This article takes the Plantationocene concept as a departure point to question Earth System Models (ESMs). The term emphasises the formative role of plantation ecologies and colonialism as drivers of planetary change. Taking the tension between the need to document the Plantationocene’s planetary impact and the inability of models to fully grasp and articulate its violent ramifications, the paper interrogates how modelling limits what stories about planetary change can be told. This includes the limited kinds of political interventions modelling enables, the colonial legacy of data collection, as well as more recent acts of data extraction and dispossession. The paper proposes that the Plantationocene can be counter-modelled in a way that integrates friction, communal counter-mapping, and climate fiction. This effort could form part of a broader reparative and radical response to the ongoing planetary catastrophe.
Akram-LodhiAHDietzKEngelsB, et al. (2021) An introduction to the Handbook of Critical Agrarian Studies. In: Akram-LodhiADietzKEngelsB, et al. (eds) Handbook of Critical Agrarian Studies. Edward Elgar, pp.1–7.
2.
AvelinoJCristanchoMGeorgiouS, et al. (2015) The coffee rust crises in Colombia and Central America (2008–2013): Impacts, plausible causes and proposed solutions. Food Security7: 303–321.
3.
AvelinoJGagliardiSPerfectoI, et al. (2023) Tree effects on coffee leaf rust at field and landscape scales. Plant Disease107(2): 247–261.
4.
BaberZ (2016) The Plants of Empire: Botanic Gardens, colonial power and Botanical Knowledge. Journal of Contemporary Asia46: 659–679.
5.
BartonJ (2020) Wiring the world: A history of the earth system concept in the U.S. earth sciences, 1982–1989. PhD Dissertation, University of Toronto, Toronto.
6.
BaruaM (2023) Plantationocene: a vegetal geography. Annals of the American Association of Geographers113(1): 13–29.
7.
BaskinJ (2015) Paradigm dressed as epoch: The ideology of the anthropocene. Environmental Values24(1): 9–29.
8.
BatesJ (2018) The politics of data friction. Journal of Documentation74(2): 412–429.
BebberDPCastilloÁDGurrSJ (2016) Modelling coffee leaf rust risk in Colombia with climate reanalysis data. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences371(1709): 20150458.
11.
BhattacharyyaG (2018) Rethinking Racial Capitalism: Questions of Reproduction and Survival. Rowman & Littlefield.
12.
BirhaneA (2020) Algorithmic colonization of Africa. SCRIPT-ed17: 389–409.
13.
BonanGBLucierOCoenDR, et al. (2024) Reimagining Earth in the Earth system. Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems16(8): e2023MS004017.
14.
BrodieP (2023) Data infrastructure studies on an unequal planet. Big Data & Society10(1): 1–14.
15.
BrönnimannSWintzerJ (2019) Climate data empathy. WIREs Climate Change10(2): 1–8.
16.
BrowneS (2015) Dark Matters: On the Surveillance of Blackness. Duke University Press.
17.
BrownIJ (2022) Ecological witnessing. In: CroneBNightingaleSStantonP (eds) Fieldwork for Future Ecologies: Radical Practice for Art and Art-Based Research. Onomatopee, pp.21–48.
18.
BuckHJ (2019) After Geoengineering: Climate Tragedy, Repair, and Restoration. Verso Books.
19.
CaldeiraKBalaG (2017) Reflecting on 50 years of geoengineering research. Earth s Future5: 10–17.
20.
CamanaÂPerinVP (2023) Tracing out scalable landscapes: Interpretative layers over plantation designs. Tapuya: Latin American Science, Technology and Society6(1): 2281079.
21.
CampSMH (2004) Closer to Freedom: Enslaved Women and Everyday Resistance in the Plantation South. The University of North Carolina Press.
22.
ChangYLathamJLichtM, et al. (2023) A data-driven crop model for maize yield prediction. Communications biology6: 439.
23.
CoenDRJonssonFA (2022) Between History and Earth System Science. Isis113(2): 407–416.
24.
CouldryNMejiasUA (2020) The Costs of Connection: How Data is Colonizing Human Life and Appropriating It for Capitalism. Stanford University Press.
