While Africans are committed to democracy, governments across the continent have failed to deliver on the democratic aspirations of the populace, with declinatory outcomes for satisfaction with democracy (SWD) over the past decade. A number of reliable variables (e.g., economics, political participation, democratic performance) have been used over the past 50 years to study trends in SWD worldwide. Yet the integrity of information ecosystems, including misinformation and censorship levels have not been fully explored as predictors of SWD. As concerns about the social web’s diffusion of misinformation have culminated in policy considerations worldwide, we focused on the African continent, where the current global push for government action to curb the misinformation tide could facilitate backsliding into authoritarian practices. Using a data set of 40,801 respondents from 34 African countries, we found that social media news use and perceptions about the circulation of misinformation impacted SWD and that citizen attitudes about government censorship of misinformation have a moderating influence on SWD.
Afrobarometer. 2023. “Declining satisfaction threatens African democracy, afrobarometer CEO reveals.”https://shorturl.at/aB569.
4.
AkbogaS.SahinO.. 2021. “Satisfaction with Democracy in Turkey: Findings from a National Survey.”Politics41(2):207–223.
5.
AndersonC.GuilloryC.. 1997. “Political Institutions and Satisfaction with Democracy: A Cross-National Analysis of Consensus and Majoritarian Systems.”American Political Science Review91(1):66–81.
6.
BailardC. S.2012. “Testing the Internet’s Effect on Democratic Satisfaction:AMulti-Methodological, Cross-National Approach.”Journal of Information Technology & Politics9(2):185–204.
7.
Bajomi-LázárP.2014. Party Colonization of the Media in Central and Eastern Europe. Budapest: Central European University Press.
8.
BaviskarS.MaloneM.. 2004. “What Democracy Means to Citizens—And Why it Matters.”European Review of Latin American and Caribbean Studies76:3–23.
9.
BedockC.2017. Reforming Democracy: Institutional Engineering in Western Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
10.
BhatiaV.ElhusseinM.KreimerB.SnappT.. 2023. “Protests, Internet Shutdowns, and Disinformation in a Transitioning State.”Media, Culture & Society45(6):1101–1118.
11.
BolD.BlaisA.GillardX.LopezL.PiletJ.-B.. 2018. “Voting and Satisfaction with Democracy in Flexible-List PR.”Electoral Studies56:23–34.
12.
BoydD.2017. “Did Media Literacy Backfire?”Journal of Applied Youth Studies1(4):83–88.
13.
BroderstadT.2023. “An Empirical Evaluation of Explanations for Political System Support.”Political Research Quarterly76(3):1542–1554.
14.
CameronS.2020. “Government Performance and Dissatisfaction with Democracy in Australia.”Australian Journal of Political Science55(2):170–190.
15.
CampbellR.2018. “Persistence and Renewal: The German Left Party’s Journey from Outcast to Opposition.”Contemporary Politics24(2):153–172.
16.
CanacheD.MondakJ.SeligsonM.. 2001. “Meaning and Measurement in Cross-National Research on Satisfaction with Democracy.”Public Opinion Quarterly65(4):506–528.
17.
CeronA.CuriniL.IacusS.. 2014. Social Media e Sentiment Analysis: L’evoluzione dei Fenomeni Sociali Attraverso la Rete. New York: Springer.
18.
CeronA.MemoliV.. 2016. “Flames and Debates: Do Social Media Affect Satisfaction with Democracy?”Social Indicators Research16(1):225–240.
19.
ChanM.YiJ.. 2024. “Social Media Use and Political Engagement in Polarized Times. Examining the Contextual Roles of Issue and Affective Polarization in Developed Democracies.”Political Communication41(5):743–762.
20.
ChangW.-C.2018. “Media Use and Satisfaction with Democracy: Testing the Role of Political Interest.”Social Indicators Research140(3):999–1016.
21.
CheesemanN.2015. Democracy in Africa: Successes, Failures, and the Struggle for Political Reform. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
22.
ChristmannP.2018. “Economic Performance, Quality of Democracy, and Satisfaction with Democracy.”Electoral Studies53:79–89.
23.
ChristmannP.TorcalM.. 2018. “The Effects of Government System Fractionalization on Satisfaction with Democracy.”Political Science Research and Methods6(3):593–611.
24.
ClaassenC.MagalhãesP.. 2022. “Effective Government and Evaluations of Democracy.”Comparative Political Studies55(5):869–894.
25.
CorderoG.SimónP.. 2016. “Economic Crisis and Support for Democracy in Europe.”West European Politics39(2):305–325.
26.
CutlerF.NuesserA.NybladeB.. 2023. “Satisfaction with Democracy: The Impact of Institutions, Contexts and Attitudes.”Canadian Journal of Political Science56(1):1–25.
