Why do some newspapers remain critical in contexts of antipress repression while others do not? It has been argued that aggressions against journalists generate a deterrence effect on the watchdog role of the press. However, evidence of the press remaining critical in hostile environments appears to defy this claim. In this paper, I explore the relationship between violent government repression and the critical function of the press. Using an original data set of local Mexican newspapers from 2011 to 2013, I examine the direct effects of violence on front-page headlines. I find that while repression does deter critical coverage, the ultimate effect is contingent upon the configuration of strategic press allies in the locality, reviewed here as nongovernmental organizations, opposition parties, and newspaper publishers.
AdseráAliciaBoixCarlesPayneMark. 2003. “Are You Being Served? Political Accountability and Quality of Government.” Journal of Law, Economics & Organization19 (2): 445–90.
2.
Article 19. 2015. Estado de Censura [State of Censorship]. Mexico City: Article XIX.
3.
Article 19. 2018. Democracia simulada. Nada que aplaudir [Simulated Democracy. Nothing to Applaud]. Mexico City: Article XIX.
4.
BartmanJos Midas. 2018. “Murder in Mexico: Are Journalists Victims of General Violence or Targeted Political Violence?”Democratization25:1093–1113. doi:10.1080/13510347.2018.1445998.
5.
BoasTaylor. 2012. “Mass Media and Politics in Latin America.” In Constructing Democratic Governance in Latin America, ed. DomínguezJorgeShifterMichael, 48–77. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
6.
BrambilaJulieta A.Lugo OcandoJairo. 2018. “Lobbying for Life: Violence against the Press and the Public Interest.” In Public Interest Communication: Critical Debates and Global Contexts, ed. JohnstonJanePieczkaMagda, 192-209. London: Routledge.
7.
BrunettiAymoWederBeatrice. 2003. “A Free Press Is Bad News for Corruption.” Journal of Public Economics87:1801–24.
ChalabyJean. 2000. “New Media, New Freedoms, New Threats.” International Communication Gazette62 (1): 19–29.
10.
Conaculta, Consejo Nacional para la Cultura y las Artes. 2010. “Encuesta Nacional de Hábitos, Prácticas y Consumo Cultural” [National Survey on Cultural Practices and Consumption]. http://www.cultura.gob.mx/encuesta_nacional/#.WvHo8i_cf6o.
11.
Committee to Protect Journalists. 2012. Attacks on the Press in 2011. Nueva York: Committee to Protect Journalists.
12.
CruzGerardo. 2016. “Libertad de Expresión En México: Principios Dogmáticos y Realidad” [Freedom of Expression in Mexico. Dogmatic Principles and Reality]. Pluralidad y Consenso6 (29): 32–45.
13.
CurranJames. 1981. “Advertising as a Patronage System.” The Sociological Review29 (S1): 71–120.
14.
DavenportChristian. 2007. “State Repression and Political Order.” Annual Review of Political Science10:1–23.
15.
De JaegherKrisHoyerBritta. 2019. “Preemptive Repression: Deterrence, Backfiring, Iron Fists, and Velvet Gloves.” Journal of Conflict Resolution63 (2): 502–27.
16.
Del PalacioCelia. 2015. “En Veracruz Se Aprende a Vivir Con Miedo” [In Veracruz You Learn to Live with Fear]. In Violencia y periodismo regional en México [Veracruz You Learn to Live with Fear. In Violence and Regional Journalism in Mexico], ed. Del PalacioCelia, 405-52. Mexico City: Juan Pablos.
17.
Di TellaRafaelFranceschelliIgnacio. 2010. “Government Advertising and Media Coverage of Corruption Scandals.” NBER Working Paper No 15402. https://www.nber.org/papers/w15402.
18.
FentonNatalie. 2014. “Journalism and Democracy: Towards a Contemporary Research Strategy in Mexico.” Goldsmiths, University of London.
19.
FigueroaPatricia. 2017. Ética en tiempos de guerra y narcotráfico. Relación entre policías –periodistas [Ethics in the time of war and drug-trafficking. The relationship between police officers and journalists]. Mexico City: Ediciones Del Lirio.
20.
FloresRogelioReyesVerónicaReidlLucy María. 2012. “Síntomas de Estrés Postraumático (EPT) En Periodistas Mexicanos Que Cubren La Guerra Contra El Narcotráfico.” [“Post Traumatic Stress Symptoms in Mexican Journalists Covering the Drug War”] Suma Psicológica19 (1): 7–17.
Fundar. 2015. Libertad de Expresión En Venta. Acceso a La Información y Censura Indirecta En Publicidad Oficial. [Freedom of Expression On Sale. Access to Information and Indirect Censorship in Governmental Advertising] Mexico City: Article 19-Fundar.
