Identifying three key re-categorisation processes – detachment, emulation, and sublimation – this article provides a situated analysis of the persistent legitimation attempts of Italian photographer-artists, despite photography’s widespread recognition as an artistic medium. Drawing on a two-year ethnography in Milan, Italy, and interviews with 23 members of the art photography field, the article argues that social categorisation plays an important role in the on-going artistic legitimation of photography, as it supports the coexistence of competing legitimating discourses and status hierarchies. In particular, the article discusses how these three processes of re-categorisation, in combination with each other, foster the legitimacy of photographer-artists while avoiding risks of contestation.
AccominottiF (2018) Consecration as a population-level phenomenon. American Behavioral Scientist65(1): 9–24.
2.
AlexanderVDBowlerAE (2021) Contestation in aesthetic fields: Legitimation and legitimacy struggles in outsider art. Poetics84: 101485.
3.
AndreaniMPazzagliaN (2019) Photography as Power: Dominance and Resistance Through the Italian Lens. Newcastle upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
4.
BaetensJPeetersH (2007) Hybridity: The reverse of photographic medium specificity?History of Photography31(1): 3–10.
5.
BaumannS (2007) A general theory of artistic legitimation: How art worlds are like social movements. Poetics35(1): 47–65.
6.
BeckerHS (1975) Art photography in America. Journal of Communication25(1): 74–84.
7.
BeckerHS (1982) Art Worlds. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
8.
BoschettiA (2024) Benedetto Croce: Dominio simbolico e storia intellettuale. Macerata: Quodlibet.
9.
BourdieuP (ed.) (1990 [1965]) Photography: A Middle-brow Art (trans. WhitesideS). Cambridge: Polity Press.
10.
BourdieuP (1993) The Field of Cultural Production: Essays on Art and Literature (ed. JohnsonR). Cambridge: Polity Press.
11.
BrunetF (2012) La photographie, éternelle aspirante à l’art. In: HeinichNShapiroR (eds) De l’artification: Enquêtes sur le passage à l’art. Paris: Éditions de l’École des hautes études en sciences sociales, 29–45.
12.
CelantG (2015) Fotografia maledetta e non. Milan: Feltrinelli.
13.
CharmazK (2014) Constructing Grounded Theory (2nd edn). London: Sage.
14.
ChristophersonRW (1974a) From folk art to fine art: A transformation in the meaning of photographic work. Urban Life and Culture3(2): 123–157.
15.
ChristophersonRW (1974b) Making art with machines: Photography’s institutional inadequacies. Urban Life and Culture3(1): 3–34.
16.
CnossenBBencherkiN (2023) Artful legitimacy: The role of materiality in practices of legitimation. Organization Studies44(6): 919–938.
17.
CraneD (1987) The Transformation of the Avant-Garde: The New York Art World, 1940–1985. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
18.
DelmestriGGreenwoodR (2016) How Cinderella became a queen: Theorizing radical status change. Administrative Science Quarterly61(4): 507–550.
19.
DiMaggioP (1987) Classification in art. American Sociological Review52(4): 440–455.
20.
DouglasM (1966) Purity and Danger: An Analysis of Concepts of Pollution and Taboo. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
21.
GidleyM (2011) Photography and the USA. London:Reaktion Books.
22.
GlynnMANavisC (2013) Categories, identities, and cultural classification: Moving beyond a model of categorical constraint. Journal of Management Studies50(6): 1124–1137.
23.
GrodalSKahlSJ (2017) The discursive perspective of market categorization: Interaction, power, and context. In: DurandRGranqvistNTyllströmA (eds) From Categories to Categorization: Studies in Sociology, Organizations and Strategy at the Crossroads. Leeds: Emerald, 151–184.
24.
GrundbergA (2021) How Photography Became Contemporary Art: Inside an Artistic Revolution from Pop to the Digital Age. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
25.
GualtieriG (2022) Is cuisine art? Considering art and craft as conceptual categories in American fine dining. Poetics95(4): 101705.
26.
HackingJ (2019) Photography and the Art Market. London: Lund Humphries.
27.
HackingJLukitshJ (2020) Photography and the Arts: Essays on 19th Century Practices and Debates. London: Bloomsbury Publishing.
28.
HeinichN (2004) La sociologie de l’art. Paris: La Découverte.
29.
HeinichN (2014) Le paradigme de l’art contemporain: Structures d’une révolution artistique. Paris: Éditions Gallimard.