27.
DaoustJ.-F.NadeauR.. 2021. “Context Matters: Economics, Politics, and Satisfaction with Democracy.”Electoral Studies74(1):102–133.
28.
DaoustJ.-F.NadeauR.. 2023. Elections and Satisfaction with Democracy: Citizens, Processes and Outcomes. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
29.
DiamondL.PlattnerM., eds. 2008. How People View Democracy. Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press.
30.
DweyerM.MolonyT.. 2019. “Mapping the Study of Politics and Social Media Use in Africa.” In Social Media and Politics in Africa: Democracy, Censorship and Security, eds. DweyerM.MolonyT., 1–18. Zed Books.
31.
EastonD.1975. “A Re-Assessment of the Concept of Political Support.”British Journal of Political Science5(4):435–457.
32.
EckerU.RoozenbeekJ.van der LindenS.Qian TayL.CookJ.OreskesN.LewandowskyS.. 2024. “Misinformation Poses a Bigger Threat to Democracy than You Might Think.”https://shorturl.at/uMi0G.
33.
Economist Intelligence Unit. 2022. Democracy Index 2021: The China Challenge. London: Economist Intelligence.
ErgunS.RivasF. M.RossiM.. 2019. “Satisfaction with Democracy in Latin America: Do the Characteristics of the Political System Matter?”Desarrollo y Sociedad83(1):353–383.
36.
EzrowL.XezonakisG.. 2016. “Satisfaction with Democracy and Voter Turnout: A Temporal Perspective.”Party Politics22(1):3–14.
37.
FerrinM.2016. “An Empirical Assessment of Satisfaction with Democracy.” In How Europeans View and Evaluate Democracy, eds. FerrinM.KriesiH., 283–306. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
38.
FombadC.2022. “Democracy and Fake News in Africa.”Journal of International and Comparative Law9(1):131–154.
39.
Fortin-RittbergerJ.HarfstP.DinglerS.. 2017. “The Costs of Electoral Fraud: Establishing the Link Between Electoral Integrity, Winning an Election, and Satisfaction with Democracy.”Journal of Elections, Public Opinion and Parties27(3):350–368
40.
Freedom House. 2023. Freedom in the World: Marking 50 Years in the Struggle for Democracy. Washington DC: Freedom House.
41.
FreilingI.StubenvollM.MatthesJ.. 2023. “Support for Misinformation Regulation on Social Media: It is the Perceived Harm of Misinformation that Matters, Not the Perceived Amount.”Policy & Internet15(4):731–749.
GarnettH.2019. “On the Front Lines of Democracy: Perceptions of Electoral Officials and Democratic Elections.”Democratization26(8):1399–1418.
44.
GoidelK.GaddieK.EhrlM.. 2017. “Watching the News and Support for Democracy: Why Media Systems Matter.”Social Science Quarterly98(3):836–855.
45.
González SantosM.Martínez-MartínezO.. 2020. “Dissatisfaction with Democracy in Latin America: Analysis of Economic and Political Factors in 2017.”Universitas32:149–166.
46.
GrabeM.BucyE.. 2023. “Towards Diagnostics and Mitigation of Polluted Information Ecosystems: Historical and Philosophical Considerations.”Problemi dell’informazione, Rivista quadrimestrale1:136–158.
47.
GrabeM.MyrickJ.. 2016. “Informed Citizenship in a Media-Centric Way of Life.”Journal of Communication66(2):215–235.
48.
GrahamC.SukhtankarS.. 2004. “Does the Economic Crisis Reduce Support for Markets and Democracy in Latin America? Some Evidence from Surveys of Public Opinion and Well-being.”Journal of Latin American Studies36(2):349–377.
49.
GuldbrandtsenM.SkaaningS.-E.. 2010. “Satisfaction with Democracy in Sub-Saharan Africa: Assessing the Effects of System Performance.”African Journal of Political Science & International Relations4(5):164–172.
50.
HayesA.2015. “An Index and Test of Linear Moderated Mediation.”Multivariate Behavioral Research50(1):1–22.
51.
HayesA.RockwoodN.. 2020. “Conditional Process Analysis: Concepts, Computation, and Advances in the Modeling of the Contingencies of Mechanisms.”American Behavioral Scientist64(1):19–54.
52.
HeyneL.2019. “Democratic Demand and Supply: A Spatial Model Approach to Satisfaction with Democracy.”Journal of Elections, Public Opinion and Parties29(3):381–401.
53.
HigashijimaM.KerrN.. 2023. “When Does the Honeymoon End? Electoral Cycles of Satisfaction with Democracy in Africa.”Political Psychology44(4):709–728.
54.
HongS.2020. “Presumed Effects of ‘Fake News’ on the Global Warming Discussion in a Cross-Cultural Context.”Sustainability12(5):2123–2133.
