To develop an empirical account of the impact of contemporary penal developments on frontline probation practice in England and Wales, this article will draw on a study that examined how the interrelated discourses of ‘risk management’ and public protection’ pervading probation policy in England and Wales are translated in enforcement practice. The study found a degree to resistance to the prevailing risk-focused policy agenda. Frontline probation practitioners reported that they tended to rely mainly on a compliance-oriented enforcement model underpinned by welfarist ideals reminiscent of penal modernism1.
Andrews DA and Kiessling JJ ( 1980) Program Structure and Effective Correctional Practices: A Summary of the CaVic Research, in R.R. Ross and P. Gendreau (eds) Effective Correctional Treatment, Toronto, Butterworth.
2.
Anninson J., Eadie T., and Knight C. ( 2008) People First: Probation Officer Perspectives on Probation Work, Probation Journal, 55(3): 259-271.
3.
Beckett K. ( 1997) Making Crime Pay: Law and Order in Contemporary American Politics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
4.
Beckett K. and Herbert S. ( 2008) Dealing with Disorder: Social Control in the Post-Industrial City. Theoretical Criminology. 12:5.
5.
Beyens K. and Scheirs (2010) Encounters of a Different Kind: Social Enquiry and Sentencing in Belgium. Punishment and Society. 12: 309-328.
6.
Bottoms AE ( 2001) Compliance and Community Penalties in A Bottoms, L Gelsthorpe and S Rex (Eds) Community Penalties: Change and Challenges, Devon, Willan.
7.
Box S. and Hale C. ( 1986) ‘Unemployment, Crime and Imprisonment, and the Enduring Problem of Prison Overcrowding’. In R Matthews and J Young (Eds.), Confronting crime (pp. 72-96). London: Sage.
8.
Brake M. and Hale C. ( 1992) Public Order and Private Lives: The Politics of Law and Order. London, Routledge.
9.
Burnett R. and McNeill F. ( 2005) The Place of Officer-Offender Relationship in Assisting Offenders to Desist from Crime, Probation Journal, 52 (3) 221-242.
10.
Burnett, C., Baker K., and Roberts R. ( 2007) Assessment, Supervision and Intervention: Fundamental Practice in Probation, in L Gelsthorpe and R Morgan (eds) Handbook of Probation. London: Willan.
11.
Cheliotis L. ( 2006) How Iron is the Iron Cage of New Penology? The Role of Human Agency in the Implementation of Criminal Justice Policy. Punishment and Society. 8 (3): 313-40.
12.
Deering J.(2010) Attitudes and Beliefs of Trainee Probation Officers: A ‘New Breed’ ? Probation Journal. 57, 1, 9-26.
13.
De Giorgi A. ( 2007) Toward a Political Economy of Post-Fordist Punishment . Critical Criminology. 15: 243-265.
14.
Downes DM and Rock PE ( 2003) Understanding Deviance: A Guide to the Sociology of Crime and Rule Breaking. Oxford, New York : Oxford University Press.
15.
Ellis C., Mortimer E., and Hedderman C. ( 1996) Enforcing Community Sentences: Supervisors’ Perspectives on Ensuring Compliance and Dealing with Breach. London : Home Office.
16.
Evans T. and Harris J. ( 2004) ‘Street-Level Bureaucracy, Social Work and the (Exaggerated) Death of Discretion’. British Journal of Social Work . 34 (6): 871-95.
17.
Farrall S. ( 2002) Rethinking What Works with Offenders. Devon: Willan.
18.
Feeley M. and Simon J. ( 1992) The New Penology: Emerging Strategy of Corrections and its Implications. Criminology: 30 (4) 449-74.
19.
Field S. and Nelken D. ( 2010) Reading and Writing Youth Justice in Italy and (England and) Wales. Punishment & Society. 12 (3): 287-308
20.
Fitzgibbon W. and Lea J. ( 2010) Police, Probation and the Bifurcation of Community. Howard Journal. 49 (3): 215-230.
