Although police researchers have often assumed that perceptions of police
effectiveness enhance police legitimacy, there has been very little empirical
support for this assumption. Employing the legitimacy scale developed by Sunshine
and Tyler, this study sought to fill this gap in our criminological knowledge using
data from a representative public survey in Accra, Ghana (N= 374). The
article reports a lack of reliability, in the Ghanaian context, for the overall
Sunshine—Tyler scale, and therefore focuses attention on a sub-scale
labelled `perceptions of police trustworthiness'. The findings show that though
perceptions of police effectiveness exercise a direct impact on perceived police
trustworthiness, the relationship is stronger if the police are also perceived to be
procedurally fair. The findings are significant as they show that building public
trust in the police requires democratic reforms that simultaneously improve the
capacity of the police to achieve both substantive effectiveness and procedural
fairness.
Adu-Mireku, S.
(2002)
`Fear of Crime among Residents of Three Communities in Accra, Ghana'
, International Journal of Comparative Sociology43(2):
153-68.
Anderson, C.J.
and
Y.V. Tverdova
(2003)
`Corruption, Political Allegiances, and Attitudes towards Government in
Contemporary Democracies'
, American Journal of Political Science47(1):
91-109.
4.
Aning, E.
(2002) `An Historical Overview of the Ghana Police
Service' , in
K. Kariakri
(ed.) The Face and Phases of the Ghana Police, pp.
7-53. Accra:
Media Foundation for West Africa.
5.
Appiahene-Gyamfi, J.
(1998)
`Violent Crime in Ghana: The Case of Robbery'
, Journal of Criminal Justice26(5):
409-24.
6.
Appiahene-Gyamfi, J.
(2002)
`An Analyses [sic] of the Broad Crime Trends and Patterns in Ghana'
, Journal of Criminal Justice30(3):
229-43.
7.
Arendt, H.
(1973) The Origins of Totalitarianism.
New York: Schocken
Books.
8.
Baker, B.
(2003)
`Policing and the Rule of Law in Mozambique'
, Policing and Society13(2):
139-58.
9.
Barker, R.
(2003) `Legitimacy, Legitimation, and the European Union:
What Crisis?', in
P. Craig
and
R. Rawlings
(eds) Law and Administration , pp. 157-74.
Oxford: Oxford University
Press.
10.
Bauman, Z.
(2000) `Social Uses of Law and Order', in
D. Garland
and
R. Sparks
(eds) Criminology and Social Theory, pp.
23-45. Oxford :
Clarendon Press.
11.
Bayley, D.H.
(1995)
`A Foreign Policy for Democratic Policing'
, Policing and Society5(2):
79-93.
12.
Bayley, D.H.
and
C. Shearing
(1996)
`The Future of Policing'
, Law and Society Review30(3):
586-606.
13.
Beetham, D.
(1991) The Legitimation of Power.
London:
Macmillan.
14.
Bottoms, A.E.
(2002) `Morality, Crime, Compliance and Public Policy'
, in
A.E. Bottoms
and
M. Tonry
(eds) Ideology, Crime and Criminal Justice: A Symposium in Honour of Sir
Leon Radzinowicz, pp. 15-60.
Cullompton
, Devon:
Willan Publishing
.
15.
Bratton, M.
and
R. Mattes
(2001)
`Support for Democracy in Africa: Intrinsic or Instrumental'
, British Journal of Political Science31(3):
447-74.
16.
Bratton, M.
,
P. Lewis
and
E. Gyimah-Boadi
(2001)
`Constituencies for Reform in Ghana'
, Journal of Modern African Studies39(2):
231-59.
17.
Brogden, M.
(1982) The Police: Autonomy and Consent.
London: Academic
Press.
18.
Cao, L.
,
S. Stack
and
Y. Sun
(1998)
`Public Confidence in the Police: A Comparative Study between Japan and
America'
, Journal of Criminal Justice26(4):
279-89.
19.
Carrabine, E.
(2004) Power, Resistance and Discourse.
