Framing the flight MH370 mystery: A content analysis of Malaysian,Chinese,and U.S. media

Abstract

This study analyzes frames related to the flight MH370 disappearance in Malaysian (N = 93), Chinese (N = 155), and U.S. (N = 150) newspapers. The results provide insight about media orientations in an international crisis, particularly regarding national interests and international citizenship. Attribution of responsibility is the dominant frame; secondary frames vary among conflict and human-interest frames, demonstrating that attribution of responsibility is the most important frame even with unknown controllability and ambiguous intentionality. Results also demonstrate significant differences in national interest frames and in the roles in the societal evaluation of risk. This study contextualizes the results in media systems, diplomatic relations, and cultures.

Keywords

Crisis communication framing international citizenship international crisis national interests

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abas A, Jamaludin MH, Abdullah NI, et al. (2014) Doppler effect used to track jet. New Straits Times, 26 March, 7.

Akhavan-Majid

Ramaprasad

(1989) Framing and ideology: A comparative analysis of U.S. and Chinese newspaper coverage of the Fourth United Nations Conference on Women and the NGO Forum. Mass Communication and Society 1(3/4): 131–152.

Gower

(2009) How do the news media frame crises? A content analysis of crisis news coverage. Public Relations Review 35(2): 107–112.

Andres L (2014) Eyes of the world are on us. New Straits Times, 16 March, 23.

Arumugam T (2014) Tripartite meeting positive and productive. New Straits Times, 8 May, 8.

Australian Transport Safety Bureau (2016) Joint agency coordination center: MH370 operational search update. Available at: https://www.atsb.gov.au/mh370-pages/updates/operational-update/.

Bereciartu GJ (1994) Decline of the Nation-State (Trans. Douglass WA). Las Vegas: University of Nevada Press.

Bradsher K (2014). Australia to revisit area of Indian Ocean in search for missing jet. The New York Times, 18 June, A4.

Brewer

(2006) National interest frames and public opinion about world affairs. The Harvard International Journal of Press/Politics 11(4): 89–99.

10.

Brown

(2005) The rough and rosy road: Sites of contestation in Malaysia’s shackled media industry. Pacific Affairs 78: 39–56.

11.

Bryant

Miron

(2004) Theory and research in mass communication. Journal of Communication 54(4): 662–704.

12.

Carragee

Roefs

(2004) The neglect of power in recent framing research. Journal of Communication 54(2): 214–233.

13.

Centre for Aviation (2014) Malaysia airlines 1H2015 outlook: More losses as capacity levels are maintained prior to transition. Available at: http://centreforaviation.com/analysis/malaysia-airlines-1h2015-outlook-more-losses-as-capacity-levels-are-maintained-prior-to-transition-201123.

14.

China Daily (2014a) Experts emphasize China’s role in rescue mission, 10 March.

15.

China Daily (2014b) Chinese naval vessels move southward in MH370 search, 16 April.

16.

China Daily (2014c) MH370 families unite so seek answers, 25 August.

17.

Cho

Gower

(2006) Framing effect on the public’s response to crisis: Human interest frame and crisis type influences responsibility and blame. Public Relations Review 32(4): 420–422.

18.

Coombs

(2007) Protecting organization reputations during a crisis: The development and application of situational crisis communication theory. Corporate Reputation Review 10(3): 163–176.

19.

Coombs

Holladay

(1996) Communication and attribution in a crisis: An experiment study in crisis communication. Journal of Public Relations 8(4): 279–295.

20.

Dai

Hyun

(2010) Global risk, domestic framing: Coverage of the North Korean nuclear test by US, Chinese, and South Korean news agencies. Asian Communication Journal 20(3): 299–317.

21.

Defense News (2013) Defense news top 100 for 2013. Available at: http://special.defensenews.com/top-100/charts/rank_2013.php?c=FEAands=T1C.

22.

Dorogi

(2001) Tainted Perceptions, Lanham, MD: University Press of American.

23.

Downing

JDH

Trouble in the backyard: Soviet media reporting on the Afghanistan conflict. Journal of Communication. 198838(2): 5–32.

24.

Entman

(1991) Framing U.S. coverage of international news: Contrasts in narratives of the KAL and Iran air incidents. Journal of Communication 41(4): 6–27.

25.

Entman

(1993) Framing: Toward clarification of a fractured paradigm. Journal of Communication 43(4): 51–58.

26.

Entman

(2005) Projections of Power: Framing News, Public Opinion, and U.S. Foreign Policy, Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

27.

Feng B and Wong E (2014) Anger over plane turns to frustration. The New York Times, 11 March, A6.

28.

Feng

Brewer

Ley

(2012) Framing the Chinese baby formula scandal: A comparative analysis of US and Chinese news coverage. Asian Journal of Communication 22(3): 253–269.

