This article explores whether national political agendas influenced the content of domestic and foreign television news media coverage of the 2011 Israel–Hamas Gilad Shalit prisoner exchange deal. The deal, which released Israeli soldier Shalit in exchange for 1,027 prisoners, is the largest prisoner exchange agreement in Israeli history for a single live soldier, but the third largest prisoner exchange agreement as a whole. A quantitative content analysis was conducted on 2,162 news reports from five international and national news networks – BBC, CNN, Fox and Israel’s Channels 1 and 2. The findings suggest important differences in the way foreign and national news networks cover controversial political events. Findings reveal that Israeli networks strongly aligned themselves with the government’s position, while the BBC provided the most balanced coverage. Prominent differences were found between the two US channels – CNN and Fox News. This work builds on a growing body of research on media framing of political events.
AdaySCluveriusJLivingstonS (2005) As goes the statue, so goes the war: The emergence of the victory frame in television coverage of the Iraq war. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media49(3): 314–331. DOI: 10.1207/s15506878jobem4903_4
2.
AuerbachYBloch-ElkonY (2005) Media framing and foreign policy: The elite press vis-à-vis US policy in Bosnia, 1992–95. Journal of Peace Research42(1): 83–99.
3.
BennettWLLawrenceRG (1995) News icons and the mainstreaming of social change. Journal of Communication45(3): 20–39.
4.
Bloch-ElkonY (2007) Studying the media, public opinion, and foreign policy in international crises: The United States and the Bosnian crisis, 1992–1995. Press/Politics12(4): 20–51.
5.
BlumlerJGurevitchM (1981) Politicians and the press: An essay on role relationships. In:NimmoDDSandersKR (eds) Handbook of Political Communication. Newbury Park, CA: Sage, 467–493.
6.
CaliendoSMGibneyMPPayneA (1999) All the news that is fit to print? New York Times coverage of human-rights violations. Harvard International Journal of Press/Politics4(4): 48–69.
7.
CallaghanKSchnellF (2001) Assessing the democratic debate: How the news media frame elite policy discourse. Political Communication18: 183–212.
8.
ChangTLeeJ (1992) Factors affecting gatekeepers’ selection of foreign news: A national survey of newspaper editors. Journalism Quarterly69: 554–561.
9.
ChehabZ (2007) Inside Hamas: The Untold Story of Militants, Martyrs and Spies. London: IB Tauris.
10.
CohenAAdoniHNossekH (1993) Television news and the intifada: A comparative study of social conflict. In:CohenAWolfsfeldG (eds) Framing the Intifada: People and Media. Norwood, NJ: Ablex.
11.
DardisFE (2006) Military accord, media discord: A cross-national comparison of UK vs US press coverage of Iraq war protest. International Communication Gazette68(5–6): 409–426.
12.
De VreeseCHPeterJSemetkoHA (2001) Framing politics at the launch of the euro: A cross-national comparative study of frames in the news. Political Communication18(2): 107–122.
13.
DunskyM (2001) Missing: The bias implicit in the absent. Arab Studies Quarterly23(3): 1.
14.
ElmasryM (2009) Death in the Middle East: An analysis of how the New York Times and Chicago Tribune framed killings in the Second Palestinian Intifada. Journal of Middle East Media5(1): 1–46.
15.
ElmasryM. (2013) Al-Jazeera and Al-Arabiya framing of the Israel–Palestine conflict during war and calm periods. International Communication Gazette75(8): 750–768. DOI: 10.1177/1748048513482545
16.
EntmannRM (1991) Symposium framing US coverage of international news: Contrasts in narratives of the KAL and Iran air incidents. Journal of Communication41(4): 6–27.
17.
EntmannRM (1993) Framing: Toward clarification of a fractured paradigm. Journal of Communication43(4): 51–58.
18.
EntmannRM (2004) Projections of Power: Framing News, Public Opinion, and U.S. Foreign Policy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 5–29.
19.
EntmannRMRojeckiA (1993) Freezing out the public: Elite and media framing of the U.S. anti-nuclear movement. Political Communication10: 155–173.
20.
EvansM (2008) The effect of media framing on international affairs: The Israeli–Palestinian conflict. International Studies Association’s 49th Annual Convention, Bridging Multiple Divides, San Francisco, 26 March.