25.
CouldryNMejiasUA (2023) The decolonial turn in data and technology research: what is at stake and where is it heading?Information Communication & Society26(4): 786–802.
26.
CrutzenPJ (2006) Albedo enhancement by stratospheric sulfur injections: A contribution to resolve a policy dilemma?Climatic Change77: 211–220.
27.
CukierKMayer-SchoenbergerV (2013) The Rise of Big Data: How it’s changing the way we think about the world. Foreign Affairs92(3): 28–40.
28.
CurleyASmithS (2024) The cene scene: Who gets to theorize global time and how do we center indigenous and black futurities?Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space7(1): 166–188.
29.
DärmannI (2020) Undienlichkeit: Gewaltgeschichte und politische Philosophie. Matthes & Seitz Berlin.
30.
DavisJMoultonAAVan SantL, et al. (2019) Anthropocene, capitalocene, . . . plantationocene?: A manifesto for ecological justice in an age of global crises. Geography Compass13(5): 1–15.
31.
DeathC (2022) Climate fiction, climate theory: Decolonising imaginations of global futures. Millennium - Journal of International Studies50(2): 430–455.
32.
de Castro LimaJAMLabanowskiJBastosMC, et al. (2020) “Modern agriculture” transfers many pesticides to watercourses: A case study of a representative rural catchment of southern Brazil. Environmental Science and Pollution Research27(10): 10581–10598.
33.
DemosTJ (2017) Against the Anthropocene: Visual Culture and Environment Today. Sternberg Press.
34.
DioufSA (2014) Slavery’s Exile: The Story of the American Maroons. NYU Press.
35.
DuncanI (2023) Fugitive rivers: Maroon Ecologies and Édouard Glissant’s La Lézarde. Green Letters27: 92–108.
36.
EdwardsPN (2010) A Vast Machine: Computer Models, Climate Data, and the Politics of Global Warming. The MIT Press.
37.
FerdinandM (2021) Decolonial Ecology: Thinking From the Caribbean World. Translated by SmithA. P.Polity.
38.
FerdinandM (2022) Behind the colonial silence of Wilderness: “In Marronage Lies the Search of a World”. Environmental Humanities14(1): 182–201.
39.
FlatøEIsbergE (2023) Temporality and environmental history in the anthropocene: Timing climates, modelling futures. In: O’GormanESan MartínWCareyM, et al. (eds) The Routledge Handbook of Environmental History. Routledge, pp.217–228.
40.
FlatoGM (2011) Earth system models: An overview. WIREs Climate Change2: 783–800.
41.
FrameBCradock-HenryNA (2023) Views from nowhere, somewhere and everywhere else: The tragedy of the horizon in the early anthropocene. Anthropocene Review10(2): 524–540.
42.
FranklinS (2021) The Digitally Disposed: Racial Capitalism and the Informatics of Value. University of Minnesota Press.
43.
GalbraithEDCarozzaDABianchiD (2017) A coupled human-Earth model perspective on long-term trends in the global marine fishery. Nature Communications8: 14884.
44.
GertenDSchönfeldMSchaubergerB (2018) On deeper human dimensions in earth system analysis and modelling. Earth System Dynamics9(2): 849–863.
45.
GetachewA (2019) Worldmaking After Empire: The Rise and Fall of Self-Determination. Princeton University Press.
46.
GramelsbergerGLenhardJParkerWS (2020) Philosophical perspectives on earth system modeling: Truth, adequacy, and understanding. Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems12(1): 1–10.
47.
GrundmannRRödderS (2019) Sociological perspectives on earth system modeling. Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems11(12): 3878–3892.
HarawayDIshikawaNGilbertSF, et al. (2016) Anthropologists are talking – About the anthropocene. Ethnos81(3): 535–564.
50.
HarawayDJ (2016) Staying With the Trouble: Making Kin in the Chthulucene. Duke University Press.
51.
HarawayDJTsingA (2019) Reflections on the Plantationocene: a conversation with Donna Haraway & Anna Tsing moderated by Gregg Mitman. Edge Effects. Available at: https://edgeeffects.net/haraway-tsing-plantationocene/ (accessed 16 May 2023).
