What makes or breaks higher education community engagement in the South African rural school context: A multiple-partner perspective

Abstract

The purpose of this study is to inform global citizenship practice as a higher education agenda by comparing the retrospective experiences of a range of community engagement partners and including often silent voices of non-researcher partners. Higher education–community engagement aims to contribute to social justice as it constructs and transfers new knowledge from the perspectives of a wide range of community engagement partners. This qualitative secondary analysis study was framed theoretically by the transformative–emancipatory paradigm. Existing case data, generated on retrospective experiences of community engagement partners in a long-term community engagement partnership, were conveniently sampled to analyse and compare a range of community engagement experiences (parents of student clients (n = 12: females 10, males 2), teachers from the partner rural school (n = 18: females 12, males 6), student-educational psychology clients (n = 31: females 14, males 17), Academic Service-Learning (ASL) students (n = 20: females 17, males 3) and researchers (n = 12: females 11, males 1). Following thematic in-case and cross-case analysis, it emerged that all higher education–community engagement partners experienced that socio-economic challenges (defined as rural school adversities, include financial, geographic and social challenges) are addressed when an higher education–community engagement partnership exists, but that particular operational challenges (communication barriers, time constraints, workload and unclear scope, inconsistent feedback, as well as conflicting expectations) hamper higher education–community engagement partnership. A significant insight from this study is that a range of community engagement partners experience similar challenges when a university and rural school partner. All community engagement partners experienced that higher education–community engagement is challenged by the structural disparity between the rural context and operational miscommunication.

Keywords

Barriers in community engagement community engagement global citizenship higher education partnership and partners retrospective experiences rural school social justice transformative–emancipatory paradigm

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adler

Clark

(2008) How It’s Done: An Invitation to Social Research, 3rd edn. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Thomson.

Albertyn

Erasmus

(2014) An introductory perspective on the knowledge enablement landscape: potential for higher education-third sector engagement. In: Albertyn

Erasmus

(eds) Knowledge as Enablement: Engagement Between Higher Education and the Third Sector in South Africa. Bloemfontein, South Africa: Sun Press, 21–37.

Andrews

(2011) Religious communities, immigration, and social cohesion in rural areas: evidence from England. Rural Sociology 76(4): 535–561.

Angeles

(2005) Income inequality and colonialism. European Economic Review 51: 1155–1176.

Arolker

Seale

(2012) Glossary. In: Seale

(ed.) Researching Society and Culture, 3rd edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, 555–604.

Ashcroft

Rayner

(2011) Higher Education in Development: Lessons from Sub-Saharan Africa. New York: Information Age.

Babbie

(2002) The Basics of Social Research. Toronto: Thomson Learning.

Babbie

(2013) The Practice of Social Research, 13th edn. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing.

Babbie

Benaquisto

(2002) Fundamentals of Research, 2nd edn. Toronto, ON, Canada: Thomson Press.

10.

Babbie

Mouton

(2001) The Practice of Social Research, South African edn. Cape Town, South Africa: Oxford University Press.

11.

Barbour

(2008) Introducing Qualitative Research: A Student Guide to the Craft of Doing Qualitative Research. Los Angeles, CA: SAGE.

12.

Bassey

(1999) Case Study Research in Educational Settings. Buckingham: Open University Press.

13.

Bazeley

(2013) Qualitative Data Analysis: Practical Strategies. Los Angeles, CA: SAGE.

14.

Beard

Dasgupta

(2006) Collective action and community-driven development in rural and urban Indonesia. Urban Studies 43(9): 1451–1468.

15.

Bednarz

Chalkley

Fletcher

et al . (2008) Community engagement for students learning in geography. Journal of Geography in Higher Education 32(1): 87–100.

16.

Beere

(2009) Understanding and enhancing the opportunities of community-campus partnerships. In: Sandmann

Thornton

Jaeger

(eds) Institutionalizing Community Engagement in Higher Education: The First Wave of Carnegie Classified Institutions. San Francisco, CA: Wiley Periodicals, 55–63.

