Vulnerability or resilience tweets? A comparative analysis of media outlets versus non-governmental organizations visual representations of the 2023 Morocco earthquake survivors

Abstract

This comparative study explores the vulnerability/resilience visual framing pattern in the survivors-related visuals tweeted by 16 media outlets and 18 non-governmental organizations during the 2023 Morocco earthquake. The study proposes a vulnerability/resilience framework and investigates its potential impact on X engagement metrics. The results indicate discrepancies between media outlets and non-governmental organizations in their vulnerability/resilience perspectives as well as their gendered representations of the survivors. Theoretical and practical implications of visual framing and strategic crisis communication are further discussed.

Keywords

Morocco earthquake non-governmental organizations media vulnerability resilience visual framing natural disasters

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abitbol

Lee

(2017) Messages on CSR-dedicated Facebook pages: What works and what doesn’t. Public Relations Review 43(4): 796–808.

Africanews (2023, September 11) Earthquake in Morocco: France tries to hide diplomatic tensions.

Ali

(2013) Media myths and realities in natural disasters. European Journal of Business and Social Sciences 2(1): 125–133.

Ali

(2014) Visual representation of gender in flood coverage of Pakistani print media. Weather and Climate Extremes 4: 35–49.

Amores

Calderón

Stanek

(2019) Visual frames of migrants and refugees in the main Western European media. Economics & Sociology 12(3): 147–161.

Azad

Hossain

Nasreen

(2013) Flood-induced vulnerabilities and problems encountered by women in northern Bangladesh. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science 4: 190–199.

Bankoff

(2001) Rendering the world unsafe: ‘Vulnerability’ as western discourse. Disasters 25(1): 19–35.

Bennett

Wells

Freelon

(2011) Communicating civic engagement: Contrasting models of citizenship in the youth web sphere. Journal of Communication 61(5): 835–856.

Bergh

(2010) Assessing local governance innovations in Morocco in light of the participatory budgeting experience in Brazil: The case of “civil society” federations (spaces associations) in Al Haouz Province. Journal of Economic and Social Research 12(1): 113–138.

10.

Berns

(2017) Framing the Victim: Domestic Violence, Media, and Social Problems. London, UK; New York, NY: Routledge.

11.

Blondheim

Liebes

(2003) From disaster marathon to media event: Live television’s performance on September 11, 2001 and September 11, 2002. Crisis Communications: Lessons from September 11: 185–197.

12.

Borah

Irom

(2021) To donate or not to donate: Visual framing of the Rohingya refugees, attitude towards refugees and donation intentions. Journal of Refugee Studies 34(4): 4381–4405.

13.

British Red Cross (2023) Morocco earthquake: latest news and updates.

14.

Cannon

(2002) Gender and climate hazards in Bangladesh. Gender & Development 10(2): 45–50.

15.

Center for Disaster Philanthropy (2023, September 21) Morocco earthquake.

16.

Chung

Lee

(2019) Visual CSR messages and the effects of emotional valence and arousal on perceived CSR motives, attitude, and behavioral intentions. Communication Research 46(7): 926–947.

17.

Cohen

(2013) States of Denial: Knowing about Atrocities and Suffering. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.

18.

Coleman

(2015) Image and Emotion in Voter Decisions. The Affect Agenda. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.

19.

Corell

Betsill

(2008) Analytical framework: Assessing the influence of NGO diplomats. In: NGO Diplomacy: The Influence of Nongovernmental Organizations in International Environmental Negotiations. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, pp.19–42.

20.

Dan

(2018) Integrative Framing Analysis: Framing Health Through Words and Visuals. London, UK: Taylor & Francis, p.182.

21.

Dasgupta

(2018) Gender portrayal in age of social networking sites: An analytical discussion. Amity Journal of Media and Communications Studies (AJMCS) 8(1).

22.

Deacon

(2003) Non-governmental organisations and the media. In: News, Public Relations and Power. London, UK: Sage Publications Ltd, pp.99–116.

23.

Dogra

(2007) ‘Reading NGOs visually’—Implications of visual images for NGO management. Journal of International Development: The Journal of the Development Studies Association 19(2): 161–171.

24.

Dogra

(2011) The mixed metaphor of ‘Third World Woman’: Gendered representations by international development NGOs. Third World Quarterly 32(2): 333–348.

25.

Entman

(1991) Framing US coverage of international news: Contrasts in narratives of the KAL and Iran air incidents. Journal of Communication 41(4): 6–27.

26.

Entman

(1993) Framing: Toward clarification of a fractured paradigm. Journal of Communication 43(4): 51–58.

27.

Euronews (2023, September 12) Rescue teams are frustrated that Morocco did not accept more international help after earthquake.

28.

Forbes-Mewett

Nguyen-Trung

(2019) Defining vulnerability. In: Vulnerability in a Mobile World. Leeds, UK: Emerald Publishing Limited, pp.5–27.

29.

Fordham

(1999) The intersection of gender and social class in disaster: Balancing resilience and vulnerability. International Journal of Mass Emergencies & Disasters 17(1): 15–36.

30.

Gale

Lewis

(2020) When the camera does lie: Selfies are dishonest indicators of dominance. Psychology of Popular Media 9(4): 447.

31.

Gathara

(2023, September 27) Decolonise how?: “we want to help you, but your government won’t let us”. The New Humanitarian.

32.

Geise

(2017) Visual framing. The International Encyclopedia of Media Effects 4: 1–12.

33.