21.
Ford PC, Pritchard et al (1997) Consumer Opinions of the Probation Service: Advice, Assistance, Befriending and the Reduction of Crime. Howard Journal of Criminal Justice . 36 (1) 42-61.
22.
Gelsthorpe L. ( 2007) ‘Probation Values and Human rights’, in L Gelsthorpe and R Morgan(eds) Handbook of Probation, London, Willan, pp. 485-517.
23.
Hearnden I. and Millie A. ( 2004) ‘Does Tougher Enforcement lead to Lower Reconviction?’Probation Journal. 5, 1, 48-58. Nellis, M. (2002) Community Justice, Time and the New National Probation Service. Howard Journal of Criminal Justice. 41, 1, 59-86.
24.
HM Inspectorate of Probation (2010) Risk of Harm Inspection Report - a Stalled Journey: An Inquiry into the Management of Offenders’ Risk of Harm to Others by London Probation in Greenwich and Lewisham, Hackney and Tower Hamlets, Merton, Sutton and Wandsworth, and Brent, Barnet and Enfield. London: HM Inspectorate of Probation.
25.
Home Office (1984) Probation Service in England and Wales: Statement of National Objectives and Priorities . London: Home Office.
26.
Home Office, Department of Health and Welsh Office ( 1992), National Standards for the Supervision of Offenders in the Community. London: Home Office .
27.
Home Office (1995) National Standards for the Supervision of Offenders in the Community. London : Home Office.
28.
Home Office (2000) The Use of Information by the Probation Services: A Thematic Inspection in 4 Parts, Part1: making National Standards Work: A Study by HMIP of Enforcement Practice in Community Penalties. London: Home Office.
29.
Home Office (2002) National Standards for the Supervision of Offenders in the Community, 2000 (Amended, 2002). London: Home Office.
30.
Home Office (2002) Offender Assessment System (OASys). London: Home Office .
31.
Home Office (2006) A Five Year Strategy for Protecting the Public and Reducing Reoffending. Command Number 6717. London: The Stationery Office .
32.
Hudson B. ( 2002) ‘Punishment and Control’ in Maguire M, Morgan R, and Reiner R (eds) (2002) Oxford Handbook of Criminology. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
33.
Kemshall H., Canton R., Bailey R., Dominey J., Simpkin B., and Yates S. ( 2002) The Effective Management of Programme Attrition: A Report for the National Probation Service. Leicester: De Montfort University.
34.
Kemshall H. and Wood J. ( 2007) ‘High Risk Offenders and Public Protection’ in L Gelsthorpe and R Morgan (eds) Handbook of Probation, London: Willan.
35.
Lipsky M. ( 1980) Street Level Bureaucracy: The Dilemmas of Individuals in Public Service. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
36.
Maguire M. and Raynor P. ( 2010) ‘Putting the OM into NOMS: Problems and Possibilities for Offender Management’ in J Brayford , F Crowe and J Deering (eds) What else Works?London: Willan, pp. 236-253.
37.
McGuire J. ( 1995) What Works: Reducing Re-offending, Chichester: Wiley Press.
38.
McNeill F. ( 2004) Supporting Desistance in Probation Practice: A Response to Maruna, Porter and Carvalho. Probation Journal. 51, 3, 241-247.
39.
McNeill F. and Robinson G. ( 2004) Purposes Matter: Examining the ‘Ends’ of Probation’ in Mair G (ed) What Matters in Probation. London: Willan .
40.
McNeill F., Burns N., Halliday S., Hutton N., and Tata C. ( 2010) Risk, Responsibility and Reconfiguration: Penal Adaptation and Misadaptation. Punishment and Society. 11 (4): 419-442.
41.
Mair G. and May C. ( 1997) Offenders on Probation, Home Office Research Study, No. 167, LondonHome Office.
42.
Ministry of Justice (2007) National Standards for the Management of Offenders: Standards and Implementation Guidance . London: Ministry of Justice.