29.

Freitag

Stokes

(2009) Global Public Relations: Spanning Borders, Spanning Cultures, New York: Routledge.

30.

Gallup (2012) Global index of religiosity and atheism. Available at: http://www.wingia.com/web/files/news/14/file/14.pdf.

31.

Gamson

Croteau

Hoynes

et al. (1992) Media images and the social construction of reality. Annual Review of Sociology 18: 373–393.

32.

Ghanem

(1997) Filling in the tapestry: The second level of agenda setting. In: McCombs

Shaw

Weaver

(eds) Communication and Democracy: Exploring the Intellectual Frontiers in Agenda-Setting Theory, Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, pp. 3–14.

33.

Glum J (2016) Flight MH370 update: Search for missing plane prompts victims’ families to seek legal help from American lawyers. Available at: http://www.ibtimes.com/flight-mh370-update-search-missing-plane-prompts-victims-families-seek-legal-help-2431672

34.

Goffman

(1974) Frame Analysis: An Essay on the Organization of Experience, Boston, MA: Northeastern University Press.

35.

Gotsi

Lopez

Andriopoulos

(2011) Building country image through corporate image: Exploring the factors that influence the image transfer. Journal of Strategic Marketing 19(3): 255–272.

36.

Grant KB (2014) 2014: Deadly year for flying – But safer than ever. CNBC, 30 December. Available at: http://www.cnbc.com.

37.

Hachten

(1987) The World News Prism: Changing Media of International Communication, Ames: Iowa State University Press.

38.

Hall

(1980) Encoding/decoding. In: Hall

Hobson

Lowe

et al. (eds) Culture, Media, Language: Working Papers in Cultural Studies, 1972–79, London: Routledge, pp. 128–138.

39.

Hall

(1997) The work of representation. In: Hall

(ed.) Representation: Cultural Representations and Signifying Practices, London: SAGE, pp. 13–64.

40.

Hamid AJ (2014) Hard decisions lie ahead for MAS. New Straits Times, 27 March, 6.

41.

Hassid

Repnikova

(2016) Why Chinese print journalists embrace the Internet. Journalism 17(7): 882–898.

42.

The Hofstede Center (n.d.) Available at: http://geert-hofstede.com.

43.

Hook

(2006) Framing Sino-American relations under stress: A reexamination of news coverage of the 2001 spy plane crisis. Asian Affairs: An American Review 33(3): 167–183.

44.

Hou L and Zhu X (2014) ‘I know what they are feeling.’ China Daily, 19 July.

45.

Hume

(2010) Memory matters: The evolution of scholarship in collective memory and mass communication. The Review of Communication 10: 181–196.

46.

Hussain H, Abas A, David A, et al. (2014a) ‘We will spare nothing in our search efforts’. New Straits Times, 14 March, 3.

47.

Hussain H, Abas A, Dermawan A, et al. (2014b) Regent: It’s heart-wrenching. New Straits Times, 1 April, 7.

48.

Hussain H, Karim, FN, Abas A, et al. (2014c) Netizens show they care. New Straits Times, 17 March, 5.

49.

International Air Transport Association (2014) Annual review. Available at: http://www.iata.org/publications/Documents/iata-annual-review-2014-en.pdf.

50.

Jalarajan Raj

Sreekumar

(2012) Covenant cog or functional fourth estate: A survey of Malaysian journalists’ attitude towards their profession. Jurnalism si Comunicare 7(1): 16–32.

51.

Jamieson A and Ciganinero J (2015) MH370 flaperon is confirmed as first debris from missing Malaysian flight. Available at: http://www.nbcnews.com/storyline/missing-jet/mh370-flaperon-confirmed-first-debris-missing-malaysia-flight-n421061.

52.

Knight

(1999) Getting past the impasse: Framing as a tool for public relations. Public Relations Review 25(3): 381–398.

53.

Kucherenko

Christen

(2014) Ability to spot and resist manipulated news media about international affairs: Does political knowledge provide it? Central European Journal of Communication 12: 51–66.

54.

Latif R (2014) Najib: Real-time tracking of aircraft long overdue. New Straits Times, 15 May, 2.

55.

Lee

(2004) Audience-oriented approach to crisis communication: A study of Hong Kong consumers’ evaluation of an organizational crisis. Communication Research 31(5): 600–618.

56.

Lee

FLF

(2011) Symbolic use of decisive events: Tiananmen as a news icon in the editorials of the elite U.S. press. The International Journal of Press/Politics 16(3): 335–356.

57.

Lee

Basnyat

(2013) From press release to news: Mapping the framing of the 2009 H1N1 A influenza pandemic. Health Communication 28(2): 119–132.

58.

