulikJA (1995) Burnout, self- and supervisor-rated job performance, and absenteeism among nurses. Journal of Behavioral Medicine18(6): 581–599.
67.
PengJXJiangXHZhangJXet al.(2013) The impact of psychological capital on job burnout of Chinese nurses: The mediator role of organizational commitment. PLoS ONE8(12): e84193.DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0084193.
68.
PoundR (1910) Law in books and law in action. American Law Review44(1): 12–36.
69.
RabinM (1994) Cognitive dissonance and social change. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization23(2): 177–194.
70.
RadaREJohnson-LeongC (2004) Stress, burnout, anxiety and depression among dentists. The Journal of the American Dental Association135(6): 788–794.
71.
RussellJACarrollJM (1999) On the bipolarity of positive and negative affect. Psychological Bulletin125(1): 3–10.
72.
SarasonS (1983) School psychology: An autobiographical fragment. Journal of School Psychology21(4): 285–295.
73.
SchaibleLMGecasV (2010) The impact of emotional labor and value dissonance on burnout among police officers. Police Quarterly13(3): 316–341.
74.
ScottR (2008) Institutions and Organizations: Ideas and Interests, Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
75.
SinghJVTuckerDJHouseRJ (1986) Organizational legitimacy and the liability of newness. Administrative Science Quarterly31(2): 171–193.
76.
Shen NZ (2014) The wastage of young judges. Economic Observer Daily, 24 February. Available at: www.eeo.com.cn/2014/0222/256512.shtml (accessed 18 March 2016).
77.
Stanovich KE (2005) How to Think Straight About Psychology (trans. Fan Z Zou ZM) (In Chinese). Beijing, China: China Light Industry Press.
78.
StoufferSASuchmanEADevinneyLCet al.(1949) The American Soldier: Adjustment during Army Life (Volume I), Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
79.
StrümpferDJW (2003) Resilience and burnout: A stitch that could save nine. South African Journal of Psychology33(2): 69–79.
80.
SuL (1996) The Rule of Law and Its Local Resources (In Chinese). Beijing, China: China Politics & Law University Press.
81.
SunLP (2005) Social transformation: The new issue on sociology of development. Sociological Studies20(1): 1–24.
82.
TangSKAuWTSchwarzerRet al.(2001) Mental health outcomes of job stress among Chinese teachers: Role of stress resource factors and burnout. Journal of Organizational Behavior22(8): 887–901.
83.
TolbertPSZuckerLG (1999) The institutionalization of institutional theory. In: StewartRCHardyC (eds) Studying Organization: Theory and Method, London, UK: SAGE, pp. 169–184.
84.
VroomV (1964) Work and Motivation, San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
85.
WangCG (2012) Legal transplantation and transformation: The development of Chinese legal system. Journal of Comparative Law3(1): 25–35.
86.
WangYLiuLWangJNet al.(2012) Work–family conflict and burnout among Chinese doctors: The mediating role of psychological capital. Journal of Occupational Health54(3): 232–240.
87.
WinstanleySWhittingtonR (2002) Anxiety, burnout and coping styles in general hospital staff exposed to workplace aggression: A cyclical model of burnout and vulnerability to aggression. Work & Stress16(4): 302–315.
88.
Yang (2015) A lawyer released a photograph of Yang's resignation letter in his personal account of Sina Weibo on 17 March 2016 - available at weibo.com/1272651680/DmELiiK9U (accessed 1 September 2017).
89.
ZhangSYYanXJiangJ (2006) Revision and application of MBI: Human services survey in Chinese police officers. Chinese Mental Health Journal20(2): 85–88.
90.
Zhou L (2014) The judges of first court in Dongguan handle the large amount lawsuits and the quit rate is over 22%. Southern Metropolis Daily, 7 January. Available at: wen.oeeee.com/a/20140107/1087731.html (accessed 18 March 2016).
91.
ZuckerL (1977) The role of institutionalization in cultural persistence. American Sociological Review42(5): 726–743.
92.
ZuckerL (1983) Organizations as institutions. In: SamuelBB (ed.) Research in the Sociology of Organizations, Greenwich, CT: JAI Press, pp. 1–47.
