Violent incongruencies: Analyzing The New York Times ’s discourse on George Floyd demonstrations and the Capitol riot

Abstract

American news media outlets have a storied past of delegitimizing protest movements, particularly through violence. However, recent literature has suggested news media outlets in America are slowly beginning to pull away from this trend. Moreover, recent protest history has several memorable examples of this attempted course correction, such as CNN’s viral ‘fiery but mostly peaceful’ headline during the demonstrations following the murder of George Floyd. Along with this series of protest demonstrations, one of the most historically significant demonstrations of protest in the 2020s was the Capitol riot of January 6, 2021. This study utilized a discourse analysis methodology to explore textual and visual framing incongruencies of participant violence in The New York Times’s coverage of these historic demonstrations. Findings point to a consistent visual and textual framing of violence within the NYT’s coverage of George Floyd Demonstrations, but not within its coverage of the Capitol riot. Possible discrepancies in participant labeling were also observed.

Keywords

Capitol riot discourse analysis framing George Floyd protest paradigm

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aiello

Parry

(2020) Visual Communication: Understanding Images in Media Culture. London: Sage Publications.

Arango

Baker

Baker , et al. (2020) Fiery clashes erupt between police and protesters over George Floyd death. The New York Times, 30 May. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/30/us/minneapolis-floyd-protests.html?searchResultPosition=64 (accessed 1 August 2023)

Ashley

Olson

(1998) Constructing reality: Print media’s framing of the women's movement, 1966 to 1986. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 75(2): 263–277.

Bekiempis

Benner

Bogel-Burroughs

, et al. (2020) Protests continue to rage after death of George Floyd. The New York Times, 28 May. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/28/us/george-floyd-national-guard.html?searchResultPosition=8 (accessed 1 August 2023)

Boyle

McLeod

Armstrong

(2012) Adherence to the protest paradigm: The influence of protest goals and tactics on news coverage in U.S. And international newspapers. International Journal of Politics 17(1): 127–144.

Broadwater

Cochrane

(2021) Inside the capitol, the sound of the mob came first. The New York Times, 6 January. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/06/us/politics/photos-capitol-building-protesters.html?searchResultPosition=16 (accessed 1 August 2023)

Chrisman

Hubbs

(2021) The language of the unheard”: Rioting as a speech act. Philosophy & Public Affairs 49(4): 379–401.

Concha

(2020) CNN ridiculed for ‘fiery but mostly peaceful’ caption with video of burning building in Kenosha. The Hill, 27 August. Available at: https://thehill.com/homenews/media/513902-cnn-ridiculed-for-fiery-but-mostly-peaceful-caption-with-video-of-burning/ (accessed 1 August 2023)

Cowart

Blackstone

Riley

(2022) Framing a movement: Media portrayals of the George Floyd protests on Twitter. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 99(3): 676–695.

10.

Cox

(2022) Black Lives Matter to media (finally): A content analysis of news coverage during summer 2020. Newspaper Research Journal 43(2): 155–175.

11.

Davis

(2020) NBC bans reporters from using the word ‘riot’ in coverage of Minnesota riots. The Daily Caller, 28 May. Available at: https://dailycaller.com/2020/05/28/nbc-riot-minnesota-george-floyd/ (accessed 1 August 2023)

12.

Dickerson

(2020) ‘Please, I don’t have insurance’: Businesses plead with protesters. The New York Times, 31 May. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/31/us/minneapolis-protests-business-looting.html?searchResultPosition=77 (accessed 1 August 2023)

13.

Dworznik

(2006) Journalism and trauma: How reporters and photographers make sense of what they see. Journalism Studies 7(4): 534–553.

14.

Elmasry

Nawawy

(2017) Do Black lives matter? A content analysis of New York Times and St. Louis Post-Dispatch coverage of Michael Brown protests. Journalism Practice 11(7): 857–875.

15.

Entman

(1993) Framing: Toward clarification of a fractured paradigm. Journal of Communication 43(4): 51–58.

16.

Farhi

(2014) New Associated Press guidelines: Keep it brief. The Washington Post, 12 May. Available at: https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/new-ap-guidelines-keep-it-brief/2014/05/12/f220f902-d9ff-11e3-bda1-9b46b2066796_story.html (accessed 1 August 2023)

17.

Farnsworth

Lichter

(2012) News coverage of new presidents in The New York Times, 1981-2009. Politics & Policy 40(1): 69–91.

18.

Fausset

Levenson

(2020) Atlanta protestors clash with police as mayor warns ‘you are disgracing our city’. The New York Times, 29 May. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/29/us/atlanta-protest-cnn-george-floyd.html?searchResultPosition=58

19.

Foucault

(1972) The Archaeology of Knowledge and the Discourse on Language ( Smith

Trans.). New York, NY: Pantheon Books.

20.

Furber

Eligon

Burch

(2020) National guard called as Minneapolis erupts in solidarity for George Floyd. The New York Times, 28 May.

21.

Hsu

Robertson

(2021) Covering Pro-Trump mobs, the news media became a target. The New York Times, 6 January. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/06/business/media/media-murder-capitol-building.html?searchResultPosition=29

22.