43.
Ministry of Justice (2008) Punishment and Reform: Our Approach to Managing Offenders. London : Ministry of Justice.
44.
Ministry of Justice (2010) Breaking the Cycle: Effective Punishment, Rehabilitation and Sentencing of Offenders . London: Ministry of Justice.
45.
National Offender Management Service (2006 ) The NOMS Offender Management Model ( http://noms.justice.gov.uk/news-publications/stratgey/offedner-managemnet-model-1.1?view=Binary) Accessed 25 January 2008.
46.
National Offender Management Service (2009 ) Investigation into the issues arising from the Serious Further Offence Review: Dano Sonnex [DS] (d.o.b. 07.07.85, age 23). London: National Offender Management Service.
47.
National Probation Service (2005) National Standards. London: National Probation Directorate.
48.
Pearson G. ( 1975) Making Social Workers: Bad Promises and Good Omens, in Bailey R and Brake M (eds) Radical Social Work, London, Arnold.
49.
Phoenix J.(2010) Pre-Sentence Reports, Magisterial Discourse and Agency in the Youth Courts in England and Wales. Punishment & Society. 12 (3): 348-366
50.
Piquero A. et al (2004) Discerning Unfairness where others may not: Low Self-Control and Unfair Sanction Perceptions. Criminology . 42 (3): 699-734.
51.
Raynor P. ( 2004) The Probation Service "Pathfinders": Finding the Path and Losing the Way? Criminal Justice. 4 (3): 309-25.
52.
Rex S. ( 1999) Desistance from Offending: Experiences of Probation. The Howard Journal. 38 (4) 366-383.
53.
Robinson G. ( 2005) What Works in Offender Management, Howard Journal of Criminal Justice, 44, 3, 307-319.
54.
Robinson G. and Burnett R. ( 2007) Experiencing Modernization: Frontline Probation Perspectives on the Transition to a National Offender Management Service. Probation Journal. 54, 318.
55.
Robinson G. and McNeill F. ( 2008) Exploring the Dynamics of Compliance with Community penalties . Theoretical Criminology. 12, 431.
56.
Rusche G. and Kirchheimer O. ( 1939) Punishment and Social Structure. New York: Columbia University Press.
57.
Senior P., Crowther-Dowey C., and Long M. ( 2007) Understanding the Modernisation of Criminal Justice. Milton Keynes: Open University Press.
58.
Strauss AL and Corbin JM ( 1998) Basics of Qualitative Research: Techniques and Procedures for Developing Grounded Theory. London: Sage Publications.
59.
Treadwell J. ( 2006) Some Personal Reflections on Probation Training, Howard Journal of Criminal Justice, 45, 1, 1-13.
60.
Tyler TR ( 1990) Why People Obey the Law. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.
61.
Tyler TR ( 2010) Legitimacy in Corrections: Policy Implications’ . Criminology and Public Policy. 9(1) 127-134.
62.
Underdown A. ( 1998) Strategies for Effective Offender Supervision: London: HM Inspectorate of Probation, Home Office.
63.
Vass AA ( 1980) Law Enforcement in Community Service: Probation, Defence or Prosecution?Probation Journal. 27 (4) 114-117.
64.
Vass AA ( 1990) Alternatives to Prison: Punishment, Custody and the Community . London, Sage.
65.
Wacquant L. ( 2009) Punishing the Poor: The Neoliberal Government of Social Insecurity (Politics, History, & Culture). Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
66.
Weaver B. and McNeill F. ( 2010), Travelling Hopefully: Desistance Theory and Probation Practice, in J Brayford, F Crowe and J Deering (eds) What else Works?London: Willan.
67.
Willis A. ( 1981), Social Welfare and Social Control: A Survey of Young Men on Probation. Research Bulletin11, London: Home Office Research Unit.
68.
Young J. ( 2007) The Vertigo of Late Modernity. London : SAGE.
