We conducted a broad longitudinal survey of three sports in which the winner must win three sets to prevail: American collegiate volleyball, international table tennis, and international men's tennis (Grand Slams and Davis Cup competitions). We found a uniform game pattern across these sports whereupon they were distinctly one-sided in their progression. This pattern persisted when we performed a more granular analysis in men's tennis studying Grand Slam tournaments separately and this slanted pattern held even within round progression. Only the ability to mount a comeback differed across sports and genders. We postulate that since the comeback narrative has a general positive appeal, greater crowds may propel a resurgent entity to win. We also conclude that scoring rules determine greatly how competitive the sport is.
GoldschmiedNMauldinKThompsonB,et al.NBA Game progression of extreme score shifts and comeback analysis: a team resilience perspective. AJSEP2024; 4: 75–81.
4.
McGannonKRMcMahonJSchinkeRJ, et al.Understanding athlete mother transition in cultural context: a media analysis of Kim Clijsters’ tennis comeback and self-identity implications. Sport Exerc. Perform. Psychol2017; 6: 20–34.
5.
HodlerMRLucas-CarrC. The mother of all comebacks” A critical analysis of the fitspirational comeback narrative of dara torres. Commun Sport2016; 4: 442–459.
6.
AfremowJA. The champion's comeback : how great athletes recover, reflect, and re-ignite. New York, NY: Rodale, 2016, 257 pages.
7.
Harnson-UtleyJJVazquezL. The comeback: rehabilitating the psychological injury. International Journal of Athletic Therapy and Training2008; 13: 35–38.
8.
VeriMJ. Baseball's greatest comeback: the miracle braves of 1914. J Sport Hist2015; 42: 445–446.
9.
MorgulevEVoslinskyAAzarOH,et al.Biased perceptions about momentum: do comeback teams have higher chances to win in basketball overtimes?Judgm Decis Mak2020; 15: 545–560.
10.
MorgulevEAzarOHBar-EliM. Does a “comeback” create momentum in overtime? Analysis of NBA tied games. J Econ Psychol2019; 75: 102126.
11.
BenoitACJenkinsJLParryRM. A Statistical Analysis of Basketball Comebacks.
12.
WeinbergRRichardsonPJacksonA,et al.Coming from behind to win: sex differences in interacting sport teams. Int J Sport Psychol1983; 14: 79–84.
13.
GillPS. Late-game reversals in professional basketball, football, and hockey. Am Stat2000; 54: 94–99.
14.
BergerJPopeD. Can losing lead to winning?Manag. Sci2011; 57: 817–827.
MandićRJakovljevićSErčuljF,et al.Trends in NBA and Euroleague basketball: analysis and comparison of statistical data from 2000 to 2017. PloS One2019; 14: e0223524.
BrimbergJHurleyWJ. Do professional hockey teams with a two-goal lead lose more often than they should?Int. J. Oper. Res2012; 15: 226–233.
19.
Lago-PeñasCGómez-RuanoMMegías-NavarroD,et al.Home advantage in football: examining the effect of scoring first on match outcome in the five major European leagues. Int J Perf Anal Spor2016; 16: 411–421.
20.
YukelsonDWeinbergR. Team resiliency in sport: research to practice. In: SchinkeRMcGannonKRSmithB (eds) Routledge international handbook of sport psychology. New York, NY: Routledge, 2016, pp.547–558.
21.
DepkenCAGandarJMShapiroDA. Set-level strategic and psychological momentum in best-of-three-set professional tennis matches. J Sports Econom2022; 23: 598–623.
22.
WeinbergRJacksonA. The effects of psychological momentum on male and female tennis players revisited. J Sport Behav1989; 12: 167–179.
23.
RansomKWeinbergR. Effect of situation criticality on performance of elite male and female tennis players. J Sport Behav1985; 8: 44–49.
24.
GhislettaPSpiniD. An introduction to generalized estimating equations and an application to assess selectivity effects in a longitudinal study on very old individuals. journal is J. Educ. Behav. Stat2004; 29: 421–437.
25.
HilbeJMHardinJW. Generalized estimating equations for longitudinal panel analysis. In: MenardS (ed.) Handbook of longitudinal research: design, measurement, and analysis. Elsevier, 2008, pp.467–474.