23.
GartnerScottReganPatrick. 1996. “Threat and Repression: The Non-linear Relationship between Government and Opposition Violence.” Journal of Peace Research33 (3): 273–87.
24.
GibsonEdward. 2012. Boundary Control: Subnational Authoritarianism in Federal Democracies. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
25.
GiraudyAgustina. 2010. “The Politics of Subnational Undemocratic Regime Reproduction in Argentina and Mexico.” Journal of Politics in Latin America2 (2): 53–84.
26.
GoldsteinRobert Justin. 1978. Political Repression in Modern America: From 1870 to the Present. Cambridge: Schenkman.
27.
GonzálezRubénReynaVíctor. 2019. “‘They Don’t Trust Us; They Don’t Care if We’re Attacked’: Trust and Risk Perception in Mexican Journalism.” Communication & Society32 (1): 147–60.
28.
GuerreroManuel. 2009. The Emergence of Political Pluralism in Mexican Broadcasting: Economics over Politics. Saarbrücken: VDM Publishing.
29.
HallinDanielPapathanassopoulosStylianos. 2002. “Political Clientelism and the Media: Southern Europe and Latin America in Comparative Perspective.” Media, Culture & Society24 (2): 175–95.
30.
HanitzschThomas. 2011. “Populist Disseminators, Detached Watchdogs, Critical Change Agents and Opportunist Facilitators: Professional Milieus, the Journalistic Field and Autonomy in 18 Countries.” International Communication Gazette73 (6): 477–94. doi:10.1177/1748048511412279.
31.
HelmkeGretchenStatonJeffrey. 2011. “The Puzzling Judicial Politics of Latin America: A Theory of Litigation, Judicial Decisions and Interbranch Conflict.” In Courts in Latin America, ed. HelmkeGretchenRíos-FigueroaJulio, 306–31. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
32.
HernándezMaría Elena. 2010. “Franquicias Periodísticas y Sinergias Productivas En La Prensa Mexicana: En Busca de Nuevos Modelos de Financiamiento” [Journalistic Franchises and Productive Sinergies in Mexican Press: Searching for New Financing Models]. In Estudios Sobre Periodismo. Marcos de Interpretación Para El Contexto Mexicano [Studies on Journalism. Interpretation Framewoks for Mexican Context], ed. HernándezMaría Elena, 55-122. Guadalajara: Universidad de Guadalajara.
33.
HollandBradleyRíosViridiana. 2017. “Informally Governing Information: How Criminal Rivalry Leads to Violence against the Press in Mexico”. Journal of Conflict Resolution61(5): 1095-1119.
34.
HughesSallie. 2003. “From the Inside Out: How Institutional Entrepreneurs Transformed Mexican Journalism.” The International Journal of Press/Politics8 (3): 87–117.
35.
HughesSallieGarcésMiguelMárquezMireyaArroyaveJesús. 2016. “Rethinking Professional Autonomy: Autonomy to Develop and to Publish News in Mexico and Colombia.” Journalism18 (8): 1–21. doi:10.1177/1464884916659409.
36.
HughesSallieMárquezMireya. 2017a. “Examining the Practices that Mexican Journalists Employ to Reduce Risk in a Context of Violence.” International Journal of Communication11:499–521.
37.
HughesSallieMárquezMireya. 2017b. “How Unsafe Contexts and Overlapping Risks Influence Journalism Practice. Evidence from a Survey of Mexican Journalists.” In The Assault on Journalism. Building Knowledge to Protect Freedom of Expression, ed. CarlssonUlaPöyhtäriReeta, 303–15. Göteborg: Nordicom-University of Gothenburg.
38.
HughesSallieMárquezMireya. 2018. “Local-Level Authoritarianism, Democratic Normative Aspirations, and Antipress Harassment: Predictors of Threats to Journalists in Mexico.” The International Journal of Press/politics23 (4): 539–60. doi:10.1177/1940161218786041.
39.
HughesSallieMelladoClaudiaArroyaveJesúsBenitezJosé Luisde BeerArnoldGarcésMiguelLangKatharinaMárquez-RamírezMireya. 2017. “Expanding Influences Research to Insecure Democracies.” Journalism Studies18 (5): 645–55.
LaaksoMarkkuTaageperaRein. 1979. “‘Effective’ Number of Parties: A Measure with Application to West Europe.” Comparative Political Studies12:3–27.
42.
LawsonChappell. 2002. Building the Fourth Estate: Democratization and the Rise of a Free Press in Mexico. Los Angeles: University of California Press.
43.
