This article discusses changes to what were seen by government planners as “out-dated” British and American propaganda systems following 9/11 and the Iraq War. It presents qualitative research examining how government propaganda strategies responded to global asymmetric threats in a post-9/11 media environment. The article draws on both documentary evidence and the accounts of elite sources from Britain and the United States including Public Relations professionals, journalists, and foreign policy, defense, and intelligence personnel. Recently, the intelligence contractor Edward Snowden revealed the extent to which the speed of adaptation in surveillance practices has left policy and oversight behind, raising concern over ethics, privacy, and transparency. The article will explore an adaptation of propaganda systems that also occurred unhindered by public debate. It will show how U.S. and U.K. Governments believed existing propaganda systems were not responding to the information environment and discusses legal, structural, and cultural issues in propaganda practices, post-9/11. Planners assisted in gradually changing structures and cultures of propaganda in both countries for reasons of operational effectiveness. The Anglo-American relationship will be highlighted as one tool capable of overcoming obstacles or restrictions in propaganda for purposes of counterterrorism. Interviews indicated that this was enabled by the countries’ different capabilities and weak legislative restrictions, which some highlighted as advantageous to planning. The article will consider the resilience of U.S./U.K. restrictions and governance of propaganda, highlighting areas for concern.
Anonymous. 2013a. Senior State Department Official, E-mail.
2.
Anonymous. 2013b. UK Official. Interview.
3.
ArmitageRichard. 2009. Former Deputy Secretary of State, Department of State. Interview, July21. Washington, D.C.
4.
ArmstrongMatt. 2013. US Chairman of the US Broadcasting Board of Governors, Former Executive Director of the Advisory Commission on Public Diplomacy (March 2011-December 2011). Telephone Interview, March6.
5.
ArundellRalph. 2013. UK Assistant Head Defense Media and Communications Operations Plans and former Assistant Director—Targeting and Information Operations, MoD, Interview, April18. London.
6.
BacevichAndrew. 2006. The New American Militarism: How Americans Are Seduced by War. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
FitzpatrickSean, K.2009. Former Executive Vice President and Vice Chair of the Board of McCann-Erickson World Group, Creative Director—National Center For Unconventional Thought at Potomac Institute for Policy Studies. Interview, June30. Williamsburg, VA.
18.
FrenchDavid. 2012. The British Way in Counterinsurgency 1945-1967. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
HoughtonKate. 1996. “Subverting Journalism: Reporters and the CIA.” In Committee to Protect Journalists SPECIAL REPORT: The United States Subverting Journalism. http://www.cpj.org/attacks96/sreports/cia.html.
McBrideDennis. 2009. Director—Potomac Institute for Policy Studies, and former Naval Captain, Interview, June5. Washington, D.C.
39.
McCartyKevin. 2013. US Former National Security Council Director for Global Outreach, Former U.S. Naval Officer, Intelligence Officer NSC and Currently Commercial Communications Consultant. Telephone Interview, March13.
40.
MillerDavidSabirRizwaan. 2012. “Counter-terrorism as Counterinsurgency in the UK ‘War on Terror.’” In Counter-terrorism and State Political Violence: The “War on Terror” as Terror, ed. PoyntingScottWhyteDavid, 12–32. London: Routledge.
41.
MillerFranklin C.2009. Senior Director for Defense Policy and Arms Control on the National Security Council. Interview: The Cohen Group, August3. Washington, D.C.
42.
MoranChristopherMurphyChristopher. 2013. Intelligence Studies in Britain and the US: Historiography since 1945. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
43.
NaglJohn. 2005. Learning to Eat Soup with a Knife: Counterinsurgency Lessons from Malaya and Vietnam. London: University of Chicago Press.
44.
NewberySamantha. 2009. “Intelligence and Controversial British Interrogation Techniques: The Northern Ireland Case, 1971-2.” Irish Studies in International Affairs20:103–19.
45.
PapacharissiZiziOliveiraMaria. 2008. “News Frames Terrorism: A Comparative Analysis of Frames Employed in Terrorism Coverage in U.S. and U.K. Newspapers.”The International Journal of Press/Politics13 (1): 52–74.
46.
PfeifleMark. 2013. Deputy National Security Advisor for Strategic Communication and Global Outreach (2007-2009). Telephone Interview, July12.
TavernerAngus. 2013. UK Former Dir. Media Operations (Policy)—Office of Director General of Media and Communication MoD. Interview, January23. Glasgow.
58.
TaylorPhilip. 2003. Munitions of the Mind - Third Edition. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
59.
TaylorPhilipSnowNancy. 2006. “The Revival of the Propaganda State: US Propaganda at Home and Abroad since 9/11.”International Communication Gazette68 (5–6): 389–407.
60.
TunnicliffeIan. 2013. Former British Army Intelligence Corps, Former Director Plans in the Office of Strategic Communications of the Coalition Provisional Authority, MoD. Telephone Interview, July8.
WeinerTim. 2008. Legacy of Ashes: History of the CIA. London: Penguin.
63.
WilkersonLawrence. 2009. Former Chief of Staff to Secretary of State Colin Powell, Department of State 2002-2005. Interview, June23. Washington, D.C.
64.
WilsonDoug. 2013. US Former Assistant Secretary of Defense for Public Affairs. Telephone Interview, May10.
65.
WingfieldThomas. 2013a. Professor of International Law George C. Marshall European Center for Security Studies & Civilian Rule of Law Advisor to Gen. Stanley A. McChrystal’s Counterinsurgency Advisory and Assistance Team (October 2009-February 2010). E-mail, May1.
66.
WingfieldThomas. 2013b. Professor of International Law George C. Marshall European Center for Security Studies & Civilian Rule of Law Advisor to Gen. Stanley A. McChrystal’s Counterinsurgency Advisory and Assistance Team (October 2009-February 2010). E-mail, May10.
67.
WingfieldThomas. 2013c. Professor of International Law George C. Marshall European Center for Security Studies & Civilian Rule of Law Advisor to Gen. Stanley A. McChrystal’s Counterinsurgency Advisory and Assistance Team (October 2009-February 2010). E-mail, May21.
68.
WingfieldThomas. 2013d. Professor of International Law George C. Marshall European Center for Security Studies & Civilian Rule of Law Advisor to Gen. Stanley A. McChrystal’s Counterinsurgency Advisory and Assistance Team (October 2009-February 2010). E-mail, May22.
69.
WingfieldThomas. 2013e. Professor of International Law George C. Marshall European Center for Security Studies & Civilian Rule of Law Advisor to Gen. Stanley A. McChrystal’s Counterinsurgency Advisory and Assistance Team (October 2009-February 2010). E-mail, May29.
70.
WingfieldThomas. 2013f. Professor of International Law George C. Marshall European Center for Security Studies & Civilian Rule of Law Advisor to Gen. Stanley A. McChrystal’s Counterinsurgency Advisory and Assistance Team (October 2009-February 2010). E-mail, June8.
71.
WingfieldThomas. 2014. Professor of International Law George C. Marshall European Center for Security Studies & Civilian Rule of Law Advisor to Gen. Stanley A. McChrystal’s Counterinsurgency Advisory and Assistance Team (October 2009-February 2010). E-mail, July15.
72.
WrightGraham. 2009. Former UK Director of Targeting and Information Operations—MoD, & British Liaison to Joint Chiefs at Department of Defense. Interview, June1. Washington, D.C.