(2003) National interest and coverage of U.S.-China relations: A content analysis of The New York Times and People’s Daily (1987–1996). International Communication Bulletin 38: 29–41.

59.

Lingan L (2014) Union’s quit demand to CEO draws flak. New Straits Times, 27 March, 12.

60.

Liu

Pennington-Gray

(2015) Bed bugs bite the hospitality industry? A framing analysis of bed bug news coverage. Tourism Management 48: 33–42.

61.

Luther

Zhou

(2005) Within the boundaries of politics: News framing of SARS in China and the United States. Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly 82(4): 857–872.

62.

McCombs

(2005) A look at agenda-setting: Past, present and future. Journalism Studies 6(4): 543–557.

63.

McCombs

Llamas

Lopez-Escobar

et al. (1997) Candidate images in Spanish elections: Second-Level agenda-setting effects. Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly 74(4): 703–717.

64.

McLuskey

Kim

(2012) Moderatism or polarization: Representations of advocacy groups’ ideology in newspapers. Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly 89(4): 565–584.

65.

Malaysia Airlines (2014) Malaysia Airlines flight incident (news release). Available at: http://www.malaysiaairlines.com/my/en/site/mh370.html.

66.

Malaysia Airlines’ future still uncertain (2016) Available at: http://www.skynews.com.au/news/world/asiapacific/2016/03/08/malaysia-airlines–future-still-uncertain.html.

67.

Mao

(2014) Cosmopolitanism and global risk: News framing of the Asian financial crisis and the European debt crisis. International Journal of Communication 8: 1029–1048.

68.

Massey

(2000) How three Southeast-Asian newspapers framed “The Haze” of 1997–98. Asian Journal of Communication 10(1): 72–94.

69.

Mehra

(1993) Introduction. In: Mehra

(ed.) Press Systems in ASEAN States, Singapore: Asian Media Information and Communication, pp. 1–11.

70.

Menon

(1998) Forward. In: Latif

(ed.) Walking the Tightrope: Press Freedom and Professional Standards in Asia, Singapore: Asian Media Information and Communication, pp. iv–iiiv.

71.

Missing Malaysia Airlines MH370 (2014) Available at: http://www.news.com.au/world/missing-malaysia-airlines-mh370-a-media-challenge/story-fndir2ev-1226859718262.

72.

Molleda

(2011) Advancing the theory of cross-national conflict shifting: A case discussion and quantitative content analysis of a transnational crisis’ newswire coverage. International Journal of Strategic Communication 5(1): 49–70.

73.

Neuendorf

(2002) The Content Analysis Guidebook, Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

74.

Neuman

Just

Crigler

(1992) Common Knowledge, Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

75.

New Straits Times (2014) Cyber troopers ‘out to tarnish image’, 8 April.

76.

New York Times (2014) Frustration turns to anger over missing flight, 10 March.

77.

Nossek

(2004) Our new and their news: The role of national identity in the coverage of foreign news. Journalism 5(3): 343–368.

78.

Novais

(2007) National influence in foreign news. The International Communication Gazette 69(6): 553–573.

79.

Orgeret

(2010) Mediated culture and the well-informed global citizen: Images of Africa in the global north. Nordicom Review 31(2): 47–61.

80.

Ostini

Fung

AYF

(2002) Beyond the four theories of the press: A new model of national media systems. Mass Communication and Society 5(1): 41–56.

81.

Paletz

Vinson

(1994) Constructing content and delimiting choice: International coverage of KAL Flight 007. Argumentation 8: 357–370.

82.

Palmlund

(1992) Social drama and risk evaluation. In: Krimsky

Golding

(eds) Social Theories of Risk, Westport, CT: Praeger, pp. 197–212.

83.

Palmlund

(2009) Risk and social dramaturgy. In: Heath

O’Hair

(eds) Handbook of Risk and Crisis Communication, New York: Routledge, pp. 192–204.

84.

Pan

Kosicki

(1993) Framing analysis: An approach to news discourse. Political Communication 10(1): 55–75.

85.

Park

Reber

(2010) Using public relations to promote health: A framing analysis of public relations strategies among health associations. Journal of Health Communication 15(1): 39–54.

86.

Park

(2013) Contrasts in the coverage of Korea and Japan by US television networks: A frame analysis. International Communication Gazette 65(2): 145–164.

87.

Park

Bier

Palenchar

(2016) Framing a mystery: Information subsidies and media coverage of Malaysia Airlines flight 370. Public Relations Review 42(4): 654–664.

88.

Paterson

(1999) Agency source influence on television foreign reporting: Case of Mururoa and Tahiti. Asia Pacific Media Educator 7(2): 16–36.

89.

Pert

(2014) Australia as a Good International Citizen, Annandale: The Federation Press.

90.

Pinsdorf

(1991) Flying different skies: How cultures respond to airline disasters. Public Relations Review 17(1): 37–56.

