Understanding Institutional Change: The Development of Institutions for the Regulation of the Natural Gas Supply Systems in the United States and the European Union

Abstract

This article compares the development of the institutions that regulate the natural gas supply systems in the United States and the European Union. Given the technical and functional similarities of these systems, the question arises as to why regulatory institutions in the US and the EU gas markets have developed in such different ways. In this study we have adopted a historical and dynamic approach, in which institutional outcomes are explored not only by focusing on ‘historic breaks’ in structural technological and economic conditions in the US and Europe, but also by looking at the ‘politics of regulation’. We illustrate the analytical value of applying a framework of incremental change over time within regulatory institutions, identifying different modes including displacement and layering, and introducing a new mode: ‘compartmentalization.’ We show that both pre-existing and newly created actors play important strategic roles in the process of institutional change and the creation of regulation, influencing the coordination between public and private parties as well as the interaction of federal and state levels in the US and supranational and national ‘orders’ in the EU. Our exploration is based on a systematic analysis of the literature on US and EU regulation of the natural gas supply systems since their early beginnings.

Keywords

European Union history institutional change natural gas politics regulation United States

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ascari

(2013) “An American Model for the EU Gas Market?” In Glachant

J.-M.

Hallack

Vazquez

Ruester

, and Ascari

(eds), Building Competitive Gas Markets in the EU: Regulation, Supply and Demand. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Baker

R.G.

and Illig

(1954) “Natural Gas Supplies for Tomorrow.” Law and Contemporary Problems, 19(3): 361–381.

Baumgartner

F.R.

and Jones

B.D.

(1993) Agendas and Instability in American Politics. Chicago: Chicago University Press.

Bernhardt

(1988) “Is Natural Gas Pipeline Regulation Worth the Fuss?” Stanford Law Review, 40(3): 753–772.

Boin

R.A.

and 't Hart

(2000) “Institutional Crises and Reforms in Policy Sectors,” In Wagenaar

(ed.), Government Institutions: Effects, Changes and Normative Foundations. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers.

Breautigam

and Hubbard

R.G.

(1986) Natural Gas: The Regulatory Transition. Regulatory Reform: What Actually Happened. Boston: Little, Brown and Company.

Breyer

and MacAvoy

P.W.

(1973) “The Natural Gas Shortage and the Regulation of Natural Gas Producers.” Harvard Law Review, 86(6): 941–987.

CEC (1988) The Internal Energy Market, COM(88) 238 final, 2 May 1988, Brussels: Commission of the European Communities.

CEC (2005) Regulation (EC) No 1775/2005 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 28 September 2005 on conditions for access to the natural gas transmission networks. Brussels: Commission of the European Communities.

10.

CEC (2006) Inquiry pursuant to Article 17 of Regulation (EC) No 1/2003 into the European gas and electricity sectors (Final Report), COM(2006) 851 final, Brussels, 10 January 2007, Brussels: Commission of the European Communities.

11.

CEC (2012) Making the internal energy market work, COM(2012) 663 final, 15 October 2012, Brussels: Commission of the European Communities.

12.

Chermak

J.M.

(1998) “Order 636 and the U.S. natural gas industry.” Resources Policy, 24(4): 207–216.

13.

CIEP (2009) Crossing Borders in European Gas Networks: The Missing Links. Den Haag: Clingendael International Energy Programme.

14.

Correljé

A.F.

(2005) “Dilemmas in Network Regulation: The Dutch Gas Industry.” In Künneke

Groenewegen

Correljé

(eds) Innovations in liberalized network industries: Between private initiatives and public interest. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

15.

Correljé

and De Vries

(2008) “Hybrid Electricity Markets: The Problem of Explaining Different Patterns of Restructuring.” In Sioshansie

F.P.

(ed.), Competitive Electricity Markets: Design, Implementation and Performance, Dordrecht: Elsevier Global Energy Policy and Economics Series.

16.

Correljé

Van der Linde

and Westerwoudt

(2003) Natural Gas in the Netherlands: From Cooperation to Competition? Den Haag: Oranje Nassau Groep/ Clingendael International Energy Programme.

17.

Court

S.J.

(2012) “Is ACER FERC-Lite?” International Gas Union Magazine, 68–72.

18.

Curtin

and Egeberg

(2008) “Tradition and Innovation: Europe's Accumulated Executive Order.” West European Politics, 31(4): 639–661.

19.

Davis

J.D.