55.
HumprechtE.2023. “The Role of Trust and Attitudes toward Democracy in the Dissemination of Disinformation: A Comparative Analysis of Six Democracies.”Digital Journalism.Published online May 10. doi:10.1080/21670811.2023.2200196.
56.
HunterL.2023. “Social Media, Disinformation, and Democracy: How Different Types of Social Media Usage Affect Democracy Cross-Nationally.”Democratization30(6):1040–1072.
International IDEA. 2022. The Global Report of Democracy 2022: Forging Social Contracts in a Time of Discontent. International IDEA.
59.
JangS. M.KimJ.. 2018. “Third Person Effects of Fake News: Fake News Regulation and Media Literacy Interventions.”Computers in Human Behavior80:295–302.
60.
Kestilä-KekkonenE.SöderlundP.. 2017. “Is it all About the Economy? Government Fractionalization, Economic Performance, and Satisfaction with Democracy across Europe, 2002–13.”Government and Opposition52(1):100–130.
61.
KnuutilaA.NeudertL.-M.HowardP.. 2022. “Who is Afraid of Fake News? Modeling Risk Perceptions of Misinformation in 142 Countries.”Harvard Kennedy School Misinformation Review3(3):1–13.
62.
KostelkaF.BlaisA.. 2018. “The Chicken and Egg Question: Satisfaction with Democracy and Voter Turnout.”Political Science & Politics51(2):370–376.
63.
KostelkaF.RovnyJ.. 2019. “It’s Not the Left: Ideology and Protest Participation in Old and New Democracies.”Comparative Political Studies52(11):1677–1712.
64.
KozyrevaA.HerzogS.LewandowskyS.HertwigR.Lorenz-SpreenP.LeiserM.ReiflerJ.. 2023. “Resolving Content Moderation Dilemmas between Free Speech and Harmful Misinformation.”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences120(7): e2210666120.
65.
KperogiF.2023. “Introduction: The Gatekeeper State Meets Digital Citizen Panoptic Gaze.” In Digital Dissidence and Social Media Censorship in Africa, ed. KperogiF., 1–18. London: Routledge.
66.
Lorenz-SpreenP.OswaldL.LewandowskyS.HertwigR.. 2023. “A Systematic Review of Worldwide Causal and Correlational Evidence on Digital Media and Democracy.”Nature Human Behavior7(1):74–101.
67.
LuZ.JiangY.LuC.NaamanN.WigdorD.. 2020. “The Government’s Dividend: Complex Perceptions of Social Media Misinformation in China.” In Proceedings of the 2020 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, 1–12. New York.
68.
LuZ.JiangY.ShenC.JackM. C.WigdorD.NaamanN.. 2021. “‘Positive Energy’ Perceptions and Attitudes Towards COVID-19 Information on Social Media in China.”Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction5(CSCW1):1–25.
69.
LundmarkS.OscarssonH.WeissenbilderM.. 2020. “Confidence in an Election Authority and Satisfaction with Democracy: Evidence from a Quasi-Natural Experiment of a Failed Election in Sweden.”Electoral Studies67(3):102216.
70.
MamdaniM.1996. Citizen and Subject: Contemporary Africa and the Legacy of Late Colonialism. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
71.
MareA.MabweazaraH.MoyoD.. 2019. “‘Fake News’ and Cyber-Propaganda in Sub-Saharan Africa: Recentering the Research Agenda.”African Journalism Studies40(4):1–12.
72.
MarienS.KernA.. 2016. “The Winner Takes It All: Revisiting the Effect of Direct Democracy on Citizens’ Political Support.”Political Behavior40(4):857–882.
73.
MartinJ.HassanF.. 2022. “Testing Classical Predictors of Public Willingness to Censor on the Desire to Block Fake News Online.”Convergence28(3):867–887.
74.
MaxonR.1992. “The Colonial Roots.” In Politics and Administration in East Africa, edited by OyugiW., 33–70. Nairobi: Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung.
75.
MudavadiK. C.MatanjiF.DiopL.TullyM.Madrid-MoralesD.. 2024. “Stakeholder Perceptions of Regulatory Responses to Misinformation in Kenya and Senegal.”Journalism. Published online May 23. doi:10.1177/14648849241255935.
76.
MunoriyarwaA.2023. “Mapping Social Media Hate Speech Regulations in Southern Africa: A Regional Comparative Analysis.” In Hate Speech on Social Media: A Global Approach, edited by BrancoF., 203–226. LabCom Books & EdiPUC.
77.
MutsvairoB.BebawiS.. 2019. “Journalism Educators, Regulatory Realities, and Pedagogical Predicaments of the ‘Fake News’ Era: A Comparative Perspective on the Middle East and Africa.”Journalism & Mass Communication Educator74(2):143–157.
