Tourists at war: The visual representations of Syrian cultural and heritage sites as instrumentalized by Russian war reporters on social media,2015

Abstract

Using a semi-automated analysis of 8174 pictures posted in 5448 Vkontakte and X posts written by nine Russian war reporters covering the military operations in Syria from October 2015 to March 2020, this article examines the role played by visuals dedicated to heritage and culture in social media narratives focused on war. In a context of compromised media outlets’ autonomy in Russia, it constitutes an important case study of soft-power towards Russian-speaking audiences and public consciousness manipulation by highlighting narrative strategies to justify the military intervention in Syria (September 2015). The presence of unexpected visuals of cultural sites, sometimes damaged by the war, constitutes an entry point to communication strategies implemented by war reporters, blurring the lines between professional work and practices related to tourism.

Keywords

narrative new journalism Russia social media Syria war correspondents

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

al-Haj Saleh

(2016) Yassin al-Haj Saleh on the Syrian Majority. Pulse media. Available at: https://pulsemedia.org/2016/10/21/yassin-al-haj-saleh-on-the-syrian-majority/ (accessed 27 December 2024).

Al Jazeera (2015) ISIL video shows mass killings in Syria’s Palmyra. Available at: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2015/7/5/isil-video-shows-mass-killings-in-syrias-palmyra (accessed 27 December 2024).

Allen

Seaton

(1999) Introduction. In: Allen

Seaton

(eds) The Media of Conflict: War Reporting and Representations of Ethnic Violence. London: Zed Books, 1–9.

Bakic-Hayden

(1995) Nesting orientalisms: The case of former Yugoslavia. Slavic Review 54(4): 917–931.

Bakhshi

Shamma

Gilbert

(2014) Faces engage us: Photos with faces attract more likes and comments on Instagram. Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems – Proceedings, Toronto, 26 April–1 May, 965–974. DOI: 10.1145/2556288.2557403.

Barthes

(2000) Camera Lucida. Reflections on Photography. London: Vintage Books.

Bērziņš

(2020) The theory and practice of new generation warfare: The case of Ukraine and Syria. Journal of Slavic Military Studies 33(3): 355–380.

Boltanski

(1999) Distant Suffering: Morality, Media and Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Buchanan

(2016) ‘I felt like a tourist instead of a soldier’: War and tourism in Italy 1943–1945. American Quaterly 68(3): 593–615.

10.

Chatterje-Doody

Yablokov

(2021) Russia Today and Conspiracy Theories: People, Power and Politics on RT. London: Taylor and Francis.

11.

Chupin

(2014) Military journalism in Russia: A torn specialization. Journal of Power Institutions in Post-Soviet Societies 16(14).

12.

Daniaud-Oudeh

(2024a) Russian media correspondents in Syria: War stories in an oriental fantasyland. International Journal of Middle East Studies 56(3): 521–528.

13.

Daniaud-Oudeh

(2024b) Soft power in Russia’s strategy: Lessons from the Syrian intervention. In: Russia’s Soft Power Strategies in the MENA Region and Africa. LUISS SoG/MAECI: LUISS Mediterranean Platform, 11–23.

14.

Daucé

(2014) Military journalists and war correspondents from the USSR to Russia: Subjectivity under fire. Journal of Power Institutions in Post-Soviet Societies 16(14). DOI: 10.4000/pipss.4121.

15.

Dunkley

Clack

(2022) The Russian weaponisation of cultural heritage. In: Clack

Dunkley

(eds) Cultural Heritage in Modern Conflict. London: Routledge, 117–142.

16.

Elswah

Howard

(2020) ‘Anything that causes chaos’: The organizational behavior of Russia Today (RT). Journal of Communication 70(5): 623–645.

17.

Fahmy

Johnson

(2012) Invasion vs occupation: A hierarchy-of-influences analysis of how embeds assess influences and performance in covering the Iraq War. International Communication Gazette 74(1): 23–42.

18.

Fridman

(2020) ‘Information war’ as the Russian conceptualisation of strategic communications. RUSI Journal 165(1): 44–53.

19.

Gerasimov

(2013)Novye vyzovy trebujut pereosmyslenija form i sposobov vedenija boevyx dejstvij (New challenges require rethinking forms and methods of conducting combat operations). Military Review, February. Military–Industrial Kurier. Available at: http://vfes.ru/vpk_08_476.pdf (accessed 26 November 2024).

20.

Gfeller

(2013) Negotiating the meaning of global heritage: ‘Cultural landscapes’ in the UNESCO World Heritage Convention, 1972–92. Journal of Global History 8(3): 483–503.

21.

Gillot

(2010) Towards a socio-political history of archaeology in the Middle East: The development of archaeological practice and its impacts on local communities in Syria. Bulletin of the History of Archaeology 20(1): 4–16.

22.

Gonzalez

(2013) Securing Paradise: Tourism and Militarism in Hawai’i and the Philippines. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

23.