52.
HareN (1970) Black ecology. Black Scholar1(6): 2–8.
53.
HartmanS (2007) Lose Your Mother: A Journey Along the Atlantic Slave Route. Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
54.
HeinrichsM (2021) NAVI/GATED/GAZE: Google Earth’s narrative of the Earth and the privatization of Gaze. In: GálRGLöfflerP (eds) Earth and Beyond in Tumultuous Times: A Critical Atlas of the Anthropocene. Meson Press, pp.125–151.
55.
HeymannMDahan DalmedicoA (2019) Epistemology and politics in Earth system modeling: Historical perspectives. Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems11(5): 1139–1152.
56.
HinnahFDSentelhasPCAlves PatrícioFR, et al. (2020) Performance of a weather-based forecast system for chemical control of coffee leaf rust. Crop Protection137: 105225.
57.
HodgsonDLSchroederRA (2002) Dilemmas of counter-mapping community resources in Tanzania. Development and Change33: 79–100.
58.
JamesCLR (1938) The Black Jacobins: Toussaint L’Ouverture and the San Domingo Revolution. Secker & Warburg Ltd.
59.
JhaSBaconCMPhilpottSM, et al. (2014) Shade coffee: Update on a disappearing refuge for biodiversity. Bioscience64(5): 416–428.
60.
KadiriAPL (2021) Data and afrofuturism: an emancipated subject?Internet Policy Review10(4): 1–26.
61.
KawamiyaMHajimaTTachiiriK, et al. (2020) Two decades of Earth system modeling with an emphasis on model for interdisciplinary research on climate (MIROC). Progress in Earth and Planetary Science7(1): 1–13.
62.
KelleyRDG (2002) Freedom Dreams: The Black Radical Imagination. Beacon Press.
63.
KwetM (2019) Digital colonialism: US empire and the new imperialism in the Global South. Race & Class60(4): 3–26.
64.
LennonJTAbramoffRZAllisonSD, et al. (2024) Priorities, opportunities, and challenges for integrating microorganisms into Earth system models for climate change prediction. mBio15(5): 1–9.
65.
LeonelliSTempiniN (2020) Data Journeys in the Sciences. Springer.
66.
LevendaAMMahmoudiD (2019) Silicon Forest and Server Farms: The (Urban) Nature of Digital Capitalism in the Pacific Northwest. UMBC Geography and Environmental Systems Department Collection.
67.
Losada CubillosJJTrujillo QuinteroHFLugo PereaLJ (2023) Extractive logic of the coloniality of nature: Feeling-thinking through agroecology as a decolonial project. Capitalism Nature Socialism34(1): 88–106.
68.
LoukissasYA (2019) All Data Are Local: Thinking Critically in a Data-Driven Society. The MIT Press.
69.
MalmA (2022) The future is the termination shock: On the antinomies and psychopathologies of geoengineering. Part One. Historical Materialism30(4): 3–53.
70.
MalmAHornborgA (2014) The geology of mankind? A critique of the anthropocene narrative. Anthropocene Review1(1): 62–69.
71.
MbembeA (2022) Thoughts on the planetary: An interview with Achille Mbembe. In: Barnard-NaudéJ (ed) Decolonising the Neoliberal University: Law, Psychoanalysis and the Politics of Student Protest. Birkbeck Law Press, pp.122–136.
72.
MbembeA (2023) La communauté terrestre. La Découverte.
73.
McCookS (2019) Coffee is Not Forever: A Global History of the Coffee Leaf Rust. Ohio University Press.
74.
McCookSVandermeerJ (2015) The big rust and the red queen: Long-term perspectives on coffee rust research. Phytopathology105(9): 1164–1173.
75.
McDanielL (1990) The flying Africans: Extent and strength of the myth in the Americas. Nieuwe West-Indische Gids/New West Indian Guide64(1/2): 28–40.
76.
McDonaldBAStukenbrockEH (2016) Rapid emergence of pathogens in agro-ecosystems: Global threats to agricultural sustainability and food security. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences371(1709): 1–9.
