Vegliò et al.'s innovative intervention offers a valuable analytical reframing, illuminating the situated complexities and lived realities of global infrastructure. Building on their multifaceted argument, this response foregrounds the dialectic between urbanization and urbanism to develop a temporal reading of global ‘infrastructure-led urbanization’. I contend that examining the temporal co-constitution of infrastructure and the urban can deepen our understanding of the changing landscapes of global infrastructure, offering new ways to conceptualize progress, endure crisis, and navigate the dynamic infrastructuring of urban futures.
AddieJ-PD (2016) Theorizing suburban infrastructure: A framework for critical and comparative analysis. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers41(3): 273–285.
3.
AddieJ-PDGlassMRNellesJ (2024) Infrastructural Times: Temporality and the Making of Global Urban Worlds. Bristol: Bristol University Press.
4.
AnguelovD (2023) Financializing urban infrastructure? The speculative state-spaces of ‘public-public partnerships’ in Jakarta. Environment and Planning A55(2): 445–470.
5.
BarakO (2013) On Time: Technology and Temporality in Modern Egypt. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
6.
DattaA (2024) Distant time: The future of urbanisation from ‘there’ and ‘then’. Dialogues in Human Geography1–21. https://doi.org/10.1177/20438206241253567.
7.
DattaAHoefslootFI (2024) The state as auteur: Timing digitalisation in Africa’s Silicon Savannah. Dialogues on Digital Society1(1): 51–68.
8.
DiCarloJ (2024) Speed, suspension, stasis: Waiting in the shadow of infrastructure. In: AddieJ-PDGlassMRNellesJ (eds) Infrastructural Times: Temporality and the Making of Global Urban Worlds. Bristol: Bristol University Press, 207–226.
9.
DodsonJ (2017) The global infrastructure turn and urban practice. Urban Policy and Research35(1): 87–92.
10.
EasterlingK (2014) Extrastatecraft: The Power of Infrastructure Space. London: Verso.
11.
EkmanP (2024) Sequencing like a state: Ciudad Guayana and the infrastructures of arrival. In: AddieJ-PDGlassMRNellesJ (eds) Infrastructural Times: Temporality and the Making of Global Urban Worlds. Bristol: Bristol University Press, 119–139.
12.
GlassMRAddieJ-PD (2024) Bridging ‘infrastructural solutions’ and ‘infrastructures as solution’: Regional promises and urban pragmatism. Urban Studies62(9): 1771–1792.
13.
GuptaA (2018) The future in ruins: Thoughts on the temporality of infrastructure. In: AnandNGuptaAAppelH (eds) The Promise of Infrastructure. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 62–79.
14.
LeitnerHSheppardE (2023) Unleashing speculative urbanism: Speculation and urban transformations. Environment and Planning A55(2): 359–366.
15.
LemanskiC (2020) Infrastructural citizenship: The everyday citizenship of adapting and/or destroying public housing in Cape Town, South Africa. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers45(3): 589–605.
16.
MerrifieldA (2002) Dialectical Urbanism: Social Struggles in the Capitalist City. New York: Monthly Review Press.
17.
MossT (2024) Usable infrastructural pasts: Mobilizing history for urban technology futures. In: AddieJ-PDGlassMRNellesJ (eds) Infrastructural Times: Temporality and the Making of Global Urban Worlds. Bristol: Bristol University Press, 49–71.
18.
NowakS (2023) The social lives of network effects: Speculation and risk in Jakarta’s platform economy. Environment and Planning A55(2): 471–489.
19.
SchindlerSKanaiM (2021) Getting the territory right: Infrastructure-led development and the re-emergence of spatial planning strategies. Regional Studies55(1): 40–51.
20.
SchindlerSKanaiMJ (2024) The times of infrastructural fundamentalism: Future profits, slow operations, long-term impacts. In: AddieJ-PDGlassMRNellesJ (eds) Infrastructural Times: Temporality and the Making of Global Urban Worlds. Bristol: Bristol University Press, 140–159.
21.
SimoneA (2025) The untimely. Dialogues on Digital Society1(1): 74–77.
22.
VegliòSSilverJPollioA, et al. (2025) A dialogue on global infrastructure-led urbanization: Concepts and reorientations. Dialogues in Human Geography1–21. https://doi.org/10.1177/20438206251321093.
23.
WiigASilverJ (2019) Turbulent presents, precarious futures: Urbanization and the deployment of global infrastructure. Regional Studies53(6): 912–923.