(1984) Blue Gold: The Political Economy of Natural Gas. World Industries Studies 3. London: George Allen & Unwin.

20.

De Bruijn

and Ten Heuvelhof

(2008) Management in Networks: On Multi-Actor Decision Making. London: Routledge.

21.

Eberlein

(2008) “The Making of the European Energy Market: The Interplay Between Governance and Government.” Journal of Public Policy, 28(1): 73–92.

22.

ECS (2007) Putting a price on energy: International pricing mechanisms for Oil and Gas. Brussels: Energy Charter Secretariat.

23.

Estrada

Bergesen

H.O.

Moe

and Sydnes

A.K.

(1988) Natural gas in Europe. Markets, Organisation and Politics. London: Pinter.

24.

Estrada

Moe

and Martinsen

Dahl K.

(1995) The Development of European Gas Markets: Environmental, Economic and Political Perspective. Chichester: John Wily & Sons.

25.

George

A.L.

and Bennett

(2005) Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

26.

Glachant

J.-M.

Hallack

Vazquez

Ruester

and Ascari

, (eds), Building Competitive Gas Markets in the EU: Regulation, Supply and Demand. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

27.

Groenleer

M.L. P.

(2011) “Regulatory governance in the European Union: The political struggle over committees, agencies and networks.” In Levi-Faur

(ed.), Handbook on the Politics of Regulation. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

28.

Matláry

Haaland J.

(1997) Energy policy in the European Union. Houndmills: Macmillan.

29.

Heather

(2010) The Evolution and Functioning of the Traded Gas Market in Britain. Oxford: The Oxford Institute for Energy Studies, NG 39.

30.

Helm

(2006) “Regulatory Reform, Capture, and the Regulatory Burden.” Oxford Review of Economic Policy, (Summer) 22(2): 169–185.

31.

Hubbard

R.G.

and Weiner

R. J.

(1986) “Regulation and Long-Term Contracting in us Natural Gas Markets.” The Journal of Industrial Economics, 35(1): 71–79.

32.

Hooghe

and Marks

(2001) Multi-Level Governance and European Integration. Lanham: Rowman and Littlefield.

33.

Jensen

W.G.

(1967) Energy in Europe: 1945–1980. London: G.T. Foulis & Co LTD.

34.

Knight

(1992) Institutions and Social Conflict. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

35.

Konoplyanik

A.A.

(2012) “Russian gas at European energy market: Why adaptation is inevitable.” Energy Strategy Reviews, (1): 42–56.

36.

Krasner

S.D.

(1988) “Sovereignty: An Institutional Perspective.” Comparative Political Studies, 21: 66–94.

37.

Leeston

A.M.

Crichton

J.A.

and Jacobs

J.C.

(1963) The Dynamic Natural Gas Industry: The Description of an American Industry from the Historical, Technical, Legal, Financial, and Economic Standpoints. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press.

38.

Leitzinger

and Collette

(2002) “A Retrospective Look at Wholesale Gas: Industry Restructuring.” Journal of Regulatory Economics, 21(1): 79–101.

39.

Light

A.R.

(1979) “The Legislated Role of the States in the National Energy Acts.” Publius, 9(1): 188–189.

40.

Levi-Faur

(2011) “Regulation and Regulatory Governance.” In Levi-Faur

(ed.), Handbook on the Politics of Regulation. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

41.

Lucas

N.J.D.

(1977) Energy and the European Communities. London: Europa Publications.

42.

Lucas

N.J.D.

(1985) Western European Energy Policies: A Comparative Study of the Influence of Institutional Structure on Technological Change. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

43.

Mabro

and Wybrew-Bond

(eds) (1999) Gas to Europe: The Strategies of the Four Major Suppliers. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

44.

MacAvoy

P.W.

(2000) The Natural Gas Market: Sixty Years of Regulation and Deregulation. New Haven, London: Yale University Press.

45.

Mahoney

(2000) “Path Dependence in Historical Sociology.” Theory and Society, 29: 507–548.

46.

Mahoney

and Thelen

(2010) Explaining institutional change: Ambiguity, agency, and power. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

47.

Makholm

J.D.

(2007) Seeking Competition and Supply Security in Natural Gas: The US Experience and European Challenge. CESSA Conference. Berlin.

48.

Makholm

J.D.

(2011) “Real unbundlings: The foundation for a competitive gas market in the United States. Competition and Regulation in Network Industries, 12(4), 321–343.