77.
McKayBMVeltmeyerH (2021) Industrial agriculture and agrarian extractivism. In: Akram-LodhiAHDietzKEngelsB, et al. (eds) Handbook of Critical Agrarian Studies. Edward Elgar, pp.503–514.
78.
McKittrickK (2013) Plantation futures. Small Axe A Caribbean Journal of Criticism17(3): 1–15.
79.
McLarenDCorryO (2021a) Clash of geofutures and the remaking of planetary order: Faultlines underlying conflicts over geoengineering governance. Global Policy12: 20–33.
80.
McLarenDCorryO (2021b) The politics and governance of research into solar geoengineering. WIREs Climate Change12(3): 1–20.
81.
MerleITixierPVirginio FilhoEDM, et al. (2020) Forecast models of coffee leaf rust symptoms and signs based on identified microclimatic combinations in coffee-based agroforestry systems in Costa Rica. Crop Protection130: 105046.
82.
MillnerSY (1995) Free grace in the wilderness: An aesthetic analysis of land and space in African American culture in the narratives of Henri Bibb, Harriet Jacobs and Josiah Henson. Doctoral dissertation, Temple University. Available at: https://www.proquest.com/docview/304119759?pq-origsite=gscholar&fromopenview=true (accessed 15 September 2023).
83.
MorrisonKD (2018) Provincializing the anthropocene: Eurocentrism in the Earth system. In: CederlöfGRangarajanM (eds) At Nature’s Edge. The Global Present and Long-Term History. Oxford University Press, pp.1–18.
84.
NaulleauAGaryCPrévotL, et al. (2022) Participatory modeling to assess the impacts of climate change in a Mediterranean vineyard watershed. Environmental Modelling & Software150: 105342.
85.
NewtonP (1999) A manual for planetary management. Nature400: 399–399.
86.
OfstehageA (2024) Making soil in the plantationocene. Journal of Peasant Studies51(3): 603–623.
OumaSPremchanderS (2022) Labour, efficiency, critique: Writing the plantation into the technological present-future. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space54(2): 413–421.
91.
O’ConnellHC (2016) “We are change”: The novum as event in Nnedi Okorafor’s Lagoon. Cambridge Journal of Postcolonial Literary Inquiry3(3): 291–312.
92.
PattersonO (1982) Slavery and Social Death. Harvard University Press.
93.
PawluczukŁHeitzigJ (2023) Understanding integrated human-Earth system models as boundary objects: Enhancing credibility and interdisciplinary collaboration. GAIA - Ecological Perspectives for Science and Society33(1): 137–141.
94.
PeanoIMacedoMLe PetitcorpsC (2023) Introduction: Viewing plantations at the intersection of political ecologies and multiple space-Times. In: Le PetitcorpsCAcedoMPeanoMI (eds) Global Plantations in the Modern World. Cambridge Imperial and Post-Colonial Studies. Palgrave Macmillan, pp.1–32.
95.
PelusoNL (1995) Whose woods are these? Counter-mapping forest territories in Kalimantan, Indonesia. Antipode27: 383–406.
96.
PendergrassD (2024) From planetary scenarios to planetary sensing: Models, observations, and political legibility. Anthropocene Review 0(0): 1–14.
97.
PerfectoIJiménez-SotoMEVandermeerJ (2019) Coffee landscapes shaping the anthropocene: Forced simplification on a complex agroecological landscape. Current Anthropology60(S20): S236–S250.
98.
Philogene HeronA (2024) Plotting survival (to live in the Hurricane’s path). In: L’Observatoire-Terre Monde (ed) Decoloniser le changement climatique. Éditions du commun, pp.163–187.
99.
RedikerM (2007) The Slave Ship: A Human History. Viking-Penguin.
100.
RhodesCGLoaizaJRRomeroLM, et al. (2022) Anopheles albimanus (Diptera: Culicidae) ensemble distribution modeling: Applications for malaria elimination. Insects13(3): 221.
101.
RobinsonC (1983) Black Marxism: The Making of the Black Radical Tradition. Zed Books.