GOV.UK (2022) Russia cut off from UK services. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/russia-cut-off-from-uk-services (accessed 27 December 2024).

24.

Government of the Russian Federation (2022) Rasporjaženie o prisuždenii premij pravitel’stva Rossijskoj Federacii 2022 goda v oblasti sredstv massovoj informacij (Order: On Awarding Prizes of the Government of the Russian Federation for 2022 in the Field of Mass Media). Available at: http://publication.pravo.gov.ru/document/0001202301120006 (accessed 26 November 2025).

25.

Greenberg

Pyszczynski

Solomon

(1986) The causes and consequences of a need for self-esteem: A terror management theory. In: Baumeister

(ed.) Public and Private Self. New York, NY: Springer (Springer Series in Social Psychology), 189–212

26.

Hermitage Museum (2016) Mixail Piotrovskij posetil Pal’miru (Mixail Piotrovskij visited Palmyra). Available at: https://www.hermitagemuseum.org/news/news_11?lng=ru (accessed 5 July 2025).

27.

Hermitage Museum (2019) Rabočee soveščanie po vozroždeniju Pal’miry v JUNESCO (Workshop on the revival of Palmyra at UNESCO). Available at: https://www.hermitagemuseum.org/news/news_409_19?lng=ru (accessed 5 July 2025).

28.

Hermitage Museum (2020) Otkrytie vystavki ‘dve Pal’miry. Arxitektura (Opening of the exhibition ‘two Palmyras.Architecture’). Available at: https://www.hermitagemuseum.org/news/news_278_20?lng=el (accessed 5 July 2025).

29.

Higgins

(2019) The OPCW FFM’s report on the April 7th 2018 Douma chemical attack versus the open source evidence. Available at: https://www.bellingcat.com/news/uk-and-europe/2014/10/11/russian-tv-inadvertently-demonstrates-mh17-wasnt-shot-down-by-aircraft-cannon-fire/ (accessed 20 November 2024).

30.

Jansson

(2018) ‘This is not ruin tourism’: Social media and the quest for authenticity in urban exploration. In: Lyons

(ed.) Ruin Porn and the Obsession with Decay. Chichester: Palgrave Macmillan, 217–234.

31.

Karmov

(2015) Fenomen Pal’miry v obščestvennom soznanii Rossii: istorija i sovremennost’ (The phenomenon of Palmyra in the public consciousness of Russia: History and modernity). Russian Colonial Studies 1(5): 165–180.

32.

Kelly

(2016) Asymmetrical itineraries: Militarism, tourism, and solidarity in occupied Palestine. American Quarterly 68(3): 723–745.

33.

Kempf

(2002) Escalating and deescalating aspects in the coverage of the Bosnia conflict. In: Escalating and Deescalating Aspects in the Coverage of the Bosnia Conflict. University of Gothenburg, Sweden: Nordicom, 227–255.

34.

Lance Keeble

Mair

(eds) (2010) Afghanistan, War, and the Media: Deadlines and Frontlines. Bury St Edmunds: Arima Publishing.

35.

Laruelle

(2021) Russia’s Islam Balancing Securitization and Integration. Paris: IFRI.

36.

Xie

(2020) Is a picture worth a thousand words? An empirical study of image content and social media engagement. Journal of Marketing Research 57(1): 1–19.

37.

Lindler

(2009) Among the troops: Seeing the Iraq war through three journalistic vantage points. Social Problems 56(1): 21–48.

38.

Lupion

(2018) The gray war of our time: Information warfare and the Kremlin’s weaponization of Russian-language digital news. Journal of Slavic Military Studies 31(3): 329–353.

39.

Magdin

(2021) Russian propaganda in the context of the Syrian crisis. In: Khatib

(ed.) The Syrian Crisis: Effects on the Regional and International Relations. Singapore: Springer, 195–211.

40.

Marten

(2019) Russia’s use of semi-state security forces: The case of the Wagner Group. Post-Soviet Affairs 35(3): 181–204.

41.

Minca

Oakes

(2006) Travels in Paradox: Remapping Tourism. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.

42.

Nicholson

Mills

(2017) Soldier tourism in First World War Egypt and Palestine: The evidence of photography. Journal of Tourism History 9(2/3): 205–222.

43.

Open Sanctions (2024) Evgeniy Evgenievich PODDUBNYY. Available at: https://www.opensanctions.org/entities/Q4367499/.

44.

Piotrovskij

(2015) On the sacredness of culture. Available at: https://www.hermitagemuseum.org/wps/portal/hermitage/what-s-on/director-blog/blog-post/15december15/?lng= (accessed 5 July 2025).

45.

Plets

(2017) Violins and trowels for Palmyra. Anthropology Today 33(4): 18–22.

46.