49.

Makholm

J.D.

(2012) The Political Economy of Pipelines: A Century of Comparative Institutional Development. Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press.

50.

March

J.G.

and Olsen

J.P.

(1989) Rediscovering Institutions: The Organizational Basis of Politics. New York, London, Toronto, Sydney: The Free Press.

51.

McGrew

J.H.

(2009) FERC, Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (2nd ed.). Chicago: American Bar Association Publishing.

52.

Newbery

D.M.

(2001) Privatization, Restructuring and Regulation of Network Utilities. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.

53.

NGSA (2012). www.naturalgas.org/business/industry.asp.

54.

North, D.C. (1990) Institutions, Institutional Change, and Economic Performance. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.

55.

Peebles

M.W.H.

(1980) Evolution of the Gas Industry. London: The MacMillan Press Ltd.

56.

Petrash

J.M.

(2006) “Long-Term Natural Gas Contracts: Dead, Dying or Merely Resting?” Energy Law Journal, 27(2): 545–583.

57.

Phillips

C.F.

(1993) The Regulation of Public Utilities: Theory and Practice. Arlington, VA: Public Utilities Reports, Inc.

58.

Pierson

(2000a) “Increasing Returns, Path Dependence and the Study of Politics.” American Political Science Review, 94(2): 251–267.

59.

Pierson

(2000b) “The Limits of Design: Explaining Institutional Origins and Change.” Governance, 13(4): 475–499.

60.

Sanders

M.E.

(1981) The Regulation of Natural Gas: Policy and Politics, 1938–1978. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.

61.

Scherer

F.M.

(1980) Industrial market structure and economic performance (2nd ed.). Boston: Houghton Mifflin Comp.

62.

Schickler

(2001) Disjointed Pluralism: Institutional Innovation and the Development of the U.S. Congress. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

63.

Spiller

P.T.

(2009) “An Institutional Theory of Public Contracts: Regulatory Implications,” In Menard

and Ghertman

(eds), Regulation, Deregulation, Reregulation – Institutional Perspectives. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

64.

Stern

J.P.

(1990) European gas Markets: Challenges and Opportunities in the 1990s. London: Royal Institute of International Affairs, Energy and Environmental Programme.

65.

Stern

J.P.

(1998) Competition and Liberalization in European Gas Markets: A Diversity of Models. London: Royal Institute of International Affairs, Energy and Environmental Programme.

66.

Stern

and Rogers

(2011) The Transition to Hub-Based Gas Pricing in Continental Europe. Oxford: The Oxford Institute for Energy Studies, NG 49.

67.

Stern

Pirani

and Yafimava

(2009) The Russo-Ukrainian Gas Dispute of January 2009: A Comprehensive Assessment. Oxford: The Oxford Institute for Energy Studies.

68.

Stewart

and Madsen

(2005) The Texan and Dutch Gas: Kicking off the European Energy Revolution. Oxford: Trafford Publishing.

69.

Streeck

and Thelen

(eds) (2005) Beyond continuity: Institutional change in advanced political economies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

70.

Thelen

(1999) “Historical institutionalism in comparative politics.” Annual Review of Political Science, 2: 369–404.

71.

Thelen

(2003) “How Institutions Evolve: Insights From Comparative Historical Analysis.” In Mahoney

and Rueschemeyer

(eds), Comparative Historical Analysis in the Social Sciences. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

72.

Troxel

C.E.

(1936) “Long-Distance Natural Gas Pipe Lines.” The Journal of Land & Public Utility Economics, 12(4): 344–354.

73.

Troxel

C.E.

(1937a) “II. Regulation of Interstate Movements of Natural Gas.” The Journal of Land & Public Utility Economics, 13(1): 20–30.

74.

Troxel

C.E.

(1937b) “III. Some Problems in State Regulation of Natural Gas Utilities.” The Journal of Land & Public Utility Economics, 13(2): 188–203.

75.

Troxel

(1947) Economics of Public Utilities. New York: Rinehart & Company, Inc.

76.

Vazquez

Hallack

and Glachant

J.-M.

(2012) “Designing the European Gas Market: More Liquid & Less Natural?” Economics of Energy & Environmental Policy, 1(3): 25–38.

77.

Westphal

(2012) The four great challenges for the European gas market, European Energy Review, 2 July.

78.

Weyman-Jones

T.G.

(1986) Energy in Europe: Issues and Policies. London: Methuen.