17.

Bender

(2008) Exploring conceptual models for community engagement at higher education institutions in South Africa. Perspectives in Education 26(1): 81–95.

18.

Benneworth

Sanderson

(2009) The regional engagement of universities: building capacity in a sparse innovation environment. Higher Education Management and Policy 21(1): 131–148.

19.

Bhatt

(2012) Doing a dissertation. In: Seale

(ed.) Researching Society and Culture, 3rd edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, 153–178.

20.

Bickman

Rog

(2009) Applied research design: a practical approach. In: Bickman

Rog

(eds) The SAGE Handbook of Applied Social Research Methods, 2nd edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, 3–43.

21.

Bowen

(2013) A civic engagement agenda for Caribbean higher education. Journal of Community Engagement and Higher Education 5(1): 74–81.

22.

Bringle

Hatcher

(2002) Campus-community partnerships: the terms of engagement. Journal of Social Issues 58(3): 503–516.

23.

Bruyere

Roybal

Thomas

(2013) Dispositions of higher education faculty toward K-12 community outreach. Journal of Community Engagement and Higher Education 5(1): 57–69.

24.

Bryman

(2001) Social Research Methods. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

25.

Butcher

Bezzina

Moran

(2011) Transformational partnerships: a new agenda for higher education. Innovative Higher Education 36: 29–40.

26.

Butcher

Howard

Labone

et al . (2003) Teacher education, community service learning and student efficacy for community engagement. Asia-Pacific Journal of Teacher Education 31(2): 109–124.

27.

Camino

(2000) Youth-adult partnerships: Entering new territory in community work and research. Applied Development Science 4(1): 11–20.

28.

Canadian Council for International Cooperation (CCIC) (1996) Global citizenship: A new way forward. Available at: http://www.ccic.ca/_files/en/what_we_do/002_public_a_new_way_forward.pdf

29.

Caputo

(2005) A campus view: civic engagement and the higher education community. National Civic Review 94: 3–8.

30.

Charmaz

(2011) Grounded theory methods in social justice research. In: Denzin

Lincoln

(eds) The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative Research, 4th edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, 359–380.

31.

Cheong

(2006) Communication context, social cohesion and social capital building among Hispanic immigrant families. Community, Work and Family 9(3): 367–387.

32.

Cherrington

(2010) Learners experiences of school violence in a rural school. Master’s Dissertation. University of Pretoria, Pretoria, South Africa. Available at: http://upetd.up.ac.za/thesis/available/etd-06132011-144001/ (accessed 7 March 2014).

33.

Chipkin

Ngqulunga

(2008) Friends and family: social cohesion in South Africa. Journal of South African Studies 34(1): 61–76.

34.

Cohen

Manion

(1994) Research Methods in Education, 4th edn. London: Routledge.

35.

Cohen

Manion

Morrison

(2000) Research Methods in Education, 5th edn. London: RoutledgeFalmer.

36.

Colbeck

Michael

(2006) The public scholarship: reintegrating Boyer’s four domains. New Directions for Institutional Research 129: 7–19.

37.

Creswell

(2003) Research Design: Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Methods Approaches, 5th edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

38.

Creswell

(2011) Controversies in mixed methods research. In: Denzin

Lincoln

(eds) The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative Research, 4th edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, 269–283.

39.

Dass-Brailsford

(2005) Exploring resiliency: academic achievement among disadvantaged black youth in South Africa. South African Journal of Psychology 35(3): 574–591.

40.

David

Clegg

(2008) Power, pedagogy and personalization in global higher education: The occlusion of second-wave feminism? Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education 29(4): 483–498.

41.

De Lange

Mitchell

Bhana

(2012) Voices of women teachers about gender inequalities and gender-based violence in rural South Africa. Gender and Education 24(5): 499–514.

