Sport specialization is of increasing prevalence and concern in the realm of youth sports. Collegiate coaches are uniquely positioned as gatekeepers to funds and opportunities for young athletes to continue their athletic careers in the collegiate setting. The purpose of this study was to explore collegiate coaches’ perceptions and beliefs of how youth sport specialization impacts an athlete's sport performance. This study included 13 head and assistant coaches currently working in collegiate athletics. Coaches came from a variety of sport and experience backgrounds. This study was conducted using an interpretive phenomenological analysis and a consensual qualitative research framework. Data were collected using semi-structured interviews and analyzed using a multi-analyst team. Themes and subthemes were generated using a multi-step data analysis and coding process. Three themes and subsequent subthemes were identified: athlete potential, physical impacts on the athlete, and athlete's relationship to sport. Each theme had corresponding subthemes highlighting positive and negative aspects of early specialization. Overall, coaches recognized the negative effects of youth sport specialization on an athlete's sport performance, but viewed youth sport specialization as a successful path for athletes to find athletic success.
McGuineTAPostEGHetzelSJ, et al.A prospective study on the effect of sport specialization on lower extremity injury rates in high school athletes. Am J Sports Med2017; 45: 2706–2712.
2.
JayanthiNAPostEGLauryTC, et al.Health consequences of youth sport specialization. J Athl Train2019; 54: 1040–1049.
3.
DiFioriJPBenjaminHJBrennerJS, et al.Overuse injuries and burnout in youth sports: a position statement from the American medical society for sports medicine. Br J Sports Med2014; 48: 287–288.
4.
MyerGDJayanthiNDifioriJP, et al.Sport specialization, part I: does early sports specialization increase negative outcomes and reduce the opportunity for success in young athletes?Sports Health2015; 7: 437–442.
5.
BellDRSneddenTRBieseKM, et al.Consensus definition of sport specialization in youth athletes using a delphi approach. J Athl Train2021; 56: 1239–1251.
6.
StrosserS. Youth sport specialization and risk of injury: a general review. Clin J Sport Med2023; 33: 652–657.
7.
BrennerJSLaBotzMSugimotoD, et al.The psychosocial implications of sport specialization in pediatric athletes. J Athl Train2019; 54: 1021–1029.
8.
DaleyMMShoopJChristinoMA. Mental health in the specialized athlete. Curr Rev Musculoskelet Med2023; 16: 410–418.
9.
ZellerAMLearAPostE, et al.A national survey on the relationship of youth sport specialization behaviors to self-reported anxiety and depression in youth softball players. Sports Health: Multidiscip Approach2024; 16: 184–194.
10.
MarquesAEkelundUSardinhaLB. Associations between organized sports participation and objectively measured physical activity, sedentary time and weight status in youth. J Sci Med Sport2016; 19: 154–157.
11.
MoeijesJVan BusschbachJTWieringaTH, et al.Sports participation and health-related quality of life in children: results of a cross-sectional study. Health Qual Life Outcomes2019; 17: 64.
12.
VellaSACliffDPMageeCA, et al.Sports participation and parent-reported health-related quality of life in children: longitudinal associations. J Pediatr2014; 164: 1469–1474.
13.
JayanthiNALaBellaCRFischerD, et al.Sports-specialized intensive training and the risk of injury in young athletes: a clinical case-control study. Am J Sports Med2015; 43: 794–801.
14.
SmithKLWeirPL. An examination of relative age and athlete dropout in female developmental soccer. Sports2022; 10: 79.
15.
WaltersBKReadCREstesAR. The effects of resistance training, overtraining, and early specialization on youth athlete injury and development. J Sports Med Phys Fitness58. Epub ahead of print July 2018. DOI: https://doi.org/10.23736/S0022-4707.17.07409-6.
16.
PadakiASPopkinCAHodginsJL, et al.Factors that drive youth specialization. Sports Health2017; 9: 532–536.
17.
PostEGRosenthalMDRootHJ, et al.Knowledge, attitudes, and beliefs of parents of youth basketball players regarding sport specialization and college scholarship availability. Orthop J Sports Med2021; 9: 232596712110245.
18.
PostEGRosenthalMDPennockAT, et al.Attitudes and beliefs of little league baseball parents regarding sport specialization and college scholarship availability. Phys Sportsmed2022; 50: 471–477.
19.
