The exponential increase in global waste production resulting from population growth, urbanization, and increased consumption has brought waste management to the forefront of global environmental challenges. This paper provides an analysis of waste management practices in two contrasting case studies. Japan a highly developed country, exemplifies a model of advanced waste management with a robust regulatory framework, extensive public engagement, and sophisticated waste sorting, recycling, and recovery infrastructure, all underpinned by “Mottainai”—a concept deeply rooted in Japanese culture that emphasizes resource conservation and waste minimization. In contrast, Poland, like many Eastern European countries, faces systemic challenges, including inadequate infrastructure, limited recycling facilities, and low public awareness. Drawing on empirical evidence and scholarly discourse, this paper highlights the critical role of societal attitudes, policy interventions, and technological advances in shaping effective waste management strategies. By elucidating the key determinants of successful waste management systems, this paper contributes insights to the global discourse on sustainable development and informs future efforts toward sustainable waste management.
Abdel-ShafyHIMansourMSM (2018) Solid waste issue: Sources, composition, disposal, recycling, and valorization. Egyptian Journal of Petroleum27(4): 1275–1290.
2.
AhmedFHasanSRanaMS, et al. (2023) A conceptual framework for zero waste management in Bangladesh. International Journal of Environmental Science and Technology20(2): 1887–1904.
3.
AlwaeliM (2015) An overview of municipal solid waste management in Poland. The current situation, problems and challenges. Environment Protection Engineering41(4): 181–193.
4.
AmponsemBBensahECAntwiE, et al. (2023) Electricity generation from biogas as resource recovery potential from solid waste composition in a mixed-income municipality. Cleaner Waste Systems4: 100067.
5.
AraiRCalisto FriantMVermeulenWJV (2024) The Japanese circular economy and sound material-cycle society policies: Discourse and policy analysis. Circular Economy and Sustainability4(1): 619–650.
6.
AshrafHRahmanGKhanMA, et al. (2023) Spatio-temporal urban sprawl of sargodha city, Punjab, Pakistan. In: Urban Environment and Smart Cities in Asian Countries: Insights for Social, Ecological, and Technological Sustainability. Cham: Springer International Publishing, pp.543–560.
7.
AsokanVASioenGBKawazuE (2024) Why not in my backyard? (W-NIMBY): The potential of design-driven environmental infrastructure to foster greater acceptance among host communities. Global Sustainability7: e26.
8.
BassiSAChristensenTHDamgaardA (2017) Environmental performance of household waste management in Europe-an example of 7 countries. Waste Management69: 545–557.
9.
BerglundC (2006) The assessment of households’ recycling costs: The role of personal motives. Ecological Economics56(4): 560–569.
10.
BergmannMArpHPHCarney AlmrothB, et al. (2023) Moving from symptom management to upstream plastics prevention: The fallacy of plastic cleanup technology. One Earth6(11): 1439–1442.
11.
BrowneKDzeboAIacobutaG, et al. (2023) How does policy coherence shape effectiveness and inequality? Implications for sustainable development and the 2030 agenda. Sustainable Development31: 3161–3174.
12.
BrownSButmanDKurtzK (2023) Steps to circularity: Impact of resource recovery and urban agriculture in Seattle and Tacoma, Washington. Journal of Environmental Management345: 118648.
13.
Central Statistical Office (2024) Poland. Available at: https://stat.gov.pl/ (accessed 1 August 2024).
14.
ChertowMChildressL (2022) Improving the US municipal waste system: Toward a circular future. One Earth5(11): 1185–1188.
15.
ChifariRLo PianoSMatsumotoS, et al. (2017) Does recyclable separation reduce the cost of municipal waste management in Japan?Waste Management60: 32–41.
16.
CichosK (2021) Restriction of transboundary waste shipments-international legal perspective in relation to Polish legislation. Zeszyty Prawnicze21(2): 257–281 [In Polish].
17.
CiechelskaA (2015) Review and evaluation of selected instruments of municipal waste management in the Second National Ecological Policy. Prace Naukowe Uniwersytetu Ekonomicznego we Wrocławiu409: 140–154 [In Polish].
18.
Den BoerEJędrczakAKowalskiZ, et al. (2010) A review of municipal solid waste composition and quantities in Poland. Waste Management30(3): 369–377.
19.