42.

Department of Education (2009) Department of Education Research Manual. Available at: http://www.mpumalanga.gov.za/education/PF/Policies/RESEARCH%20MANUAL.pdf.

43.

De Villiers

Van den Berg

(2012) The implication and evaluation of resiliency programme for children. South African Journal of Psychology 42(1): 93–102.

44.

De Vos

Strydom

Fouché

et al . (2011) Research at Grass Roots: For the Social Sciences and Human Services Professions, 4th edn. Pretoria, South Africa: Van Schaik.

45.

Department of Basic Education (2014) 2014 school realities. Available at: http://www.education.gov.za/LinkClick.aspx?fileticket=UdGRjcHLNik%3d&tabid=462&mid=1327

46.

Ebersöhn

(2010a) Resilience and career counseling: describing the utility of quadrant mapping. Journal of Psychology in Africa 20(3): 386–393.

47.

Ebersöhn

(2014) Teacher resilience: theorizing resilience and poverty. Teachers and Teaching: Theory and Practice 20: 568–594.

48.

Ebersöhn

Maree

(2006) Demonstrating resilience in an HIV and AIDS context: an emotional intelligence perspective. Gifted Education International 22(1): 14–30.

49.

Ebersöhn

Bender

CJG

Carvalho-Malekane

(2010) Informing educational psychology training with students’ community engagement experiences. Perspectives in Education 28(3): 87–98.

50.

Eisenhart

Jurow

(2011) Teaching qualitative research. In: Denzin

Lincoln

(eds) The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative Research, 4th edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, 699–714.

51.

Ellingson

(2011) Analysis and representation across the continuum. In: Denzin

Lincoln

(eds) The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative Research, 4th edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, 595–610.

52.

Engelbrecht

Oswald

Forlin

(2006) Promoting the implementation of inclusive education in primary schools in South Africa. British Journal of Special Education 33: 121–129.

53.

Erasmus

(2014) The political unconscious of higher education community engagement in South Africa. In: Albertyn

Erasmus

(eds) Knowledge as Enablement: Engagement Between Higher Education and the Third Sector in South Africa. Bloemfontein, South Africa: Sun Press, 100–118.

54.

Fasko

(1999) A system approach to self-efficacy and achievement in rural schools. Education 119(2): 292–300.

55.

Flyvbjerg

(2011) Case study. In: Denzin

Lincoln

(eds) The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative Research, 4th edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, 301–316.

56.

Fogel

Cook

(2006) Considerations on the scholarship of engagement as an area of specialization for faculty. Journal of Social Work Education 42(3): 595–606.

57.

Freire

(1972) Pedagogy of the Oppressed. New York: Penguin Books.

58.

Freire

(1973) Education for Critical Consciousness. New York: The Seabury Press.

59.

Freire

(1992) Pedagogy of Hope. New York: Continuum.

60.

Freire

(1993) Pedagogy of the Oppressed. London: Continuum.

61.

Freire

Macedo

(1987) Literacy: Reading the Word and the World. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

62.

Frey

Whitehead

(2009) International education policies and the boundaries of global citizenship in the US. Journal of Curriculum Studies 41(2): 269–290.

63.

Gall

Borg

(2010) Educational Research: An Introduction, 8th edn. New York: Allyn and Bacon.

64.

Gardiner

(2008) Education in rural areas: issues in education policy. Available at: http://www.cepd.org.za/files/CEPD_Issues_in_education_Education_in_rural_areas.pdf

65.

Gelb

(2003) Inequality in South Africa: nature, causes and responses. Available at: http://www.tips.org.za/files/Gelb_Inequality_in_SouthAfrica.pdf

66.

Gonzalez-Perez

(2010) The civically engaged university model in Colombia. International Journal of Technology and Sustainable Development 9(3): 161–173.

67.

Grauer

(2012) A case for case study research in education. In: Klein

(ed.) Action Research Methods: Plain and Simple. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 69–79.

