We respond to the thoughtful commentaries by elaborating on the tensions around rights, the challenges of organizing under rentier capitalism, and the potential for solidarity – or at least temporary alliance – in the context of incommensurabilities. We remain agnostic about the concept of a right to the rural, but convinced of the need to build broad popular movements.
AshwoodLDiamondDWalkerF (2019) Property rights and rural justice: a study of US right-to-farm laws. Journal of Rural Studies67: Elsevier:120–129.
2.
BarracloughL (2025) From rights to relations with the rural: lessons from Indigenous studies. Dialogues in human geography: [Online].
3.
BattistoniA (2025) Free Gifts: Capitalism and the Politics of Nature. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
4.
CaloAShieldsKIlesA (2023) Using property law to expand agroecology: Scotland’s land reforms based on human rights. The Journal of Peasant Studies50(5): 2075–2111.
5.
ChuaC (2025) We can’t wish away the state. Dialogues in Human Geography: [online first]:1–5.
Dunbar-OrtizRA (2016) The relationship between Marxism and indigenous struggles and implications of the theoretical framework for international indigenous struggles. Historical Materialism : Research in Critical Marxist Theory24(3): The Netherlands: Brill:76–91.
8.
FanJ (2025) The characteristics of rural rights in China: the separation of land ownership, land-use rights, and land-use designation rights. Dialogues in human geography: [Online].
9.
Fitz-HenryE (2025) Rights to the rural or reparations for stolen land and labour?Dialogues in human geography: [Online].
10.
HayesKKabaM (2023) How much discomfort is the whole world worth?Boston Review3(27): 183–194.
11.
KelegamaT (2025) The politics of rural access and settler colonialism: Weli Oya and the tensions of a right to the rural. Dialogues in human geography: [Online].
12.
LevienM (2018) Dispossession without Development: Land Grabs in Neoliberal India. New York: Oxford University Press.
13.
McElroyEVergerioM (2022) Automating gentrification: landlord technologies and housing justice organizing in New York city homes. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space40(4): SAGE Publications Sage UK: London, England:607– 626.
14.
PurcellM (2002) Excavating Lefebvre: the right to the city and its urban politics of the inhabitant. GeoJournal58(2/3): Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers:99–108.
15.
RanaA (2024) The Constitutional Bind : How Americans Came to Idolize a Document that Fails Them. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
16.
ShoemakerJA (2024) Re-placing property. U. Chi. L. Rev91: HeinOnline:811.
17.
ShoemakerJATierneyJF (2025) Trading acres. Yale Law Journal135.
18.
Siskyou County Administrator (2005) The Code of the West...The Realities of Rural Living. Siskyou County, CA.
19.
SorgC (2024) You are not a loan: contentious debt politics since the north Atlantic financial crisis. Globalizations21(1): Taylor & Francis:39–55.
20.
TuckEYangKW (2012) Decolonization is not a metaphor. Decolonization: Indigeneity, Education & Society1(1): 1–40.
21.
Van SantLFairbairnM (2025) Towards a right to the rural?Dialogues in human geography.[Online].
