Making the Case for Evidence-Based Design in Healthcare: A Descriptive Case Study of Organizational Decision Making

Abstract

Objective:

The aim of this study was to describe the organizational decision-making process used in the selection of evidence-based design (EBD) concepts, the criteria used to make these decisions, and the extent to which leadership style may have influenced the decision-making process. Five research questions were formulated to frame the direction of this study, including: (1) How did healthcare leaders learn of innovations in design? (2) How did healthcare leaders make decisions in the selection of healthcare design concepts? (3) What criteria did healthcare leaders use in the decision-making process? (4) How did healthcare leaders consider input from the staff in design decisions? and (5) To what extent did the leadership style of administrators affect the outcomes of the decision-making process?

Background:

Current issues affecting healthcare in the community led the principal investigator's organization to undertake an ambitious facilities expansion project. As part of its planning process, the organization learned of EBD principles that seemingly had a positive impact on patient care and safety and staff working conditions. Although promising, a paucity of empirical research addressed the cost/benefit of incorporating many EBD concepts into one hospital setting, and there was no research that articulated the organizational decision-making process used by healthcare administrators when considering the use of EBD in expansion projects.

Methods:

A mixed-method, descriptive, qualitative, single-case study and quantitative design were used to address the five research questions. The Systems Research Organizing Model provided the theoretical framework. A variety of data collection methods was used, including interviews of key respondents, the review of documentary evidence, and the Multifactor Leadership Questionnaire.

Results:

A participatory process was used throughout the design decision phases, involving staff at all levels of the organization. The Internet and architects facilitated learning about EBD. Financial considerations were a factor in decision making. The prevalence of the transformational leadership style among the organization's administrators exceeded the U.S. mean.

Keywords

Evidence-based design organizational decision making leadership style

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. (2005). The hospital built environment: What role might funders of health services research play? Retrieved December 29, 2007, from http://www.ahrq.gov/qual/hospbuilt/hospenv.htm

Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. (2007). Transforming hospitals: Designing for safety and quality. Retrieved June 22, 2008, from http://www.ahrq.gov/qual/transform.htm

Alquist

(1994). California Senate Bill 1953: Building standards. Retrieved April 1, 2007, from http://info.sen.ca.gov/pub/93-94/bill/sen/sb_1951-2000/sb_1953_bill_940922_chaptered

Barker

A. M.

Sullivan

D. T.

, & Emery

M. J.

(2006). Leadership competencies for clinical managers: The renaissance of transformational leadership. Sudbury, MA: Jones and Bartlett.

Bass

, & Avolio

(2004). Construct validation and norms for the Multifactor Leadership Questionnaire (MLQ-Form 5x). Retrieved with permission on May 30, 2009, from www.mindgarden.com

Bass

B. M.

Avolio

B. J.

Jung

D. I.

, & Berson

(2003). Predicting unit performance by assessing transformational and transactional leadership. Journal of Applied Pyschology, 88(2), 207–218.

Berry

L. L.

Parker

Coile

R. C.

Hamilton

O'Neill

D. D.

, & Sadler

B. L.

(2004). The business case for better buildings. Frontiers of Health Services Management, 21(1), 3–24.

Brewer

B. B.

Verran

J. A.

, & Stichler

J. F.

(2008). The systems research organizing model: A conceptual perspective for facilities design. Health Environment Research & Design Journal, 1(4), 7–19.

Dunham-Taylor

(2000). Nurse executive transformational leadership found in participative organizations. Journal of Nursing Administration, 30(5), 241–250.

10.

Feldbauer

Boan

Nadzam

Finis

, & Nadzam

(2008). Design of a patient-safe environment: The Joint Commission position. Health Environments Research & Design Journal, 1(2), 65–68.

11.

Flood

P. C.

Hannan

Smith

K. G.

Turner

West

M. A.

, & Dawson

(2000). Chief executive leadership style, consensus decision making, and top management team effectiveness. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 9(3), 401–420.

12.