68.

Harding

(2013) Qualitative Data Analysis from Start to Finish. Los Angeles, CA: SAGE.

69.

Hart

Northmore

Gerhardt

et al . (2009) Developing access between universities and local community groups: a university helpdesk in action. Journal of Higher Education Outreach and Engagement 13(3): 45–59.

70.

Hayden

(2013) A review of curriculum in the UK: internationalising in a changing context. The Curriculum Journal 24(1): 8–26.

71.

Hays

(2004) Case study research. In: deMarrais

Lapan

(eds) Foundations for Research: Methods of Inquiry in Education and the Social Sciences. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, 217–234.

72.

Henry

(2009) Practical sampling. In: Bickman

Rog

(eds) The SAGE Handbook of Applied Social Research Methods, 2nd edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, 77–105.

73.

Irwin

(2012) Paulo Freire’s Philosophy of Education: Origins, Developments, Impacts and Legacies. New York: Continuum International Publishing Group.

74.

Irwin

(2013) Qualitative secondary data analysis: ethics, epistemology and context. Progress in Development Studies 13(4): 295–306.

75.

Jackson

Hutchinson

Peters

et al . (2013) Understanding avoidant leadership in health care: findings from a secondary analysis of two qualitative studies. Journal of Nursing Management 21: 572–580.

76.

Jenson

Saint-Martin

(2003) New routes to social cohesion? Citizenship and the social investment state. Canadian Journal of Sociology 28(1): 77–99.

77.

Jones

Coffey

(2012) Voice hearing: a secondary analysis of talk by people who hear voices. International Journal of Mental Health Nursing 21: 50–59.

78.

Jorgenson

Shultz

(2012) Global citizenship education (GCE) in post-secondary institutions: what is protected and what is hidden under the umbrella of GCE? Journal of Global Citizenship, and Equity Education 2(1): 1–22.

79.

Keating

Ortloff

Philippou

(2009) Introduction: citizenship education curricula: the changes and challenges presented by Global and European Integration. Journal of Curriculum Studies 41(2): 145–158.

80.

Kumar

(2011) Research Methodology: A Step-by Step Guide for Beginners, 3rd edn. London: SAGE.

81.

Lapum

Hamzavi

Veljkovic

et al . (2012) A performance and poetical narrative of critical social theory in nursing education: An ending and threshold of social justice. Nursing Philosophy 13: 27–45.

82.

Lawrence

Gabriella

(2004) Experimental research to inform educational policy. In: deMarrais

Lapan

(eds) Foundations for Research: Methods of Inquiry in Education and the Social Sciences. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, 329–352.

83.

Leibowitz

(2010) Towards SoTL as critical engagement: a perspective from the ‘south’. International Journal for the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning 4(2): 1–5.

84.

Levine

(2007) The Future of Democracy: Developing the Next Generation of American Citizens. London: University Press of New England.

85.

Lincoln

Lynham

Guba

(2011) Paradigmatic controversies, contradictions, and emerging confluences, revisited. In: Denzin

Lincoln

(eds) The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative Research, 4th edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, 97–128.

86.

Lindenfeld

(2010) Working outside the box: advertising campaigns, downtown revitalization, and community engagement. Journal of Community Engagement 1(2): 1–10.

87.

Lodico

Spaulding

Voegtle

(2010) Methods in Educational Research: From Theory to Practice, 2nd edn. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

88.

Loots

(2011) Teachers’ implementation of an asset-based intervention for school-based psychosocial support. PhD Thesis, University of Pretoria, Pretoria, South Africa. Available at: http://upetd.up.ac.za/thesis/available/etd-06022011-161318/ (accessed 27 June 2014).

89.

Machimana

(2012) Perceptions of the association between alcohol misuse and the risk of HIV-infection among male youths in Soshanguve, Gauteng Province. MA Dissertation, University of South Africa, Pretoria, South Africa.

