A Conceptual Framework for the Domain of Evidence-Based Design

Abstract

The physical facilities in which healthcare services are performed play an important role in the healing process. Evidence-based design in healthcare is a developing field of study that holds great promise for benefiting key stakeholders: patients, families, physicians, and nurses, as well as other healthcare staff and organizations. In this paper, the authors present and discuss a conceptual framework intended to capture the current domain of evidence-based design in healthcare. In this framework, the built environment is represented by nine design variable categories: audio environment, visual environment, safety enhancement, wayfinding system, sustainability, patient room, family support spaces, staff support spaces, and physician support spaces. Furthermore, a series of matrices is presented that indicates knowledge gaps concerning the relationship between specific healthcare facility design variable categories and participant and organizational outcomes. From this analysis, the authors identify fertile research opportunities from the perspectives of key stakeholders.

Keywords

Evidence-based design healthcare conceptual framework research priorities

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alimoglu

M. K.

, & Donmez

(2005). Daylight exposure and the other predictors of burnout among nurses in a University Hospital. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 42(5), 549–555.

Baggs

J. G.

Ryan

S. A.

Phelps

C. E.

Richeson

J. F.

, & Johnson

J. E.

(1992). The association between interdisciplinary collaboration and patient outcomes in a medical intensive care unit. Heart & Lung, 21(1), 18–24.

Baskaya

Wilson

, & Ozcan

Y. Z.

(2004). Wayfinding in an unfamiliar environment—Different spatial settings of two polyclinics. Environment and Behavior, 36(6), 839–867.

Bay

E. J.

Kupferschmidt

Opperwall

B. J.

, & Speer

(1988). Effect of the family visit on the patient's mental status. Focus on Critical Care/American Association of Critical-Care Nurses, 15(1), 11–16.

Ben-Abraham

Keller

Szold

Vardi

Weinberg

Barzilay

, & Paret

(2002). Do isolation rooms reduce the rate of nosocomial infections in the pediatric intensive care unit? Journal of Critical Care, 17(3), 176–180.

Berry

L. L.

, & Bendapudi

(2003). Clueing in customers. Harvard Business Review, 81(2), 100–106.

Berry

L. L.

, & Parish

J. T.

(2008). The impact of facility improvements on hospital nurses. Health Environments Research & Design Journal, 1(2), 5–13.

Berry

L. L.

Parker

Coile

R. C.

Jr. Hamilton

D. K.

O'Neill

D. D.

, & Sadler

B. L.

(2004). The business case for better buildings. Frontiers of Health Services Management, 21(1), 3–24.

Berry

L. L.

, & Seltman

K. D.

(2008). Management lessons from Mayo Clinic. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.

10.

Blomkvist

Eriksen

C. A.

Theorell

Ulrich

R. S.

, & Rasmanis

(2005). Acoustics and psychosocial environment in intensive coronary care. Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 62, 132–139.

11.

Buchanan

T. L.

Barker

K. N.

Gibson

J. T.

Jiang

B. C.

, & Pearson

R. E.

(1991). Illumination and errors in dispensing. American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy, 48(10), 2137–2145.

12.

Cama

(2009). Evidence-based healthcare design. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.

13.

Capeluto

I. G.

(2003). Energy performance of the self-shading building envelope. Energy and Building, 35(3), 327–336.

14.

Carpman

J. R.

, & Grant

M. A.

(1993). Design that cares: Planning health facilities for patients and visitors (2nd ed.). Chicago, IL: American Hospital Publishing.

15.

Carpman

J. R.

Grant

, & Simmons

(1983). Wayfinding in the hospital environment: The impact of various floor numbering alternatives. Journal of Environmental Systems, 13(4), 353–364.

16.

Carpman

J. R.

Grant

M. A.

, & Simmons

D. A.

(1990). Avoiding the hidden costs of ineffective wayfinding. Health Facilities Management, 3(4), 34–37.

17.

Chang

Y. J.

Pan

Y. J.

Lin

Y. J.

Chang

Y. Z.

, & Lin

C. H.

(2006). A noise-sensor light alarm reduces noise in the newborn intensive care unit. American Journal of Perinatology, 23(5), 265–271.

18.

Chatham

M. A.

(1978). The effect of family involvement on patients' manifestations of postcardiotomy psychosis. Heart & Lung, 7(6), 995–999.

19.

Diette

G. B.

Lechtzin

Haponik

Devrotes

, & Rubin

H. R.

(2003). Distraction therapy with nature sights and sounds reduces pain during flexible bronchoscopy: A complementary approach to routine analgesia. Chest, 123(3), 941–948.