91.

Quest

The Vanishing of Flight MH370: The True Story of the Hunt for the Missing Malaysian Plane. 2016New York: Berkley.

92.

Ramanathan

(2016) Cross-cultural perspectives and influences in reporting airline disasters: The MH370 episode. Media Asia 43(1): 23–34.

93.

Riffe

Lacy

Fico

(2005) Analyzing Media Messages: Using Quantitative Content Analysis in Research, New York: Routledge.

94.

Ruigrok

van Atteveldt

(2007) Global angling with a local angle: How U.S., British, and Dutch newspapers frame global and local terrorist attacks. The Harvard International Journal of Press and Politics 12(1): 68–90.

95.

Said

(1993) Culture and Imperialism, New York: Knopf.

96.

Sani

MAM

(2005) Media freedom in Malaysia. Journal of Contemporary Asia 35(3): 341–367.

97.

Santos

Tainsky

Schmidt

et al. (2013) Framing the octagon: An analysis of news-media coverage of mixed martial arts. International Journal of Sport Communication 6(1): 66–86.

98.

Schattle

(2015) Global citizenship as a national project: The evolution of segye shimin in South Korean public discourse. Citizenship Studies 19(1): 53–68.

99.

Scherer

(2016) The FCC’s rules and policies regarding media ownership, attribution, and ownership diversity. Journal of Current Issues in Media and Telecommunications 8(1): 45–66.

100.

Scheufele

Tewksbury

(2007) Framing, agenda setting, and priming: The evolution of three media effects models. Journal of Communication 57(1): 9–20.

101.

Schultz

Kleinnijenhuis

Oegema

et al. (2012) Strategic framing in the BP crisis: A semantic network analysis of associative frames. Public Relations Review 38(1): 97–107.

102.

Semetko

Valkenburg

(2000) Framing European politics: A content analysis of press and television news. Journal of Communication 50(2): 93–109.

103.

Shoemaker

Reese

(1996) Mediating the Message: Theories of Influences on Mass Media Content, London: Longman.

104.

Steele

(2011) Justice and journalism: Islam and journalistic values in Indonesia and Malaysia. Journalism 12(5): 533–549.

105.

Steele

(2013) ‘Trial by the press’: An examination of journalism, ethics, and Islam in Indonesia and Malaysia. The International Journal of Press/Politics 18(3): 342–359.

106.

Tai

Sun

(2007) Media dependencies in a changing media environment: The case of the 2003 SARS epidemic in China. New Media and Society 9(6): 987–1009.

107.

Taylor

Kent

(1999) Challenging assumptions of international public relations: When government is the most important public. Public Relations Review 25(2): 131–144.

108.

Tunstall

(1977) The Media are American. Anglo-American Media in the World, London: Constable.

109.

Van Gorp

(2007) The constructionist approach to framing: Bringing culture back in. Journal of Communication 57(1): 60–78.

110.

Vankin J (2016) Watch ‘60 Minutes’ Malaysia Airlines flight MH370 story stream online: Cover-up of “rogue pilot” taking plane, program charges. Available at: http://www.inquisitr.com/3367944/malaysia-airlines-flight-mh370-60-minutes/.

111.

Vincent

Crow

Davis

(1989) When technology fails: The drama of airline crashes in network television news. Journalism Monographs 117: 46–54.

112.

Wardell J (2014) Search for MH370 to be most expensive in aviation history. Reuters. Available at: http://www.reuters.com.

113.

Westcott B (2016) Third piece of plane wreckage confirmed as MH370 debris. CNN, 7 October. Available at: http://www.cnn.com/2016/10/07/asia/mh370-mauritius-debris-confirmed/.

114.

Willnat

Wong

(2013) Online media and political participation: The case of Malaysia. Mass Communication and Society 16: 557–585.

115.

World Press Freedom Index (2014) Available at: https://rsf.org/index2014.

116.

Yan Y and Kim Y (2015) Framing the crisis by one’s seat: A comparative study of newspaper frames of the Asiana crash in the U.S.A., Korea, and China. Asian Journal of Communication 25(5): 486–506.

117.

Zaremba

(1988) Mass Communication and International Politics: A Case Study of Press Reactions to the 1973 Arab-Israeli War, Salem, WI: Sheffield.

118.

Zhang Y, Jin Y and Tang Y (2015) Framing depression: Cultural and organizational influences on coverage of a public health threat and attribution of responsibilities in Chinese news media, 2000–2012. Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly 92(1): 99–120.

119.

Zhao L (2014) Calls for patience despite progress. China Daily, 7 April.

120.

Zhao

(2000) From commercialization to conglomeration: The transformation of the Chinese press within the orbit of the party state. Journal of Communication 50(2): 3–26.