Previous studies have reported discrepancy effects of education and income on cardiovascular diseases. This systematic review and meta-analysis was therefore conducted which aimed to summarize effects of education and income on cardiovascular diseases.
Methods
Studies were identified from Medline and Scopus until July 2016. Cohorts were eligible if they assessed associations between education/income and cardiovascular diseases, had at least one outcome including coronary artery diseases, cardiovascular events, strokes and cardiovascular deaths. A multivariate meta-analysis was applied to pool risk effects of these social determinants.
Results
Among 72 included cohorts, 39, 19, and 14 were studied in Europe, USA, and Asia. Pooled risk ratios of low and medium versus high education were 1.36 (95% confidence interval: 1.11–1.66) and 1.21 (1.06–1.40) for coronary artery diseases, 1.50 (1.17–1.92) and 1.27 (1.09–1.48) for cardiovascular events, 1.23 (1.06–1.43) and 1.17 (1.01–1.35) for strokes, and 1.39 (1.26–1.54) and 1.21 (1.12–1.30) for cardiovascular deaths. The effects of education on all cardiovascular diseases were still present in US and Europe settings, except in Asia this was present only for cardiovascular deaths. Effects of low and medium income versus high on these corresponding cardiovascular diseases were 1.49 (1.16–1.91) and 1.27 (1.10–1.47) for coronary artery diseases, 1.17 (0.96–1.44) and 1.05 (0.98–1.13) for cardiovascular events, 1.30 (0.99–1.72) and 1.24 (1.00–1.53) for strokes, and 1.76 (1.45–2.14) and 1.34 (1.17–1.54) for cardiovascular deaths.
Conclusion
Social determinants are risk factors of cardiovascular diseases in developed countries, although high heterogeneity in pooling. Data in Asia countries are still needed to update pooling.
Global target 1: A 25% relative reduction in the overall mortality from cardiovascular diseases, cancer, diabetes, or chronic respiratory diseases. In: World Health Organization: Global status report on noncommunicable diseases 2014. 1st ed. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization, 2014, pp.9–22.
2.
KannelWBMcGeeDL. Diabetes and cardiovascular disease: The Framingham study. JAMA1979; 241: 2035–2038.
3.
KeilUKuulasmaaK. WHO MONICA Project: Risk factors. Int J Epidemiol1989; 18: S46–S55.
4.
YusufSHawkenSÔunpuuS. Effect of potentially modifiable risk factors associated with myocardial infarction in 52 countries (the INTERHEART study): Case-control study. Lancet2004; 364: 937–952.
5.
YusufSReddySÔunpuuS. Global burden of cardiovascular diseases part I: General considerations, the epidemiologic transition, risk factors, and impact of urbanization. Circulation2001; 104: 2746–2753.
6.
LangTLepageBSchieberA-C. Social determinants of cardiovascular diseases. Public Health Rev2012; 33: 601–622.
7.
McKee M and Chow CK. The social determinants of cardiovascular disease. In: Yusuf S, Cairns JA, Camm AJ, et al. (eds) Evidence-Based Cardiology. 3rd ed. Wiley, 2011, pp.211–220.
8.
RoseGMarmotM. Social class and coronary heart disease. Br Heart J1981; 45: 13–19.
9.
SmithGDBartleyMBlaneD. The Black report on socioeconomic inequalities in health 10 years on. BMJ1990; 301: 373–373.
10.
MarmotMGStansfeldSPatelC. Health inequalities among British civil servants: The Whitehall II study. Lancet1991; 337: 1387–1393.
11.
JohnsonJLHeinemanEFHeissG. Cardiovascular disease risk factors and mortality among black women and white women aged 40–64 years in Evans County, Georgia. Am J Epidemiol1986; 123: 209–220.
12.
LinCCRogotEJohnsonNJ. A further study of life expectancy by socioeconomic factors in the National Longitudinal Mortality Study. Ethn Dis2002; 13: 240–247.
13.
Nietert PJ, Sutherland SE, Keil JE, et al. Demographic and biologic influences on survival in whites and blacks: 40 Years of follow-up in the Charleston heart study. Int J Equity Health 2006; 5: 8–16.