20.

Evans

Pati

, & Harvey

(2008). Rethinking acuity adaptability. Healthcare Design, 8(4), 22–25.

21.

Flynn

E. A.

Barker

K. N.

Gibson

J. T.

Pearson

R. E.

Berger

B. A.

, & Smith

L. A.

(1999). Impact of interruptions and distractions on dispensing errors in an ambulatory care pharmacy. American Journal of Health Systems Pharmacy, 56(13), 1319–1325.

22.

Fowler

K. M.

, & Rauch

E. M.

(2008). Assessing green building performance: A post occupancy evaluation of 12 GSA buildings. Richland, WA: Pacific Northwest National Laboratory.

23.

Gabor

J. Y.

Cooper

A. B.

Crombach

S. A.

Lee

Kadikar

Bettger

H. E.

, & Hanly

P.J.

(2003). Contribution of the intensive care unit environment to sleep disruption in mechanically ventilated patients and healthy subjects. American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine, 167(5), 708–715.

24.

Gittell

J. H.

Fairfield

K. M.

Bierbaum

Head

Jackson

Kelly

Zuckerman

(2000). Impact of relational coordination on quality of care, postoperative pain and functioning, and length of stay. Medical Care, 38(8), 807–819.

25.

Goodell

K. H.

Cao

C. G.

, & Schwaitzberg

S. D.

(2006). Effects of cognitive distraction on performance of laparoscopic surgical tasks. Journal of Laparoendoscopic & Advanced Surgical Techniques. Part A, 16(2), 94–98.

26.

Guenther

, & Vittori

(2007). Sustainable healthcare architecture. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.

27.

Gulwadi

G. B.

, & Calkins

M. P.

(2008). The impact of the design of healthcare environments on patient falls. Concord, CA: Center for Health Design.

28.

Gurascio-Howard

, & Malloch

(2007). Centralized and decentralized nurse station design: An examination of caregiver communication, work activities, and technology. Health Environments Research & Design Journal, 1(1), 44–56.

29.

Hamilton

D. K.

, & Shepley

M. M.

(2009). Design for critical care: An evidence-based approach. Oxford, United Kingdom: Architectural Press (Elsevier).

30.

Hamilton

D. K.

, & Watkins

D. H.

(2009). Evidence-based design for multiple building types: Applied research-based knowledge for multiple building types. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.

31.

Happ

M. B.

Swigart

V. A.

Tate

J. A.

Arnold

R. M.

Sereika

S. M.

, & Hoffman

L. A.

(2007). Family presence and surveillance during weaning from prolonged mechanical ventilation. Heart & Lung, 36(1), 47–57.

32.

Hendrich

A. L.

Bender

P. S.

, & Nyhuis

(2003). Validation of the Hendrichs II falls risk model: A large concurrent case/control study of hospitalized patients. Applied Nursing Research, 16(1), 9–21.

33.

Hendrich

A. L.

Fay

, & Sorrells

A. K.

(2004). Effects of acuity-adaptable rooms on flow of patients and delivery of care. American Journal of Critical Care, 13(1), 35–45.

34.

Hendrickson

S. L.

(1987). Intracranial pressure changes and family presence. The Journal of Neuroscience Nursing, 19(1), 14–17.

35.

Hien

W. N.

Wang

Chandra

A. N.

Pandey

A. R.

, & Wei

(2005). Effects of double glazed façade on energy consumption. Energy and Buildings, 37(6), 563–572.

36.

Hodge

, & Thompson

J. F.

(1990). Noise pollution in the operating theatre. Lancet, 335(8694), 891–894.

37.

Huelat

B. J.

(2007). Wayfinding: Design for understanding. Concord, CA: Center for Health Design.

38.

Jadad

A. R.

, & Enkin

M. W.

(2007). Randomized controlled trials (2nd ed.). Oxford, United Kingdom: BMJ Books—Blackwell Publishing.

39.

Janssen

P. A.

Klein

M. C.

Harris

S. J.

Soolsma

, & Seymour

L. C.

(2000). Single room maternity care and client satisfaction. Birth, 27(4), 235–243.

40.

Kahn

P. H.

Jr. Friedman

Gill

B. T.

Hagman

Severson

R. L.

Freier

N. G.

Stolyar

(2008). A plasma display window? The shifting baseline problem in a technologically-mediated natural world. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 28(2), 192–199.

41.