102.
RödderSHeymannMStevensB (2020) Historical, philosophical, and sociological perspectives on earth system modeling. Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems12(10): e2020MS002139.
103.
RogersAMedlynBEDukesJS, et al. (2017) A roadmap for improving the representation of photosynthesis in Earth system models. New Phytologist213(1): 22–42.
104.
RosenthalC (2018) Accounting for Slavery: Masters and Management. Harvard University Press.
105.
RosenthalC (2021) Lessons from the ‘Data Exhaust’ of Plantation Slavery. Harvard Data Science Review3(2): 1–9.
106.
Rubiano RivadeneiraNCartonW (2022) (In)justice in modelled climate futures: A review of integrated assessment modelling critiques through a justice lens. Energy Research & Social Science92: 102781.
SarkarSRangarajanS (2022) Marine entanglements: Tropical materialism and hydrographic imaginary in Nnedi Okorafor’s Lagoon. ETropic: Electronic Journal of Studies in the Tropics21(2): 180–197.
109.
SaundersPJ (2008) Fugitive dreams of diaspora: Conversations with Saidiya Hartman. Anthurium: A Caribbean Studies Journal6(1): 7.
110.
SayersD (2014) A Desolate Place for a Defiant People: The Archaeology of Maroons, Indigenous Americans, and Enslaved Laborers in the Great Dismal Swamp. University Press of Florida.
111.
SchafferS (2015) Ceremonies of measurement: Rethinking the World History of Science. Annales70(02): 335–360.
112.
Schneider-MayersonM (2018) The influence of climate fiction: An empirical survey of readers. Environmental Humanities10(2): 473–500.
113.
Schneider-MayersonM (2019) Whose odds? The absence of climate justice in American Climate Fiction Novels. ISLE Interdisciplinary Studies in Literature and Environment26(4): 944–967.
114.
SciencexMedia (2022) Anthropocene, capitalocene, plantationocene: Conceptualizing the climate crisis. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cEd34VdKz3g (accessed 21 May 2023).
115.
SharpeC (2016) In the Wake: On Blackness and Being. Duke University Press.
116.
SheridanRB (1969) The Plantation Revolution and the Industrial Revolution, 1625-1775. Caribbean Studies9(3): 5–25.
117.
SiddikMABShehabiAMarstonL (2021) The environmental footprint of data centers in the United States. Environmental Research Letters16(6): 064017.
118.
SilverJJOkamotoDKArmitageD, et al. (2022) Fish, people, and systems of power: Understanding and disrupting feedback between colonialism and fisheries science. American Naturalist200(1): 168–180.
119.
SisheberBMarshallMMengistuD, et al. (2024) The influence of temporal resolution on crop yield estimation with Earth Observation data assimilation. Remote Sensing Applications Society and Environment36: 101272.
120.
SmithMJPalmerPIPurvesDW, et al. (2014) Changing how Earth System Modeling is done to provide more useful information for decision making, Science, and Society. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society95(9): 1453–1464.
121.
SörlinSWormbsN (2018) Environing technologies: A theory of making environment. History and Technology34(2): 101–125.
122.
SteffenWRichardsonKRockströmJ, et al. (2020) The emergence and evolution of Earth System Science. Nature Reviews Earth & Environment1: 54–63.
123.
StolerAL (2016) Duress: Imperial Durabilities in Our Times. Duke University Press.
124.
SultanaF (2022) The unbearable heaviness of climate coloniality. Political Geography99: 102638.
125.
TáíwòOO (2022) Reconsidering Reparations. Oxford University Press.
126.
TempiniN (2020) The reuse of digital computer data: Transformation, recombination and generation of data mixes in Big Data Science. In: LeonelliSTempiniN (eds) Data Journeys in the Sciences. Springer, pp.239–263.
127.
TheilenJTBaurABiekerF, et al. (2021) Feminist data protection: An introduction. Internet Policy Review10(4): 1–26.
128.
TilleyL (2020) “The impulse is cartographic”: Counter-Mapping Indonesia’s Resource Frontiers in the context of Coloniality. Antipode52(5): 1434–1454.