Gupta

Lamba

Kumaraguru

, et al. (2013, May) Faking sandy: Characterizing and identifying fake images on twitter during hurricane sandy. In: Proceedings of the 22nd international conference on World Wide Web, pp.729–736.

34.

Hansson

Orru

Siibak

, et al. (2020) Communication-related vulnerability to disasters: A heuristic framework. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 51: 101931.

35.

Hove

Paek

Isaacson

, et al. (2013) Newspaper portrayals of child abuse: Frequency of coverage and frames of the issue. Mass Communication and Society 16(1): 89–108.

36.

Hughes

Palen

(2009) Twitter adoption and use in mass convergence and emergency events. International Journal of Emergency Management 6(3-4): 248–260.

37.

Jenkins

(2006) Small business champions for corporate social responsibility. Journal of Business Ethics 67: 241–256.

38.

Kim

Yang

(2017) Like, comment, and share on Facebook: How each behavior differs from the other. Public Relations Review 43(2): 441–449.

39.

Korf

(2007) Antinomies of generosity: Moral geographies and post-tsunami aid in Southeast Asia. Geoforum; Journal of Physical, Human, and Regional Geosciences 38(2): 366–378.

40.

Kortendiek

Oertel

(2023) Caught between vulnerability and competence–UNHCR’s visual framing of refugees, economic threat perceptions and attitudes toward asylum seekers in Germany. Journal of Immigrant & Refugee Studies Advance Online Publication: 1–17. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15562948.2023.2179151.

41.

Lee

Lim

Shi

(2022) Visually framing disasters: Humanitarian aid organizations’ use of visuals on social media. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 0(0). DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/10776990221081046.

42.

Le Monde Africa (2023, September 13) Morocco earthquake: according to a French NGO, the authorities could have accepted a little more help.

43.

Xie

(2020) Is a picture worth a thousand words? An empirical study of image content and social media engagement. Journal of Marketing Research 57(1): 1–19.

44.

Metz

Elshamy

(2023, September 11) Moroccans sleep in the streets for 3rd night following an earthquake that took more than 2,100 lives. AP News.

45.

Miller

LaPoe

(2016) Visual agenda-setting, emotion, and the BP oil disaster. Visual Communication Quarterly 23(1): 53–63.

46.

Mitchell

Tanner

Lussier

(2007) ‘We know what we need’: South Asian women speak out on climate change adaptation.

47.

Nelson

Meadows

Cannon

, et al. (2002) Uncertain predictions, invisible impacts, and the need to mainstream gender in climate change adaptations. Gender & Development 10(2): 51–59.

48.

Neumayer

Plümper

(2007) The gendered nature of natural disasters: The impact of catastrophic events on the gender gap in life expectancy, 1981–2002. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 97(3): 551–566.

49.

Nwabueze

Oduah

(2015) Media re-victimization of rape victims in a shame culture? Exploring the framing and representation of rape cases in Nigerian dailies. Global Media Journal 13(24): 1–20.

50.

Ordenes

Grewal

Ludwig

, et al. (2019) Cutting through content clutter: How speech and image acts drive consumer sharing of social media brand messages. Journal of Consumer Research 45(5): 988–1012.

51.

Pond

(2016) The space between us: Twitter and crisis communication. International Journal of Disaster Resilience in the Built Environment 7(1): 40–48.

52.

Poulsen

(2007) Firsthand reports from California wildfires pour through Twitter. Wired.

53.

Raja-Yusof

Norman

Abdul-Rahman

, et al. (2016) Cyber-volunteering: Social media affordances in fulfilling NGO social missions. Computers in Human Behavior 57: 388–397.

54.

Rodriguez

Dimitrova

(2011) The levels of visual framing. Journal of Visual Literacy 30(1): 48–65.

55.

Rose

(2004) Defining and measuring economic resilience to disasters. Disaster Prevention and Management: An International Journal 13(4): 307–314.

56.

Seo

(2020) Transnational nonprofits’ social media use: A survey of communications professional and an analysis of organizational characteristics. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 49(4): 849–870.

57.

Shao

(2009) Understanding the appeal of user-generated media: A uses and gratification perspective. Internet Research 19(1): 7–25.

58.

Smith

Gallicano

(2015) Terms of engagement: Analyzing public engagement with organizations through social media. Computers in Human Behavior 53: 82–90.

59.

Spence

Lachlan

Lin

, et al. (2015) Variability in twitter content across the stages of a natural disaster: Implications for crisis communication. Communication Quarterly 63(2): 171–186.

60.

Stirrat

(2006) Competitive humanitarianism: Relief and the tsunami in Sri Lanka. Anthropology Today 22(5): 11–16.

61.

Strasburger

Wilson

Jordan

(2009) Children, Adolescents, and the Media. Los Angeles, CA: Sage.

62.

Sun

Liu

(2023) Identifying different frames of resilience–vulnerability nexus in disaster study. Environmental Hazards 23(2): 113–129.

63.

Tucker

(2011) Governing global civil society: The WTO, NGOs and the politics of traditional knowledge and biodiversity . Doctoral Dissertation, University of Bristol.

64.

UNICEF (2023, September 11) At least 100,000 children affected by Morocco earthquake.

65.

Vital Voices (2023, September 13) Morocco earthquake response: Vital voices urges prioritizing support to local women-led organizations.

66.

Wisner

Blaikie

Cannon

, et al. (2004) At Risk: Natural Hazards, People’s Vulnerability and Disasters. London, UK: Routledge.