Kaplan

Orris

, & Machi

(2009). A research agenda for advancing patient, worker and environmental health and safety in the health care sector. Health Care Without Harm. Retrieved April 29, 2010, from http://www.noharm.org/lib/downloads/other/Research_Agenda_Health_Safety.pdf

42.

Karro

Dent

A. W.

, & Farish

(2005). Patient perceptions of privacy infringements in an emergency department. Emergency Medicine Australasia, 17(2), 117–123.

43.

Kerzman

Chetrit

Brin

, & Toren

(2004). Characteristics of falls in hospitalized patients. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 47(2), 223–229.

44.

Khodakarami

Knight

, & Nasrollahi

(2008). Reducing the demands of heating and cooling in Iranian hospitals. Renewable Energy, 34(4), 1162–1168.

45.

Krauss

M. J.

Nguyen

S. L.

Dunagan

W. C.

Birge

Costantinou

Johnson

Fraser

V. J.

(2007). Circumstances of patient falls and injuries in nine hospitals in a midwestern healthcare system. Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology, 28(5), 544–550.

46.

Leape

L. L.

Brennan

T. A.

Laird

Lawthers

A. G.

Localio

A. R.

Barnes

B. A.

Hiatt

(1991). The nature of adverse events in hospitalized patients. Results of the Harvard Medical Practice Study II. New England Journal of Medicine, 324(6), 377–384.

47.

Lee

D. W.

Chan

A. C.

Wong

S. K.

Fung

T. M.

A. C.

Chan

S. K.

Chung

S.C.

(2004). Can visual distraction decrease the dose of patient controlled sedation required during colonoscopy? A prospective randomized controlled trial. Endoscopy, 36(3), 197–201.

48.

Leppamaki

Partonen

Piiroinen

Haukka

, & Lonnqvist

(2003). Timed bright-light exposure and complaints related to shift work among women. Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment & Health, 29(1), 22–26.

49.

Levine

Marchon

, & Hanley

(1984). The placement and misplacement of you-are-here maps. Environment and Behavior, 16(2), 139–157.

50.

D. H. W.

Lam

T. N. T.

, & Wong

S. L.

(2006). Lighting and energy performance for an office using high frequency dimming controls. Energy Conversion and Management, 47(9/10), 1133–1145.

51.

Love

(2003). Noise exposure in the orthopaedic operating theatre: A significant health hazard. ANZ Journal of Surgery, 73(10), 836–838.

52.

Malkin

(2002). Medical and dental space planning (3rd ed.). New York, NY: Wiley.

53.

Malkin

(2008). A visual reference for evidence-based design. Concord, CA: Center for Health Design.

54.

Mason

D. J.

(2003). Family presence: Evidence versus tradition. American Journal of Critical Care, 12(3), 190–192.

55.

Mlinek

E. J.

, & Pierce

(1997). Confidentiality and privacy breaches in a university hospital emergency department. Academic Emergency Medicine, 4(12), 1142–1146.

56.

Murthy

V. S.

Malhotra

S. K.

Bala

, & Raghunathan

(1995). Detrimental effects of noise on anaesthetists. Canadian Journal of Anaesthesia, 42(7), 608–611.

57.

Nanda

Hathorn

, & Neumann

(2007). The art-cart program at St. Luke's Episcopal-Hospital, Houston. Healthcare Design, 7(7), 10–12.

58.

Newsham

G. R.

Mancini

, & Birt

B. J.

(2009). Do LEED-certified buildings save energy? Yes, but…. Energy and Buildings, 41(8), 897–905.

59.

Pati

Harvey

T. E. J.

, & Barach

(2008). Relationships between exterior views and nurse stress: An exploratory examination. Health Environments Research & Design Journal, 2(2), 27–38.

60.

Pechacek

C. S.

Andersen

, & Lockley

S. W.

(2008). Combining annual daylight simulation with photobiology data to assess the relative circadian efficacy of interior spaces. Paper presented at the eSim 2008 conference of IBPSA, Quebec City, Canada, May 20–22, 2008.

61.

Powers

K. S.

, & Rubenstein

J. S.

(1999). Family presence during invasive procedures in the pediatric intensive care unit: A prospective study. Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine. 153(9), 955–958.

62.

Puntillo

K. A.

, & McAdam

J. L.

(2006). Communication between physicians and nurses as a target for improving end-of-life care in the intensive care unit: Challenges and opportunities for moving forward. Critical Care Medicine, 34(11), S332–340.

63.

Ramsay

M. A.

(2000). Physician fatigue. Proceedings (Baylor University Medical Center), 13(2), 148–150.

64.