90.

McLaren

Leonard

(1993) Paulo Freire: A Critical Encounter. London: Routledge.

91.

McMillan

Schumacher

(2014) Research in Education: Evidence-Based Inquiry, 7th edn. Edinburg Gate: Pearson Education.

92.

McNall

Reed

Brown

et al . (2009) Brokering community-university engagement. Innovative Higher Education 33: 317–331.

93.

Mahoney

Levine

Hinga

(2010) The development of after-school program educators through university-community partnerships. Applied Developmental Science 14(2): 89–105.

94.

Mampane

Bouwer

(2011) The influence of township schools on the resilience of their learners. South African Journal of Education 31: 114–126.

95.

Mapesela

Hlalele

Alexander

(2012) Overcoming adversity: a holistic response to creating sustainable rural learning ecologies. Journal of Human Ecology 38(2): 91–103.

96.

Maree

Pietersen

(2007) Sampling. In: Maree

(ed.) First Steps in Research. Pretoria, South Africa: Van Schaik, 172–181.

97.

Mariage

Garmon

(2003) A case of educational change: improving student achievement through a school-university partnership. Remedial and Special Education 24(4): 215–234.

98.

Markham

(2013) Bridging the divide: from service to public work. Journal of Community Engagement and Higher Education 5(1): 68–73.

99.

Mathee

Harpham

Barnes

et al . (2009) Inequality in poverty: the emerging public health challenge in Johannesburg. Development Southern Africa 26(5): 722–732.

100.

Maurrasse

(2001) Beyond the Campus: How Colleges and Universities Form Partnerships with Their Communities. New York: Routledge.

101.

May

(1998) Poverty and inequality in South Africa. Indicator South Africa 15: 53–58.

102.

Mertens

(2004) Transformative research and evaluation and dimensions of diversity. In: Shaw

Greene

Mark

(eds) Handbook of Evaluation: Programme, Policy, and Practice. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, 1–10.

103.

Mertens

(2005) The transformative prism: resilience and social justice in mixed methods research. In: Proceedings of the first international congress of qualitative inquiry, University of Illinois, Urban-Champaign, IL, May, 1–10.

104.

Mertens

(2012) Transformative mixed methods: addressing inequalities. American Behavioral Scientist 56: 802–813.

105.

Minkler

(2005) Community-based research partnerships: challenges and opportunities. Journal of Urban Health 82(2): 3–12.

106.

Mooij

Smeets

De Wit

(2011) Multi-level aspects of social cohesion of secondary schools and pupils’ feelings of safety. British Journal of Educational Psychology 81: 369–390.

107.

Moseley

(2007) Collaborating in the field, working for change: reflecting on partnerships between academics, development organizations and rural communities in Africa. Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography 28: 334–347.

108.

Nattrass

Seekings

(2001) Democracy and distribution in highly unequal economies: the case of South Africa. Journal of Modern African Studies 39(3): 471–498.

109.

Nestel

Gray

Simmons

et al . (2014) Community perceptions of a rural medical school: a pilot qualitative study. Advances in Medical Education and Practice 5: 407–413.

110.

Neuman

(1997) Social Research Methods: Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches, 3rd edn. London: Allyn and Bacon.

111.

O’Meara

Sandmann

Saltmarsh

et al . (2011) Studying the professional lives and work of faculty involved in community engagement. Innovative Higher Education 36: 83–96.

112.

Osler

(2011) Teacher interpretations of citizenship education: national identity, cosmopolitan ideals, and political realities. Journal of Curriculum Studies 43(1): 1–24.

113.

Osman

Petersen

(2010) Students’ engagement with engagement: the case of teacher education students in higher education in South Africa. British Journal of Educational Studies 58(4): 407–419.

114.

Oxfam (2013) The cost of inequality: how wealth and income extremes hurt us all. Available at: http://www.oxfam.org/sites/www.oxfam.org/files/cost-of-inequality-oxfam-mb180113.pdf

115.