21.
EvansM (2010) Framing international conflicts: Media coverage of fighting in the Middle East. International Journal of Media & Cultural Politics6(2): 209–233.
22.
FirstA (2009) Enemies, fellow victims, or the forgotten? News coverage of Israeli Arabs in the 21st century. Conflict and Communication Online9(2).
23.
FrielHFalkR (2007) Israel–Palestine on Record: How the New York Times Misreports Conflict in the Middle East. London: Verso.
24.
GaberISeymourEThomasL (2009) Review commentary: Is the BBC biased? The corporation and the coverage of the 2006 Israeli–Hezbollah war. Journalism10(2): 239–259.
25.
GamsonW (1992) Talking Politics. New York: Cambridge University Press.
26.
GamsonWA (1989) News as framing. American Behavioral Scientist32(2): 157–161.
27.
GamsonWA. (1992) Media images and the social construction of reality. Annual Review of Sociology18: 373–393.
28.
GitlinT (1980) The Whole World Is Watching: Mass Media in the Making and Unmaking of the New Left. Berkeley: University of California Press.
29.
GolanGWantaW (2003) International elections on the US network news: An examination of factors affecting newsworthiness. Gazette: The International Journal for Communication Studies65: 25–40.
30.
HallinDC (1986) The ‘Uncensored War’: The Media and Vietnam. Berkeley: University of California Press.
31.
HandleyRIsmailA (2010) Territory under siege: ‘Their’ news, ‘our’ news and ‘ours both’ news of the 2008 Gaza crisis. Media, War & Conflict3(3): 279–297.
32.
HawkinsV (2011) Media selectivity and the other side of the CNN effect: The consequences of not paying attention to conflict. Media, War & Conflict4(1): 55–68.
33.
HermanESChomskyN (1988) Manufacturing Consent: A Propaganda Model. New York: Pantheon Books.
34.
HessS (1996) International News and Foreign Correspondents. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institute.
35.
JamiesonKHWaldmanP (2003) The Press Effect: Politicians, Journalists, and the Stories that Shape the Political World. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
36.
KaraNAtabeyM (2013) Too close and too far: Framing the Iraq and Lebanon wars in the media of north Cyprus. International Communication Gazette75(2) 174–187.
37.
KarnielYLavie-DinurAAzranT (2014) Broadcast coverage of Gaddafi’s final hours in images and headlines: A brutal lynch or the desired death of a terrorist?International Communication Gazette. DOI: 1748048514562686.
KumarD (2006) Media, war, and propaganda: Strategies of information management during the 2003 Iraq war. Communication and Critical/Cultural Studies3(1): 48–69.
40.
Lavie-DinurAKarnielYSamuel-AzranT (2013) ‘Our’ criminals – Israeli press coverage of domestic political criminals. Journal of Intercultural Communication Research42(3): 275–299.
41.
LevinD (2003) Structure of news coverage of a peace process: A test of the indexing and zero-sum hypotheses. International Journal of Press/Politics8(4): 27–53.
42.
LevineE (2003) Live! Defining television quality at the turn of the 21st century. Paper presented at Media in Transition III: Television Conference, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA.
43.
LiebesT (1992) Our war/their war: Comparing the intifadeh and the gulf war on U.S. and Israeli television. Critical Studies in Mass Communication9: 44–55.
44.
LiebesT (1997) Reporting the Arab–Israeli Conflict: How Hegemony Works. London: Routledge.
45.
McManusJH (1992) What kind of commodity is news?Communication Research19(6): 787–805.
46.
NavehC (2002) The role of the media in foreign policy decision-making: A theoretical framework. Conflict & Communication Online1(2): 1–14.
47.
NewtonK (1999) Mass media effects: Mobilization or media malaise?British Journal of Political Science29(4): 577–599.
48.
NossekH (2000) Foreign news and the construction of reality: Between the mondial and Mondo Cane. Paper presented at the Conference on International News in the 21st Century, March. Leicester, Centre for Mass Communication Research.
49.
NossekH (2004) Our news and their news: The role of national identity in the coverage of foreign news. Journalism5: 343–363.
50.