DerhabNElkhweskyZ (2023) A systematic and critical review of waste management in micro, small and medium-sized enterprises: future directions for theory and practice. Environmental Science and Pollution Research30(6): 13920–13944.
ErdemM (2022) Optimisation of sustainable urban recycling waste collection and routing with heterogeneous electric vehicles. Sustainable Cities and Society80: 103785.
GohEEsfandiarKJieF, et al. (2022) Please sort out your rubbish! An integrated structural model approach to examine antecedents of residential households’ waste separation behaviour. Journal of Cleaner Production355: 131789.
26.
GoranovaSAnguelovK (2024) Critical review of Bulgarian legislation related to circular economy. Environment Technology Resources Proceedings of the International Scientific and Practical Conference1: 168–172.
27.
Grodzińska-JurczakMTarabułaMReadAD (2003a) Increasing participation in rational municipal waste management—A case study analysis in Jaslo City (Poland). Resources Conservation and Recycling38(1): 67–88.
28.
Grodzińska-JurczakM (2003b) The relation between education, knowledge and action for better waste management in Poland. Waste Management & Research21(1): 2–18.
29.
Grodzińska-JurczakMTomalPTarabuła-FiertakM, et al. (2006) Effects of an educational campaign on public environmental attitudes and behaviour in Poland. Resources Conservation and Recycling46(2): 182–197.
GworekBHajdukAKodaE, et al. (2013) Influence of a municipal waste landfill on the spatial distribution of polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins and dibenzofurans (PCDDs/Fs) in the natural environment. Chemosphere92: 753–759.
32.
HasnatMKhanMKSiddiquiEF, et al. (2024) Conserving oceans from plastic waste using convolution neural network model. Ecology, Environment and Conservation 0971765X: S184–S190.
33.
HayashiMTamanoK (2024) Community and Japanese developmental capitalism: A scaled and sociological political economy. Critical Sociology 08969205241256103.
34.
HerradorMde JongWNasuK, et al. (2023) The rising phenomenon of circular cities in Japan. Case studies of Kamikatsu, Osaki and Kitakyushu. Science of the Total Environment894: 165052.
35.
HuJMiaoLHanJ, et al. (2024) Waste separation behavior with a new plastic category for the plastic resource circulation: Survey in Kansai, Japan. Journal of Environmental Management349: 119370.
36.
HuJLHonmaSChangTM (2023) Recycling efficiencies in Japan’s administrative regions: Findings from Network Data Envelopment Analysis. Circular Economy and Sustainability4(1): 1–21.
37.
HusainA (2023) Management and disposal of solid waste: Practices and legislations in different countries. In: Management of Wastewater and Sludge. CRC Press, pp.271–295.
38.
InoueM (2014) Perspectives on early childhood environmental education in Japan. In: Research in Early Childhood Education for Sustainability: International Perspectives and Provocations. London: Routledge, pp.79–96.
39.
IraguhaFHandono RamelanASetyonoP (2022) Assessment of current solid waste management practices, community perceptions, and contributions in the City of Kigali, Rwanda. IOP Conference Series Earth and Environmental Science1016: 012056.
40.
IshimuraY (2022) The effects of the containers and packaging recycling law on the domestic recycling of plastic waste: Evidence from Japan. Ecological Economics201: 107535.
41.
ItoKFujiwaraTChoH, et al. (2024) Waste-to-energy plant evaluation of combustion stability using an automatic crane system with AI-based waste identification. Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management26: 1997–2012.
42.
JakharRSamekLStyszkoK (2023) A comprehensive study of the impact of waste fires on the environment and health. Sustainability15(19): 14241.
43.
JakimiukAMatsuiYPodlasekA, et al. (2022) Assessment of landfill protection systems in Japan-a case study. Acta Scientiarum Polonorum. Architectura21(4): 21–31.
44.
JakubusMStejskal (2020) Municipal solid waste management systems in Poland and the Czech Republic. A comparative study. Environment Protection Engineering46(3): 61–78.
45.
JayasingheRKoliyabandaraPAVithanageM (2023) Waste in one health: Building resilient communities through sustainable waste management. In: One Health: Human, Animal, and Environment Triad. Wiley, pp.211–220.
46.
JimCYHuiLCRupprechtCDD (2022) Public perceptions of green roofs and green walls in Tokyo, Japan: A call to heighten awareness. Environmental Management70(1): 35–53.
