There is a need for greater understanding of the health impact of various design
elements in neonatal intensive care units (NICUs) as well as cost-benefit
information to make informed decisions about the long-term value of design
decisions. This is particularly evident when design teams are considering the
transition from open-bay NICUs to single-family-room (SFR) units. This paper
introduces the guiding principles behind target value design (TVD)—a price-led
design methodology that is gaining acceptance in healthcare facility design
within the Lean construction methodology. The paper also discusses the role that
set-based design plays in TVD and its application to NICUs.
American Academy of
Pediatrics. (2011). Newborn intensive care
units (NICUs) and neonatologists of the USA & Canada.
Rockville, MD: Neonatology
Today.
2.
AnsariS.BellJ.,
& CAM-I Target Cost Core Group. (1997).
Target costing: The next frontier in strategic cost
management. Austin, TX:
Consortium for Advanced Manufacturing
International.
3.
ArthurJ.
(2011). Lean six sigma for hospitals: Simple steps to
fast, affordable, flawless healthcare. New York,
NY:
McGraw-Hill.
4.
ASTM. (2006).
Standard practice for measuring life-cycle costs of buildings
and building systems. Annual Book of ASTM
Standards. West Conshohocken, PA:
Author.
5.
BallardH.
G. (2000). The
last planner system of production control. Doctorate,
University of Birmington,
United Kingdom.
BallardG.
(2011). Target value design: Current benchmark
(1.0). Lean Construction Journal,
79–84.
8.
BallardG.,
& ReiserP.
(2004). The St. Olaf College fieldhouse project: A case
study in designing to target cost. Paper presented at the
Proceedings of the 12th Annual Conference of the International Group for Lean
Construction (IGLC-12), August 3–5, 2004, Elsinore,
Denmark.
BarnettD.
L. (2004). A
primer on sustainable building. Snowmass,
CO: Rocky Mountain
Institute.
11.
BerensR.,
& WeigleC.
(1996). Cost analysis of ceiling tile
replacement for noise abatement. Journal of
Perinatology, 16(3),
199–201.
12.
BerryL.
L.ParkerD.CoileR. C.HamiltonD. K.O'NeilleD.
D., & SadlerB.
L. (2004).
The business case for better buildings.
Frontiers of Health Services Management,
21(1),
5–24.
13.
BlackJ.
T., & HunterS.
L. (2003).
Lean manufacturing systems and cell design.
Dearborn, MI:
SME.
14.
BoardmanA.,
& ForbesD.
(2007). A cost-benefit analysis of private versus
semi-private inpatient rooms in a new hospital. Working paper.
Phelps Centre for the Study of Government and Business,
Sauder School of Business, Vancouver,
BC.
15.
BullJ.
W. (1993). Life
cycle costing for construction. London, United
Kingdom: Blackie Academic &
Professional.
16.
CalkinsM.,
& CassellaC.
(2007). Exploring the cost and value of private
versus shared bedrooms in nursing homes.
Gerontologist, 47(2),
169–183.
17.
CarreiraB.
(2005). Lean manufacturing that works: Powerful tools
for dramatically reducing waste and maximizing profits.
New York, NY:
AMACOM.
18.
CarterB.CarterA.,
& BennettS.
(2008). Families' views upon experiencing change
in the neonatal intensive care unit environment from the “baby barn” to the
private room. Journal of Perinatology,
28, 827–829.
19.
ChaudhuryH.MahmoodA.,
& ValenteM.
(2005). Advantages and disadvantages of single
versus multiple occupancy rooms in acute care environments: A review and
analysis of the literature. Environment &
Behavior, 37(6),
760–786.
20.
ChristiansenC.
(2009). Embracing change.
Health Environments Research & Design Journal,
3(1),
15–27.
21.
CliftonM.
B.BirdH. M. B.AlbanoR.
E., & TownsendW.
P. (2004).
Target costing: Market-driven product design.
New York, NY:
Dekker.
22.
CooperR.,
& SlagmulderR.
(1997). Target costing and value engineering.
Portland, OR: Productivity
Press.
23.
DavisJ.
W. (2009). Lean
manufacturing: Implementation strategies that work.
New York, NY: Industrial
Press.
24.
DenerolleS.