BuckleyPSBishopMKaneP, et al.Early single-sport specialization: a survey of 3090 high school, collegiate, and professional athletes. Orthop J Sports Med2017; 5: 2325967117703944.
20.
BuckleyPSCiccottiMCBishopM, et al.Youth single-sport specialization in professional baseball players. Orthop J Sports Med2020; 8: 232596712090787.
21.
PostEGThein-NissenbaumJMStifflerMR, et al.High school sport specialization patterns of current division I athletes. Sports Health2017; 9: 148–153.
22.
RuggCMCoughlanMJLiJN, et al.Early sport specialization among former national collegiate athletic association athletes: trends, scholarship attainment, injury, and attrition. Am J Sports Med2021; 49: 1049–1058.
23.
WilhelmAChoiCDeitchJ. Early sport specialization: effectiveness and risk of injury in professional baseball players. Orthop J Sports Med2017; 5: 2325967117728922.
24.
BellDRPostEGTrigstedSM, et al.Prevalence of sport specialization in high school athletics: a 1-year observational study. Am J Sports Med2016; 44: 1469–1474.
25.
WilkinsSJMartinMKahanovL, et al.Motivation and Behaviors Related to Sport Specialization in College Baseball Players. J Athl Train. Epub ahead of print 1 September 2023. DOI: https://doi.org/10.4085/1062-6050-0023.23.
26.
SmithJAShinebourneP. Interpretative phenomenological analysis. In: Cooper H, Camic PM, Long DL, et al. (eds) APA Handbook of research methods in psychology, vol 2: research designs: quantitative, qualitative, neuropsychological, and biological. Washington: American Psychological Association, 2012, pp.73–82.
27.
HusserlE. The idea of phenomenology. Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands, 1973.
28.
HernandezMIMillerECBieseKM, et al.Secondary school athletic Trainers’ navigation of patient socioeconomic Status challenges in care: a qualitative study. IJERPH2022; 19: 16709.
29.
RybaTV. Researching children in sport: methodological reflections. J Appl Sport Psychol2008; 20: 334–348.
30.
AndersonCALeahyMJDelValleR, et al.Methodological application of multiple case study design using modified consensual qualitative research (CQR) analysis to identify best practices and organizational factors in the public rehabilitation program. J Vocat Rehabil2014; 41: 87–98.
31.
HillCEKnoxS. Essentials of consensual qualitative research. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association, 2021.
32.
AjzenI. The theory of planned behavior. Organ Behav Hum Decis Process1991; 50: 179–211.
33.
McConnell-HenryTChapmanYFrancisK. Member checking and heideggerian phenomenology: a redundant component. Nurse Res2011; 18: 28–37.
34.
SmithJAJarmanMOsbornM. Doing interpretative phenomenological analysis. In: Murray M and Chamberlain K (eds) Qualitative health psychology: theories and methods. London, UK: Sage Publications Ltd, 1999, pp.218–240.
35.
SmithBMcGannonKR. Developing rigor in qualitative research: problems and opportunities within sport and exercise psychology. Int Rev Sport Exerc Psychol2018; 11: 101–121.
36.
YardleyL. Dilemmas in qualitative health research. Psychol Health2000; 15: 215–228.
BieseKMWinansMRudekG, et al.Sport specialization and sport motivation in middle school-aged athletes. J Athl Train2024; 59: 274–280.
39.
GroenewalPHPutrinoDNormanMR. Burnout and motivation in sport. Psychiatric Clinics of North America2021; 44: 359–372.
40.
RoosKGMarshallSWKerrZY, et al.Epidemiology of overuse injuries in collegiate and high school athletics in the United States. Am J Sports Med2015; 43: 1790–1797.
41.
AhlquistSCashBMHameSL. Associations of early sport specialization and high training volume with injury rates in national collegiate athletic association division I athletes. Orthop J Sports Med2020; 8: 2325967120906825.
42.
EricssonKAKrampeRTTesch-RömerC. The role of deliberate practice in the acquisition of expert performance. Psychol Rev1993; 100: 363–406.
43.
HarwellKSouthwickD. Beyond 10,000 hours: addressing misconceptions of the expert performance approach. J Expert2021; 4: 220–233.
44.
NorthJ. An overview and critique of the ‘10,000 h rule’ and ‘theory of deliberate practise’. Leeds, England: Leeds Metropolitan University, 2012.