47.
KasznikDŁapniewskaZ (2023) The end of plastic? The EU’s directive on single-use plastics and its implementation in Poland. Environmental Science & Policy145: 151–163.
48.
KatadaSFukudaANakajimaC, et al. (2021) Aerobic composting and anaerobic digestion decrease the copy numbers of antibiotic-resistant genes and the levels of lactose-degrading Enterobacteriaceae in dairy farms in Hokkaido, Japan. Frontiers in Microbiology12: 737420.
49.
KawasakiYAkamatsuRWarschburgerP (2022) The relationship between traditional and common Japanese childhood education and adulthood towards avoiding food waste behaviors. Waste Management145: 1–9.
50.
KodaEMiszkowskaASieczkaA, et al. (2020) Heavy metals contamination within restored landfill site in Poland. Environmental Geotechnics7(7): 512–521.
51.
KodaEOsińskiPPodlasekA, et al. (2023) Geoenvironmental approaches in an old municipal waste landfill reclamation process: Expectations vs reality. Soils and Foundations63(1): 101273.
52.
KodamaT (2017) Environmental education in formal education in Japan. Japanese Journal of Environmental Education26(4): 4_21–4_26.
53.
KuanSHLowFSChiengS (2022) Towards regional cooperation on sustainable plastic recycling: comparative analysis of plastic waste recycling policies and legislations in Japan and Malaysia. Clean Technologies and Environmental Policy24(3): 761–777.
KurisuKHBortoletoAP (2011) Comparison of waste prevention behaviors among three Japanese megacity regions in the context of local measures and socio-demographics. Waste Management31(7): 1441–1449.
56.
KurokawaHIgeiKKitsukiA, et al. (2023) Improvement impact of nudges incorporated in environmental education on students’ environmental knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors. Journal of Environmental Management325: 116612.
57.
LagerkvistA (2024) Time to dump the waste hierarchy?Waste Management & Research42(1): 1–2.
58.
LatosińskaJMiłekDKomórA, et al. (2021) Selective collection of municipal waste in a residential district with multi-family Buildings—Case study from Poland. Resources10(8): 83.
59.
LeeHSakamotoYYoshizawaY (2023) Analysis of information to promote participation in waste separate collection: Used cooking oil in Japan. Cleaner Waste Systems6: 100119.
60.
European Commission (2023) COM(2023) 304 final: Report from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions on the risk of Member States failing to achieve the 2025 and 2035 recycling and landfill diversion targets. Brussels: European Commission. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/PL/TXT/HTML/?uri=COM:2023:304:FIN
61.
LuísSRoseta-PalmaCMatosM, et al. (2020) Psychosocial and economic impacts of a charge in lightweight plastic carrier bags in Portugal: Keep calm and carry on?Resources Conservation and Recycling161: 104962.
62.
MaamariOMradMMouchatiA, et al. (2017) Assessing the feasibility of waste management solutions based on sorting at source and recycling. International Journal of Environment and Waste Management19(3): 216–232.
63.
MaghmoumiAMarashiFHoushfarE (2020) Environmental and economic assessment of sustainable municipal solid waste management strategies in Iran. Sustainable Cities and Society59: 102161.
64.
MaranoA (2023) The definition of waste for the purposes of its possible taxation: The Italian experience between European profiles and possible comparisons. In: ComelliAMilneJEAndersenMSAshiaborH (eds) Taxation and the Green Growth Challenge. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, pp.199–213.
65.
MarcinkowskiAHarężaP (2022) Environmental Impact of the Pretreatment Process of Packaging Waste for Recycling. Stanislaw Staszic Academy of Mining and Metallurgy in Cracow. Cracow: AGH Publishers, p.81 [In Polish].
66.
MarcinkowskiAKowalskiAM (2012) The problem of preparation the food packaging waste for recycling in Poland. Resources Conservation and Recycling69: 10–16.
67.
MarczukAMisztalWJóźwiakowskiK, et al. (2019) The research on effectiveness of the electronic and electrical waste selective collection system in Lublin city, Poland. Archives of Environmental Protection 45(3): 45.
68.
MarekDBaunMDąbrowskiM (2017) The challenge of implementing European Union environmental law in the new member states: The Urban Waste Water Treatment Directive in the Czech Republic and Poland. Environment and Planning C Politics and Space35(6): 1117–1135.