(2011). Technical report: The application of Target
value design to 3 hospital projects. Project
Production Systems Laboratory, University of California,
Berkeley.
25.
EvansR.HaryottR.HasteN.,
& JonesA.
(1998). The long term costs of owning and using
buildings. London, UK:
Royal Academy of
Engineering.
26.
GluckL.
(1985). Conceptualization and initiation of a neonatal
intensive care nursery in 1960. Paper presented at the Neonatal
Intensive Care: A History of Excellence, October 7, Bethesda,
MD.
HamiltonD.
K. (2006).
Evidence-based design supports evidence-based medicine in the
ICU. ICU Management Journal (Belgium),
6(3), 31.
29.
HarrellJ.,
& MoonR.
(2008). Designs for the
delicate. Health Facilities Management,
21(12),
45–48.
30.
HarrisD.ShepleyM.WhiteR.KolbergJ.,
& HarrollK.
(2006). The impact of single family room design
on patients and caregivers: Executive summary.
Journal of Perinatology,
26(Suppl 3),
S38–S48.
31.
Institute of Medicine.
(2006). Preterm birth: Causes, consequences, and
prevention. Washington, DC:
National Academy of
Sciences.
32.
JacksonB.
(2004). Construction management jump start.
Indianapolis, IN:
Wiley.
33.
JimmersonC.
(2007). A3 problem solving for healthcare: A practical
method for eliminating waste. Boca Raton,
FL: CRC
Press.
34.
JimmersonC.
(2010). Value stream mapping for healthcare made
easy. Boca Raton, FL:
CRC Press.
35.
KenneyC.
(2011). Value stream mapping for healthcare made
easy. Boca Raton, FL:
CRC Press.
36.
KirkS.
J., & Dell'IsolaA.
J. (1995). Life
cycle costing for design professionals. New York,
NY:
McGraw-Hill.
37.
KoskelaL.
(1992). Application of the new production philosophy to
construction. In CIFE Technical Report #72 (pp.
1–81). Stanford,
CA: Stanford
University.
38.
LangstonC.
A. (2005).
Life-cycle cost approach to building evaluation.
Amsterdam, The Netherlands:
Elsevier.
39.
LichtigW.
A. (2005a).
Sutter Health: Developing a contracting model to support Lean
project delivery. Lean Construction
Journal, 2(1),
105–112.
40.
LichtigW.
A. (2005b). Ten
key decisions to a successful construction project: Choosing something
new—the Integrated Agreement for Lean Project Delivery. September
29–30, The Intercontinental Toronto
Centre.
41.
LichtigW.
A. (2006).
The integrated agreement for Lean project
delivery. Construction Lawyer,
26(3),
1–8.
42.
LikerJ.
(2004). The Toyota way. New
York, NY:
McGraw-Hill.
MartinJ.
A.HamiltonB. E.VenturaS. J.OstermanM. J.KirmeyerS.MathewsT. J.WilsonE.
C. (2011).
Births: Final data for 2009. In StatisticsN.
V. (Ed.), National Vital
Statistics Reports (Vol. 60, No. 1).
Hyattsville, MD: National
Center for Health Statistics.
45.
MoonS.
(2005). Construction and costs—Going
up. Modern Healthcare,
35(10),
30–42.
46.
NicoliniD.TompkinsC.HoltiR.OldmanA.,
& SmalleyM.
(2000). Can target costing and whole life
costing be applied in the construction industry? Evidence from two case
studies. British Journal of Management,
11, 303–324.
47.
OrtenstrandA.WestrupB.,
& BrostromE.
A. (2010).
The Stockholm neonatal family centered care study: Effects of
length of stay and infant morbidity.
Pediatrics, 125,
e278–e285.
48.
ParrishK.
(2009). Applying a set-based design approach to
reinforcing steel design. Doctoral dissertation,
University of California,
Berkeley, Berkeley, CA.
49.
ParrishK.StranskyK. E.RogersC.DuncanM. H.SmithG. C.NeilJ.InderT.
(2007). Exploration of set-based design for reinforced
concrete structures. Paper presented at the International Group for
Lean Construction (IGLC-15), MI,
213–222.
50.
PhillipsC.
R. (2010).
Family-Centered Maternity Care Business Case.
Santa Cruz, CA: Phillips +
Fenwick.
51.