Plets

(2024) Russia in Palmyra: Contextualizing the Kremlin’s postconflict heritage rehabilitation effort. Journal of Eastern Mediterranean Archaeology and Heritage Studies 12(1): 63–78.

47.

Politovskaja

(2001) A Dirty War: A Russian Reporter in Chechnya. London: Harvill Press.

48.

Pollock

(2016) Archaeology and contemporary warfare. Annual Review of Anthropology 45(1): 215–231.

49.

Porter

(2011) Military Orientalism Eastern War Through Western Eyes. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.

50.

Putin

(2013) Vystuplenie na toržestvennom sobranii, posvjaščennom 225-letiju Central’nogo duxovnogo upravlenija musul’man Rossii [Speech at the ceremonial meeting dedicated to the 225th anniversary of the Central Spiritual Administration of Muslims of Russia]. Available at: http://kremlin.ru/events/president/transcripts/19473.

51.

Putin

(2022) Order on working group for coordinating interaction between authorities and organisations on mobilisation training and social and legal protection of participants in special military operation. Available at: https://en.kremlin.ru/acts/news/70155. (accessed 10 October 2024).

52.

RBTH (2016) Archaeologist: ‘For Russia, Syria’s cultural heritage is personal’. Available at: https://www.rbth.com/international/2016/10/05/archeologist-for-russia-syrias-cultural-heritage-is-personal_636093 (accessed 5 July 2025).

53.

Ronayne

(2016) The culture of caring and its destruction in the Middle East: Women’s work, water, war and archaeology. In: Hamilakis

Duke

(eds) Archaeology and Capitalism: From Ethics to Politics. London: Taylor & Francis.

54.

Russkoe geografičeskoe obščestvo (2019) Pamjatniki Pal’miri : istorija i sovremennost’ (Monuments of Palmyra : History and modernity). Available at: https://rgo.ru/activity/redaction/photo/pamyatniki-palmiry-istoriya-i-sovremennost/ (accessed 5 July 2025).

55.

SANA (2016) Hermitage Museum Director: Roadmap set for restoring archeological sites in Palmyra. Available at: https://www.sana.sy/en/?p=83719 (accessed 5 July 2025).

56.

TASS (2016a) Shojgu nagradil medaljami žurnalistov za osveščenie operacii v Sirii (Shoigu awarded medals to journalists for covering the operation in Syria). Available at: https://tass.ru/obschestvo/3213554 (accessed 10 October 2024).

57.

TASS (2016b) Valerij Gergiev i orkestr Mariinskij dali koncert v osvoboždennoj Pal’mire (Valeri Gergiev and the Mariinsky orchestra gave a concert in freed Palmyra). Available at: https://tass.ru/kultura/3262137 (accessed 5 May 2016).

58.

TASS (2018) Russia helped to protect Christians in Syria, Patriarch Kirill says. Available at: https://tass.com/society/984135/amp (accessed 26 November 2024).

59.

Teaiwa

(1999) Reading Paul Gauguin’s Noa Noa with Epeli Hau ‘ofa’s Kisses in the Nederends: Militourism, feminism, and the ‘Polynesian’ body. In: Wilson

(ed.) Inside Out: Literature, Cultural Politics, and Identity in the New Pacific. Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield, 249–63.

60.

Tuastad

(2010) Neo-Orientalism and the new barbarism thesis: Aspects of symbolic violence in the Middle East conflict(s). Third World Quarterly 24(4): 591–599.

61.

URA (2019) Ekaterinburgskij finalist glavnogo kadrovogo konkursa strany pomožet vosstanovit’ pamjatniki v Sirii (Ekaterinburg finalist of country’s main personnel competition will help restore monuments in Syria). Available at: https://ura.news/news/1052369550 (accessed 5 July 2025).

62.

US Department of State’s Humanitarian Information Unit (2013) Syria: Cultural Heritage Sites at Risk. Available at: https://hiu.state.gov (accessed 15 Janauary 2025).

63.

Vail

, et al (2012) The aftermath of destruction: Images of destroyed buildings increase support for war, dogmatism, and death thought accessibility. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 48(5): 1069–1081.

64.

Van Nuenen

(2019) Algorithmic authenticity: Sociotechnical authentication processes on online travel platforms. Tourist Studies 19(3): 378–403.

65.

Van Oppen

(2009) Reporting from Bosnia: Reconceptualising the notion of a ‘journalism of attachment’. Journal of Contemporary European Studies 17(1): 21–33.

66.

Vandevoordt

(2016) Covering the Syrian conflict: How Middle East reporters deal with challenging situations. Media, War & Conflict 9(3): 306–324.

67.

Zelizer

(2005) Death in wartime: Photographs and the ‘other war’ in Afghanistan. Harvard International Journal of Press/Politics 10(3): 26–55.

Tourists at war: The visual representations of Syrian cultural and heritage sites as instrumentalized by Russian war reporters on social media,2015–2020

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References