69.
MaYJiangY (2023) Ecosystem-based adaptation to address urbanization and climate change challenges: The case of China’s sponge city initiative. Climate Policy23(2): 268–284.
70.
MekonnenGBTokaiA (2020) A historical perspective of municipal solid waste management and recycling system in Japan: learning for developing countries. Journal of Sustainable Development13(3): 85–101.
NaveenkumarRIyyappanJPravinR, et al. (2023) A strategic review on sustainable approaches in municipal solid waste management and energy recovery: Role of artificial intelligence, economic stability and life cycle assessment. Bioresource Technology421: 129044.
73.
NobusawaY (2023) The policy of plastic waste reduction: A case of Kanagawa zero plastic waste declaration. Japanese Society and Culture5(1): 11.
74.
OforiEKAppiah-OpokuS (2023) Sustainable development goals in BRICS and G7 countries: Increasing accomplishments through policy synergies in four dimensions. Sustainable Development287–306.
75.
OgawaAPandyaswargoAHTsubouchiR, et al. (2023) Demonstration of a contactless waste collection system: A Japanese case study. IET Smart Cities5: 303–316.
76.
OkeAKruijsenJ (2016) The importance of specific recycling information in designing a waste management scheme. Recycling1(2): 271–285.
77.
OleniaczRDrzewieckiWGorzelnikT, et al. (2023) Assessment of the impact of waste fires on air quality and atmospheric aerosol optical depth: A case study in Poland. Energy Reports9: 16–38.
78.
OlivoVEPriettoPDMKorfEP (2023) Current status of municipal solid waste in medium-sized Brazilian cities through integrated management. International Journal of Environment and Waste Management32(2): 152–164.
79.
OngIBLSovacoolBK (2012) A comparative study of littering and waste in Singapore and Japan. Resources Conservation and Recycling61: 35–42.
80.
PetrykAMalinowskiMDziewulskaM, et al. (2019) The impact of the amount of fees for the collection and management of municipal waste on the percentage of selectively collected waste. Journal of Ecological Engineering20(10): 46–53.
81.
PrzydatekG (2020) Assessment of changes in the municipal waste accumulation in Poland. Environmental Science and Pollution Research27(20): 25766–25773.
82.
PrzydatekGKanownikW (2024) Assessment of direction changes in waste electrical and electronic equipment management in Poland. Environmental Science and Pollution Research31(35): 48773–48783.
83.
PuiuS (2021) Recycling initiatives in Romania and reluctance to change. In: VertigansSIdowuSO (eds) Global Challenges to CSR and Sustainable Development: Root Causes and Evidence From Case Studies. Springer, pp.163–187.
84.
RamosARouboaA (2022) Life cycle thinking of plasma gasification as a waste-to-energy tool: Review on environmental, economic and social aspects. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews153: 111762.
85.
RazaliFDaudDWeng-WaiC, et al. (2020) Waste separation at source behaviour among Malaysian households: The theory of planned behaviour with moral norm. Journal of Cleaner Production271: 122025.
86.
RogowskaJZimmermannAMuszyńskaA, et al. (2019) Pharmaceutical household waste practices: Preliminary findings from a case study in Poland. Environmental Management64: 97–106.
87.
SarquahKNarraSBeckG, et al. (2022) Bibliometric analysis; characteristics and trends of refuse derived fuel research. Sustainability14: 1994.
88.
SatoY (2017) Mottainai: A Japanese sense of anima mundi. Journal of Analytical Psychology62(1): 147–154.
89.
SchindlerJ (2021) Packaging consumption and waste management. Between culture and disaster. Cultural Studies Works25(3): 63 [In Polish].
90.
SilvaARosanoMStockerL, et al. (2017) From waste to sustainable materials management: Three case studies of the transition journey. Waste Management61: 547–557.
91.
SinghAKanaujiaASinghVK, et al. (2023) Artificial intelligence for sustainable development goals: Bibliometric patterns and concept evolution trajectories. Sustainable Development32: 724–754.
92.
SirolaNSutinenUMNärvänenE, et al. (2019) Mottainai!—A practice theoretical analysis of Japanese consumers’ food waste reduction. Sustainability11(23): 6645.
93.
SongJFengRYueC, et al. (2022) Reinforced urban waste management for resource, energy and environmental benefits: China’s regional potentials. Resources Conservation and Recycling178: 106083.