30.
HeinichNShapiroR (eds) (2012) De l’artification: Enquêtes sur le passage à l’art. Paris: Éditions de l’École des hautes études en sciences sociales.
31.
HillSPMinghelliG (eds) (2014) Stillness in Motion: Italy, Photography, and the Meanings of Modernity. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
32.
JohnsonCDowdTJRidgewayCL (2006) Legitimacy as a social process. Annual Review of Sociology32(1): 53–78.
33.
KarpikL (2010) Valuing the Unique: The Economics of Singularities (trans. ScottN). Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
34.
KhaireMWadhwaniRD (2010) Changing landscapes: The construction of meaning and value in a new market category – modern Indian art. Academy of Management Journal53(6): 1281–1304.
35.
LamontM (2012) Toward a comparative sociology of valuation and evaluation. Annual Review of Sociology38(1): 201–221.
36.
LampelJMeyerAD (2008) Field-configuring events as structuring mechanisms: How conferences, ceremonies, and trade shows constitute new technologies, industries, and markets. Journal of Management Studies45(6): 1025–1035.
37.
LangeS (2023) In and out of the zoom: The photographic act as frame of precarity in Italy’s postcolonial cinema since 1990. Studies in European Cinema20(2): 187–208.
38.
LenaJC (2019) Entitled: Discriminating Tastes and the Expansion of the Arts. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
39.
LetellierI (2024) La légitimation et la popularisation de la photographie comme art en France (années 1970–années 1990). Doctoral Dissertation, Université Lumière – Lyon II. TEL Archives Ouvertes. Available at: https://tel.archives-ouvertes.fr/tel-05109341 (accessed 30 June 2025).
40.
MarraC (2001) Le idee della fotografia. La riflessione teorica dagli anni Sessanta ad oggi. Milan: Mondadori Bruno.
MorelG (2006) Le photoreportage d’auteur: L’institution culturelle de la photographie en France depuis les années 1970. Paris: CNRS Éditions.
43.
PaderniM (ed) (2009) Laboratorio Italia: la fotografia nell’arte contemporanea. Milan: Johan & Levi.
44.
ParkC (2009) Diversification and status signals in the art world and the art markets: A case of the fine art photography galleries of New York. Development and Society38(1): 91–122.
45.
PelizzariMA (2011) Photography and Italy. London: Reaktion Books.
46.
RouilléA (2005) La photographie: Entre document et art contemporain. Paris: Gallimard.
47.
RussoA (2011) Storia culturale della fotografia italiana: dal Neorealismo al Postmoderno. Turin: Giulio Einaudi Editore.
48.
RussoA (2022) Italian Neorealist Photography: Its Legacy and Aftermath. Milton Park: Routledge.
49.
Sagot-DuvaurouxD (2012) Le marché de la photographie contemporaine est-il soluble dans celui de l’art contemporain? In: SoulagesFTamisierM (eds) Photographie contemporaine & art contemporain. Paris: Éditions Klincksieck, 113–124.
50.
ValtortaR (2009) L’incerta collocazione della fotografia nella cultura italiana. In: Cavalli SforzaLL (ed.) La cultura italiana: Vol. IX – Musica, spettacolo, fotografia, design. Turin: UTET, 112–126.
51.
ValtortaR (2019) Photography and landscape in Italy in the 1980s: Being in a group, looking for identity. Photographies12(2): 155–175.
52.
ValtortaRMinghelliG (2014) Photography and the construction of Italian national identity. In: HillSPMinghelliG (eds) Stillness in Motion: Italy, Photography and the Meanings of Modernity. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 27–66.
53.
Van GelderHWestgeestH (2008) Photography between Poetry and Politics: The Critical Position of the Photographic Medium in Contemporary Art. Leuven: Leuven University Press.
54.
Van VenrooijASchmutzV (2018) Categorical ambiguity in cultural fields: The effects of genre fuzziness in popular music. Poetics66: 1–18.
55.
VergneJ-PWryT (2014) Categorizing categorization research: Review, integration, and future directions. Journal of Management Studies51(1): 56–94.
56.
ZaffaroniLG (2020) Distinctions between photographs matter: Theorising the artistic legitimisation of photography in Italy. Mediální Studia14(1): 34–54.
57.
ZaffaroniLG (2023) Arte nella fotografia. La legittimazione artistica della fotografia in Italia. Milan: Vita e Pensiero.