MárquezMireya. 2015. “El Impacto de La Violencia Criminal En La Cultura Periodística Posautoritaria: La Vulnerabilidad Del Periodismo Regional En México” [The Impact of Criminal Violence on Post-Authoritarian Journalistic Culture. The Vulerability of Regional Journalism in Mexico]. In Violencia y Periodismo Regional En México [Violence and Regional Journalism in Mexico], ed. Del PalacioCelia. Ciudad de México: Juan Pablos.
MoustafaTamir. 2008. “Law and Resistance in Authoritarian States: The Judicialization of Politics in Egypt.” In The Politics of Courts in Authoritarian Regimes, ed. GinsburgTomMoustafaTamir, 132–55. Nueva York: Cambridge University Press.
47.
PaletzDavid L.EntmanRobert. 1980. “Presidents, Power and the Press.” Presidential Studies Quarterly10 (3): 416–26.
48.
PhillipsBrian. 2015. “How Does Leadership Decapitation Affect Violence? The Case of Drug Trafficking Organizations in Mexico.” The Journal of Politics77 (2): 324–36.
49.
RellyJeannine E.de BustamanteCeleste González. 2014. “Silencing Mexico: A Study of Influences on Journalists in the Northern States.” The International Journal of Press/Politics19 (1): 108–31. doi:10.1177/1940161213509285.
50.
RellyJeannine E.de BustamanteCeleste González. 2017. “Global and Domestic Networks Advancing Prospects for Institutional and Social Change: The Collective Action Response to Violence against Journalists.” Journalism & Communication Monographs19 (2): 84–152. doi:10.1177/1522637917702618.
51.
RepnikovaMaria. 2018. “Contesting the State under Authoritarianism: Critical Journalists in China and Russia.” Comparative Politics51 (1): 41–60.
52.
RiffeDanielAustCharlesLacyStephen. 1993. “The Effectiveness of Random, Consecutive Day and Constructed Week Samples in Newspaper Content Analysis.” Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly70 (1): 133–39.
53.
RiffeDanielFicoFrederickLacyStephen. 2005. Analyzing Media Messages: Using Quantitative Content Analysis in Research. Mahwah: Lawrence Erlbaum.
54.
Riva-PalacioRaymundo. 1997. “A Culture of Collusion: The Ties that Bind the Press and the PRI.” In A Culture of Collusion: An Inside Look at the Mexican Press, ed. OrmeWilliam A., 21–32. Miami: North South Center Press-Lynne Rienner.
55.
SalazarGrisel. 2018. “¿Cuarto Poder? Mercados, Audiencias y Contenidos En La Prensa Estatal Mexicana” [Fourth Estate? Markets, Audiences and Contents in Mexican Regional Press]. Política y Gobierno25 (1): 125–52.
56.
SchedlerAndreas. 2013. The Politics of Uncertainty: Sustaining and Subverting Electoral Authoritarianism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
57.
SeguraMaría SoledadWaisbordSilvio. 2016. Media Movements: Civil Society and Media Policy Reform in Latin America. London: Zed Books.
58.
ShoemakerPamelaReeseStephen. 2013. Mediating the Message in the 21st Century: A Media Sociology Perspective. New York: Routledge.
59.
SingerLeticia. 1993. Mordaza de Papel [Paper Gag]. México, D.F.: El Caballito.
60.
SmulovitzCatalinaPeruzzottiEnrique. 2000. “Societal Accountability in Latin America.” Journal of Democracy11 (4): 147–58.
61.
SteinElizabeth. 2013. “The Unraveling of Support for Authoritarianism: The Dynamic of Media, Elites and Public Opinion in Brazil, 1972–82.” The International Journal of Press/Politics18 (1): 85–107.
62.
VanbergGeorg. 2005. The Politics of Constitutional Review in Germany. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
63.
VonDoeppPeterYoungDaniel J.2012. “Assaults on the Fourth Estate: Explaining Media Harassment in Africa.” The Journal of Politics75 (1): 36–51.
64.
Von HoldtKarl. 2014. “On Violent Democracy.” The Sociological Review62 (S2): 129–51.
65.
WaisbordSilvio. 2002. “Antipress Violence and the Crisis of the State.” The International Journal of Press/Politics7 (3): 90–109.
66.
WaisbordSilvio. 2007. “Democratic Journalism and ‘Statelessness.’”Political Communication24 (2): 115–29. doi:10.1080/10584600701312837.
WaisbordSilvio. 2015. “Watchdog Journalism.” In The International Encyclopedia of Political Communication, ed. MazzoleniGianpietro, 1-5. Hoboken: John Willey & Sons.
69.
World Association of Newspapers and News Publishers. 2014. Comprando Complacencia: Publicidad Oficial y Censura Indirecta En México [Buying Compliance: Governmental Advertising and Indirect Censorship in Mexico]. New York: Proceso.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