129.
TsingAL (2015) The Mushroom at the End of the World: On the Possibility of Life in Capitalist Ruins. Princeton University Press.
130.
Tuhus-DubrowR (2013) Cli-Fi: Birth of a genre. Dissent60(3): 58–61.
131.
TurnhoutE (2024) A better knowledge is possible: Transforming environmental science for justice and pluralism. Environmental Science & Policy155: 103729.
132.
URI Center for the Humanities (2023) 2023 Innovations in Storytelling Humanities Lecture Series - Akeia de Barros Gomes and Jason Mancini. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lCKXls-j3wY (accessed 4 November 2024).
133.
Van BeekLVersteegW (2023) Plausibility in models and fiction: What Integrated Assessment Modellers can learn from an interaction with climate fiction. Futures151: 103195.
134.
VandermeerJJacksonDPerfectoI (2014) Qualitative dynamics of the coffee rust epidemic: educating intuition with theoretical ecology. Bioscience64(3): 210–218.
135.
van DoorenT (2014) Flight Ways: Life and Loss at the Edge of Extinction. Columbia University Press.
136.
Van VuurenDPBayerLBChuwahC, et al. (2012) A comprehensive view on climate change: coupling of earth system and integrated assessment models. Environmental Research Letters7(2): 024012.
137.
VaronJPeñaP (2021) Artificial intelligence and consent: A feminist anti-colonial critique. Internet Policy Review10(4): 1–25.
138.
VetteseTPendergrassD (2022) Half-Earth Socialism: A Plan to Save the Future From Extinction, Climate Change, and Pandemics. Verso.
139.
WainwrightJBryanJ (2009) Cartography, territory, property: Postcolonial reflections on indigenous counter-mapping in Nicaragua and Belize. Cultural Geographies16: 153–178.
140.
WallaceR (2016) Big Farms Make Big Flu: Dispatches on Influenza, Agribusiness, and the Nature of Science. NYU Press.
141.
WangCXuY (2024) Reflecting on the plantationocene: The political economy of sugarcane plantations in Guangxi, China. Journal of Peasant Studies51: 564–585.
142.
WardNDMegonigalJPBond-LambertyB, et al. (2020) Representing the function and sensitivity of coastal interfaces in Earth system models. Nature Communications11(1): 2458.
WhyteK (2024) Climate action at the speed of consent. In: L’Observatoire Terre-Monde (ed.) Décoloniser le changement climatique. Éditions du commun, pp.88–104.
145.
WhyteKP (2018) Indigeneity in geoengineering discourses: Some considerations. Ethics Policy & Environment21(3): 289–307.
146.
WickbergAGärdeboJ (2023) Editors’ introduction: What are environing media? In: WickbergAGärdeboJ (eds) Environing Media. Routledge, pp.1–12.
147.
WickbergALidströmSLagerkvistA, et al. (2024) The mediated planet: Datafication and the environmental SDGs. Environmental Science & Policy153: 1–5.
148.
WilentzG (1989) If you surrender to the air: Folk legends of flight and resistance in African American literature. MELUS16(1): 21–32.
149.
WilliamsE (2022) Capitalism and Slavery. Penguin Books. Original work published 1944.
150.
WolfordW (2021) The plantationocene: A Lusotropical contribution to the theory. Annals of the American Association of Geographers111(6): 1622–1718.
151.
WynterS (1971) Novel and history, plot and plantation. Savacou5: 95–102.
152.
YanWJiangWHanX, et al. (2020) Simulating and predicting crop yield and soil fertility under climate change with fertilizer management in Northeast China based on the decision support system for agrotechnology transfer model. Sustainability12(6): 2194.
153.
YoungJR (2017) All god’s children had wings: The Flying African in history, literature, and Lore. Journal of Africana Religions5(1): 50–70.
154.
YusoffK (2018) A Billion Black Anthropocenes or None. University of Minnesota Press.
155.
ZhaoTCoshMHRoyA, et al. (2021) Remote sensing experiments for earth system science. International Journal of Digital Earth14(10): 1237–1242.