78.
NakaayiF.2023. “Case Studies on Anti-Social Media Laws in African Countries.” In Digital Dissidence and Social Media Censorship in Africa, edited by KperogiF., 242–266. London: Routledge.
79.
NisbetE.MortensonC.LiQ.. 2021. “The Presumed Influence of Election Misinformation on Others Reduces Our Own Satisfaction with Democracy.”The Harvard Kennedy School Misinformation Review1(SI):1–16.
80.
NorrisP.1999. Critical Citizens: Global Support for Democratic Government. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
81.
NorrisP.2013. “The New Research Agenda Studying Electoral Integrity.”Election Studies34(4):563–575.
82.
OyugiW.2003. “The Politics of Transition in Kenya, 1992–2003: Democratic Consolidation or Deconsolidation?” In The Politics of Transition in Kenya: From KANU to NARC, eds. OyugiW.WanyandeP.Odhiambo-MbaiC., 345–381. Nairobi: Heinrich Böll Foundation.
83.
PabloC.MarianoT.. 2017. “The Political and Economic Causes of Satisfaction with Democracy in Spain–A Twofold Panel Study.”West European Politics40(6):1241–1266.
84.
PlacekM.2024. “Social Media, Quality of Democracy, and Citizen Satisfaction with Democracy in Central and Eastern Europe.”Journal of Information Technology & Politics21(1):6–22.
85.
QuarantaM.MartiniS.. 2016. “Does the Economy Really Matter for Satisfaction with Democracy? Longitudinal and Cross-Country Evidence from the European Union.”Electoral Studies42(1):164–174.
86.
RamiroL.2016. “Support for Radical Left Parties in Western Europe: Social Background, Ideology, and Political Orientations.”European Political Science Review8(1):1–23.
87.
Reporters without Borders. 2022. World Press Freedom Index: A New Era of Polarization. London: Reporters without Borders.
88.
RichT.2015. “Losers’ Consent or Non-Voter Consent? Satisfaction with Democracy in East Asia.”Asian Journal of Political Science23(3):243–259.
89.
ShomerY.PutG.-J.Gedalya-LavyE.. 2016. “Intra-Party Politics and Public Opinion: How Candidate Selection Processes Affect Citizens’ Satisfaction with Democracy.”Political Behavior38(3):509–534.
90.
SinghS.2016. “Compulsory Voting and Dissatisfaction with Democracy.”British Journal of Political Science48(3):843–854.
91.
SinghS.MayneQ.. 2023. “Satisfaction with Democracy: A Review of a Major Public Opinion Indicator.”Public Opinion Quarterly87(1):187–218.
92.
StoycheffE.2020. “Relatively Democratic: How Perceived Internet Interference Shapes Attitudes about Democracy.”The International Journal of Press/Politics25(3):390–406.
93.
StoycheffE.BurgessS.MartucciM.. 2020. “Online Censorship and Digital Surveillance: The Relationship between Suppression Technologies and Democratization across Countries.”Information, Communication & Society23(4):474–490.
94.
TsfatiY.BoomgaardenH.StrömbäckJ.VliegenthartR.DamstraA.LindgrenE.. 2020. “Causes and Consequences of Mainstream Media Dissemination of Fake News: Literature Review and Synthesis.”Annals of the International Communication Association44(2):157–173.
95.
TullyM.Madrid-MoralesD.WassermanH.GondweG.IreriK.. 2021. “Who is Responsible for Stopping the Spread of Misinformation? Examining Audience Perceptions of Responsibilities and Responses in Six Sub-Saharan African Countries.”Digital Journalism10(2):1–19.
96.
VlachovaK.2019. “Lost in Transition, Found in Recession? Satisfaction with Democracy in Central Europe Before and After Economic Crises.”Communist and Post-Communist Studies52(3):227–234.
WassermanH.2020. “Fake News from Africa: Panics, Politics and Paradigms.”Journalism21(1):3–16.
99.
WeßelsB.2015. “Political Culture, Political Satisfaction, and the Rollback of Democracy.”Global Policy 6(S1):93–105.
100.
WikeR.CastilloA.. 2018. Many Around the World Are Disengaged from Politics. Pew Research Center 17. https://shorturl.at/ajAUZ.
101.
WongS.LiangJ.. 2021. “Dubious until Officially Censored: Effects of Online Censorship Exposure on Viewers’ Attitudes in Authoritarian Regimes.”Journal of Information Technology & Politics18(3):310–323.
102.
ZasloveA.GeurkinkB.JacobsK.AkkermanA.. 2021. “Power to the People? Populism, Democracy, and Political Participation: A Citizen’s Perspective.”West European Politics44(4):727–751.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