14.
Beebe-DimmerJLynchJWTurrellG. Childhood and adult socioeconomic conditions and 31-year mortality risk in women. Am J Epidemiol2004; 159: 481–490.
15.
Notara V, Panagiotakos D, Kogias Y, et al. The impact of education status on the 10-year (2004–2014) cardiovascular disease incidence and all cause mortality, among acute coronary syndrome patients: The GREECS longitudinal study. J Prev Med Public Health 2016; 49: 220–229.
16.
Jacobsen BK and Thelle DS. Risk factors for coronary heart disease and level of education. The Tromsø Heart Study. Am J Epidemiol 1988; 127: 923–932.
17.
CireraLTormoM-JChirlaqueM-D. Cardiovascular risk factors and educational attainment in Southern Spain: A study of a random sample of 3091 adults. Eur J Epidemiol1998; 14: 755–763.
18.
MackenbachJPCavelaarsAKunstAE. Socioeconomic inequalities in cardiovascular disease mortality. An international study. Eur Heart J2000; 21: 1141–1151.
19.
AndersenIOslerMPetersenL. Income and risk of ischaemic heart disease in men and women in a Nordic welfare country. Int J Epidemiol2003; 32: 367–374.
20.
SalomaaVNiemeläMMiettinenH. Relationship of socioeconomic status to the incidence and prehospital, 28-day, and 1-year mortality rates of acute coronary events in the FINMONICA myocardial infarction register study. Circulation2000; 101: 1913–1918.
21.
LammintaustaAImmonen-RäihäPAiraksinenJKE. Socioeconomic inequalities in the morbidity and mortality of acute coronary events in Finland: 1988 To 2002. Ann Epidemiol2012; 22: 87–93.
22.
Hosseinpoor AR, Bergen N, Mendis S, et al. Socioeconomic inequality in the prevalence of noncommunicable diseases in low- and middle-income countries: Results from the World Health Survey. BMC Public Health 2012; 12: 474–486.
23.
Manrique-GarciaESidorchukAHallqvistJ. Socioeconomic position and incidence of acute myocardial infarction: A meta-analysis. J Epidemiol Community Health2011; 65: 301–309.
24.
CoxAMMcKevittCRuddAG. Socioeconomic status and stroke. Lancet Neurol2006; 5: 181–188.
25.
MarshallIJWangYCrichtonS. The effects of socioeconomic status on stroke risk and outcomes. Lancet Neurol2015; 14: 1206–1218.
26.
ChenRHuZChenR-L. Socioeconomic deprivation and survival after stroke in China: A systematic literature review and a new population-based cohort study. BMJ Open2015; 5: e005688–e005688.
27.
VathesatogkitPBattyGDWoodwardM. Socioeconomic disadvantage and disease-specific mortality in Asia: Systematic review with meta-analysis of population-based cohort studies. J Epidemiol Community Health2014; 68: 375–383.
28.
KaplanGAKeilJE. Socioeconomic factors and cardiovascular disease: A review of the literature. Circulation1993; 88: 1973–1998.
29.
Khaing W, Vallipakorn SA-O and Thakkinstian A. The effect of education and income on cardiovascular outcomes: A systematic review and meta-analysis. PROSPERO International prospective register of systematic reviews, http://www.crd.york.ac.uk/PROSPERO/display_record.asp?ID=CRD42016046615 (2016, accessed 31 August 2016).
EggerMSmithGDSchneiderM. Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. BMJ1997; 315: 629–634.
34.
PetersJLSuttonAJJonesDR. Contour-enhanced meta-analysis funnel plots help distinguish publication bias from other causes of asymmetry. J Clin Epidemiol2008; 61: 991–996.
35.
StataCorp. Stata Statistical Software: Release 14, College Station, TX: StataCorp LP, 2015.
36.
MoherDLiberatiATetzlaffJ. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. Ann Int Med2009; 151: 264–269.
37.
LeeY-TLinRSSungFC. Chin-Shan Community Cardiovascular Cohort in Taiwan–baseline data and five-year follow-up morbidity and mortality. J Clin Epidemiol2000; 53: 838–846.