Institute of Medicine. (1999). To err is human: Building a safer healthcare system. Retrieved April 21, 2007, from http://iom.edu/∼/media/Files/Report%20Files/1999/To-Err-is-Human/To%20Err%20is%20Human%201999%20%20report%20brief.pdf

13.

Institute of Medicine. (2001). Crossing the quality chasm: A new health system for the 21st century. Retrieved April 21, 2007, from http://www.nap.edu

14.

Janis

I. L.

(1972). Victims of groupthink. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin.

15.

Janis

I. L.

(1989). Crucial decisions: Leadership in policymaking and crisis management. New York, NY: Free Press, a Division of Macmillan.

16.

Jones

W. J.

(2004). Renewal by earthquake: Designing 21st century hospitals in response to California's seismic safety legislation. Prepared for the California HealthCare Foundation. Retrieved from http://www.chcf.org/publications/2004/03/renewal-by-earthquake

17.

Joseph

(2006). The role of the physical and social environment in promoting health, safety and effectiveness in the healthcare workplace. Retrieved April 3, 2007, from www.healthdesign.org

18.

Joseph

Bosch

Frederick

, & Jackson

(2007). Researching the effectiveness of a participatory evidence-based design process. Healthcare Design, 7(3), 8–12.

19.

Lowe

K. B.

Kroeck

K. G.

, & Sivasubramaniam

(1996). Effectiveness correlates of transformational and transactional leadership: A meta-analytic review. Leadership Quarterly, 7, 385–425.

20.

Malkin

(2008). A visual reference for evidence-based design. Concord, CA: Center for Health Design.

21.

Malloch

, & Porter-O'Grady

(2005). The quantum leader: Application for the new world of work. Sudbury, MA: Jones and Bartlett.

22.

Meade

, & Kulick

(2007). SB1953 and the challenges of hospital seismic safety in California. Prepared for the California HealthCare Foundation. Retrieved from http://www.chcf.org/∼/media/Files/PDF/S/SB1953Report.pdf

23.

Page

(2004). Keeping patients safe: Transforming the work of nurses. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.

24.

Peterson

R. S.

(1997). A directive leadership style in group decision making can be both a virtue and vice: Evidence from elite and experimental groups. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 72(5), 1107–1121.

25.

Reiling

(2004). Facility design focused on patient safety. Frontiers of Health Services Management, 21(1), 41–46.

26.

Rostenberg

, & Ross

(2007). The cost of innovation. Healthcare Design, 7(1), 18–26.

27.

Sadler

B. L.

DuBose

, & Zimring

(2008). The business case for building better hospitals through evidence-based design. Health Environments Research & Design Journal, 1(3), 22–39.

28.

Schafer

, & Crichlow

(1996). Antecedents of groupthink: A quantitative study. Journal of Conflict Resolution, 40(3), 415–435.

29.

Schroder

, & Breen

(2007). Hospital of the future: Lessons for inpatient facility planning and strategy. Washington, DC: The Advisory Board Company.

30.

Stankos

, & Schwarz

(2007). Evidence-based design in healthcare: A theoretical dilemma. Interdisciplinary Design and Research eJournal, 1(1), 1–15.

31.

Ulrich

Zimring

Joseph

Quan

, & Choudhary

(2004). The role of the physical environment in the hospital of the 21st century: A once-in-a-lifetime opportunity. Concord, CA: Center for Health Design.

32.

Ulrich

Zimring

Zhu

Dubose

Seo

H. B.

Choi

Y. S.

Joseph

(2008). A review of the research literature on evidence-based healthcare design. Health Environments Research & Design Journal, 1(3), 61–125.

33.

Yin

(2003). Case study research: Design and methods (3rd ed). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.

34.

Zimring

Augenbroe

G. L.

Malone

E. B.

, & Sadler

B. L.

(2008). Implementing healthcare excellence: The vital role of the CEO in evidence-based design. Health Environments Research & Design Journal, 1(3), 7–21.