Kanno-Youngs

Tavernise

Cochrane

(2021) As House was breached, a fear ‘we’d have to fight’ to get out. The New York Times, 6 January. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/06/us/politics/capitol-breach-trump-protests.html?searchResultPosition=25

23.

Kilgo

Mourão

(2021) Protest coverage matters: How media framing and visual communication affects support for Black civil rights protests. Mass Communication & Society 24(4): 576–596.

24.

Leatherby

Ray

Singhvi

, et al. (2021) How a presidential rally turned into a Capitol rampage. The New York Times, 12 January. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/01/12/us/capitol-mob-timeline.html (accessed 1 August 2023)

25.

Literat

Boxman-Shabtai

Kligler-Vilenchik

(2023) Protesting the protest paradigm: TikTok as a space for media criticism. The International Journal of Press/Politics 28(2): 362–383.

26.

Mares

Sun

(2010) The multiple meanings of age for television content preferences. Human Communication Research 36(3): 372–396.

27.

McCombs

Weaver

(eds) (1973) Proceedings from ICA ’73: Annual Meeting of the International Communication Association, Montreal, Canada.

28.

McLeod

(1995) Communicating deviance: The effects of television news coverage of social protest. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media 39(1): 4–19.

29.

Moniuszko

(2020) Chris Cuomo calls for police accountability: ‘Too many see the protests as the problem’. USA Today, 3 June. Available at: https://www.usatoday.com/story/entertainment/celebrities/2020/06/03/chris-cuomo-calls-police-accountability-defends-protests/3133326001/ (accessed 1 August 2023)

30.

Mourão

Brown

Sylvie

(2021) Framing Ferguson: The interplay of advocacy and journalistic frames in local and national newspaper coverage of Michael Brown. Journalism 22(2): 320–340.

31.

Pan

Kosicki

(1993) Framing analysis: An approach to news discourse. Political Communication 10(1): 55–75.

32.

Poniewozik

(2021) Donald Trump’s last picture show. The New York Times, 6 January. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/06/arts/television/donald-trump-capitol-mob-tv.html?searchResultPosition=17 (accessed 1 August 2023)

33.

Powell

Boomgaarden

De Swert

, et al. (2015) A clearer picture: The contribution of visuals and text to framing effects. Journal of Communication 65(6): 997–1017.

34.

Rose

(ed.) (2012) Visual Methodologies: An Introduction to Researching With Visual Materials, 3rd edn. London: Sage.

35.

Sandoval

(2020) Protests flare in Brooklyn over Floyd death as de Blasio appeals for Calm. The New York Times, 30 May. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/30/nyregion/nyc-protests-george-floyd.html?searchResultPosition=60 (accessed 1 August 2023)

36.

Scheufele

(1999) Framing as a theory of media effects. Journal of Communication 49(1): 103–122.

37.

Shoemaker

(1982) The perceived legitimacy of deviant political groups: Two experiments on media effects. Communication Research 9(2): 249–286.

38.

Simon

Jerit

(2007) Toward a theory relating political discourse, media, and public opinion. Journal of Communication 57(2): 254–271.

39.

Stamps

Mastro

(2020) The problem with protests: Emotional effects of race-related news media. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 97(3): 617–643.

40.

Taylor

(2020) George Floyd protests: A timeline. The New York Times, 25 May. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/article/george-floyd-protests-timeline.html?searchResultPosition=75 (accessed 1 August 2023)

41.

The Media Insight Project (2014) The personal news cycle: How Americans choose to get their news. American Press Institute, 17 March. Available at: https://americanpressinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/The_Media_Insight_Project_The_Personal_News_Cycle_Final.pdf

42.

Tonkiss

(2004) Analysing discourse. In: Seale

(ed.) Researching Society and Culture. London: Sage, pp.245–260. (accessed 1 August 2023)

43.

Tracy

(2021) New York Times adds 455,000 subscriptions in third quarter. The New York Times, 3 November. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/03/business/media/new-york-times-3q-earnings.html (accessed 1 August 2023)

44.

Tumin

Bogert

(2021) Evening briefing special edition: A pro-Trump mob storms the Capitol. The New York Times, 6 January. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/06/briefing/pro-trump-mob-storms-the-capitol.html?searchResultPosition=1 (accessed 1 August 2023)

45.

Wang

(2014) Criticising images: Critical discourse analysis of visual semiosis in picture news. Critical Arts 28(2): 264–286.

46.

Wulfsohn

(2020) NBC allegedly tells reporters not to use word ‘riots’ in George Floyd coverage . Fox News, 28 May. Available at: https://www.foxnews.com/media/nbc-news-george-floyd-coverage (accessed 1 August 2023)

47.

(2013) Framing occupy Wall Street: A content analysis of The New York Times and USA Today. Journal of International Communication 7(1): 2412–2432.

48.

Zulli

Coe

Isaacs

(2023) News framing in the aftermath of the January 6 attacks on the U.S. Capitol: An analysis of labels, definitional uncertainty, and contextualization. American Behavioral Scientist 67(6): 702–720.