Pitso

(2014) Factors that promote or hinder the voice of the third sector in public service delivery: Perspective on the Batho Pele Principles. In: Albertyn

Erasmus

(eds) Knowledge as Enablement: Engagement between Higher Education and the Third Sector in South Africa. Bloemfontein, South Africa: Sun Press, 195–213.

116.

Reitenauer

Spring

Kecskes

et al . (2005) Building and maintaining community partnerships. In: Cress

Collier

Reitenauer

et al . (eds) Learning through Serving: A Student Guidebook for Service-Learning across the Disciplines. Sterling, VA: Stylus Publishing, 17–31.

117.

Robson

(2002) Real World Research, 2nd edn. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing.

118.

Rohleder

Swartz

Carolissen

et al . (2008) ‘Communities Isn’t just about trees and shops’: Students from two South African universities engage in dialogue about ‘community’ and community work. Journal of Community and Applied Social Psychology 18: 253–267.

119.

Seekings

(2007) The mutability of distributive justice attitudes in South Africa. South African Review of Sociology 38(1): 20–44.

120.

Shields

Bryan

(2012) Building a policy-oriented research partnership for knowledge mobilization and knowledge transfer: the case of the Canadian metropolis project. Administrative Sciences 2: 250–272.

121.

Shultz

(2007) Educating for global citizenship: conflicting agendas and understandings. The Alberta Journal of Education Research 53(3): 248–258.

122.

Slamat

(2010) Community engagement as scholarship: A response to hall. In: Kagisano (ed.) Community Engagement in South African Higher Education. Pretoria, South Africa: Jacana Media, 104–114.

123.

Statistics South Africa (2014) Poverty trends in South Africa: an examination of absolute poverty between 2006 and 2011. Available at: http://www.ngopulse.org/resource/poverty-trends-south-africa-examination-absolute-poverty-between-2006-and-2011

124.

Strier

(2011) The construction of university-community partnerships: entangled perspectives. Higher Education 62: 81–97.

125.

The World Bank (2012) South Africa economic update focus on inequality of opportunity. Available at: http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTAFRICA/Resources/257994-1342195607215/SAEU-July_2012_Full_Report.pdf

126.

Tilbury

(2011) Education for Sustainable Development: An Expert Review of Process and Learning. Paris: UNESCO.

127.

Trahair

(2013) Using the vision of community engagement to broaden the tunnel vision of research myopia. International Journal of Science in Society 4: 101–109.

128.

Tregenna

Tsela (2012) Inequality in South Africa: the distribution of income, expenditure and earnings. Development Southern Africa 29(1): 35–61.

129.

United Nations (2013) Inequality matters: report of the World Social situation 2013. Available at: http://www.un.org/esa/socdev/documents/reports/InequalityMatters.pdf

130.

Vargas

Arauza

Folsom

et al . (2012) A community engagement process for families with children with disabilities: lessons in leadership and policy. Maternal Child Health Journal 16: 21–30.

131.

Venter

(2013) A teachers’ experience of implementing the asset-based approach to teach grade 7 learners. Master’s Dissertation, University of Pretoria, Pretoria, South Africa. http://hdl.handle.net/2263/40451 (accessed 4 June 2016).

132.

Wagner

Alexander

(2013) Evaluating transformative research programmes: a case study of the NSF small grants for exploratory research programme. Research Evaluation 22: 187–197.

133.

Webber

Jones

(2011) Re-positioning as a response to government higher education policy development: an Australian case study. Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management 33(1): 17–26.

134.

Welman

Kruger

Mitchell

(2005) Research Methodology, 3rd edn. Cape Town, South Africa: Oxford University Press.

135.

Whitehead

Kriel

Richter

(2005) Barriers to conducting a community mobilization intervention among youth in a rural South African Community. Journal of Community Psychology 33(3): 253–259.