RosenblumD.
(2005). Single family room care: Before and after
data. Paper presented at the Gravens Conference: The Physical and
Developmental Environment of the High-Risk Infant, January 26–28, Clearwater
Beach, FL.
52.
RybkowskiZ.
(2009). The application of root cause analysis and
target value design to evidence-based design in the capital planning of
health care facilities. Doctoral dissertation,
University of California,
Berkeley, Berkeley, CA.
53.
RybkowskiZ.
K. (2010).
Letter to the editors. Health
Environments Research & Design Journal,
3(2),
126–130.
54.
ShepleyM.HarrisD.,
& WhiteR.
(2008). Open-bay and single family room neonatal
intensive care units: Caregiver satisfaction and stress.
Environment & Behavior,
40(2),
249–268.
55.
ShepleyM.HarrisD.WhiteR.,
& SteinbergF.
(2008). Impact of single-family rooms on family
behavior. The AIA Report on University
Research, 3,
174–185.
56.
SmithT.
J.SchoenbeckK.,
& ClaytonS.
(2009). Staff perceptions of work quality of a
neonatal intensive care unit before and after transition from an open bay to
a private room design. Work,
33, 211–227.
57.
StandardC.,
& DavisD.
K. (1999).
Running today's factory: A proven strategy for lean
manufacturing. Cincinnati, OH:
Hanser Gardner
Publications.
58.
StevensD.
C.HelsethC. C.KhanM. A.MunsonD.
P., & ReidE.
J. (2011).
A comparison of parent satisfaction in an open-bay and
single-family room neonatal intensive care unit.
Health Environments Research & Design Journal,
4(3),
110–123.
59.
SuhrJ.
(1999). The choosing by advantages decision-making
system. Westport, CT:
Quorum Books.
60.
TappingD.KozlowskiS.ArchboldL.,
& SperlT.
(2009). Value stream management for Lean healthcare:
Four steps to planning, mapping, implementing and controlling improvements
in all types of healthcare environments. Chelsea,
MI: MCS Media
Inc.
61.
WalshW.
F.McCulloughK.
L., & WhiteR.
D. (2006).
Room for improvement: Nurses' perceptions of providing care
in a single room newborn intensive care setting.
Advances in Neonatal Care,
6(5),
261–270.
62.
Walsh-SukysM.ReitenbachA.Hudson-BarrD.,
& DePompeiP.
(2001). Reducing light and sound in the neonatal
intensive care unit: An evaluation of patient safety, staff satisfaction and
costs. Journal of Perinatology,
21(4),
230–235.
63.
WardA.
C.LikerJ. K.CristianoJ.
J., & SobekD.
K.II
(1995). The second Toyota paradox: How delaying
decisions can make better cars faster. Sloan
Management Review, 36(3),
43–61.
64.
WhiteR.
(2007). Flooring choices for newborn
ICUs. Journal of Perinatology,
27(S2),
S29–S31.
65.
WhiteR.
(2011). The newborn intensive care unit
environment of care: How we got here, where we're headed, and
why. Seminars in Perinatology,
35(1),
2–7.
66.
WhiteR.BrowneJ.CiccoR.EricksonD.GravenS.GregoryS.KingJ.
(2007). Recommended standards for newborn ICU
design. Journal of Perinatology,
19(8), Part II,
S2–S12.
67.
WhiteR.SmithJ.,
& HarrellJ.
(2012). New recommended standards for NICU
design. Paper presented at the The Gravens Conference: The Physical
and Developmental Environment of the High Risk Infant, January 26–28, Clearwater
Beach, FL.
68.
WomackJ.
P., & JonesD.
T. (2003).
Lean thinking. New York, NY:
Free Press.
69.
WomackJ.
P.JonesD.
T., & RoosD.
(1990). The machine that changed the world.
New York, NY: Free
Press.
70.
ZidelT.
G. (2006). A
Lean guide to transforming healthcare: How to implement Lean principles in
hospitals, medical offices, clinics and other healthcare
organizations. Milwaukee, WI:
ASQ Quality Press.
71.
RybkowskiZ.
K.ShepleyM.
M. & BallardH.
G. (2012).
Target value design: Applications to newborn intensive care
units. Health Environments Research & Design
Journal, 5(4),
5–23.