94.
SoniADasPKKumarP (2022) A review on the municipal solid waste management status, challenges and potential for the future Indian cities. Environment Development and Sustainability25: 13755–13849.
95.
StępieńM (2019) Selected problems of management of municipal waste segregation and recycling in Poland. Zeszyty Naukowe Politechniki Częstochowskiej Zarządzanie33: 261–270 [In Polish].
96.
SzostakEDudaPDudaA, et al. (2020) Characteristics of plastic waste processing in the modern recycling plant operating in Poland. Energies14(1): 35.
97.
TanakaM (1999) Recent trends in recycling activities and waste management in Japan. Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management1: 10–16.
98.
TanakaM (2007) Waste management for a sustainable society. Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management9: 2–6.
99.
TanakaM (2014) Municipal solid waste management in Japan. In: PariatambyATanakaM (eds) Municipal solid waste management in Asia and the Pacific Islands: Challenges and strategic solutions. Springer Singapore, pp. 157–171.
100.
TriassiMDe SimoneBMontuoriP, et al. (2023) Determination of residual municipal solid waste composition from rural and urban areas: A step toward the optimization of a waste management system for efficient material recovery. Sustainability15(18): 13378.
101.
TsimnadisKKyriakopoulosGL (2024) Investigating the role of municipal waste treatment within the European Union through a novel created common sustainability point system. Recycling9(3): 42.
102.
TuszyńskaL (2017) Environmental education in the perspective of sustainable development. Studies in Global Ethics and Global Education7(7): 43–56 [In Polish].
103.
VaverkovaMMatsuiYVaverkaI (2023) Mottainai in civil engineering-A message from Japan. Acta Scientiarum Polonorum Architectura22: 205–217.
104.
VaverkováMDKodaE (2023) Why landfill deposits are a distinguishing feature of the anthropocene. Anthropocene Review10: 463–473.
105.
VaverkováMDPolakJKurcjuszM, et al. (2024) Enhancing sustainable development through interdisciplinary collaboration: Insights from diverse fields. Sustainable Development1–28.
106.
VelisCAWilsonDCGavishY, et al. (2023) Socio-economic development drives solid waste management performance in cities: A global analysis using machine learning. Science of the Total Environment872: 161913.
107.
WąsowiczKFamielecSChełkowskiM (2018) Municipal Waste Management in Modern Cities. Foundation of the Cracow University of Economics [In Polish].
108.
WąsowiczMDeszczka-TarnowskaM (2015) Rational waste management as an undertaking for national economic security. Journal of Modern Science1(24): 231–247 [In Polish].
109.
WongMH (2022) Integrated sustainable waste management in densely populated cities: The case of Hong Kong. Sustainable Horizons2: 100014.
110.
WongTHFRogersBCBrownRR (2020) Transforming cities through water-sensitive principles and practices. One Earth3(4): 436–447.
111.
WyrzykowskaBHanariNOrlikowskaA, et al. (2009) Dioxin-like compound compositional profiles of furnace bottom ashes from household combustion in Poland and their possible associations with contamination status of agricultural soil and pine needles. Chemosphere76(2): 255–263.
112.
YamadaKIiRYamamotoM, et al. (2023) Japan’s greenhouse gas reduction scenarios toward net zero by 2050 in the material cycles and waste management sector. Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management25: 1807–1817.
113.
YolinC (2015) Waste Management and Recycling in Japan Opportunities for European Companies (SMEs Focus). Tokyo: EU-Japan Center for Industrial Cooperation, pp.30–32.
114.
YuZKhanSARPonceP, et al. (2022) Exploring essential factors to improve waste-to-resource recovery: A roadmap towards sustainability. Journal of Cleaner Production350: 131305.
115.
ZarębskaJLewickaB (2020) Changes in waste packaging management and implementation to achieve a circular economy-Polish case study. Acta Innovations34: 50–57.
116.
ZębekEMZiętyJJ (2022) Effect of landfill arson to a “Lax” system in a circular economy under the current EU energy policy: Perspective review in waste management law. Energies15(22): 8690.
117.
ZhangBLaiKHWangB, et al. (2019) From intention to action: How do personal attitudes, facilities accessibility, and government stimulus matter for household waste sorting?Journal of Environmental Management233: 447–458.