Aldershot:
Ashgate.
20.
Cebulak, W.
(1996)
`Rising Crime Rates amidst Transformations in Eastern Europe:
Socio-Political Transition and Societal Response'
, International Journal of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice20(1):
76-82.
21.
Coicaud, J.-M.
(2002) Legitimacy and Politics: A Contribution to the Study
of Political Right and Political Responsibility. Trans. D.A. Curtis.
Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press.
22.
Coleman, C.
and
J. Moynihan
(1996) Understanding Crime Data.
Buckingham : Open University
Press.
23.
Dasgupta, P.
(1988) `Trust as a Commodity', in
D. Gambetta
(ed.) Trust: Making and Breaking Cooperative Relations, pp.
49-71. Oxford:
Basil Blackwell .
24.
Deflem, M.
(1994)
`Law Enforcement in British Colonial Africa: A Comparative Analysis of
Imperial Policing in Nyasaland, the Gold Coast, and Kenya'
, Police Studies17(1):
45-68.
25.
De Vaus, D.A.
(1996) Surveys in Social Research, 4th edn.
London: UCL
Press.
26.
Eck, J.
and
D. Rosenbaum
(1994) `The New Police Order: Effectiveness, Equity, and
Efficiency in Community Policing', in
D. Rosenbaum
(ed.) The Challenge of Community Policing: Testing the Promises,
pp. 3-23. Los Angeles, CA:
SAGE.
27.
Ericson, R.V.
(1982) Reproducing Order: A Study of Police Patrol Work
. Toronto: Toronto University
Press .
28.
Field, A.
(2005) Discovering Statistics Using SPSS.
London:
SAGE.
29.
Fitzgerald, M.
,
M. Hough
,
I. Joseph
and
T. Quershi
(2002) Policing for London.
Devon: Willan
Publishing.
30.
Gillespie, W.H.
(1955) The Gold Coast Police: 1844-1938.
Accra: The Government
Printer.
31.
Goldsmith, A.
(2003)
`Policing Weak States: Citizen Safety and State Responsibility'
, Policing and Society13(1):
3-21.
32.
Goldsmith, A.
(2005)
`Police Reform and the Problem of Trust'
, Theoretical Criminology9(4):
443-70.
33.
Hadar, I.
and
J.R. Snortum
(1975)
`The Eye of the Beholder: Differential Perceptions of Police by Police and
the Public'
, Criminal Justice and Behaviour2(1):
37-54.
34.
Hahn, H.
(1971) `The Public and the Police: A Theoretical
Perspective' , in Police in Urban Society, pp.
9-33. Los Angeles :
SAGE.
35.
Hinds, L.
and
K. Murphy
(2007)
`Public Satisfaction with Police: Using Procedural Justice to Improve
Police Legitimacy'
, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology40(1):
27-43.
36.
Ho, T.
and
J. McKean
(2004)
`Confidence in the Police and Perceptions of Risk'
, Western Criminology Review5(2):
108-18.
37.
Holmes, L.
(1993) The End of Communist Power: Anti-Corruption Campaigns
and Legitimation Crisis. Cambridge:
Polity Press.
38.
Jesilow, P.
,
J.A. Meyer
and
N. Namazzi
(1995)
`Public Attitudes towards the Police'
, American Journal of Police19(2):
67-88.
39.
Junger, M.
and
I.H. Marshall
(1997)
`The Interethnic Generalizability of Social Control Theory: An Empirical
Test'
, Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency34(1):
79-112.
40.
Karikari, K.
(2002) `Introduction', in The Face and Phases of
the Ghana Police, pp. 1-5.
Accra: Media Foundation for West
Africa.
41.
Karstedt, S.
(2003)
`Legacies of a Culture of Inequality: The Janus Face of Crime in
Post-Communist Countries', Crime
, Law and Social Change40(2/3):
295-320.
42.
Killingray, D.