38.
SchwarzKAElmanCS. Identification of factors predictive of hospital readmissions for patients with heart failure. Heart Lung2003; 32: 88–99.
39.
SuiXGheorghiadeMZannadF. A propensity matched study of the association of education and outcomes in chronic heart failure. Int J Cardiol2008; 129: 93–99.
40.
ArrichJLalouschekWMüllnerM. Influence of socioeconomic status on mortality after stroke: Retrospective cohort study. Stroke2005; 36: 310–314.
41.
PeterRGässlerHGeyerS. Socioeconomic status, status inconsistency and risk of ischaemic heart disease: A prospective study among members of a statutory health insurance company. J Epidemiol Community Health2007; 61: 605–611.
42.
RouxAVDMerkinSSArnettD. Neighborhood of residence and incidence of coronary heart disease. N Engl J Med2001; 345: 99–106.
43.
ChristensenSMogelvangRHeitmannM. Level of education and risk of heart failure: A prospective cohort study with echocardiography evaluation. Eur Heart J2011; 32: 450–458.
44.
Van MinhHByassPWallS. Mortality from cardiovascular diseases in Bavi District, Vietnam. Scand J Public Health2003; 31: 26–31.
45.
LynchJWKaplanGACohenRD. Do cardiovascular risk factors explain the relation between socioeconomic status, risk of all-cause mortality, cardiovascular mortality, and acute myocardial infarction?Am J Epidemiol1996; 144: 934–942.
46.
NaskaAKatsoulisMTrichopoulosD. The root causes of socioeconomic differentials in cancer and cardiovascular mortality in Greece. Eur J Cancer Prev2012; 21: 490–496.
47.
BostockSSteptoeA. Association between low functional health literacy and mortality in older adults: Longitudinal cohort study. BMJ2012; 344: e1602–e1602.
48.
MeijerAConradiHJBosEH. Prognostic association of depression following myocardial infarction with mortality and cardiovascular events: A meta-analysis of 25 years of research. Gen Hosp Psychiatry2011; 33: 203–216.
49.
NielsenKMFaergemanOFoldspangA. Cardiac rehabilitation: Health characteristics and socio-economic status among those who do not attend. Eur J Public Health2008; 18: 479–483.
50.
LahelmaEMartikainenPLaaksonenM. Pathways between socioeconomic determinants of health. J Epidemiol Community Health2004; 58: 327–332.
51.
Lewis MW, Khodneva Y, Redmond N, et al. The impact of the combination of income and education on the incidence of coronary heart disease in the prospective Reasons for Geographic and Racial Differences in Stroke (REGARDS) cohort study Chronic Disease Epidemiology. BMC Public Health 2015; 15.
52.
BravemanPACubbinCEgerterS. Socioeconomic status in health research: One size does not fit all. JAMA2005; 294: 2879–2888.
53.
AhmedAAZhangYBourgeRC. Abstract 12064: Low income, regardless of education level, is a significant independent predictor of incident heart failure in community-dwelling, Medicare-eligible older adults. Circulation2011; 124: A12064–A.
54.
ShaversVL. Measurement of socioeconomic status in health disparities research. J Natl Med Assoc2007; 99: 1013–1023–1013–1023.
55.
MarmotMRyffCDBumpassLL. Social inequalities in health: Next questions and converging evidence. Soc Sci Med1997; 44: 901–910.
56.
MarmotMGRoseGShipleyM. Employment grade and coronary heart disease in British civil servants. J Epidemiol Community Health1978; 32: 244–249.
57.
AndersenIGamborgMOslerM. Income as mediator of the effect of occupation on the risk of myocardial infarction: Does the income measurement matter?J Epidemiol Community Health2005; 59: 1080–1085.
58.
LuYHajifathalianKRimmEB. Mediators of the effect of body mass index on coronary heart disease: Decomposing direct and indirect effects. Epidemiology2015; 26: 153–162.
59.
MacKinnonDPFairchildAJFritzMS. Mediation analysis. Annu Rev Psychol2007; 58: 593–614–593–614.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
