This article explores the relevance of school design in providing an important social-spatial context for promoting citizenship in young people. Drawing on a small-scale study that investigated the perspectives of pupils and teachers, it contrasts the ways in which the social control and monitoring of pupils differed in two secondary schools. Comparing features of everyday life in one new and one old-build school, this study found that school design could either heighten or lessen the need for teacher control of pupils. As a consequence the layout of the schools could enable or restrict young people’s opportunities for self-determination, as well as encourage the normalization of the acceptance of control by others. The implications of this for the production of autonomous and self-governing citizens will be addressed.
BeinartSAndersonBLeeS. (2002) Youth at Risk?A National Survey of Risk Factors Protective Factors and Problems Behaviour Among Young People in England, Scotland and Wales. London: Communities that Care.
2.
BiestaG (2009) What kind of citizenship? What kind of democracy? Citizenship education and the Scottish curriculum for excellence. European Educational Research Journal8(2): 146–157.
3.
BlatchfordP (1998) Social Life in School. London: Falmer Press.
4.
BrownJ (2007) Gender, time and space understanding problem behaviour in young children. Children & Society21(2): 98–110.
5.
BrownJMunnP (2008) School violence as a social problem: charting the rise of the problem and the emerging specialist field. International Studies in Sociology of Education18(3–4): 217–228.
6.
BrownJSimpsonM (2008) ‘They’re just like caged animals’: security, surveillance and school architecture. Paper presented at the annual meeting of British Education Research Association, Edinburgh, September.
7.
BryceTNellisMCorriganAGallagherHLeePSercombeH (2010) Biometric Surveillance in Schools: cause for concern or case for curriculumScottish Educational Review42 (1) 3–22.
8.
BurkeCGrosvenorI (2003) The School I’d like: Children’s Reflections on an Education for the 21st Century. London: Routledge Farmer.
CunninghamSLavalleteM (2004) ‘Active citizens’ or ‘irresponsible truants’? School student strikes against the war. Critical Social Policy24(2): 255–269.
11.
DevineJ (1995) Can metal detectors replace the panoptican?Cultural Anthroplogy10(2): 171–195.
12.
DrakefordMScourfieldJHollandS. (2009) Welsh childrens’ views on government and participation. Childhood16(2): 247–264.
13.
FurlongACartmelF (2007) Young People and Social Change New Perspectives, 2nd edn.Maidenhead: Open University Press.
14.
GordonTHollandJLahelmaE (2000) Making Spaces Citizenship and Difference in Schools. London: Macmillan Press.
15.
HarberC (2002) Schooling as violence: an exploratory overview. Educational Review54(1): 7–16.
16.
JamesAProutA (eds) (1990) Constructing and Reconstructing Childhood. Basingstoke: Falmer Press.
17.
Kumar KatyalN (2002) Architecture as Crime ControlThe Yale Law Journal, 111(5): 1039–1139.
18.
KupchikAMonahanT (2006) The new American school: preparation for post-industrial discipline. British Journal of Sociology27(5): 617–631.
19.
Learning and Teaching Scotland (2002) Education for Citizenship. A Paper for Discussion and Development. Dundee: Learning and Teaching Scotland.
20.
LeonardM (2006) Segregated schools in segregated societies: issues of safety and risk. Childhood (13): 441–458.
21.
LewisT (2003) The surveillance economy of post columbine schools. The Review of Education, Pedagogy and Cultural Studies25(4): 335–355.
22.
LyonD (1994) The Electronic Eye: The Rise and Fall of the Surveillance Society. Cambridge: Polity Press.
23.
MadgeNBarkerJ (2007) Risk and Children. London: Risk Commission RSA.
24.
MaitlesHGilchristI (2005) ‘We’re citizens now’! The development of positive values through a democratic approach to learning. Journal for Critical Education Policy3(1): 1740–1743.
25.
MathewsH (2005) Editorial: rising four: reflections on the state of growing up. Children’s Geographies3(3): 271–273.
26.
MonahanTTorresRD (2010) Introduction. In: MonahanTTorresRD (eds) Schools under Surveillance. London Rutgers: University Press, 1–18.
ThompsonS (2005) Territorializing the primary school playground: deconstructing the geography of playtime. Children’s Geographies3(1): 63–78.
39.
TupperJCarsonAJohnstonT. (2008) Building place: student’s negotiation of spaces and citizenship in schools. Canadian Journal of Education31(4): 1065–1092.
40.
WarnickRB (2007) Surveillance cameras in schools: an ethical analysis. Harvard Educational Review77(3): 317–343.
41.
WatsonL (2007) Building the future of learning. European Journal of Education42(2): 255–263.