(1991) `Guarding the Extended Frontier: Policing the Gold
Coast, 1865-1913', in
D.M. Anderson
and
D. Killingray
(eds) Policing the Empire: Government, Authority and Control,
1830-1940, pp. 106-25.
Manchester
& New York:
Manchester University Press.
43.
Lewis, P.G.
(1984) `Legitimation and Political Crises: East European
Developments in Post Stalin Period', in
P.G. Lewis
(ed.) Eastern Europe: Political Crisis and Legitimation , pp.
1-41. Sydney:
Croom Helm.
44.
Luhmann, N.
(1979) Trust and Power.
Chichester : John Wiley &
Sons.
45.
Manning, P.K.
(2003) Policing Contingencies.
Chicago, IL: University of Chicago
Press.
46.
Pinkard, T.
(2003) `MacIntyre's Critique of Modernity', in
M.C. Murphy
(ed.) Alasdair MacIntyre, pp. 176-99.
Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press.
47.
Reiner, R.
(1992)
`Policing a Postmodern Society'
, Modern Law Review55(6):
761-81.
48.
Reiner, R.
(2000) The Politics of the Police.
Oxford: Oxford University
Press.
49.
Ren, L.
,
L. Cao
,
N. Lovrich
and
M. Gaffney
(2005)
`Linking Confidence in the Police with the Performance of the Police:
Community Policing can Make a Difference'
, Journal of Criminal Justice33(1):
55-66.
50.
Roberts, J.
and
J.M. Hough
(2005) Understanding Public Attitudes to Criminal
Justice . Maidenhead: Open
University Press .
51.
Rothschild, J.
(1977)
`Observation on Legitimacy in Contemporary Europe'
, Political Science Quarterly92(3):
487-501.
52.
Runciman, D.
(1997) Pluralism and the Personality of the State.
Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press.
53.
Sherman, L.W.
and
J.E. Eck
(2002) `Policing for Crime Prevention', in
L.W. Sherman
,
D.P. Farrington
,
B.C. Welsh
and
D.L. MacKenzie
(eds) Evidence-Based Crime Prevention, pp.
295-329. London:
Routledge .
54.
Sunshine, J.
and
T.R. Tyler
(2003)
`The Role of Procedural Justice and Legitimacy in Shaping Public Support
for Policing'
, Law and Society Review37(3):
513-48.
55.
Tankebe, J.
(2007) Policing and Legitimacy in a Post-Colonial Democracy:
A Theoretical and Empirical Study of Ghana. PhD Thesis (unpublished),
University of Cambridge
.
56.
Tankebe, J.
(2008)
`Colonialism, Legitimation and Policing in Ghana'
, International Journal of Law, Crime and Justice36(1):
67-84.
57.
Tyler, T.R.
(1990) Why People Obey the Law.
Yale : Yale University
Press.
58.
Tyler, T.R.
(2003) `Procedural Justice, Legitimacy and the Effective Rule
of Law', in
M. Tonry
(ed.) Crime and Justice, vol. 30, pp.
283-357. Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press.
59.
Tyler, T.R.
and
Y.J. Huo
(2002) Trust in the Law: Encouraging Public Cooperation with
the Police and Courts. New York:
Russell-Sage Foundation.
60.
United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC)
(2005) Crime and Development in Africa. Available at
http://www.unodc.org/pdf/African_report.pdf (accessed 15 October
2006).
61.
Walker, A.
,
C. Kershaw
and
S. Nicholas
(2006) Crime in England and Wales, 2005/2006. Home Office
Statistical Bulletin. London:
Home Office.
62.
Ward, W.B.F.
(1948) A History of Ghana.
London: G. Allen &
Unwin.
63.
Weitzer, R.
and
S.A. Tuch
(2004)
`Race and Perceptions of Police Misconduct'
, Social Problems51(3):
305-25.
64.
Zedner, L.
(2003)
`Too much Security?'
, International Journal of the Sociology of Law31(3):
155-84.
65.
Zedner, L.
(2006)
`Liquid Security: Managing the Market for Crime Control'
, Criminology and Criminal Justice6(3):
267-88.