OliverPEManeyGM (2000) Political process and local newspaper coverage of protest events: From selection bias to triadic interaction. American Journal of Sociology106: 463–505.
51.
OrgadS (2009) Watching how others watch us: The Israeli media’s treatment of international coverage of the Gaza War. Communication Review12(3): 250–261.
52.
PaletzDL (2002) The Media in American Politics. New York: Longman.
53.
ReeseSD (2004) Militarized journalism: Framing dissent in the Persian gulf wars. In:AllanSZelizerB (eds) Reporting the War: Journalism in Wartime. New York: Routledge.
54.
ReeseSDBuckalewB (1995) The militarism of local television: The routine framing of the Persian gulf war. Critical Studies in Mass Communication12(1): 40–59.
55.
RivenburghN (1996) Social identification and media coverage of foreign relations. In:MalekA (ed.) News Media & Foreign Relations. Norwood, NJ: Ablex.
56.
RobinsonP (2000) The policy–media interaction model: Measuring media power during humanitarian crisis. Journal of Peace Research37(5): 613–633.
57.
RosengrenKE (1974) International news: Methods, data and theory. Journal of Peace Research1: 145–156.
58.
RossSD (2003) Framing of the Palestinian–Israeli conflict in thirteen months of New York Times editorials rounding the attack of September 11, 2001. Conflict and Communication2(2).
Samuel-AzranTLavie-DinurAKarnielY (2015) Narratives used to portray in-group terrorists: A comparative analysis of the Israeli and Norwegian press. Media, War & Conflict8(1): 3–19.
61.
SavignyHMarsdenL (eds) (2013) Media, Religion and Conflict. Ashford: Ashgate.
62.
SchudsonM (2002) What’s unusual about covering politics as usual. In:ZelizerBAllanS (eds) Journalism after September 11. New York: Routledge.
63.
SilverstoneR (2007) Media and Morality. Cambridge: Polity Press.
64.
SrebernyAStevensonR (1999) Comparative analysis of international news flow: An example of global media monitoring. In:NordenstrengKGriffinMS (eds) International Media Monitoring. Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press.
65.
StevensonRLGaddyGD (1984) Bad news and the third world. In:StevensonRLShawDL (eds) Foreign News and the New World Information Order. Iowa: Iowa State University Press.
66.
TankardJW (2001) The empirical approach to the study of media framing. In:ReeseSD. (eds) Framing Public Life. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
67.
Tenenboim-WeinblattK (2011) Journalism as an agent of prospective memory. In:On Media Memory. Chichester: Palgrave Macmillan, 213–225.
68.
Tenenboim-WeinblattK (2013) Bridging collective memories and public agendas: Toward a theory of mediated prospective memory. Communication Theory23(2): 91–111.
69.
TuchmanG (1978) Making News: A Study in the Construction of Reality. New York: Free Press.
70.
ViserM (2003) Attempted objectivity: An analysis of the New York Times and Ha’aretz and their portrayals of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict. Harvard International Journal of Press/Politics8(4): 114.
71.
WagemakersJ (2010) Legitimizing pragmatism: Hamas’ framing efforts from militancy to moderation and back?Terrorism and Political Violence22(3): 358–378.
72.
WaisbordS (2002) Journalism, risk, and patriotism. In:ZelizerBAllanS (eds) Journalism afterSeptember11. New York: Routledge.
73.
WesterståhlJJohanssonF (1994) Foreign news: News values and ideologies. European Journal of Communication9: 71–89.
74.
WolfsfeldG (1997) Media and Political Conflict: News from the Middle East. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
75.
WolfsfeldG (2001) The News Media and Peace Processes: The Middle East and Northern Ireland (Peace Works No. 37). Washington, DC: United States Institute of Peace.
76.
WolfsfeldG (2004) Media and the Path to Peace. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
77.
WolfsfeldGFroshPAwabdyMT (2008) Covering death in conflicts: Coverage of the second intifada on Israeli and Palestinian television. Journal of Peace Research45(3): 401–17.
78.
WuHD (2000) Systemic determinants of international news coverage: A comparison of 38 countries. Journal of Communication50(2): 110–130.
79.
YuranN (2001) Channel 2: The New Statehood. Tel Aviv: Resling Publishing (in Hebrew).