Sadler

B. L.

, & Ridenour

(2009). Transforming the healthcare experience through the arts. San Diego, CA: Aesthetics, Inc.

65.

Sanderson

P. M.

Tosh

Philp

Rudie

Watson

M. O.

, & Russell

W. J.

(2005). The effects of ambient music on simulated anaesthesia monitoring. Anaesthesia, 60(11), 1073–1078.

66.

Sarkamo

Tervaniemi

Laitinen

Forsblom

Soinila

Mikkonen

Hietanen

(2008). Music listening enhances cognitive recovery and mood after middle cerebral artery stroke. Brain, 131(Pt 3), 866–876.

67.

Schwendimann

(2006). Patient falls: A key issue in patient safety in hospitals. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Basel, Zurich, Switzerland.

68.

Shepley

M. M.

(2002). Predesign and postoccupancy analysis of staff behavior in a neonatal intensive care unit. Children's Health Care, 31(3), 237–253.

69.

Shepley

M. M.

Harris

D. D.

, & White

(2008). Open-bay and single-family room neonatal intensive care units: Caregiver satisfaction and stress. Environment and Behavior, 40(2), 249–268.

70.

Sternberg

E. M.

(2009). Healing spaces: The science of place and well-being. Boston, MA: Belknap Press.

71.

Suter

, & Baylin

(2007). Choosing art as a complement to healing. Applied Nursing Research, 20(1), 32–38.

72.

Topf

(2000). Hospital noise pollution: An environmental stress model to guide research and clinical interventions. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 31(3), 520–528.

73.

Ulrich

R. S.

(1984). View through a window may influence recovery from surgery. Science, 224(4647), 420–421.

74.

Ulrich

R. S.

(1991). Effects of interior design on wellness: Theory and recent scientific research. Journal of Health Care Interior Design, 3, 97–109.

75.

Ulrich

R. S.

(2008). Biophilic design of healthcare environments. In Kellert

Heerwagen

, and Mador

(Eds.), Biophilic design for better buildings and communities (pp. 87–106). New York, NY: Wiley.

76.

Ulrich

R. S.

Zimring

C. M.

Zhu

DuBose

Seo

Choi

Joseph

(2008). A review of the research literature on evidence-based healthcare design. Health Environments Research & Design Journal, 1(3), 61–125.

77.

U.S. Green Building Council Research Committee. (2008). A national Green building research agenda. Washington, DC: Author.

78.

Vieira

E. R.

, & Miller

(2008). Facing the challenge of patient transfers: Using ceiling lifts in healthcare facilities. Health Environments Research & Design Journal, 2(1), 6–16.

79.

Wakamura

, & Tokura

(2001). Influence of bright light during daytime on sleep parameters in hospitalized elderly patients. Journal of Physiological Anthropology and Applied Human Science, 20(6), 345–351.

80.

Walch

J. M.

Rabin

B. S.

Day

Williams

J. N.

Choi

, & Kang

J. D.

(2005). The effect of sunlight on post-operative analgesic medication usage: A prospective study of patients undergoing spinal surgery. Psychosomatic Medicine, 67, 156–163.

81.

Weinger

M. B.

, & Englund

C. E.

(1990). Ergonomic and human factors affecting anesthetic vigilance and monitoring performance in the operating room environment. Anesthesiology, 73(5), 995–1021.

82.

Weisman

G. D.

(1981). Evaluating architectural legibility: Wayfinding in the built environment. Environment and Behavior, 13, 189–204.

83.

Werner

, & Schindler

L. E.

(2004). The role of spatial reference frames in architecture—Misalignment impairs wayfinding performance. Environment and Behavior, 36(4), 461–482.

84.

Williams

C. M.

(2005). The identification of family members' contribution to patients' care in the intensive care unit: A naturalistic inquiry. Nursing in Critical Care, 10(1), 6–14.

85.

Wright

Hull

A. J.

, & Lickorish

(1993). Navigating in a hospital outpatients' department: The merits of maps and wall signs. Journal of Architectural & Planning Research, 10(1), 76–89.

86.

Zhan

, & Miller

M. R.

(2003). Excess length of stay, charges, and mortality attributable to medical injuries during hospitalization. Journal of the American Medical Association, 290(14), 1868–1874.

87.

Zimring

(1990). The costs of confusion: Non-monetary and monetary costs of the Emory University hospital wayfinding system. Atlanta, GA: Georgia Institute of Technology.

88.

Zwarenstein

Goldman

, & Reeves

(2009). Interprofessional collaboration: Effects of practice-based interventions on professional practice and healthcare outcomes. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2009(3), CD000072.